<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<itemContainer xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://omeka.ibu.edu.ba/items/browse?output=omeka-xml&amp;page=2&amp;sort_field=Dublin+Core%2CCreator" accessDate="2026-06-04T04:37:28+01:00">
  <miscellaneousContainer>
    <pagination>
      <pageNumber>2</pageNumber>
      <perPage>10</perPage>
      <totalResults>3494</totalResults>
    </pagination>
  </miscellaneousContainer>
  <item itemId="115" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="117">
        <src>https://omeka.ibu.edu.ba/files/original/30b109a3ee49615f9896aafab096f018.pdf</src>
        <authentication>6f030960731f984f0924cdaadee459bf</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="886">
                    <text>	&#13;  
	&#13;  

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

Performance of Moving Average Investment Timing Strategy
in UK Stock Market: Individual Stocks versus Portfolios

Muhammad Ishfaq Ahmad
Lahore Business School, The
University of Lahore
m_ishfaq452@yahoo.com
	&#13;  

Wang Ghohui
Liaoning Technical University
gsxy.wgh@163.co
	&#13;  

Mudassar Hasan
Lahore Business School, The
University of Lahore
mudassar.hassan@lbs.uol.edu.p

Ramiz Ur Rehman
Lahore Business School,
The University of Lahore
ramiz_rehman@gmail.com
	&#13;  
Abstract: This paper aims to test whether moving average (MA) investment
Keywords:	&#13;  Individual
Stocks, Higher Yields, and
timing strategy is applicable on individual stocks, portfolios formed from these
Sharpe Ratio.
stocks, or 	&#13;  both. Moreover, our objective is to compare the performance of MA

Anika Sattar
Liaoning Technical University
anikasattar@yahoo.com

Muneeb Ahmad
Liaoning Technical University
muneeb452@yahoo.com

strategy with a buy-and-hold strategy. The data on individual stocks listed on

JEL Classification: G10,

London Stock Exchange, United Kingdom (UK) is collected over the period

G11and D53

starting from December 31, 1999, through February 29, 2016. For the same
period, we use daily values of UK-DS Market-PRICE INDEX and 1-Month
Treasury bill rate. The paper follows Han et al. (2013) to peruse our
investigation. The study applies both MA and buy-and-hold strategies to
individual stocks and portfolios sorted by volatility. Since most results are
found insignificant, no evidence is found to support that one strategy is better

Article History
Submitted:	&#13;  17.4.2017
Resubmitted: 28.2.2018
Accepted: 18.5.2018

http://dx.doi.org/	&#13;  
10.14706/JECOSS17722

than the other when applied to individual stocks. However, trading behavior
and success ratios across groups provide mixed results, hinting slightly towards
the failure of MA strategy. The pervasive noise in daily stock return data is
the reason why MA strategy consistently produces insignificant results.
Moreover, when applied to volatility-sorted portfolios, MA strategy
substantially beats buy-and-hold strategy by yielding higher average return
and risk-adjusted returns, lower standard deviations, large-and-positive
skewness and Sharpe ratios, and much success ratios across portfolios. Both for
individual stocks and portfolios, dynamics of returns and especially trading
behavior suggest that the performance of MA strategy decreases with rising lag
lengths, meaning MA signal weakens for a longer history.
Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

5

�Muhammad Ishfaq Ahmad, Wang Ghohui, Mudassar Hasan, Anika Sattar, Muneeb Ahmad,
Ramiz Ur Rehman	&#13;  

Literature Review
Historically, stock price prediction has received an enormous amount of attention
among investors, practitioners, and academicians. Broadly, two classes of analyses
have been used for predicting stock prices. These are commonly known as
fundamental and technical analyses. Fundamental analysis uses intrinsic properties of
an asset, specifically stock, to estimate future price or intrinsic value. On the
contrary, in technical analysis historical data of prices is used to drive signals about
future prices. Lately, nevertheless, technical trading rules have been commonly used
by investors and financial analysts to make investment decisions (Neely, 1997;
Taylor and Allen (1992)). More recently, however, (Han, Zhou, &amp; Zhu, 2016) find
results that favor the persistent profitability of the MA trading rule. Zhou and Zhu
(2013) documents as MA follows the trend. It is further expected to be high
profitability in high IU stocks when there is amore extended price continuation.
Metghalchi, Marcucci, and Chang (2012) accept that MA scan forecast. Shintani,
Yabu, and Nagakura (2012) point out that MA signals are helpful for investment
over a longer time horizon.
On the other hand, numerous studies provide either mixed or reverse evidence. For
instance, (Allen &amp; Karjalainen, 1999) establish that, for US stock market, the
technical trading strategy does not perform better than buy-and-hold strategy even
after accounting for trading costs. Sullivan, Timmermann, and White (1999)
examine US futures market and conclude that, after making snooping bias
adjustment, there is no clue supporting the profitability of technical analysis.
Hoffmann and Shefrin (2014) find that investors who apply technical analysis as
their primary strategy in options trading are biased towards short-term speculative
trading decisions that are sub-optimal in the long run. Similarly, studying futures
markets, (Roberts, 2005) finds no evidence to support the profitability of technical
trading rules. Lukac and Brorsen (1990) point out that the returns of technical
trading rules are leptokurtic and exhibit positive skewness. The study also reports
that the historical applications of t-test for the returns produced by technical trading
rules can be biased.
It is worth considering that MA is most popular among a range of technical analysis
rules available. Therefore, some literature primarily focuses on moving average; Such
as (Hudson, Dempsey, &amp; Keasey, 1996)show that technical analysis rules (especially
the MAs) do not perform superior to buy-and-hold strategy when trading is costly;
though these rules have predictive power.Wei, Cheng, and Wu (2014) comment
that MAs are the trading rules that are most widely known and used by practitioners
and financial traders in the markets because MA methods are easily
understandable.Brock, Lakonishok, and LeBaron (1992) further examine the
6

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Performance of Moving Average Investment Timing Strategy in UK Stock Market:
Individual Stocks versus Portfolios	&#13;  

application of the MA timing strategy on Dow–Jones Industrial Average and
conclude that MA strategy outperforms buy-and-hold strategy. Mills (1997) also
demonstrates similar finding while applying the strategy to FT-30 Index. Kwon and
Kish (2002) list down the same results for New York Stock Exchange (NYSE).
More recently, (Han, Yang, &amp; Zhou, 2013) apply the moving average (MA) timing
strategy in US stock market. The main findings of the study are, MA strategy
performs significantly better than buy-and-hold strategy when applied to volatility
decile groups. Further, it produces significant average and excess returns. Moreover,
these returns also hold for when MA is calculated for more considerable lag lengths.
Finally, the excess returns are thus produced sufficiently cover the transaction costs.
This study primarily replicates the research carried out by (Han et al., 2013) while
simplifying, and to some extent differentiating, itself in the following ways. First, it
studies the application of MA strategy in UK stock market. Second, it considers five
quantile groups of individual stocks rather than portfolios. The groups are sorted
based on the volatility of individual stocks. Third, it utilizes Capital Asset Pricing
Model (CAPM) solely to test for abnormal returns. Fourth, it confirms the
robustness of results by using only two ways, alternative lag lengths, and trading
behaviors. Finally, it compares the results of individual stocks with that of portfolios.
Overarching the core aim of the study is to explore either moving average (MA)
investment timing strategy is applicable on individual stocks or portfolios, for the
stocks listed on the London Stock Exchange. Furthermore, our objective is to
compare the performance of MA strategy with a buy-and-hold strategy. The
following section explains the material and methods which contains the discussion
regarding the nature and sources of data and the econometric model's output as well.
We conclude the study in the last section under the conclusion head.

Material and Methods
We collect stock price data of 1,565 stocks listed on London Stock Exchange,
United Kingdom (UK) from December 31, 1999, to February 29, 2016 (4,217
days). Daily values of UK-DS Market - PRICE INDEX and 1-Month Treasury
Security rate are also downloaded for the same period. The data downloaded from
Thomson Reuters’ DataStream. Risk-free rate and market index data are free from
missing values. However, since stock price data does have missing values, so we have
to replace such values by not available (NA).
Initially, we calculate the daily returns for each stock. These are the returns under
the buy-and-hold strategy. As part of the cleaning process, we replace all returns
greater than 300%with NA before moving further. Then for every day, following
Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

7

�Muhammad Ishfaq Ahmad, Wang Ghohui, Mudassar Hasan, Anika Sattar, Muneeb Ahmad,
Ramiz Ur Rehman	&#13;  

(Brock et al., 1992) and (Han et al., 2013), a 10-day moving average (MA) price,
Ajt,L of each stock is calculated by using the stock prices (Pt) of previous ten days.
The MA price formula is given as follows;

Ajt , L =

Pjt −( L −1) + Pjt −( L −2) + .... + Pjt −1 + Pjt
L

,

(1)

where t = a particular day,
L= the lag lengths which is 10 in the first case,
J = number of stocks; so, j = 1,…,1565.
It is quite simple to apply MA strategy once MA prices are obtained. MA strategy is
based on the following notion: on a day, if yesterday’s market price (Pt) is higher
than yesterday’s moving average price (Ajt,L), invest in the market today; otherwise,
invest in the 1-month T-bill today. Mathematically, MA strategy can be expressed as
~

R

jt , L

=

{

R jt ,
r ft

if Pjt −1 &gt; A jt −1, L ;
otherwise.

(2)

Where Rj,t = return on a stock, j , under buy-and-hold strategy
t = a particular day
rft= the daily 1-month T-bill rate on day t.
Rjt,L= MA return on a particular day, for a particular stock, and for a
particular lag length which is 10 in this case.
MAG is defined as the difference between MA and buy-and-hold returns.
Once we have MA returns, MAGs can be calculated in the following way;
~

MAG jt , L = R jt , L − R jt .

(3)

Note that MAGs measure the performance of MA strategy relative to buy-and-hold
strategy. The last portion of Table 1 also reports the success ratio of MA strategy.
The idea of success ratio can be described as follow. On a particular day, if MA
return is equal to the maximum of either buy-and-hold or risk-free return of that
day, the day is considered a success-day; otherwise, it is regarded as a failure-day.
Finally, the ratio of all success-days to total trading days available is reported as
success ratio.

8

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Performance of Moving Average Investment Timing Strategy in UK Stock Market:
Individual Stocks versus Portfolios	&#13;  

Further, to assess the risk-adjusted performance of MAGs, We apply CAPM
regression between MAG returns and daily excess returns on the market, rMKT,t,
Famaand French (1993) Which can be expressed as,

MAG jt ,L = α j + β

j , MKT

rMKT + ε jt ,
,t

j = 1 ,..., 1,565.

(4)

Where αj, βj,MKT are the alpha(risk-adjusted return) and beta on for each stock.
Robustness of results is checked by repeating some steps of the methodology
mentioned above. For instance, average returns and alphas are calculated in a similar
way but with alternative lag lengths. Alternatively, we test MA strategy for 20-day,
50-day, 100-day, and 200-day lag lengths. However, to further test robustness
through random switching strategy, only 10-day lag length is considered. The notion
of random switching strategy can be explained as follows: a coin is tossed every day,
and if by doing so the uniform distribution provides a probability greater than .5,
the random strategy is to invest in the market; in risk-free security otherwise. This
process is repeated 10 times for every stock. It means under random strategy; first
stock has 10 returns against each day. Then daily returns on 30-day T-bill are
subtracted from the respective returns of all days, and for all columns, to calculate
excess returns produced by random switching strategy. Each column of excess
returns thus calculated is regressed upon excess returns on the market to yield 10
regressions, average returns, alphas, and t-statistics. The averages of all these values
are reported in last two columns of Table 3. The exact process is reiterated for other
random strategy groups.
Finally, it is of interest to see how often daily signals help MA strategy to trade.
Consider any stock. A trade happens only if, on a particular day, MA return is equal
to buy-and-hold return; and, on the previous day, MA return is equal to risk-free
return. Alternatively, a trade also occurs when the situation is reversed; that is if, on a
particular day, MA return is equal to the risk-free return; and, on the previous day,
MA return is equal to buy-and-hold return. After counting for a number oftrades,
we can quickly calculate average hold period, a fraction of trading days and
breakeven transaction cost (BETC).
As a final note, we would like to explain how we sorted all stocks into five quantiles.
We construct five quantiles based upon the standard deviation (volatility) of each
stock from a buy-and-hold strategy. Similarly, we create a differential quantile whose
returns are equal to the difference between returns of stocks in the highest and the
lowest quantiles. The stocks belonging to each quantile remain the same throughout
the process. So, each reported figure is the average of all stocks into a quantile.

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

9

�Muhammad Ishfaq Ahmad, Wang Ghohui, Mudassar Hasan, Anika Sattar, Muneeb Ahmad,
Ramiz Ur Rehman	&#13;  

Results and Discussion
Performance of Buy-and-Hold and Moving Average (MA) Strategy
a. Descriptive Statistics
Table 1: Descriptive Statistics

9.38

(4.02)
34.45

0.61

0.19

(0.89)
3

5.60

43.50

0.82

0.07

1.15

1.99

60.97

2.20

-0.03

99.70

6.05

-10.72 101.21 4.48
(-0.19)

1.34

0.39

19.25

-0.03

6.45

28.27

2.68

0.52

-13.56
(-0.34)

2.55

-0.04

0.38

32.63 -0.45

0.26

0.39

47.15 -1.61

0.33

0.40

77.27 -6.73

0.08

0.40

78.08 -4.91

0.07

0.02

Skewness

25.59 -0.37

12.05
(1.02)

37.69

4.56

0.42

18.16
(1.19)

60.76

6.60

0.04

(0.34)
-0.35

0.34

(0.30)

(1.56)

(0.06)
H-L

22.75

(2.01)

(0.11)
5(H)

17.60*

16.76 -0.16 -10.48

(1.17)

(1.73)

(0.54)
4

11.93

Success of
MA Strategy

2

2.33 -25.81 -0.49

Sharpe
Ratio

(0.94)

11.03** 14.27

Sharpe
Ratio

0.34

Skewness

0.55

Standard
Deviation

Sharpe
Ratio

22.14

Average
Return

Skewness

11.54

Standard
Deviation

MA(10) Timings Quantiles

Panel C
Performance of MA Investment
Timing
Strategy
MAGs

Average
Return

Volatility Quantiles	&#13;  

Standard
Deviation

1(L)

MA Investment Timing Strategy

Panel B

Average
Return

Ranks	&#13;  

Panel A	&#13;  
Buy-and-Hold
Strategy	&#13;  

4.52
(0.29)

61.79

4.52

-0.32

-2.83
(0.07)

Table 1 summarizes various aspects of returns (performance) on quantiles, MA (10
days) timing groups, and the respective MAGs. In Panel-A, we report several
statistics of returns on five volatility quantile groups under buy-and-hold strategy
namely average return, standard deviation, skewness, and Sharpe ratio. Table 1 also
represents the performance of differential quantile, the difference between the
highest and the lowest quantile, as its last row. The insignificance of average returns
across all groups suggests we do not have substantial evidence supporting the
performance of the buy-and-hold strategy in either way. Despite the fact, we
comment on the results as follows. The rising volatility and decreasing average
10

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Performance of Moving Average Investment Timing Strategy in UK Stock Market:
Individual Stocks versus Portfolios	&#13;  

returns lead to a dipping Sharpe ratio across quantiles. More importantly, increasing
skewness across most quantile groups indicates that the groups accompany a higher
chance for significant positive returns.
Panel-B shows that only the returns of the first, 11.03% per annum, and the third
group, 17.6% per annum, are significant. However, relaxing the level of significance
a bit, the returns of second and fourth groups, with t-stats 1.73 and 1.56 respectively
(reasonably close to 1.96), may also qualify for significance. Now the results of 10days moving average timing strategy make sense in that the average returns on most
MA groups are not only higher than that of buy-and-hold strategy but are an
increasing function of quantiles, except the fifth and differential groups. However,
for all quantiles, the standard deviations of MA groups are substantially lower than
buy-and-hold groups. Consider a case of the lowest and the highest groups an
example. The annualized standard deviation of the lowest and the highest groups
under buy-and-hold strategy are 22.14% and 99.70% respectively; whereas the same
groups produce the standard deviations as 14.27% and 60.76% in case of MA
strategy. The findings also depict that the average returns of all groups have sizeable
positive skewness which ranges between 1.34 and 6.60; though it also shows an
increasing trend from the second to the highest group. However, first and
differential groups are an exception here. It points out the fact that all MA group
returns not only have the chance to produce substantial positive returns, but the
volatility enhances this chance for most MA groups indeed. Since four MA quantiles,
second, though the highest, enjoy increasing average returns with lower standard
deviations, as directly opposed to buy-and-hold groups, they yield positive Sharpe
ratios. Although inconsistent across quantiles, most of the findings in Panel-B appear
to suggest that MA strategy performs slightly better than buy-and-hold strategy in
timing individual stocks.
Panel-C shows the superior performance results of MAGs, the difference between
MA returns and volatility quantile returns. The average returns across all quantiles
are not significant. Therefore, the results provide no evidence supporting the
superior performance of MA strategy over buy-and-hold strategy. Additionally, we
comment on the remaining results of Panel-C as follow. As compared to volatility
groups, MAG groups yield mixed findings regarding lower standard deviations,
higher Sharpe ratios, and, most importantly, negative skewness across most of the
quantiles. Negative skewness indicates the possibility of significant negative returns
by MAGs. When comparing among volatility, MA, and MAG quantiles, we also
note that the standard deviations of MAGs fall somewhere between the standard
deviations of corresponding MA and volatility quantiles, lower than that of volatility
quantiles but higher than MA quantiles. Finally, the success ratios across most
Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

11

�Muhammad Ishfaq Ahmad, Wang Ghohui, Mudassar Hasan, Anika Sattar, Muneeb Ahmad,
Ramiz Ur Rehman	&#13;  

MAGs, ranging from 34% to 40%, point towards failure instead. Hence, Panel-C
does not provide sufficient evidence in support of MA strategy outperforming the
buy-and-hold strategy.
To conclude the discussion on results presented in Table 1, it is evident that based
upon average returns of groups, we fail to conclude that MA timing strategy
outperforms the buy-and-hold strategy when applied to individual stocks-despite of
the fact that MA strategy yields some higher returns and low standard deviations.
Instead, the results of skewness, Sharpe ratio, and success ratio indicate otherwise.
However, the results are too inconsistent to draw any conclusion whatsoever. We
further attempt to explain MAGs by using a risk-based model that is Capital Asset
Pricing Model (CAPM)
b. Explanation of MAGs Using CAPM Regression

3
4
5(H)
H-L

Adj.R2
(%)

2

βMKT

1(L)

Α

Rank

Table 2: CAPM Results

2.38
(1.18)
3.38
(0.32)
12.18
(1.04)
18.39
(1.22)
4.93
(0.30)
8.25
(0.81)

-0.15**
(-8.53)
-0.26**
(-11.32)
-0.27**
(-9.10)
-0.22**
(-4.83)
-0.18**
(-2.42)
-0.21**
(-7.24)

5.05
5.71
4.56
1.64
0.43
3.48

Table 2 shows the results of CAPM regressions run between excess returns on groups (MAGs) and excess returns on
the market under theMA-10 strategy. Adjusted r-squares are in percentages. Annualized alphas and betas also
accompany t-stats in parenthesis. **, * denote the results are significant at 1% and 5% levels respectively. The sample
period is from December 31, 1999, to February 29, 2016. See Data and Methodology Sectionfor calculations and
other details.

Table 2 reports the results of regression for MAGs produced by 10-day moving
average (MA-10) timing strategy. Note again that all risk-adjusted returns, the
alphas, are insignificant. At one hand, the betas of all MAG quantiles are negative,
highly significant, and range from -.15 to -.26 across quantiles; on the other hand,
adjusted R2 for most of the MAGs that varies from .43% to 5.71% across quantiles
are extremely low. Low R2 also confirms that stock returns, and ultimately MAGs,
are highly volatile. Hence, coupling together results, beta and adjusted R2, MAG
12

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Performance of Moving Average Investment Timing Strategy in UK Stock Market:
Individual Stocks versus Portfolios	&#13;  

returns do not move against the market. Moreover, excess market returns do not
explain MAG returns well. Therefore, as the analysis does not offer evidence
supporting the profitability of MA timing strategy, we can reasonably conclude that
the results of Table 1 and Table 2 support each other.

Robustness Checks
Now, we test the robustness of these results in following two ways. First, we assess
the performance (profitability) of MA strategy by using alternative lags, for instance,
lag lengths with 20, 50, 100, 200 days. Then, we investigate the trading dynamics of
MA strategy while accounting for transaction costs.
a. Alternative Lag Lengths
Table 3: MA Strategy Results

1(L)

2

3

4

5(H)

H-L

Α

Random Switching
Average Return

α

Average Return

MAG-200

α

Average Return

MAG-100

α

MAG-50
Average Return

Α

Average Return

Rank

MAG-20

-0.93

1.81

-1.91

0.79

-2.73

-0.01

-2.75

-0.05

1.76

-0.60

(1.03)

(1.03)

(0.73)

(0.72)

(0.55)

(0.55)

(0.45)

(0.45)

(0.02)

(-0.32)

1.54

2.35

0.27

0.98

-0.51

0.17

-0.07

0.66

5.77

6.52

(0.18)

(0.19)

(0.00)

(0.01)

(-0.11)

(-0.11)

(-0.07)

(-0.06)

(0.03)

(1.04)

9.77

9.93

7.75

7.92

5.99

6.22

5.08

5.31

4.95

10.76

(0.83)

(0.85)

(0.52)

(0.54)

(0.36)

(0.38)

(0.28)

(0.30)

(0.01)

(1.38)

15.62

15.86

12.29

12.54

9.26

9.53

7.79

8.06

-0.88

-7.50

(1.00)

(1.03)

(0.75)

(0.78)

(0.55)

(0.58)

(0.44)

(0.46)

(0.00)

(-0.92)

1.65

2.05

1.78

2.19

2.33

2.78

1.50

1.95

4.75

20.34

(0.15)

(0.17)

(0.10)

(0.11)

(0.07)

(0.09)

(0.04)

(0.06)

(0.01)

(1.16)

-4.94

6.40

-3.83

4.88

0.91

3.73

2.22

3.18

3.58

1.92

(-0.03)

(0.65)

(-0.02)

(0.43)

(0.02)

(0.30)

(0.02)

(0.24)

(0.03)

(0.53)

Table 3 presents the results of MA strategy when applied for alternative lag lengths namely 20-day, 50-day, 100-day,
and 200-day. We also report the results of random strategy.All average returns and CAPM alphas are annualized
with t-stats provided in parenthesis. **, * denote the results are significant at 1% and 5% levels respectively. The
sample period is from December 31, 1999, to February 29, 2016. See Data and Methodology Section for
calculations and other details.

Table 3 depicts the average returns and CAPM alphas of MAGs for alternative lag
lengths. All alternative lag lengths bring similar findings as lag-10. Unfortunately, we
find no average return and alphas as significant. For making a further comparison
with MA strategy, last part of Table 3 reports the performance results, the average
Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

13

�Muhammad Ishfaq Ahmad, Wang Ghohui, Mudassar Hasan, Anika Sattar, Muneeb Ahmad,
Ramiz Ur Rehman	&#13;  

return, and alpha, generated by random switching strategy. The results indicate that
the random switching strategy does not produce substantial results because all
average returns and alphas are found extremely small and insignificant. Finally, after
combining the results of MAG-10 with Table 3, the insignificance of all results
provides no evidence to conclude that MA strategy performs better than buy-andhold strategy when applied to individual stocks.
b. Trading Behavior
Table 4: Trading Behavior

BETC

Trading Fraction

No. of Trades

Holding Period

MA-200

BETC

Trading Fraction

No. of Trades

Holding Period

MA-100

BETC

No. of Trades

Trading Fraction

Holding Period

MA-50

BETC

Trading Fraction

No. of Trades

Holding Period

MA-20

BETC

Trading Fraction

No. of Trades

Rank

Holding Period

MA-10

1(L) 127.08 296 0.07 31.75 151.65 202 0.05 43.28 190.80 125 0.03 56.93 223.78 87 0.02 58.19 253.87 59 0.01 64.18
2

41.65 423 0.10 33.20 56.81 285 0.07 43.27 79.48 169 0.04 56.50 102.40 116 0.03 72.61 128.58 76 0.02 97.51

3

34.82 382 0.09 63.23 53.71 255 0.06 84.28 96.06 151 0.04 121.08 115.06 104 0.03 143.56 141.86 70 0.02 164.25

4

35.01 319 0.08 83.14 51.11 214 0.05 106.00 78.87 125 0.03 149.98 103.37 86 0.02 177.40 134.95 58 0.01 242.84

5(H) 31.09 281 0.07 36.59 46.28 196 0.05 42.52 66.49 119 0.03 56.81 94.16 80 0.02 102.74 124.90 56 0.01 158.65

Table 4 states the number of trades, fraction of trading days (trading fraction), average holding period, and BETCs
(breakeven transaction costs measured in basis points) for each MA quantile across all lag lengths. The sample period
is from December 31, 1999, to February 29, 2016. See Data and Methodology Section for calculations and other
details.

Table 4 reports the results of the average holding period, no. of trades, a fraction of
trading days, and breakeven transaction costs (BETC) of MA strategy for each
quantile across all lag lengths. Note that BETC is the transaction cost which makes
the MAG average return equal to zero. As discussed in Material and Method section,
the fundamental notion of MA strategy is to use daily signals to make trades. Here
the primary concern is the frequency of trading since it has to do with transaction
costs. The more the strategy trades, the higher the transaction costs would be.
Therefore, too many trades can make the survival of abnormal returns vulnerable to
transaction costs. It necessitates seeing whether these abnormal returns can still hold
after offsetting for transactions costs. As groups are formed based upon volatility, the
performance of MA strategy should improve as we move towards groups with higher
volatility. That is, for MA strategy to be successful, following results should hold:

14

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Performance of Moving Average Investment Timing Strategy in UK Stock Market:
Individual Stocks versus Portfolios	&#13;  

from the lowest to the highest quantile, no. of trades and a fraction of trading should
rise whereas average holding period, and BETC should fall. See how results in Table
4 meet these criteria.
Note that no. of trades, trading fraction, and BETC for the second to fourth
quantile show opposite trend, except for the highest and the lowest quantiles. One
can easily see that irrespective of the lag length, as volatility rises, no. of trades and
fraction of trading days tend to decline while BETC rises. However, holding period
tends to fall with rising volatility. Despite the fact, all BETCs are relatively large and
well above the actual transaction costs in the UK (.45bp to 1.35pb)1,the majority of
our results go against the success of MA strategy. Therefore, most of the evidence
presented inTable4 lead to the reverse conclusion, that is, across all lag lengths and
most quantiles, MA strategy trades less with increasing transaction costs. Therefore,
we can finally conclude that when MA investment timing strategy is applied to the
individual stocks, most of the results provide no evidence of its superior performance
as compared to buy-and-hold strategy. Instead results of trading behavior indicate
towards the failure of MA strategy.

A Note on Insignificant Results quoted
In statistical analysis, as the holding period gets shortened, the likeliness of data
showing random noise increases (Brigham &amp; Ehrhardt, 2013), and this may be the
reason why most of the results are insignificant. Remember t-stat is also known as
signal-to-noise ratio. Here signal and noise are represented by average return and
standard error respectively. Notably, Table1 depicts most of the average returns to be
quite healthy but having more substantial standard deviations. It leads to more
significant standard errors, which substantially lower the t-stats. So, it may be argued
that the daily returns on which the whole analysis is based be quite noisy, making the
most results insignificant. The comparison of performance results of individual
stocks and portfolios is evident in the following section.

Portfolios versus Individual Stocks- Performance of MA Strategy
Now, we are in a position to compare the results of MA strategy for portfolios and
individual stocks.

	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;   	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  

1 As quoted by Trading Services Price List (On-Exchange and OTC) published by London Stock Exchange, effective from February 1,
2016.

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

15

�Muhammad Ishfaq Ahmad, Wang Ghohui, Mudassar Hasan, Anika Sattar, Muneeb Ahmad,
Ramiz Ur Rehman	&#13;  

0.19

11.93

22.75 1.34

0.39

43.50

0.82

0.07

17.60* 28.27 2.68

0.52

60.97

2.20

-0.03

(4.02)

(0.89)
3

5.60

5(H)
H-L

1.15

(0.11)
1.99
99.70 6.05
(0.06)
-10.72 101.21 4.48

-0.03
-0.35

(-0.19)
Portfolios
1(L)

3.33**
5.04*
3.19

8.80

-1.21

-1.51

20.20** 12.83
(6.14)

0.26

0.39

0.04
-0.32

18.16
(1.19)
4.52
(0.29)
-2.83

47.15 -1.61

0.33

0.40

77.27 -6.73

0.08

0.40

78.08 -4.91

0.07

0.02

8.39**

3.90

2.91

1.42

0.61

-0.59

2.4

10.34** 7.03

1.94

1.06

0.58

0.16

2.45 14.55** 8.50

1.99

1.37

0.58

0.52

2.74 23.22** 9.45

2.13

2.15

0.60

4.12 22.49** 10.42 1.88

1.88

0.61

1.31

0.30

(8.37)
(5.72)
(6.67)
(9.56)

1.37 46.18** 10.49 1.57
(17.14)
1.35 34.50** 9.93
(13.53)

MAPs

3.09

(12.28)

0.51

32.63 -0.45

-0.50

(11.39)
11.86 -1.04 -0.36 21.78** 6.91

23.54** 15.06 -0.22

12.05

(0.07)

(11.49)

(6.09)
H-L

0.25 15.35** 5.20

10.51 -1.11 0.034 17.75** 6.06

(-0.49)
5(H)

0.42

(15.91)

(1.18)
4

0.38

MA(10) Timings Strategy

-1.70 0.103 11.68** 2.86

(2.23)
3

(1.56)
6.45 60.76 6.60
(0.34)
-13.56 61.79 4.52

4.89

(2.66)
2

25.59 -0.37 -0.04

(1.02)
37.69 4.56

(-0.34)

Buy and Hold Strategy

2.55
(0.30)

(2.01)
19.25

16.76 -0.16 -10.48 0.34

(1.17)

(1.73)

(0.54)
4

The success of MA Strategy

0.61

9.38

-0.49

Skewness

34.45

(0.94)
2

Sharpe Ratio

0.34 11.03** 14.27 2.33 -25.81

Skewness

0.55

Average Return

22.14

Sharpe Ratio

11.54

Standard Deviation

MAGs

Average Return

MA(10) Timings Strategy
Standard Deviation

Buy-and-Hold Strategy

Skewness

Panel C

Standard Deviation

1(L)

Panel B

Average Return

Ranks

Panel A

Sharpe Ratio

Table 5: Comparison of Table 1

(8.40)
1.64

3.18 14.10** 8.60

0.60

(6.37)

See Table 5 for this comparison. It contains information of portfolios as well as
individual stocks. It is evident that applying MA strategy to portfolios brings better
16

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Performance of Moving Average Investment Timing Strategy in UK Stock Market:
Individual Stocks versus Portfolios	&#13;  

results than to individual stocks-which accompany inconclusive evidence. Mostly,
MA portfolios not just produce significantly positive and increasing returns, lower
standard deviations, and higher Sharpe and success ratios relative to individual
stocks-MA groups, but they also perform better than buy-and-hold portfolios. There
could be two reasons for this superior performance- noise in daily returns and
diversification effect. Impact of noise can easily be seen in the form of higher
standard deviations and ultimately lower t-stats for all individual stock groups.
Moreover, the better portfolio returns with lower standard deviations may also imply
the benefits of diversification.
Table 6: Comparison of Table 2
Rank

Individual Stock Group MAGs
Α
Adj.R2(%)
βMKT
2.38
-0.15**
5.05
(1.18)
(-8.53)
3.38
-0.26**
5.71
(0.32)
(-11.32)
12.18
-0.27**
4.56
(1.04)
(-9.10)
18.39
-0.22**
1.64
(1.22)
(-4.83)
4.93
-0.18*
0.43
(0.30)
(-2.42)
8.25
-0.21**
3.48
(0.81)
(-7.24)

1(L)
2
3
4
5(H)
H-L

α
8.47**
(10.13)
10.52**
(7.72)
14.77**
(9.11)
23.45**
(12.37)
22.67**
(9.45)
14.19**
(6.69)

Portfolio MAPs
βMKT
-0.11**
(-41.41)
-0.24**
(-54.77)
-0.30**
(-56.62)
-0.31**
(-50.31)
-0.24**
(-31.05)
-0.13**
(-18.79)

Adj.R2(%)
30.28
43.18
44.82
39.07
19.62
8.19

The Table 6 is highlighting some more features. When comparing with individual
stocks, note all portfolio alphas are highly significant and increasing. Similarly, all
betas accompany bigger t-stats and with substantially higher adjusted r squares.
Table 7: Comparison of Table 3
Groups
MAG-20
Rank Average
A
Return
1(L)

2

3

4

5(H)

MAG-50
Average
α
Return

MAG-100
Average
α
Return

MAG-200
Average
A
return

Random Switching
Average
Α
Return

-0.93

1.81

-1.91

0.79

-2.73

-0.01

-2.75

-0.05

1.76

-0.60

(1.03)

(1.03)

(0.73)

(0.72)

(0.55)

(0.55)

(0.45)

(0.45)

(0.02)

(-0.32)

1.54

2.35

0.27

0.98

-0.51

0.17

-0.07

0.66

5.77

6.52

(0.18)

(0.19)

(0.00)

(0.01)

(-0.11)

(-0.11)

(-0.07)

(-0.06)

(0.03)

(1.04)

9.77

9.93

7.75

7.92

5.99

6.22

5.08

5.31

4.95

10.76

(0.83)

(0.85)

(0.52)

(0.54)

(0.36)

(0.38)

(0.28)

(0.30)

(0.01)

(1.38)

15.62

15.86

12.29

12.54

9.26

9.53

7.79

8.06

-0.88

-7.50

(1.00)

(1.03)

(0.75)

(0.78)

(0.55)

(0.58)

(0.44)

(0.46)

(0.00)

(-0.92)

1.65

2.05

1.78

2.19

2.33

2.78

1.50

1.95

4.75

20.34

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

17

�Muhammad Ishfaq Ahmad, Wang Ghohui, Mudassar Hasan, Anika Sattar, Muneeb Ahmad,
Ramiz Ur Rehman	&#13;  
Table 7 (Continued)
(0.15)
H-L

(0.10)

(0.11)

(0.07)

(0.09)

(0.04)

(0.06)

(0.01)

(1.16)

-4.94

6.40

-3.83

4.88

0.91

3.73

2.22

3.18

3.58

1.92

(-0.03)

(0.65)

(-0.02)

(0.43)

(0.02)

(0.30)

(0.02)

(0.24)

(0.03)

(0.53)

Portfolios
1(L)

(0.17)

MAP-20

MAP-50

MAP-100

MAP-200

Random Switching

8.41**

8.48**

7.37**

7.47**

6.64**

6.74**

4.59**

4.8**

2.58

0.65

(8.36)

(10.12)

(7.37)

(9.06)

(6.94)

(8.48)

(5.40)

(6.61)

(0.04)

(0.84)

2

9.93** 10.08** 8.14**

8.36**

7.93**

8.19**

5.23**

5.74**

3.42

1.42

(5.34)

(6.24)

(4.37)

(6.2)

(3.16)

(4.62)

(0.03)

(1.08)

3

13.02** 13.2** 11.67** 11.95** 10.45** 10.78** 6.17**

6.84**

2.54

0.51

(2.88)

(4.34)

(0.02)

(0.33)

21.05** 21.24** 17.86** 18.16** 14.49** 14.84** 8.92**

9.69**

0.23

-1.79

(5.88)
4

(8.51)
5(H)

(8.22)

(11.17)

(4.41)

(5.12)

(9.53)

(4.60)

(6.69)

(7.72)

(3.54)

(5.11)

(0.00)

(-0.96)

19.82** 19.97** 14.16** 14.37** 7.47**

7.71**

0.40

0.91

12.81

10.80**

(5.10)

(5.78)

(2.70)

(3.11)

(0.15)

(0.38)

(0.07)

(4.21)

11.41** 11.48** 6.78**

6.89**

0.82

0.96

-4.19

-3.88

11.12

9.18**

(3.1)

(0.35)

(0.42)

(-1.83)

(-1.77)

(0.06)

(4.03)

(5.11)

(8.3)

(7.01)

(7.39)

(5.62)

(7.38)
H-L

(7.4)

(5.37)

(2.92)

Table 7 also supports the better performance of MA strategy for portfolios as most of
the average returns and alphas are significant across all portfolios, overall lag lengths,
except random switching which do not provide robust results even in case of
portfolios.
Table 8: Comparison of Table 4

BETC

Trading Fraction

No. of Trades

Avg. Holding Period

MA-200

BETC

No. of Trades

Trading Fraction

Avg. Holding Period

MA-100

BETC

Trading Fraction

No. of Trades

Avg. Holding Period

MA-50

BETC

Trading Fraction

No. of Trades

Avg. Holding Period

MA-20

BETC

No. of Trades

Trading Fraction

Avg. Holding Period

Rank

MA-10

1(L) 127.08 296 0.070 31.75 151.65 202 0.048 43.28 190.80 125 0.030 56.93 223.78 87 0.021 58.19 253.87 59 0.015 64.18
2

41.65 423 0.100 33.20 56.81 285 0.068 43.27 79.48 169 0.041 56.50 102.40 116 0.028 72.61 128.58 76 0.018 97.51

3

34.82 382 0.091 63.23 53.71 255 0.060 84.28 96.06 151 0.036 121.08 115.06 104 0.025 143.56 141.86 70 0.018 164.25

18

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Performance of Moving Average Investment Timing Strategy in UK Stock Market:
Individual Stocks versus Portfolios	&#13;  
Table 8 (Continued)
4

35.01 319 0.076 83.14 51.11 214 0.051 106.00 78.87 125 0.030 149.98 103.37 86 0.021 177.40 134.95 58 0.014 242.84

5(H) 31.09 281 0.067 36.59 46.28 196 0.046 42.52 66.49 119 0.029 56.81 94.16 80 0.019 102.74 124.90 56 0.014 158.65
MA-10

MA-20

MA-50

MA-100

MA-200

1(L) 9.64 408 0.100 31.22 15.93 246 0.062 51.80 29.14 133 0.034 83.36 60.25 63 0.016 156.39 70.86 52 0.013 127.75
2

8.71 452 0.110 34.74 14.41 272 0.069 55.32 22.19 175 0.044 69.93 52.10 73 0.018 161.32 76.65 48 0.012 157.72

3

8.96 439 0.110 50.33 13.81 284 0.072 69.42 25.52 152 0.038 115.40 56.70 67 0.017 231.55 70.86 52 0.013 171.62

4

9.81 401 0.100 87.92 15.80 248 0.062 128.56 31.24 124 0.031 216.51 45.36 84 0.021 255.97 61.57 60 0.015 215.02

5(H) 10.17 387 0.098 88.23 16.46 238 0.060 126.00 35.50 109 0.027 195.22 44.83 85 0.022 130.39 72.23 51 0.013 11.41

Table 8 which showsthe trading behavior of both strategies brings almost similar
results. In both cases, we observe opposite trends across quantile and groups. Instead
of increasing, no. of trades and trading fraction tend to fall. On the other hand,
BETC rises across portfolios and groups instead of falling, however, remains well
above the actual transaction cost in the UK.

Conclusion
First, we apply MA investment timing strategy to the groups of individual stocks
sorted by volatility. The fact that overwhelming majority of results under MA or
buy-and-hold strategies are insignificant helps to maintain that there is no evidence
to support the superiority of either strategy when applied to individual stocks.
However, trading behavior and success ratios across groups provide some mixed
results while indicating more towards the failure of MA strategy. We argue that
prevalent noise in daily stock return data is the reason for such consistency in
insignificant results.
Second, when applied to volatility-sorted portfolios, MA strategy substantially beats
the buy-and-hold strategy by yielding higher average return and risk-adjusted return,
lower standard deviation, large-and-positive skewness and Sharpe ratio, and
considerable success ratios across portfolios. Both for individual stocks and
portfolios, returns and especially trading behavior suggest that the performance of
MA strategy diminishes as we go farther in history; that is, the longer the lag length,
the worse the performance.

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

19

�Muhammad Ishfaq Ahmad, Wang Ghohui, Mudassar Hasan, Anika Sattar, Muneeb Ahmad,
Ramiz Ur Rehman	&#13;  

References
Allen, F., &amp; Karjalainen, R. (1999). Using genetic algorithms to find technical
trading rules1. Journal of financial economics, 51(2), 245-271.
Brigham, E. F., &amp; Ehrhardt, M. C. (2013). Financial management: Theory &amp;
practice: Cengage Learning.
Brock, W., Lakonishok, J., &amp; LeBaron, B. (1992). Simple technical trading rules
and the stochastic properties of stock returns. The Journal of finance, 47(5), 17311764.
Han, Y., Yang, K., &amp; Zhou, G. (2013). A new anomaly: The cross-sectional
profitability of technical analysis. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,
48(5), 1433-1461.
Han, Y., Zhou, G., &amp; Zhu, Y. (2016). A trend factor: Any economic gains from
using information over investment horizons? Journal of financial economics, 122(2),
352-375.
Hoffmann, A. O., &amp; Shefrin, H. (2014). Technical analysis and individual investors.
Journal of Economic Behavior &amp; Organization, 107, 487-511.
Hudson, R., Dempsey, M., &amp; Keasey, K. (1996). A note on the weak form
efficiency of capital markets: The application of simple technical trading rules to UK
stock prices-1935 to 1994. Journal of Banking &amp; Finance, 20(6), 1121-1132.
Kwon, K.-Y., &amp; Kish, R. J. (2002). Technical trading strategies and return
predictability: NYSE. Applied Financial Economics, 12(9), 639-653.
Lukac, L. P., &amp; Brorsen, B. W. (1990). A comprehensive test of futures market
disequilibrium. Financial Review, 25(4), 593-622.
Metghalchi, M., Marcucci, J., &amp; Chang, Y.-H. (2012). Are moving average trading
rules profitable? Evidence from the European stock markets. Applied Economics,
44(12), 1539-1559.
Mills, T. C. (1997). Technical analysis and the London Stock Exchange: Testing
trading rules using the FT30. International Journal of Finance &amp; Economics, 2(4),
319-331.
20

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Performance of Moving Average Investment Timing Strategy in UK Stock Market:
Individual Stocks versus Portfolios	&#13;  

Neely, C. J. (1997). Technical analysis in the foreign exchange market: a layman's
guide. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review(Sep), 23-38.
Roberts, M. C. (2005). Technical analysis and genetic programming: constructing
and testing a commodity portfolio. Journal of Futures Markets, 25(7), 643-660.
Shintani, M., Yabu, T., &amp; Nagakura, D. (2012). Spurious regressions in technical
trading. Journal of Econometrics, 169(2), 301-309.
Sullivan, R., Timmermann, A., &amp; White, H. (1999). Data‐snooping, technical
trading rule performance, and the bootstrap. The Journal of finance, 54(5), 16471691.
Taylor, M. P., &amp; Allen, H. (1992). The use of technical analysis in the foreign
exchange market. Journal of international Money and Finance, 11(3), 304-314.
Wei, L.-Y., Cheng, C.-H., &amp; Wu, H.-H. (2014). A hybrid ANFIS based on nperiod moving average model to forecast TAIEX stock. Applied Soft Computing, 19,
86-92.
Zhou, G., &amp; Zhu, Y. (2013). An equilibrium model of moving-average
predictability and time-series momentum. Unpublished working paper, Washington
University in St. Louis.

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

21

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="79">
            <name>Extent</name>
            <description>The size or duration of the resource.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="877">
                <text>3744</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="878">
                <text>Performance of Moving Average Investment Timing Strategy  in UK Stock Market: Individual Stocks versus Portfolios</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="96">
            <name>Author</name>
            <description>Author</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="879">
                <text>Ahmad, Muhammad Ishfaq
Ghohui, Wang
Hasan, Mudassar
Sattar, Anika
Ahmad, Muneeb
Rehman, Ramiz Ur</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="94">
            <name>Abstract</name>
            <description>A summary of the resource.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="880">
                <text>Abstract: This paper aims to test whether moving average (MA) investment  timing strategy is applicable on individual stocks, portfolios formed from these  stocks, or both. Moreover, our objective is to compare the performance of MA  strategy with a buy-and-hold strategy. The data on individual stocks listed on  London Stock Exchange, United Kingdom (UK) is collected over the period  starting from December 31, 1999, through February 29, 2016. For the same  period, we use daily values of UK-DS Market-PRICE INDEX and 1-Month  Treasury bill rate. The paper follows Han et al. (2013) to peruse our  investigation. The study applies both MA and buy-and-hold strategies to  individual stocks and portfolios sorted by volatility. Since most results are  found insignificant, no evidence is found to support that one strategy is better  than the other when applied to individual stocks. However, trading behavior  and success ratios across groups provide mixed results, hinting slightly towards  the failure of MA strategy. The pervasive noise in daily stock return data is  the reason why MA strategy consistently produces insignificant results.  Moreover, when applied to volatility-sorted portfolios, MA strategy  substantially beats buy-and-hold strategy by yielding higher average return  and risk-adjusted returns, lower standard deviations, large-and-positive  skewness and Sharpe ratios, and much success ratios across portfolios. Both for  individual stocks and portfolios, dynamics of returns and especially trading  behavior suggest that the performance of MA strategy decreases with rising lag  lengths, meaning MA signal weakens for a longer history.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="45">
            <name>Publisher</name>
            <description>An entity responsible for making the resource available</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="881">
                <text>International Burch University</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="882">
                <text>2018</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="97">
            <name>Keywords</name>
            <description>Keywords.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="883">
                <text>Article
PeerReviewed</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="98">
            <name>DOI</name>
            <description>Digital object identifier</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="884">
                <text>doi: "10.14706/JECOSS17722 "     </text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="885">
                <text>ISSN 1986-8499; </text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="11">
        <name>H Social Sciences (General),HB Economic Theory</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="116" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="118">
        <src>https://omeka.ibu.edu.ba/files/original/a4acbbf36d796eb8cbba76c83aa65af0.docx</src>
        <authentication>156d72fd351bb766e04eb4f1381219f5</authentication>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="79">
            <name>Extent</name>
            <description>The size or duration of the resource.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="887">
                <text>3778</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="888">
                <text>Semantic preference and semantic prosody-a theoretical overview</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="96">
            <name>Author</name>
            <description>Author</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="889">
                <text>Begagić, Mirna</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="94">
            <name>Abstract</name>
            <description>A summary of the resource.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="890">
                <text>Abstract: Semantic preference and semantic prosody are two notions that were carefully analysed in post-Firthian corpus linguistics and in the past few years there has been a growing interest in them. As corpora have become larger in size, and tools for extracting different lexical items for different purposes have been developed, the two terms have been addressed more frequently by linguists1. Throughout history, semantic preference and semantic prosody have sometimes been used for the same phenomenon but at other times the two were considered different but closely related. Previous corpus-based studies on the two terms have shown that they can be attached to many investigated lexical items. Therefore, this paper aims to present a detailed theoretical overview of the two terms in order to emphasise their immense importance for identifying the meaning of all the lexical items.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="45">
            <name>Publisher</name>
            <description>An entity responsible for making the resource available</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="891">
                <text>International Burch University</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="892">
                <text>2018</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="97">
            <name>Keywords</name>
            <description>Keywords.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="893">
                <text>Article
PeerReviewed</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="894">
                <text>ISSN 2566-4638    (In Press)  </text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="4">
        <name>P Philology. Linguistics,PA Classical philology</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="117" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="119">
        <src>https://omeka.ibu.edu.ba/files/original/186831be8e1cb0b34e1be41a2462c77b.pdf</src>
        <authentication>3c0c1c4c723a5af6ffb421922e8395f7</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="904">
                    <text>	&#13;  
	&#13;  

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

Labour Market Transition Differences between Natives and
Immigrants in EU Economies
Valerija Botrić
The Institute of Economics, Zagreb
vbotric@eizg.hr

Abstract: The recent economic crisis has had an adverse effect on the
labour markets of European economies and certain population groups

	&#13;  

have been disproportionally affected by it. Increased migration flows

Keywords: immigrant-native

gap, labour market transitions,
European cross-country
differences, crisis.

may very well have created further pressures on the labour markets of
host countries. The focus of the analysis here is on differences in
transitions from unemployment to employment and vice versa
between native and immigrant populations in European economies
during the 1998-2015 period. The analysis reveals different
outcomes to transitions from unemployment to employment, where in
certain countries and years, the unemployed natives find

JEL Classification: F22, J15
Article History
Submitted: 24.5.2017
Resubmitted: 26.2.2018
Accepted:1.6.2018

http://dx.doi.org/10.14706/JE
COSS17723

proportionally more jobs, while in other countries and years, it is the
immigrants. In most of the countries, however, employed immigrants
are more likely to lose a job than natives. In addition to identifying
the immigrant-native gap, the characteristics of individuals as
potential contributing factors to the gap have also been assessed. The
results of this analysis show that similar individual characteristics
exert a different influence on the immigrant-native gap in labour
market outcomes in different countries. Thus, similar individual
characteristics are rewarded differently in different countries, i.e.,
their labour markets.

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

22

�Labour Market Transition Differences between Natives and Immigrants in EU Economies	&#13;  

Introduction
Recent migration flows have overwhelmed European economies and raised
numerous political, economic, social and practical questions. Regardless of the origin
of immigrants and their reasons for moving to a host country, a key measure of the
relative success of the migration process addressed in economic discussions is based
on the integration of immigrants into the local labour market (OECD/European
Union, 2015). In view of the above, interactions between immigrants and the
domicile workforce gain public attention. Although competition between natives
and immigrants can be perceived as an important aspect in terms of access to welfare
services and education (Senik et al., 2009), the fear of competing for jobs frequently
becomes the dominate topic in public discussions. Hence, natives as incumbent
workers on local labour market are more likely to oppose increased immigration for
fear of losing their jobs or less opportunities for wage growth (Scheve and Slaughter,
2001; Ortega and Polavieja, 2012).
Even before the recent migration wave, similar issues have led to heated public
discussions on EU enlargement, regardless of the fact that the underlying economic
idea of the European Union project is the free movement of all resources (including
human). Some studies advocate the macroeconomic benefits of increased mobility,
such as an increase in the GDP per capita, increase in the
employment/unemployment rate and decrease in inflationary pressures
(Blanchflower and Shadforth, 2009; Kahanec et al, 2013; Del Boca and Venturini
2016; Elsner and Zimmermann 2016). Some studies argue that the welfare systems
of host countries are not additionally burdened by the arrival of immigrants
(Giulietti et al. 2013), predominately due to the fact that the migrant population is
usually younger than the average host population and is of working age, and
consequently are net contributors to social security systems if integrated successfully
in the host country’s labour market.
The recent recession has placed additional emphasis on the issue of labour market
outcomes of immigrants. An important finding is that immigrants have been more
affected by the economic crisis (Barrett and Kelly, 2012 for Ireland; RodríguezPlanas and Nollenberger, 2016 for Spain; Bratsberg, Raaum and Røed, 2018 for
Norway). Although relevant literature has identified this problem in individual
countries, a comparative cross-country perspective has not as yet been fully explored.
The present paper explores differences between transitions from unemployment to
employment and vice versa between natives and immigrants in the European Union
Old member states during the recent crisis. The emphasis is on transitions, since
changes in labour market status reveal whether immigrants face relatively more
adverse conditions than native populations. Even though the topic has been
Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

23

�Valerija Botric	&#13;  

addressed in the literature before, the main contribution of the paper is that it
provides a comparative approach for European economies. Thus, the analysis reveals
the immigrant-native gap and examines the contribution of different personal traits
to the gap across analysed countries. Due to self-selection of immigrants into
different countries, immigrants with different personal traits prevail in different
European economies. An interesting investigation is the manner in which the
personal characteristics of immigrants explain the immigrant-native gap across
Europe. The main contribution of the paper is to provide a comparative analysis of
labour market transitions between immigrant and native population during the latest
economic crisis. Additionally, in acknowledging the self-selection of immigrants into
different economies, the paper seeks to compare the personal traits that contribute to
the immigrant-native gap in different European economies.
The paper adopts the following structure. The first section briefly reviews the most
relevant findings from the literature. The next section discusses the methodology of
the empirical analysis in the paper. Section 3 presents the results and provides a
discussion, while the last section offers conclusions.

Literature Review
The population of immigrants in a country at any given point in time depends on a
number of very different factors. Hatton and Williamson (2005) examine world
migration in a historical perspective and propose that these include a variety of
economic and demographic factors. Some of these factors relate to characteristics of
home and host countries, such as distance, colonial relationship, trade relationship,
differences in economic performance and language similarities.
Extant studies focus on the contribution of migration to the receiving country’s
economy. On the macroeconomic level, Ortega and Peri (2014) document long-run
income per capita growth, driven by total factor productivity, reflecting increased
diversity in productive skills and innovation. In that framework, migrants are
depicted as workers desirable to local employers, enabling them to combine
diversities of native and immigrant labour to increase production. Still, there is no
consensus in the literature whether increased immigration will have a relatively small
(Grossman, 1982) or diverse and non-negligible effect (Orrenius and Zavodny,
2007) on the natives’ labour market outcomes.
The final results may depend on the ability of migrants to adjust to host country
conditions. Chiswick (1978) suggested that migrants sometimes lack specific skills,
which leads to migrant (self-)selection into low-skilled jobs and cohort effects.
24

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Labour Market Transition Differences between Natives and Immigrants in EU Economies	&#13;  

Additionally, both migrants (Chiswick, Rebhun and Beider, 2016) and their families
(Föbker and Imani, 2017) face language barriers in host countries. Another type of
barrier relates to the national orientation of the educational systems, leading to the
question of transferability of qualifications (Chapman and Iredale, 1993).These
obstacles imply higher financial costs of integration, which mostly lead to an
increased burden for the host country welfare system.
On the other hand, welfare systems in host countries may influence the skill
composition of immigrants. Borjas (1999) suggested that welfare services may attract
immigrants who otherwise would not have migrated, and then discourage them from
leaving their country of destination, by acting as a safety net. In this model, the host
country will receive positively self-selected migrants as long as the correlation
between the return to skills in the two countries is high and the dispersion in the
wage distribution is higher in the host country than in the source country.
The argument is additionally explained by Peri and Sparber (2009), who suggest that
immigrants and natives specialize in different tasks. Consequently, they do not
compete for the same job, but their work is considered complementary. However,
the question remains whether immigrants voluntarily self-select themselves into
manually intensive and relatively unskilled jobs or whether they are forced to seek
employment below their qualifications level. The fact that relatively inexpensive
labour is available could be desirable to employers, but not so welcomed by
incumbent employees.
Some authors argue that in the classic insider-outsider labour market framework,
immigrants are considered as outsiders, experiencing more difficulties in access to the
market than the native population (Marino et al. 2015). For example, Krings (2009)
documents that unions frequently campaign against immigration, because in their
view this increased supply-side competition increases the bargaining power of
employers and undermines incumbent employee rights. This leads to the incumbent
worker’s loss of market power and reduces the probability of negotiating a wage
increase. Accordingly, some authors argue that anti-immigration campaigns originate
for fear of social dumping (Meardi 2012). The question remains whether such
actions are additionally aggravated in times of economic downturn and relaxed
during phases of economic boom.
Aiyar et al. (2016) argue that gaps in activity, employment, unemployment rates and
wages between immigrants and natives can be related to the relatively slow
integration of immigrants into host country labour markets. The slow integration
process is not only due to inadequate or underdeveloped policies in the host
Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

25

�Valerija Botric	&#13;  

countries, but also due to the heterogeneity of immigrants. For example, those who
arrive on account of family reunification might not have job placement as their
primary goal, while those arriving for humanitarian reasons might be prohibited
from seeking work for the initial period due to host country regulations.
Studies on European economies corroborate findings that immigrants have lower
labour force participation, higher rates of unemployment, and are frequently
clustered in lower-paid jobs (Heath et al. 2008). Empirical studies investigating the
differences in labour market outcomes between immigrants and natives are relatively
abundant, but frequently focus on a single country (for example, Corluy and Verbist,
2014; Langevin et al, 2013), although there are estimates that cover employment
probability differences across European economies (Dustmann and Frattini, 2011).
Some authors argue that the relative outcomes of immigrants change during the
different stages of business cycle (Dustmann, Glitz and Vogel, 2010). There is some
evidence that the latest crisis exhibited previously undocumented features (de la Rica
and Polonyankina, 2013). However, most of the studies emphasize that, regardless of
the similarity in characteristics of the immigrant and native population, the
differences in their labour market outcomes persist, even in the case of high-skilled
immigrants (Grigoleti-Richter, 2017).
Since the heterogeneity of immigrants may be partly the answer, the present study
focuses on the labour market transitions. The underlying reason is that this approach
identifies those individuals who are employed and have documented attachment to a
labour market. In similar way, those who are unemployed (the ILO definition
assumes that they are actively seeking work) decide to participate in the host country
labour market and the reason for the differences in labour market outcomes is not
due to self-selection into participation.
Some studies show a strong impact of business cycles on immigrant labour market
outcomes, due to the differences in sectoral composition of employment in
comparison to the native population (Dustmann, Glitz and Vogel, 2010). Also,
migrants arriving during a recession encounter difficulties upon arrival, which then
persist, even when labour market conditions improve (Åslund and Rooth, 2007,
McDonald and Worswick, 1998).In that respect, the literature also notes that
immigrants are more likely than natives to end up not just in non-employment, but
also in self-employment (for example, Blume, et al (2009) in Denmark). Recently,
Garda (2016) analysed labour market transitions in OECD economies using
European Community Household Panel data. Significant differences between
countries have been found for the analysed period 2005-2012. For example, there
are high-transition countries where workers move from employment to joblessness

26

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Labour Market Transition Differences between Natives and Immigrants in EU Economies	&#13;  

(Austria, Finland, Portugal, Spain and Sweden) and low-frequency transition
countries (Belgium, the Czech Republic, France, Luxembourg, Poland, the Slovak
Republic and Slovenia). The rest of the paper is devoted to exploring the crosscountry differences of labour market transitions across European economies in more
detail.

Research Methodology
The analysis relies on the EU Labour Force Survey data for the period 1998-2015.
This data source provides comparable data for analysed countries. The aim of the
analysis was to include all the European economies for which the data was available.
However, since the dataset contains individual answers to the Survey1, in accordance
with the confidentiality threshold, each case that has up to three answers to a specific
question is considered as missing observations. Thus, the rest of the paper presents
only the data for which sufficient observations were achievable.
To distinguish between natives and immigrants, a simple indicator has been utilized
– if a person is citizen of a resident country, she is considered a native2. Otherwise,
she is considered immigrant. This approach yields different treatment of individuals
across countries, since each EU country has a separate regulation for acquiring
citizenship (Ritzen and Kahanec, 20017). As Dustmann and Frattini (2011) clarify,
there are in general two approaches regarding citizenship. The first refers to AngloSaxon countries which consider immigrants as those born outside their country of
residence. The other concept is related to citizenship, when people are born in the
country of residence, but are not entitled to citizenship based on the relevant
legislation. Regardless of the definition used in a country, the analysis in the paper
retains the same definition across the countries in order to maintain comparability.
To get additional insight, a different concept has also been applied. A person is
considered a native if (s)he was born in the country, while immigrants have been
divided into two categories – those born in other EU countries and other
	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;   	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  
1

According to the European Commission (2016, p. 6) in the case of LFS data available for scientific
purposes “In any reports, including all publications and unpublished papers, three cell size thresholds
will be distinguished for LFS results: confidentiality threshold: up to 3 observations (unweighted
sample), results must not be published”.
2
This definition is data-specific, since LFS does not contain data on a person’s immigration history. The
countries differ in their citizen acquisition policies, EU countries might have different policies towards
intra-EU migrants and some changes occurred in the process during the Great Recession (Alarian,
2017). This should be kept in mind when interpreting the results in the present study.

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

27

�Valerija Botric	&#13;  

immigrants3. According to the data, a person arriving from EU countries in the
period until 2004 relates to individuals from EU-15 countries, in the period 20052006 refers to individuals from EU-25 countries, in the period 2007- 2013 from
EU-27 countries, and after 2013 individual from EU-28 countries.
Since this paper focuses on labour market transitions, the sample is restricted to
persons aged 15-64. Two labour market transitions are analysed – (i) from
unemployment to employment and (ii) from employment to unemployment. In
each case the current labour market status is compared to the labour market status of
the same individual a year ago. Specifically, LFS contains a question on the current
labour market status and the status an individual had a year ago. A transition variable
is formed as a comparison between those two statuses. Due to the data source used,
other important questions concerning labour market outcomes (such as duration of
unemployment once the person losses a job or the frequency of unemployment
spells) are not covered in the present research.
The descriptive analysis focuses on the last available year (2015) and the evolution of
transitions in the period 1998-2015. In addition to the descriptive analysis, an
empirical analysis of contributions to the existing gap is performed based on data for
the year 2015. The empirical analysis focuses on countries where the descriptive
analysis has established that immigrants are in the most disadvantageous position.
The case of transitions from employment to unemployment involves those countries
exhibiting greatest evidence that immigrants lose disproportionally more jobs than
natives.
The empirical analysis rests on the well-established Fairlie (1999) methodology. The
methodology identifies and decomposes the overall gap between the two subgroups
into the contribution of each specific factor considered relevant. It is applied in cases
when the outcome is binary, such as in our case when observing whether a person
has made a transition or not. The significance of a specific factor for the outcome is
estimated in the underlying probit model (Fairlie, 2005). Once the significant
variables are identified, the methodology determines the degree to which the gap
between the outcomes can be explained by that specific variable.
Given that we want to explore transitions between labour market states, many of the
traditional variables used in analysing predictions of labour market outcomes are
perfectly correlated with changing the labour market status. For example, occupation
perfectly explains the transition from unemployment to employment. The same
	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;   	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  
3

Due to the previously mentioned confidentiality threshold, the data could not be disclosed for a
larger number of country-years.

28

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Labour Market Transition Differences between Natives and Immigrants in EU Economies	&#13;  

argument applies for the economic activity a person worked in/starts working in.
The choice of explanatory variables is governed by the data used, but their inclusion
is justified by the existing literature. Motivation for the choice of explanatory
variables is offered below:
• Sex of a person. Studies show that – even though on average women migrate as
frequently as men - family reunification is the main cause of female migration to
Australia, Canada, Europe, New Zealand, and the United States (Ghosh 2009).
Additionally, push factors, such as escaping home country (formal and informal)
discriminatory institutions can play an important role in a female’s decision to move
(Ferrant, et al 2014). The probability that females will be immediately integrated
into the host country labour market is lower, even though gender equality in the
workplace in the host country can be a strong pulling factor (Baudassé and Bazillier
2014). Even when participating in the labour market, women face difficulties.
Studies have found that migrant women may face double discrimination – as
migrants and as women (Ghosh, 2009). To address these issues, we included a
dummy variable that equals one if a person is male. Even though studies show that
migrant women are more vulnerable on the labour market, the recent crisis had
adverse effects on male workers. Studies reveal that women were less affected (Farris,
2015) so our initial assumption is that they will be less likely to lose a job, but we
cannot assume that they will be also more likely to gain employment. To the extent
that the effect of the crisis had a greater impact on male-related jobs (and in
particular in industries where the immigrant workforce is more strongly
represented), we expect that the sex of a person will be significant positive factor in
explaining the gap in immigrant-native transitions from employment to
unemployment. To the extent that the crisis brought about an additional shift
towards increased demand for traditional female occupations and thus contributed
to the activation of the female labour force, we expect that the sex of a person will be
significant negative factor contributing to the gap in immigrant-native transitions
from unemployment to employment.
• Age of a person. This is a standard predictor for labour market outcomes.
Literature provides evidence that European youth have been hit more by the recent
economic crisis (Bruno, Marelli, Signorelli, 2014). Even in boom periods, youths
frequently change careers (in some countries more frequently than others), meaning
that they may have been “in-between jobs” at the time of Survey more so than the
mature working-age population. At the same time, older population groups might
begin to consider retirement options and in turn employers may be more willing to
part with older employees given that they consider them to be less a productive
option for future business endeavours. Thus, both population subgroups are at a
Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

29

�Valerija Botric	&#13;  

greater risk of losing their jobs, while older persons are also less likely to find a job
upon becoming unemployed. Although the same is true for both the immigrant and
native population, the question is whether their age structure of immigrant and
native can contribute to the explanation of the gap. Given that young persons are
more likely to migrate (as recently discussed by Bernard, Bell and Charles-Edwards,
2016) and immigrants from some countries are more likely to have larger families
than the host country population, the case may very well be that the immigrant
population is disproportionally young. We operationalize this by including dummy
variables for each cohort starting from 15-24 to 55-64, with the most working active
age cohort 35-44 serving as a reference. Youth have been more adversely affected by
the crisis (O’Higgins, 2012). Therefore, the expectation is that migrant youth will
face twice as many difficulties – the probability of losing a job will be higher for the
migrant youth while the probability of finding a job will be lower. To the extent that
the immigrant population belongs disproportionally to the age cohort most adversely
affected by the crisis in the host labour market, we assume that this variable will have
a significantly positive contribution in explaining the immigrant-native gap in
transitions from employment to unemployment and a significantly negative
contribution in explaining the gap in transitions from unemployment to
employment.
• Degree of urbanisation of the area in which a person lives. The labour market is
more vibrant in densely populated areas and provides more job opportunities, which
in turn is more likely to affect the successful economic integration of immigrants
into a host country (Pischke and Velling, 1997; Borjas 2001, Jaeger 2008). Recently,
Verdugo (2016) also emphasized the role of public housing (in densely populated
areas) as an important factor for immigrants choosing a location within a host
country. Hence, the assumption is that immigrants are more likely to choose densely
populated areas and are more likely to live in immigration hubs (regardless of
whether it is their own choice or by necessity). This may also create additional job
prospects, for example, through social network effect and thus ease the transition
from unemployment to employment. Similarly, it may also create low job areas with
vicious circles of unemployment and poverty, contributing to job loss transitions.
We operationalize this situation by including three dummy variables – sparsely,
densely and intermediately populated areas, where the dense area is the reference in
probit equations. To the extent that immigrants are more concentrated than the
native population in densely populated areas, we expect that our explanatory
variables will have a significant negative contribution to explaining the gap in the
transition from unemployment to employment (due to lower overall labour market
demand in less densely populated areas) and a significantly positive contribution in
explaining the gap formation in transitions from employment to unemployment

30

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Labour Market Transition Differences between Natives and Immigrants in EU Economies	&#13;  

(due to relatively more adverse labour market conditions for immigrant workers in
less densely populated areas).
• A person’s education is an important predictor of labour market outcome.
Immigrants frequently face obstacles in obtaining recognition of their qualifications
in host countries and subsequently end-up taking jobs that are below comparable
levels of the native population. This, however, implies that the immigrant
population may have lower reservation wages than the native population. Employers
may exploit this situation by acquiring more productive workers for lower wages.
However, the relationship is not straightforward. The educational attainment may
not be easily transferred to work activities in host countries due to numerous
obstacles (including language or cultural barriers). Studies have also found that there
are important educational attainment differences with respect to second-generation
immigrants (Borjas 1992). Hence, the expected role of education is crucial, but the
direction of this variable’s contribution remains unclear at first. We included
educational attainment using 3 dummy variables – low, medium and high levels of
education, where medium is the reference value. To the extent that a country is able
to attract immigrants with higher levels of education than the native population and
with relatively good labour market integration policies, we expect that the higher
education variable is a significant negative contributor of the gap in transitions from
unemployment to employment. To the extent that a country is attracting
immigrants with lower levels of education than the native population, and
immigrants are faced with additional adverse conditions on the local labour market,
we expect that the lower education variable is a significant positive predictor of the
gap in transitions from employment to unemployment.

Results and Discussion
Transitions from Unemployment to Employment
First, focus is placed on the differences in transitions from unemployment to
employment. Specifically, these transitions include persons who were unemployed a
year ago but are employed at the time of the Survey. To make comparisons across
countries, the data show transitions as percentage of those who are unemployed
during the current year in the respective population. The differences between
immigrants and the native population for all European Union countries with a
sufficient number of observations in the year 2015 are presented in Figure 1, panel
A. The transitions are also illustrated for the same countries following country of
birth as a distinction between immigrant and native population, with those born in

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

31

�Valerija Botric	&#13;  

the country described as “home”, and the other labels are self-explanatory (Figure 1,
panel B).
Figure 1: Transition from Unemployment to Employment, 2015

panel A
60
50
40
30
20

Latvia

Malta

Poland

Portugal

Sweden

Slovenia

UK

Malta

Poland

Portugal

Sweden

Slovenia

UK

Litva

Latvia

Immigrants

Italy

Hungary

Greece

France

Finland

Spain

Estonia

Denmark

Czech R.

Germany

Cyprus

Belgium

0

Austria

10

Natives

Home

EU

Litva

Italy

Hungary

Greece

France

Finland

Spain

Estonia

Denmark

Czech R.

Germany

Cyprus

Belgium

70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0

Austria

panel B

non-EU

Source: author’s calculations based on EU-LFS data.

32

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Labour Market Transition Differences between Natives and Immigrants in EU Economies	&#13;  

The data clearly reveal differences among European countries. Regardless of the
overall transition rate (which also depends on the characteristics of the local labour
market), there are:
• Countries where transitions from unemployment to employment are similar for
the native and immigrant population: Austria, Belgium, Germany, Spain, Greece;
• Countries where unemployed immigrants were more likely to find a job than
natives: Cyprus, Czech Republic, Italy, Malta, Poland and UK;
• Countries where unemployed natives were more likely to find a job than
immigrants: Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Hungary, Latvia, Sweden.
These differences might not be the same over time, since countries can adopt
different policies and/or experience additional immigration flows influencing the
ability of local labour market to absorb them. To explore this further, we turn our
focus on the evolution of the transition rates from unemployment to employment in
the 1998-2015 period. The data presented below refer to the initial definition of
immigrants and natives based on citizenship4. Initial analysis captured all European
countries, but the data presented in Figure 2 are only for the countries that had
enough observations throughout the analysed period. Figure 2 contains separate
panels for Belgium, the Czech Republic, Germany, Denmark, Estonia, Finland,
Greece, Portugal and the United Kingdom.

	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;   	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  
4

The data based on country of birth can be obtained from the author upon request. It has to be
emphasized that the evolution of “native” and “country-born” population is virtually the same, since
the correlation for the two datasets (for all the countries and all available years) in the case of transition
from unemployment to employment is 0.997788. The same comparison for the “immigrant”
population is not appropriate, because disaggregating the overall immigrant into EU-born and non-EUborn leads to a larger number of cases where the data cannot be disclosed due to publication threshold
restrictions imposed by Eurostat. Additionally, in a number of countries at the beginning of the sample,
there was a large proportion of cases with “no-answer” for the country of birth variable. Indeed, as can
be noticed from the comparison presented in Figure 1, this “no-answer” issue was carried out
throughout the analysed period in the case of Germany.

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

33

�Valerija Botric	&#13;  

Figure 2: Transition from Unemployment to Employment, 1998-2015

34

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Labour Market Transition Differences between Natives and Immigrants in EU Economies	&#13;  

Source: author’s calculations based on EU-LFS data.
The data reveal different patterns of transitions from unemployment to employment,
clearly connected with overall labour market developments. For example, what is
noticeable are the deteriorating conditions in the Greek economy which exerted a
negative effect on transitions to employment for both immigrant and natives, while
the decline for the immigrants was particularly steep at the beginning of analysed
period and again in the 2009-2011 period. In some economies – Finland and the
Czech Republic - the crisis period (around the year 2008) was associated with
increased transitions of immigrant population towards employment, while no similar
patterns were recorded for native population.
The data presented in the figure also show countries with (almost) continuously
different transitions of immigrants and natives. On one side of the spectrum is
Denmark, where natives were more likely to make the transition from
unemployment to employment throughout the analysed period. On the other side
are Portugal and United Kingdom, where since the early 2000s, immigrant
transitions from unemployment to employment are higher than for natives.

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

35

�Valerija Botric	&#13;  

For the countries with the largest identified gap, we explore whether the differences
in characteristics of native and immigrant population can explain the existing hap.
The results of the estimates based on the Fairile methodology are presented in Table
1.
Table 1: Contributions to the Gap in Transition from Unemployment to
Employment, 2015
Native

Denmark Estonia Finland France Hungary Latvia Sweden Slovenia
0.42
0.53
0.25
0.28
0.41
0.46
0.48
0.24

Immigrant

0.28

0.38

0.21

0.22

0.28

0.32

0.37

0.21

Gap

0.14

0.14

0.04

0.05

0.13

0.14

0.12

0.03

% gap explained

-3.61

17.11

-45.16

56.34

-15.10

43.74

12.98

63.25

-1.87

0.07

-1.16

29.05*

Contributions to the gap (as percentage of the estimated gap)
0.54
0.53
-4.41
1.38*
Male
Age 15-24

2.70

24.22*

-6.33

8.05*

1.27

16.07* 3.88*

-2.91

Age 25-34

-3.70

6.51*

-24.99* -0.75*

0.14

10.93* -4.02*

1.89

Age 45-54

-1.03

-1.30

Age 55-64

-7.34*

4.76

Inter-urban

0.00

-0.14

Sparse-urb

3.84*

Edu-low

-3.30*

-1.22

Edu-high

-1.51

3.21*

4.51

N

2580

751

1135

-1.02

0.91*

-2.73*

-75.38* -10.59* 17.28*
-4.88

1.69

-0.08

-16.97*

8.20* -19.69* -0.05*

-0.81*

8.66*

3.53*

-0.02

-8.89

5.56*

-26.59*

1.64

0.01*

30.71*

43.35* 46.80*

-6.69*

-0.11

0.49*

41.82*

5.87*

-4.27*

1.44*

-3.50*

39.55*

33154

13332

2452

6136

4037

-19.31* 25.23*

Source: author’s estimates based on EU-LFS data.
The important point to notice is that, although the size of the gap differs, in all
analysed countries the natives are more likely to make a transition from
unemployment to employment than the immigrant population. The transition was
most frequent in the case of Sweden, and least frequent for Slovenia – indeed, most
countries had higher transition rates for the immigrant population than Slovenia had

36

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Labour Market Transition Differences between Natives and Immigrants in EU Economies	&#13;  

for the native population. This suggests that labour market in Slovenia was rather
sluggish5.
The analysis reveals that the explanatory variables have various contributions in
explaining the existing gap in transitions from unemployment to employment
between native and immigrants across countries. The variables jointly provide an
explanation for most of the gap in transition from unemployment to employment in
Slovenia (63 percent of the gap), France (56 percent of the gap) and Latvia (43
percent). However, the results imply that had the immigrants and natives the same
characteristics based on analysed variables, the gap in transitions from
unemployment to employment would be even larger in three analysed countries –
Finland, Hungary and Denmark. Based on these results the probable assumption is
that in these three countries the immigrant population fulfils in specific section of
labour market demand.
Not a single personal characteristic has been found significant in all of the analysed
countries. This implies that each country attracts different types of immigrants and
depending on specific labour market integration policies, immigrants with similar
characteristics have different outcomes in comparison to native populations. This
finding is in line with previous literature, but the results enable us to explore these
differences. Even when significant, the same variable does not have the same sign of
contribution to the gap. For example, low education contributes to the explanation
of the gap for France, Finland and Slovenia. It seems that in these countries,
immigrants are on average relatively less educated (or their qualifications are not
recognized by the home country education system), thus decreasing their chances of
finding a job. However, in case of Slovenia, higher education among immigrants also
contributes to a relatively unfavourable outcome for immigrants. Thus, the
argument may very well be that, at least in Slovenia, there are important differences
in the structure of educational attainment (formal or not) between immigrants and
natives that influence respective labour market transitions.
Another important example in some countries is age. In the case of Finland, had
immigrants been represented in the age cohort 55-64 as much as natives, the gap in
the average transition from unemployment to employment would be even larger.
Similar results are also valid for Sweden, France and Denmark. However, the
differences in this age cohort between immigrants and natives provide an explanation
of the existing gap in Hungary, Latvia and Estonia. This also shows that the age
	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;   	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  
5
For an overview of labour market indicators in EU economies in 2015 please consult European Union
(2016).

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

37

�Valerija Botric	&#13;  

structure of immigrants in comparison to the native population differs among the
analysed countries.
The overall conclusion is that not only does the gap in transitions differs, but the
path of the gap also differs, and the contributions of the variables in explaining the
gap differ across European economies. Transitions seem to be idiosyncratic to host
country labour markets. To illustrate this, we analyse in which economic activities
immigrants and natives found a job. The data in Table 2 are presented as
percentages of the respective population that has made the transition from
employment to unemployment.
Table 2: Percentage of Previously Unemployed Natives in Immigrants According to
the Economic Activity of Their Employment, 2015
Denmark
NACE I
A

N
3.4

0.5

14.4

14.0

Estonia

France

I

I

N

N

Hungary

Latvia

I

I

N

4.8

4.3

1.8

29.6

20.6

5.7

10.7

16.3

B
C

6.9

N
5.2

11.7

16.4

17.0

0.1
29.5

Sweden

Slovenia

I

I

N

N

1.1

0.8

2.5

0.2
4.0

7.4

D

0.5

0.4

0.4

0.3

1.1

0.4

E

0.7

0.5

0.6

2.5

0.4

0.4

49.1

23.1

0.8

F

3.4

5.7

23.0

15.1

12.2

7.4

7.2

25.9

12.4

4.0

5.0

G

9.6

17.3

6.6

19.0

10.1

12.8

7.0

15.5

15.4

11.2

12.2

12.2

H

7.5

4.6

8.2

4.2

4.2

4.8

3.4

11.2

7.1

7.2

5.0

4.7

I

15.8

5.0

6.6

6.4

7.6

6.5

4.3

0.0

4.4

11.6

5.9

8.0

J

6.2

2.2

1.9

1.3

2.0

0.6

0.0

1.8

3.2

2.8

2.1

1.0

1.5

0.5

0.0

1.1

1.6

0.8

1.7

1.5

0.9

0.3

7.8

2.4

4.0

1.1

3.5

2.6

4.4

0.7

1.7

10.8

5.9

3.9

9.7

6.5

5.1

5.2

2.0

11.1

6.3

2.6

2.3

6.4

33.8

3.9

14.8

4.4

3.9

8.0

5.5

8.0

3.1

5.6

18.8

11.9

8.1

K

1.4

L

1.4

M

3.4

2.9

N

10.3

4.8

O

3.3

4.9

40.7

6.9

P

4.8

10.3

Q

12.3

16.6

3.5

12.7

13.4

3.2

3.6

R

2.1

3.0

1.6

1.1

2.5

1.5

1.9

S

2.7

2.2

2.9

3.2

4.1

1.1

7.2

2.0

0.2

T

8.2

3.4

1.7

15.4
2.4

15.1

9.1

5.9
11.3

7.5

3.1

5.8

4.1

3.6

3.1

3.0

0.6

Source: author’s calculations based on EU-LFS data.

38

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Labour Market Transition Differences between Natives and Immigrants in EU Economies	&#13;  

Note: NACE activities are: A – Agriculture, forestry and fishing; B- Mining and
Quarrying; C – Manufacturing; D – Electricity; Gas, Steam, and Air Conditioning
Supply; E – Water Supply, Sewerage, Waste Management and Remediation
Activities; F – Construction; G – Wholesale and Retail Trade, Repair of Motor
Vehicles and Motorcycles; H – Transportation and Storage; I – Accommodation and
Food Service Activities; J – Information and Communication; K – Financial and
Insurance Activities; L – Real Estate Activities; M – Professional, Scientific and
Technical Activities; N –Administrative and Support Services; O – Public
Administration and Defence, Compulsory Social Security; P – Education; Q –
Human Health and Social Work Activities; R – Arts, Entertainment and Recreation;
S – Other Service Activities; T – Activities of Households as Employers; U –
Activities of Extraterritorial Organisations and Bodies.
Based on the data in Table 2, we notice that in Denmark immigrants are most likely
to find a job in accommodation and support services. This is also the activity where
the difference between immigrant and native transition to employment is the
highest. Sweden is another example where immigrants are more likely to find work
in this activity than natives. However, for Sweden, it seems that in 2015 most
immigrants found employment in education. This is not the case in other
economies. Indeed, in most countries education activity employed the native
population. The dominant sector for immigrants in Slovenia was manufacturing and
public administration in Hungary. In both these countries the number of
immigrants that made a transition was rather low. France, a country with a high
share of immigrant transition, mostly employed them in construction, and human
health and social work.
The data in Table 3 explore differences in working conditions between immigrant
and native population for the case where they made the transition from
unemployment to employment. The questions were related to the quality of job.
The data in Table 3 show: percentage of the respective population employed on a
permanent contract, percentage of the respective population that declared that their
jobs do not involve working in shifts, working during the evening, working during
nights, Saturday or Sunday work.
Table 3: Working Conditions of Immigrants and Natives Who Made the Transition
from Unemployment to Employment, 2015
Country
Denmark

Permanency

No Shift

No Evening

No Night

No Saturday

No Sunday

I

20.5

87.7

62.3

90.4

67.8

100.0

N

26.1

93.4

65.4

91.9

69.1

74.9

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

39

�Valerija Botric	&#13;  

Table 3 (Continued)
Estonia

Finland

France

Hungary

Latvia

Sweden

Slovenia

I

27.9

72.1

60.7

88.5

67.2

73.8

N

13.5

75.6

61.4

93.2

64.6

76.8

I

50.0

71.4

78.6

92.9

92.9

85.7

N

51.3

77.7

68.7

93.2

78.5

80.8

I

66.2

73.9

32.8

36.2

26.5

32.0

N

65.1

76.3

28.7

33.0

22.5

29.3

I

77.8

96.3

88.9

92.6

74.1

77.8

N

63.4

81.4

78.2

87.7

71.4

85.2

I

20.7

71.6

66.4

92.2

62.9

75.9

N

13.2

68.1

69.1

89.2

64.5

74.1

I

66.8

76.8

70.0

88.0

67.6

68.8

N

60.3

74.0

66.8

85.5

65.0

68.1

I

62.3

49.1

58.5

71.7

43.4

64.2

N

71.7

56.3

58.4

84.0

43.3

71.1

Source: author’s calculations based on EU-LFS data.
Contrary to initial expectations, the immigrant population on average does not
always end up in jobs associated with more adverse working conditions. For
example, a higher percentage of immigrants made the transition to permanent jobs
in Sweden, Latvia, Hungary and Estonia. A higher percentage of immigrants found
employment not involving shift work in Hungary, Latvia and Sweden. Moreover, a
higher percentage of immigrants found employment not involving Sunday work in
Denmark, Finland, France and Latvia.
Transitions from Employment to Unemployment
Next we turn our attention to analysing differences in transitions from employment
to unemployment. We define the transition as occurring if a person who has been
employed a year ago is currently unemployed. The differences between immigrants
and the native population for all European Union countries with a sufficient number
of observations for the year 2015 are presented in Figure 3, panel A. The Figure 3 in
panel B also contains information on the transition from employment to
unemployment by country of birth – home country, EU country and non-EU
country.

40

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Labour Market Transition Differences between Natives and Immigrants in EU Economies	&#13;  

Figure 3: Transition from Employment to Unemployment, 2015

Source: author’s calculations based on EU-LFS data
When comparing these results with those presented in Figure 1, it becomes evident
that transition rates from employment to unemployment are lower than those from
unemployment to employment. This is as expected. The most obvious explanation is

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

41

�Valerija Botric	&#13;  

that the number of employed is always larger than the number of unemployed,
hence the base of the second transition rate is larger, yielding a smaller percentage. A
more substantial explanation is that rigidity of labour market institutions influence
both hiring and firing procedures. Thus, the more rigid is the labour market, the
costlier it will be for employers to fire employees, and thus they are more likely to
sustain an above-optimal employment level even during times of crisis. Bassanini and
Garnero (2013) found that the more restrictive the regulation, the smaller is the rate
of within-industry job-to-job transitions, in particular towards permanent jobs.
However, regulations are not the only explanation. Employers may want to retain for
workers an above-optimal employment level during the bust phase given that human
capital is scarce and employers are generally aware of the cyclical nature of an
economy. In that case, relative attitudes towards immigrant workforce might become
more evident.
The data clearly suggest that in almost all the countries (with exception of the Czech
Republic) transition rates from employment to unemployment in 2015 were higher
for immigrants than for natives. This indicates that immigrants are more likely to
lose their job and the relative likelihood is highest in France, Spain and Portugal.
Other countries also have significant differences – for example, Austria, and
Denmark.
Again, we explored this issue within a dynamic perspective, to reveal whether these
patterns persist in countries. The data presented below refer to the initial definition
of immigrant and natives based on citizenship6. The data are again presented only
for those countries for which transitions were observable throughout the 1998-2015
period (Figure 4). Figure 4 contains separate panels for Belgium, the Czech
Republic, Germany, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, Greece, Portugal and the United
Kingdom.

	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;   	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  
6

The data based on country of birth can be obtained from the author upon request. It has to be
emphasized that the pathway for “native” and “country-born” population is virtually the same, since the
correlation for the two datasets (for all the countries and all available years) in the case of transition
from employment to unemployment is 0.995794. Given that the number of transitions in this case is
lower, there are more cases when the data cannot be publicly disclosed due to the threshold imposed by
Eurostat.

42

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Labour Market Transition Differences between Natives and Immigrants in EU Economies	&#13;  

Figure no. 4: Transition from Employment to Unemployment, 1998-2015

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

43

�Valerija Botric	&#13;  

Source: author’s calculations based on EU-LFS data.
Evidence shows that for most of the countries (again with the exception of the Czech
Republic), immigrants are more likely to lose employment than natives during the
analysed period. It may be that immigrants are more likely to be employed in the
economic sectors more adversely affected by economic crises (Kogan, 2004). For
some countries, – for example, Greece – there is additional effect of the crisis adverse
impact on immigrants. For other countries – for example, United Kingdom – the
crisis had the effect of the narrowing the gap between immigrants and natives losing
their jobs, hence the assumption may be that it had a more adverse effect on the
native population.
Both transitions reveal that the pathway for the immigrant population is more erratic
than for natives. The pathways for transitions of native populations are generally
smoother, usually exhibiting spikes during the steepest economic downturns. Thus,
it seems that while natives are more likely to lose their jobs in times of crises, the

44

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Labour Market Transition Differences between Natives and Immigrants in EU Economies	&#13;  

immigrant population has more difficulties in predicting their chances of retaining
jobs even during favourable economic times.
To analyse contributions to the gap, our focus is directed to countries where
immigrants have the highest probabilities of losing jobs in comparison to the native
population. The analysis again relies on the Fairlie methodology including the same
set of initial predictors (Table 4).
Table 4: Contributions to the Gap in Transition from Employment to
Unemployment, 2015
Austria

Denmark

France

Italy

Portugal

Sweden

Native

0.02

0.02

0.03

0.02

0.03

0.02

Immigrant

0.04

0.05

0.08

0.05

0.06

0.05

Gap

-0.03

-0.03

-0.05

-0.03

-0.03

-0.03

% gap explained

22.10

4.07

17.87

26.84

12.40

3.89

Contributions to the gap (as percentage of the estimated gap)
Male

0.08

0.31*

0.74*

0.20*

0.31

0.79*

Age 15-24

0.87*

1.34*

-3.11*

2.96*

5.03*

-0.61*

Age 25-34

2.65*

2.58

1.55*

7.16*

4.20*

2.65*

Age 45-54

1.95*

-0.71

2.61*

3.84*

2.38*

-0.14

Age 55-64

2.47*

0.82

2.35*

5.65*

3.17*

-3.42*

Inter-urban

0.00*

0.89*

-0.17*

0.90*

-0.06

0.59

Sparse-urb

10.44*

3.06*

4.27*

0.89*

2.04*

1.17*

Edu-low

1.80*

-1.14*

7.68*

3.46*

-4.81*

5.51*

Edu-high

-2.40*

-3.10*

1.97*

1.78*

0.15

-2.68*

N

79223

49864

193469

192701

63242

76236

Source: author’s estimations based on EU-LFS data.
The data in Table 4 show that in all analysed countries, immigrants had higher
transition rates from employment to unemployment than the native population. The
chosen variables explain the relatively small percentage of the gap in transition from
employment to unemployment between the immigrant and native population – the
Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

45

�Valerija Botric	&#13;  

highest in Italy (26 percent of the gap), Austria (22 percent) and France (17
percent). For the case of transitions in the opposite direction, the level of significance
and the sign of specific predictors differ across the analysed countries. Regardless of
the fact that there are no common features, individual analysis at the country level is
noteworthy. It is interesting to note that in sparsely populated areas of Austria,
immigrants are more likely to lose jobs. Another interesting fact is that in Italy,
younger age cohorts of immigrants (25-34) are more likely than natives to lose jobs.
In the case of France, a low education is an important predictor for the
disproportional job loss among immigrants. Specifically for this country, a
comparative analysis of both transitions indicates that educational attainment plays
an important role in relative labour market integration of immigrants.
A large segment of the gap remains unexplained due to the differences in
characteristics between natives and immigrants. This suggests that there are many
other factors as to why the immigrants are more likely to lose jobs than natives, more
factors than we were able to analyse with the existing dataset. To contribute to a
discussion on the potential factors, Table 5 presents the structure of immigrants and
natives in the analysed countries based on the economic activity they previously
worked in. The data consider only of those individuals who made the transition
from employment to unemployment.
Table 5: The Structure of Immigrants and Natives Based on the Economic Activity
of Their Previous Job, 2015
Austria
I
A

Denmark

France

I

N

I

N

I

N

0.8

5.2

1.5

1.9

1.9

4.9

3.2

0.2
16.2

Portugal

N

B
C

Italy

18.2

11.1

13.8

8.3

13.2

I

Sweden
N

I

N

2.9

4.0

1.1

14.3

7.2

8.4

0.5
13.0

16.5

D

0.7

0.4

0.8

0.5

E

0.5

0.5

1.6

0.9

0.6

1.1

5.4

0.5

0.3
0.5

0.5

F

17.4

12.0

5.2

7.9

21.8

10.1

17.6

14.4

15.2

10.9

7.2

7.9

G

13.4

18.2

13.3

15.2

10.1

14.9

5.8

17.7

9.8

18.6

11.2

11.1

H

4.2

4.8

4.4

5.6

4.5

4.2

2.3

5.1

5.4

3.5

3.2

4.9

I

16.4

11.2

22.2

5.2

8.3

6.7

11.3

12.0

30.4

12.3

16.0

6.2

J

1.2

2.7

3.7

3.6

1.8

2.6

1.6

2.7

4.6

K

1.0

2.1

2.0

1.8

1.0

1.4

1.3

1.2

1.4

0.5

1.1

0.5

0.6

1.2

4.1

3.4

3.9

4.2

3.4

L
M

46

3.7

4.1

3.7

1.0

4.0

7.8

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Labour Market Transition Differences between Natives and Immigrants in EU Economies	&#13;  

Table 5 (Continued)
N

9.7

5.9

O

1.2

3.2

P

1.7

3.0

Q

5.2

5.6

R

3.5

S

2.2

14.8

5.2

9.2

4.7

3.6

1.7

4.7

1.4

5.9

7.8

4.3

5.6

3.1

6.7

15.5

7.0

10.2

3.4

3.6

2.2

2.1

1.7

2.6

0.6

2.0

2.8

2.3

1.6

3.3

2.5

2.4

1.4

0.5

31.6

2.3

T
U

4.1

5.4

4.3

4.5

12.0

9.4

4.9

3.2

4.9

4.3

6.7

12.8

9.8

5.4

6.1

9.6

9.9

6.5

1.6

3.3

2.5

3.2

2.3

0.1

Source: author’s calculations based on EU-LFS data.
Note: NACE activities are: A – Agriculture, forestry and fishing; B- Mining and Quarrying; C –
Manufacturing; D – Electricity; Gas, Steam, and Air Conditioning Supply; E – Water Supply,
Sewerage, Waste Management and Remediation Activities; F – Construction; G – Wholesale and Retail
Trade, Repair of Motor Vehicles and Motorcycles; H – Transportation and Storage; I –
Accommodation and Food Service Activities; J – Information and Communication; K – Financial and
Insurance Activities; L – Real Estate Activities; M – Professional, Scientific and Technical Activities; N
– Administrative and Support Services; O – Public Administration and Defence, Compulsory Social
Security; P – Education; Q – Human Health and Social Work Activities; R – Arts, Entertainment and
Recreation; S – Other Service Activities; T – Activities of Households as Employers; U – Activities of
Extraterritorial Organisations and Bodies.

The data in Table 5 show that in Austria most immigrants had previously worked in
construction, followed by accommodation and food services and manufacturing. For
natives, manufacturing is also an economic activity that sheds a large labour force.
This clearly indicates that manufacturing is undergoing restructuring and
immigrants are not the ones who are particularly vulnerable in this economic
activity. Construction is another segment heavily affected by the latest economic
crisis and it is evident that in most of the analysed economies this has had a more
severe impact on the immigrant population (Austria, France, Portugal and Italy).
Accommodation and food services is one of the activities where immigrants also
experienced higher percentage job losses in Portugal, Sweden and Denmark. It is
interesting to note that in Italy the highest percentage of immigrants who lost jobs
come from activities of households as employers. These findings once again confirm
that immigrants frequently find jobs in economic sectors that are more prone to
labour shedding during economic downturns.
Once losing their jobs, immigrants may find it more difficult to find a new job,
which is reflected in the different durations of job searching. Table 6 presents the
structure of the immigrant and native population based on the duration of search,
and only for those who have made the transition from employment to
unemployment.
Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

47

�Valerija Botric	&#13;  

Table 6: The Percentage of Immigrants and Natives Who Made the Transition from
Employment to Unemployment According to the Duration of Unemployment,
2015
Country
less than 6 months
6-11 months 1 year and longer
I
68.2
29.4
2.5
Austria
N
68.0
27.3
4.7
I
63.7
27.4
8.9
Denmark
N
69.4
25.0
5.6
I
45.1
25.3
26.4
France
N
46.5
29.4
18.4
I
51.3
36.0
12.7
Italy
N
53.4
29.8
15.6
I
58.7
25.0
16.3
Portugal
N
54.5
31.8
13.7
I
57.6
27.2
5.6
Sweden
N
64.1
25.3
3.8
Source: author’s calculations based on EU-LFS data.
The data in Table 6 reveal that natives are more likely to have shorter
unemployment spells (Denmark, France, Italy and Sweden). France has the largest
share of immigrants with long spells of unemployment, but the indicator for the
native population is also the highest. Hence, although immigrants do encounter
adverse labour market conditions, they do so along with the native population.

Conclusions
The recent economic crisis has had an adverse effect on the labour markets of
European economies. Additionally, Europe has recently faced increased immigration
flows. Both immigration and the crisis have exerted additional pressures on labour
markets. The studies frequently indicate that, even without such pressures,
immigrants fare worse on the labour markets of host countries than natives. This
study re-examines this question for the period covering the most recent European
history.
The analysis in this paper focuses on differences in transitions from unemployment
to employment, and employment to unemployment between native and immigrant
populations in European economies during the 1998-2015 period. Transitions,
48

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Labour Market Transition Differences between Natives and Immigrants in EU Economies	&#13;  

rather than outcomes, have been chosen for the analysis to avoid a discussion on
different labour market participation motivation for subgroups of immigrant
populations. Thus, the focus of the analysis is both on immigrants and natives who
were participating in the labour market – either through employment or actively
seeking employment.
The analysis reveals that outcomes differ when it comes to transitions from
unemployment to employment – in some countries/years the natives find
proportionally more employment, while in others it is the immigrants. In most of
the countries, however, immigrants are more likely to lose a job than natives.
Similarly, in most countries, a connection can be made between crisis and increased
job loss for natives. Immigrants are also more likely to experience adverse effects of
the crisis, but the probability that they will lose a job is also higher in other periods.
In addition to identifying the immigrant-native gap, the characteristics of individuals
as potential contributors to the gap have been assessed. The results of this segment of
the analysis show that similar characteristics exert a different influence on the
differences in immigrant-native labour market transitions in the analysed countries.
This finding supports previous claims in the literature that there is certain selfselection of immigrants into different host countries, according to different socioeconomic factors. While this has been previously established, we address this issue
here in regard to the labour market. Since the heterogeneity of immigrants has been
documented once more, this time focusing on a narrow segment of labour market
transitions, it seems that calls for a unified approach to policy discussions that have
been heard during the recent migrant wave in Europe might be displaced. The
policies should also consider path dependency and adjust measures so as to be best
suited for the population on their particular territory. The results do not claim that
this is important for all segments of migration integration policies, but they do
suggest that it is important for labour market integration, even for cases where
migrants are already active on the host country labour market.
The paper has documented the increased vulnerability of immigrants on the host
markets of European countries. Yet, due to the period analysed, it has not fully
captured the effect of the most recent increased immigration flows arriving into
territories of the European economies. Future research efforts should be devoted to
the importance of integrating these immigrants and a comparative analysis of the
policy approaches undertaken by different countries in dealing with increased
migratory pressures.

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

49

�Valerija Botric	&#13;  

References
Aiyar, S., Barkbu, B., Batini, N., Berger, H. Detragiache, E., Dizioli, A., Ebeke, C.,
Lin, H., Kaltani, L, Sosa, S., Spilimbergo, A., &amp; Topalova, P. (2016). The Refugee
Surge in Europe: Economic Challenges, IMF Staff Discussion Note SDN/16/02,
Retrieved from https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/sdn/2016/sdn1602.pdf.
Alarian, H.M. (2017). Citizenship in hard times: intra-EU naturalisation and the
Euro crisis. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 43(13), 2149-2168.
Åslund, O., &amp; Rooth, D.O. (2007).Do when and where matter? Initial labour
market conditions and immigrant earnings.Economic Journal, 117(518), 422-448.
Barrett A., &amp; Kelly, E. (2012).The impact of Ireland’s recession on the labour
market outcomes of its immigrants. European Journal of Population, 28(1), 99-111.
Bassanini, A., &amp; Garnero, A. (2013). Dismissal protection and worker flows in
OECD countries: Evidence from cross-country/cross-industry data. Labour
Economics, 21(C), 25-41.
Baudassé, T., &amp; Bazillier, R. (2014). Gender Inequality and Emigration: Push
Factor or Selection Process?. International Economics, 139(October), 19-47.
Bernard, A., Bell, M., &amp; Charles-Edwards, E. (2016). Internal migration age
patterns and the transition to adulthood: Australia and Great Britain compared.
Journal of Population Research, 33(2), 123-146.
Blanchflower, D. G., &amp; Shadforth, C. (2009). Fear, unemployment and migration.
The Economic Journal, 119(535), F136-F182.
Blume, K. Ejrnæs, M., Skyt Nielsen, H., &amp; Würtz, A. (2009). Labor market
transitions of immigrants with emphasis on marginalisation and self-employment.
Journal of Population Economics, 22(4), 881-908.
Borjas, G.J. (1992). Ethnic capital and intergenerational mobility. Quarterly Journal
of Economics, 107(1), 123-150.
Borjas, G. J. (1999). Immigration and Welfare Magnets. Journal of Labor Economics,
17 (4/1), 607-637.

50

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Labour Market Transition Differences between Natives and Immigrants in EU Economies	&#13;  

Borjas, G.J. (2001). Does immigration grease the wheels of the labor market?.
Brookings Papers on Economic Activity,(1), 69-119.
Bratsberg, B., Raaum, O., &amp; Røed, K. (2018).Job Loss and Immigrant Labour
Market Performance. Economica, 2018 (85), 124-151.
Bruno, G., Marelli, E., &amp; Signorelli, M. (2014).The Rise of NEET and Youth
Unemployment in EU Regions after the Crisis. Comparative Economic Studies, 56(4),
592-615.
Chapman, B.J., &amp; Iredale, R.R. (1993). Immigrant Qualifications: Recognition and
Relative Wage Outcomes. The International Migration Review, 27(2), 359-387.
Chiswick, B.R. (1978). The effect of Americanization on the earnings of foreignborn men. Journal of Political Economy, 86(5), 897-921.
Chiswick, B. R., Rebhun, U., &amp; Beider, N. (2016).Linguistic and Economic
Adjustment among Immigrants in Israel, IZA Discussion Paper Series, No.
10214.Retreived from:
http://ftp.iza.org/dp10214.pdfhttp://ftp.iza.org/dp10214.pdf.
Corluy, V., &amp; Verbist, G. (2014). Can education bridge the gap? Education and the
employment position of immigrants in Belgium. ImPRovE Discussion Paper No.
14/02. Antwerp: Retrieved from:
http://www.centrumvoorsociaalbeleid.be/ImPRovE/Working%20Papers/ImPRovE
%20WP%201402_1.pdf.
Del Boca, D., &amp; Venturini, A. (2016). Migration in Italy is backing the old age
welfare. In M. Kahanec &amp; K. F. Zimmermann (Eds.), Labor migration, EU
enlargement, and the great recession(pp. 59-84). Berlin: Springer.
De la Rica, S., &amp; Polonyankina, T. (2013). The impact of Immigration on
Occupational Specialisation among Natives in Spain: Does the Business Cycle
Matter?. Revista de Economía Aplicada, 21(63), 51-74.
Dustmann, C., &amp; Frattini, T. (2011). Immigration: The European Experience.
CReAM Discussion Paper No 22/11, Retrieved from
http://www.ucl.ac.uk/~uctpb21/doc/CDP_22_11.pdf .

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

51

�Valerija Botric	&#13;  

Dustmann, C., Glitz, A., &amp; Vogel, T. (2010). Employment, Wages and the
Economic Cycle: Differences between Immigrants and Natives. European Economic
Review, 54(1), 1-17.
Elsner, B., &amp; Zimmermann, K. F. (2016). 10 years after: EU enlargement, closed
borders, and migration to Germany. In M. Kahanec &amp; K. F. Zimmermann(Eds.),
Labor migration, EU enlargement, and the great recession (pp. 85-102). Berlin:
Springer.
European Commission. (2016). Access to Confidential Data for Scientific Purposes
(Scientific Use Files): Guidelines for Publication.
European Union. (2016). Labour Market and Wage Developments in Europe:
Annual Review 2016, Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.
Fairlie, R.W. (1999). The Absence of the African-American Owned Business: An
Analysis of the Dynamics of Self-Employment. Journal of Labor Economics, 17(1),
80-108.
Fairlie, R. W. (2005). An Extension of the Blinder-Oaxaca Decomposition
Technique to Logit and Probit Models. Journal of Economic and Social Measurement,
30(4), 305-316.
Farris, S.R. (2015). Migrants’ regular army of labour: gender dimensions of the
impact of the global economic crisis on migrant labor in Western Europe, The
Sociological Review, 63(1), 121-143.
Ferrant, G., Loiseau, E., &amp; Nowacka, K. (2014).The Role of Discriminatory Social
Institutions in Female South‐South Migration. OECD Development Centre, Paris.
Retrieved from https://www.oecd.org/dev/developmentgender/SIGI%20and%20Female%20Migration_final.pdf.
Föbker, S., &amp; Imani, D. (2017). The role of language skills in the settling-in process
– experiences of highly skilled migrants’ accompanying partners in Germany and the
UK. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 43(16), 2720-2737.
Garda, P. (2016). The Ins and Outs of Employment in 25 OECD Countries,
OECD Economics Department Working Papers No.1350, OECD Publishing,
Paris.

52

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Labour Market Transition Differences between Natives and Immigrants in EU Economies	&#13;  

Ghosh, J. (2009). Migration and Gender Empowerment: Recent Trends and
Emerging Issues. Human Development Research Paper 04, United Nations
Development Programme, Human Development Report Office, New York.
Giulietti, C., Guzi, M., Kahanec, M., &amp; Zimmermann, K. F. (2013).
Unemployment benefits and immigration: Evidence from the EU. International
Journal of Manpower, 34(1), 24-38.
Grigoleit-Richter, G. (2017). Highly skilled and highly mobile? Examining gendered
and ethnicised labour market conditions for migrant women in STEM professions in
Germany. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 43(16), 2738-2755.
Grossman, J.B. (1982). The substitutability of natives and immigrants in
production. Review of Economics and Statistics, 64(4), 596-603.
Hatton, T.J., &amp; Williamson, J.G. (2005). What fundamentals drive world
migration?. In G. Borjas &amp; J.Crips(Eds.),Poverty, International Migration and Asylum
(pp. 15-38).UK: Palgrave-Macmillian for WIDER.
Heath, A. F., Rothon, C., &amp; Kilpi, E. (2008). The second generation in Western
Europe: education, unemployment, and occupational attainment. Annual Review of
Sociology, 34, 211-235.
Jaeger, D.A. (2008). Green Cards and the Location Choices of Immigrants in the
United States, 1971-2000. Research in Labor Economics, 27(1), 131-183.
Kahanec, M., &amp; Zaiceva, A. (2008). Labour Market Outcomes of Immigrants and
Non-Citizens in the EU: An East-West comparison, IZA Discussion Paper No.
3420.
Kahanec, M., Zimmermann, K. F., Kurekova, L., &amp; Biavaschi, C. (2013). Labour
migration from EaP countries to the EU – Assessment of costs and benefits and
proposals for better labour market matching. IZA research report no. 56.
Krings, T. (2009).A race to the bottom? Trade unions, EU enlargement and the free
movement of labour. European Journal of Industrial Relations, 15(1), 49-69.
Kogan, I. (2004).Last hired, first fired? The unemployment dynamics of male
immigrants in Germany. European Sociological Review, 20(5), 445-461.

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

53

�Valerija Botric	&#13;  

Langevin, G., Masclet, D., Moizeau, F., &amp; Peterle, E. (2013).Educational
Attainment, Wages and Employment of Second-Generation Immigrants in France.
Center for Research in Economics and Management, Working Paper 2013-27,
Retrieved from http://perso.univrennes1.fr/david.masclet/Educational%20attainment%20.pdf .
Marino, S., Penninx, R., &amp; Roosblad, J. (2015). Trade unions, immigration and
immigrants in Europe revisited: union’s attitudes and actions under new conditions.
Comparative Migration Studies, 3(1), 1-16.
McDonald, J.T., &amp; Worswick, C. (1998). The earnings of immigrant men in
Canada: job tenure, cohort, and macroeconomic conditions. Industrial and Labor
Relations Review, 51(3), 465-482.
Meardi, G. (2012). Union immobility? Trade unions and the freedoms of
movement in the enlarged EU. British Journal of Industrial Relations, 50(1), 99-120.
Peri, G., &amp; Sparber, C. (2009).Task Specialization, Immigration, and Wages.
American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 1(3), 135-169.
OECD/EuropeanUnion. (2015). Indicators of Immigrant Integration 2015: Settling
In. Paris: OECD Publishing.
O’Higgins, N. (2012). This Time It’s Different? Youth Labour Markets during ‘The
Great Recession’. Comparative Economic Studies, 54(2), 395-412.
Orrenius, P.M., &amp; Zavodny, M. (2007). Does immigration affect wages? A look at
occupation level evidence. Labour Economics, 14(5), 757-773.
Ortega, F., &amp; Peri, G. (2014). Openness and income: The roles of trade and
migration. Journal of International Economics, 92(2), 231-251.
Ortega, F., &amp; Polavieja, J. G. (2012).Labour-Market Exposure as a Determinant of
Attitudes toward Immigration. Labour Economics, 19(3), 298-311.
Pischke, J.S., &amp; Velling, J. (1997). Employment effects of immigration to Germany:
An analysis based on local labor markets. The Review of Economics and Statistics,
79(4), 594-604.

54

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Labour Market Transition Differences between Natives and Immigrants in EU Economies	&#13;  

Ritzen, J., &amp; Kahanec, M. (2017).A Sustainable Immigration Policy for the EU.IZA
Policy Paper No. 126.
Rodríguez-Planas, N., &amp; Nollenberger, N. (2016). Labor market integration of new
immigrants in Spain, IZA Journal of Labor Policy, 5: 4.Retreived from
https://doi.org/10.1186/s40173-016-0062-0.
Senik, C., Stichnoth, H., &amp; van der Straten, K. (2009). Immigration and Native’s
Attitudes towards the Welfare State: Evidence from the European Social Survey.
Social Indicators Research, 91(3), 345-370.
Scheve, K., &amp; Slaughter, M. (2001). Labor Market Competition and Individual
Preferences over Immigration Policy. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 83(1),
133-145.
Verdugo, G. (2016). Public housing magnets: public housing supply and
immigrants’ location choices. Journal of Economic Geography, 16(1), 237-265.

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

55

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="79">
            <name>Extent</name>
            <description>The size or duration of the resource.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="895">
                <text>3745</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="896">
                <text>Labour Market Transition Differences between Natives and  Immigrants in EU Economies</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="96">
            <name>Author</name>
            <description>Author</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="897">
                <text>Botrić, Valerija</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="94">
            <name>Abstract</name>
            <description>A summary of the resource.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="898">
                <text>Abstract: The recent economic crisis has had an adverse effect on the  labour markets of European economies and certain population groups  have been disproportionally affected by it. Increased migration flows  may very well have created further pressures on the labour markets of  host countries. The focus of the analysis here is on differences in  transitions from unemployment to employment and vice versa  between native and immigrant populations in European economies  during the 1998-2015 period. The analysis reveals different  outcomes to transitions from unemployment to employment, where in  certain countries and years, the unemployed natives find  proportionally more jobs, while in other countries and years, it is the  immigrants. In most of the countries, however, employed immigrants  are more likely to lose a job than natives. In addition to identifying  the immigrant-native gap, the characteristics of individuals as  potential contributing factors to the gap have also been assessed. The  results of this analysis show that similar individual characteristics  exert a different influence on the immigrant-native gap in labour  market outcomes in different countries. Thus, similar individual  characteristics are rewarded differently in different countries, i.e.,  their labour markets.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="45">
            <name>Publisher</name>
            <description>An entity responsible for making the resource available</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="899">
                <text>International Burch University</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="900">
                <text>2018</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="97">
            <name>Keywords</name>
            <description>Keywords.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="901">
                <text>Article
PeerReviewed</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="98">
            <name>DOI</name>
            <description>Digital object identifier</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="902">
                <text>doi: "10.14706/JECOSS17723 "     </text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="903">
                <text>ISSN 1986-8499, </text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="12">
        <name>H Social Sciences (General),HD Industries. Land use. Labor</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="118" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="120">
        <src>https://omeka.ibu.edu.ba/files/original/8dbf9cfbf5dc993d0e0ac30a004712d4.docx</src>
        <authentication>13b3ea68948d9cd98a2f21c3998205db</authentication>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="79">
            <name>Extent</name>
            <description>The size or duration of the resource.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="905">
                <text>3779</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="906">
                <text>Bilingualism in Kuwait – a linguistic landscape approach</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="96">
            <name>Author</name>
            <description>Author</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="907">
                <text>Brdarević Čeljo, Amna
Zolota, Sead</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="94">
            <name>Abstract</name>
            <description>A summary of the resource.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="908">
                <text>Abstract: This paper examined the linguistic landscape of the Governorate of Farwaniya, the biggest governorate in the State of Kuwait, by means of public and private signs displayed in the city center and side streets. A corpus of 150 photos of diverse signs, both official and non-official, was collected, categorized, analyzed and discussed. The results point to an undeniable representation of the Arabic language in both public and private spheres of life as well as to a substantial presence of the English language on a wide range of signage therefore confirming the imprint the process of globalization has made on this EFL context. The findings also indicate that some other world languages, namely Bengali, Hindi, and Chinese, are represented in the linguistic landscape of Kuwait but rather poorly.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="45">
            <name>Publisher</name>
            <description>An entity responsible for making the resource available</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="909">
                <text>International Burch University</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="910">
                <text>2018</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="97">
            <name>Keywords</name>
            <description>Keywords.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="911">
                <text>Article
PeerReviewed</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="912">
                <text>ISSN 2566-4638    (In Press)  </text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="4">
        <name>P Philology. Linguistics,PA Classical philology</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="119" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="121">
        <src>https://omeka.ibu.edu.ba/files/original/c39d4fcf4127d4c98fe50761be78b4e5.pdf</src>
        <authentication>f9a3edaf624ec2bf00cc0d37b8a9e78b</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="922">
                    <text>	&#13;  
	&#13;  

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

Bilateral Intra-Industry Trade in Country Characteristics
Context: The Case Study of Trade of Bosnia and Herzegovina
with Croatia
Snježana Brkić
School of Economics and Business University of Sarajevo
snjezana.brkic@efsa.unsa.ba

Abstract: The paper focuses primarily on intra-industry trade (IIT)
which is researched in the context of country-specific characteristics. A
three-decade-long academic research of IIT phenomena suggests that IIT
is likely to be more intensive and mostly of horizontal type between
countries that are at a similar stage of economic development, with the
same level of trade openness and with intensive and significantly
liberalized mutual trade. Geographical proximity of countries, especially
their common border, as well as their similarities in some non-economic
characteristics such as history, culture, language, also contribute to IIT
intensity. Bosnia and Herzegovina (BH) and Croatia match most of

Keywords:	&#13;  : Intra-Industry Trade
(IIT), Grubel-Lloyd Index (G-L
Index), Country Characteristics,
Bosnia and Herzegovina (BH),
Croatia
JEL Classification: F10, F14,
F15
Article History
Submitted: 11.9.2017
Resubmitted: 20.4.2018
Accepted: 26.7.2018

these criteria for intensive and increasing IIT. The aim of the research is
to check aforementioned thesis on IIT on a case study of BH in its trade
with Croatia over the period from 2003 till 2016. Research is focused

http://dx.doi.org/10.14706/JECO
SS17726

on IIT characteristics – intensity, trend and structure, both at aggregate
level (based on calculating corrected and uncorrected Grubel-Lloyd
indices) and at division level of Standard International Trade
Classification – SITC (based on calculating standard Grubel-Lloyd
index and relative unit values of export and import). The research
findings indicate a continuously rising, although lower than expected,
intensity of IIT, taking into account similarities between given countries
in comparison with other important trading partners of BH and taking
into account a high level of data aggregation. In BH trade with Croatia
inter-industry trade still prevails while high intensive IIT appears in a
very low number of product groups, coupled with the dominance of
vertical IIT. However,at the same time a growing trend and a
significant increase of IIT intensity in trade with Croatia have been
identified.
Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

100

�Bilateral Intra-Industry Trade in Country Characteristics Context: The Case Study of Trade
of Bosnia and Herzegovina with Croatia	&#13;  

Introduction
Empirical research into intra-industry trade (IIT) of a series of countries indicates the
existence of a significant IIT share and a greater presence of the horizontal type of
IIT in the mutual trade between countries with similar economic and non-economic
characteristics. The dominant IIT, mostly of horizontal type, is more likely to
develop between countries that are geographically close (particularly the neighboring
ones), and that are similar by size, economic development, trade openness, culture
and language, and have the common history, countries that intensively trade with
each other and belong to the same economic integration.
The aim of the paper is to establish whether the intensity and structure of IIT
between Bosnia and Herzegovina (BH) and Croatia develop in line with the
theoretical hypotheses and empirical findings on IIT between countries of given
characteristics. Upon comparing economic and other characteristics of the two
countries, the research focuses on measuring the share of BH IIT at an aggregate
level and determining the trend of IIT in BH trade with the world, Croatia and
other significant trading partners. The last section of research pertains to measuring
the IIT intensity in the BH trade with Croatia by industries, in order to determine
the number of product groups where IIT prevails, and a more common IIT type
having in mind the product differentiation (vertical or horizontal).
The IIT analysis is based on the calculation of aggregate Grubel-Lloyd indices, both
uncorrected and corrected for trade imbalance, and Grubel-Lloyd indices at the
industry level. For the purpose of this research the industry, i.e. the product group
has been defined at the level of divisions of the Standard International Trade
Classification (SITC) rev. 3, i.e. at a two-digit aggregation level 1 , and IIT was
measured based on the data by industries which registered exports and /or imports in
BH trade with Croatia over the observed period.
The observed time period covers fourteen years, from 2003 to 2016. It is the longest
period with available data at a two-digit SITC level for BH from an unique national
source and with a satisfactory degree of reliability.2 This period can be divided into
two parts: the period of free trade between the observed countries from 2003 to
2013, and the period from 2014 to 2016, when the degree of liberalization was
taken back to a lower level due to Croatia’s accession to the European Union (EU).

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

101

�Snježana Brkić	&#13;  

Literature Review
As opposed from the inter-industry trade which implies trade in products of
different industries and which is still the prevailing trade type in the structure of
international trade flows, intra-industry trade (IIT) is a kind of trade where products
of the same classification are simultaneously found in the structure of exports and
structure of imports of the trading countries. In simpler terms, IIT is the
international trade of products within the same industry. Probably the shortest,
although comprehensive enough definition says that IIT is a two-way trade in
products related in demand and/or supply (Brkić, 2012).
The explanation of the IIT phenomenon is based on a few theoretical concepts and
models, primarily those included in the modern theory of international trade and
based on imperfect competition, increasing returns and product differentiation.
Germs of the contemporary explanation of IIT are already found in the first modern
theories of international trade – Linder’s concept of demand similarity (1961) and
Vernon’s theory of product life cycle (1966). The first “true” IIT models based on
increasing returns and product differentiation were constructed by Krugman (1979)
and Lancaster (1980). The development of IIT model has led to the differentiation
between its horizontal and vertical component. The theoretical basis of horizontal
IIT was developed in models by Lancaster (1980), Krugman (1981), Helpman
(1981, 1987), Eaton and Kierzkowski (1984), and Bergstrand (1990), while the
theoretical basis of vertical IIT type rests upon papers published by Falvey (1981),
Shaked and Sutton (1984), Falvey and Kierzkowski (1987), and Flam and Helpman
(1987).
Research into the factors affecting IIT resulted in distinguishing IIT determinants
related to country characteristics (general and specific) on the one hand, and IIT
determinants related to industry characteristics on the other. The most common
general country characteristics include: size, economic development level, geographic
distance, trade barriers/degree of openness and trade intensity. Specific country
characteristics may include: common border, membership in same economic
integrations, similarity of culture and language, political ties, common history, etc.
One of the first theoretical concepts to implicitly offer the explanation of IIT
phenomenon based on country characteristics was developed by Linder (1961), who
introduced the hypothesis of similarity of demand. Some twenty years later, Linder’s
thesis was to be elaborated by Krugman (1980), and Helpman and Krugman (1985);
their papers led to a few claims about the determining role of country characteristics.
In a few papers of the 1980s3, Balassa highlighted the importance of countries’ size
and their mutual geographical distance for all types of international trade. Falvey
102

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Bilateral Intra-Industry Trade in Country Characteristics Context: The Case Study of Trade
of Bosnia and Herzegovina with Croatia	&#13;  

(1981) and Falvey and Kierzkowski (1987), and then Davis (1995) as well developed
concepts that relate IIT with factor endowment, which had previously been
exclusively considered as an inter-industry trade determinant.
Leamer (1988) and later Harrigan (1994, 1996) related IIT with policies, pointing
to the significance of market openness for the growth of international trade in
general, and IIT in particular. Numerous empirical studies also dealt with studying
the correlation between IIT and trade policy such as Pagoulatos and Sorensen
(1975), Loertscher and Wolter (1980), Caves, (1981), Bergstrand (1983, 1989,
1990), Havrylyshyn and Civan (1983), Balassa (1967, 1986c) Balassa and Bauwens
(1987), Torstensson (1996), Sharma (2000, 2002, 2004), Lee and Sohn (2005),
Veeramani (2009), and others. Most researchers reached the identical conclusion
that IIT intensity inversely varies compared to the level of trade restrictions. Trade
liberalization between trading countries in general, and particularly within higher
degrees of economic integration, is a significant determinant of IIT. Experiences of
developed economic integrations in the world, particularly of the EU point to the
conclusion that economic integration leads to an increase in intra-, rather than interindustry trade. The reason includes greater possibilities for production and trade in
differentiated products. The positive effect of regional economic integration on IIT
was determined in a number of studies: Balassa (1966, 1979); Grubel and Lloyd
(1975); Drabek and Greenaway (1984); Balassa and Bauwens (1987); Greenaway
(1987); Havrylyshyn and Kunzel (1997); Matthews (1998); Manger (2015); and
others.
A special interest of IIT researchers, starting from the already mentioned Balassa, was
aroused by the size and economic development of trading countries. According to
Lancaster (1980) and Bergstrand (1990), the larger the market size, the more space
there is for product differentiation and a greater import demand for differentiated
products, and the market size is therefore expected to be in the positive correlation
with IIT. Krugman (1979, 1980), and Helpman and Krugman (1985) find
arguments in the fact that a larger market presents a greater possibility for achieving
the economy of scale, which leads to a greater IIT. In empirical literature there are a
number of confirmations of the hypothesis on the impact of average size of trading
countries on IIT, starting from Balassa and Bauwens (1987), Bergstrand (1990),
Guell and Richards (1998) to more recent research by Durkin and Krygier (2000),
Kandogan (2003) and others. In the context of these considerations, one can expect
a greater IIT between countries of similar economic size. Due to the similarity in the
level of economic development between countries, which is typically expressed
through the similarity in the level of income p/c, one can also expect a greater
intensity of mutual IIT, which was established in the studies by Balassa and Bauwens
Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

103

�Snježana Brkić	&#13;  

(1987), Bergstrand (1990), Stone and Lee (1995), Nilsson (1999), etc. Similarity in
the level of economic development between countries indicates the similarity in their
ability to manufacture differentiated products and similarity in the size and pattern
of their demand for differentiated products.
Certain studies focused on the correlation between geography and IIT showed that
an increase in distance leads to a decrease in IIT far faster than in inter-industry
trade since, besides transport costs, some other factors such as the availability of
product information, which decreases as the distance increases, are also of a great
significance for the former trade type.4 Strong empirical evidence of IIT dependence
on geography can be found in literature – in papers by Loertscher and Wolter
(1980), Bergstrand (1983), Balassa (1986b), Balassa and Bauwens (1987), Culem
and Lundberg (1986), Hummels and Levinson (1995), Stone and Lee (1995), Amiti
and Venables (2002), Venables, Rice and Stewart (2003), Jambor and Torok (2013),
etc.
Historical, political and cultural ties are also significant for a decrease in the so-called
unfamiliarity costs in international trade, and thus for an increase in the IIT share.
Rauch (1999) stressed the significance of ethnic ties in international trade,
particularly in the trade in differentiated products, which are frequently subjects of
greater IIT. Finally, IIT intensity is also affected by trade intensity which measures
the volume of trading between countries. If two countries mutually trade to a
significant degree, it is more likely that, due to the spurred specialization, the share
of differentiated industrial products in the trade, and thus the trade overlap, will
grow.
Together with the development of theoretical explanation and modeling of IIT, ways
of its measurement were developed. A number of authors proposed different
measures of IIT intensity, change and structure: from static ones, such as the initial
Grubel-Lloyd index (Grubel and Lloyd, 1971, 1975), which evolved further and
reached its aggregate form and the form corrected for the impact of trade imbalance,
alternative indices created by Aquino (1978), Loertscher and Wolter (1980), Glejser,
Gossens and Eede (1982), to indices expressing change in IIT that can be considered
dynamic, such as Hamilton-Kniest index (1991), and marginal IIT index (Brülhart,
1994).

104

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Bilateral Intra-Industry Trade in Country Characteristics Context: The Case Study of Trade
of Bosnia and Herzegovina with Croatia	&#13;  

Applied Methodology
Values of the individual IIT indices were calculated, expressed and interpreted either
for each year of the period and/or as an average for the entire observed period and/or
for the selected years of the period.
Measuring the IIT share by countries (for all industries in total and for
manufacturing industry in particular) used the aggregate Grubel-Lloyd index (G-L
index) first in its uncorrected form:

∑ (Χ + Μ ) − ∑ Χ − Μ
=
∑ (Χ + Μ )
i

Βj

i

i

i

i

0 ≤ Bj ≤ 1

i

i

i

(1)

i

Bj – aggregate G-L index for a given country „j”, i.e. the IIT share; Xi – exports of
industry „i” from a given country; Mi – imports of industry „i”from a given country; i =
1,..., n – the number of industries.

Since IIT measurement using the aggregate G-L index is affected by the size of trade
imbalance between partners (Grubel and Lloyd, 1975) in the direction of IIT
underestimation, corrected G-L indices were calculated in the same time.

Cj =

∑ (X
i

∑ (X

i

i

+ Mi )− ∑ Xi − Mi
i

+ Mi )−

i

∑ X − ∑M
i

i

0 ≤ Cj ≤1

(2)

i

i

Measurement and comparison of IIT share by industries used the standard GrubelLloyd index (Grubel and Lloyd, 1975).

Bi =

(X i + M i ) −

Xi − Mi

Xi + Mi

0 ≤ Bi ≤ 1

(3)
(4)

for X i = 0 ili M i = 0 ⇒ X i − M i = ( X i + M i ) ⇒ Bi = 0

(5)

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

105

�Snježana Brkić	&#13;  

for X i = M i ⇒ X i − M i = 0 ⇒

(X i + M i ) − 0
Xi + Mi

= 1 ⇒ Bi = 1

(6)

If the index value equals 1, it means that there is a total overlap between exports and
imports of the given industry, and that the entire trade in industry “i” is of intraindustry type. If the value of index is 0, foreign trade of industry “i” is entirely the
inter-industry trade. For most product groups, the value of G-L index is between the
two extreme values. Values of IIT index can be classified into four categories, which
facilitates the interpretation of research results (Brkić, 2012):
- Bi ∈ [0.00; 0.25] – value of G-L index in this interval indicates strong interindustry tendencies;
- Bi ∈ [0.26; 0.50] – value of G-L index in this interval means the existence
of weak inter-industry tendencies;
- Bi ∈ [0.51; 0.75] – value of G-L index in this interval reflects the dominant
IIT, though relatively weaker intra-industry tendencies;
- Bi ∈ [0.76; 1.00] – value of G-L index in this interval signifies the existence
of prominent dominance of IIT.
Industries where vertical or horizontal IIT respectively prevails were identified using
the most frequently applied methodology in the empirical literature on IIT, which
was developed by Greenaway, Hine and Milner (1995). The methodology is based
on the assumption that the relative gap between unit values of exports and imports
reflects the difference in the quality of products traded between two countries.

UV X
UV M
HIIT : RUV ∈ [(1 − α ), (1 + α )]
VIIT : RUV ∈ [(1 + α ),+∞] or RUV ∈ [0, (1 − α )]
RUV =

(7)
(8)
(9)

UVX – unit value of exports; UVM – unit value of imports; α – arbitrarily fixed dispersion
factor ( = 0.15).

Horizontal IIT exists if the ratio between unit values of exports and imports (the
relative unit value – RUV) ranges in the interval from 0.85 to 1.15. If the relative
unit value is beyond this interval, the trade is identified as vertical IIT: vertical IIT in
higher-quality products in case the ratio exceeds 1.15 (which means that quality of
exports is higher than that of imports) or vertical IIT in lower-quality products in
case the ratio is below 0.85 (which means that quality of exports is lower than that of
imports).

106

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Bilateral Intra-Industry Trade in Country Characteristics Context: The Case Study of Trade
of Bosnia and Herzegovina with Croatia	&#13;  

Comparison of the size of observed countries used data on annual nominal GDP
expressed by current prices in US dollars (USD), and the estimates of economic
development used data on GDP per capita in US dollars, from a single source for the
entire period – World Economic Outlook Database by the International Monetary
Fund (IMF, 2017).
The trade intensity was calculated as the share of partner country’s market in the
overall foreign trade of the observed country.

TI =

X j +Mj

∑ X j + ∑M j

(10)

TI – trade intensity; Xj – exports of a given country to country „j”; Mj – imports of a
given country from country „j”; ∑Xj – total exports of a given country; ∑Mj – total
imports of a given country;

In economic studies, geographical distance is very often expressed as a direct straightline distance in kilometers between capitals of the observed pair of countries, which
was used in this research as well. The distance between the BH capital and capitals of
its trading partners indirectly “measures” the effects of transport, transaction and
information costs on trade, and on the IIT share.

Data Analysis and Results
Country Characteristics
The analysis of geographic orientation and the volume of export and import flows of
BH reveals that the trade between Croatia and BH is particularly intensive in the
entire period. In the absolute expression, exports gradually grew, and in 2016 were
twice as great as in the beginning of the observed period. Imports from Croatia grew
until 2008, when it began to decrease gradually (Appendix Table 7).
Croatia is the most significant BH trading partner, extremely important both as an
export destination and as a country of import origin. The average share of Croatia in
the foreign trade with BH, i.e. the average intensity of BH trade with Croatia in the
observed period amounts to 15.34%. Almost over the whole period (until 2014)
Croatia was ranked first by its significance for BH imports, although the share of
Croatia began to decrease more significantly after 2009 (e.g. from 18.28% in 2009
to 14.44% in 2012, and 10.02% in 2016) (Appendix Table 3). Croatia is also very
significant for BH as an export market. Over the first seven years of the observed
period Croatia absorbed BH exports more than any other country, and from 2010 it

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

107

�Snježana Brkić	&#13;  

was mostly ranked second, after Germany. On the other hand, BH was a significant
export destination for Croatia as well – the average share of BH in Croatian exports
amounts to 13.5%, which ranks BH second, after Italy (Appendix Table 4). The
significance of exports from BH for Croatia is far smaller – the average share of BH
in Croatian imports is only about 3.1%; however, BH is still among the “top ten”
countries of origin in Croatian imports over the most part of the analyzed period,
and the first among CEFTA countries which Croatia imports from.
Geographic proximity and common border of the observed countries undeniable
contribute to mutual trade. For BH, Croatia is the second closest trading partner
(after Serbia 5 ) – distance between Sarajevo and Zagreb equals 291 km (CEPII,
2013). Both countries have the longest shared land border compared to borders with
other neighboring countries: the border between BH and Croatia is over a half
(61%) length of the entire BH border – it is as much as 931 km long6 out of 1,537
km in total (Federal Ministry of Environment and Tourism, 2017). The length of
Croatian land border equals 2,374.9 km; the length of border with BH is almost
twice as long as the border with the other Croatia’s neighbor, Slovenia (Croatian
Bureau of Statistics, 2015).
The common state in the past, special political ties and a similar language and
culture are essential determinants of the overall economic, and therefore trade
relations between BH and Croatia. The common state and the single market have
existed in these regions for over 70 years – roots of the common state date back as
early as to the First World War. Countries that used to be in the common state for a
few decades inevitably share a number of economic, cultural, ethnic and other
features and ties, significant for mutual trade in general, and for IIT in particular.
Two decades ago they had the same official language (Serbocroatian), and the
present Croatian language, which is the official language in the Republic of Croatia
is also one of the official languages in BH, since Croats are one of the three
constituent ethnic groups of BH.
The described elements – common state in the past, geographic proximity and
common border, and political and cultural ties between the two countries – are
certainly significant for the mutual trade, as well as significant prerequisites for closer
economic integration. The history of trade liberalization between BH and Croatia, as
two sovereign states, is almost two decades long. The first free trade agreement
signed by independent BH in March 1995 was an agreement with the Republic of
Croatia. This agreement was valid for the following six years, when it was replaced
by a new one, made under the auspices of the Stability Pact for Southeastern Europe,
and within a network of bilateral free trade agreements in the region. The new

108

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Bilateral Intra-Industry Trade in Country Characteristics Context: The Case Study of Trade
of Bosnia and Herzegovina with Croatia	&#13;  

agreement which established a bilateral free trade area between BH and Croatia was
in force from 1 January 2001 to the point when the two countries became members
of the regional free trade area, the so-called CEFTA 2006 (The Central European
Free Trade Agreement), which further improved free trade.7
The early trade liberalization in the relations between the two countries (from 1995,
i.e. 2001), the two decades of the existence of a free trade area between the two
countries, together with the significant unilateral opening of BH toward the world in
general (over a few years, BH foreign trade coefficient ranged from 84 to 93%8)
points to a potential for a high IIT share in their mutual trade. In the period from
2001 to mid-2013, when Croatia became the EU member-state, the two countries
had the mutual duty-free trade, without quantitative restrictions and other measures
of equivalent effect, which primarily resulted from the bilateral free trade agreement
and, from 2007, from the creation of the regional free trade area. Since 2013, some
trade restrictions in bilateral trade were re-introduced or increased due to Croatia’s
withdrawal from CEFTA in 2006; however, the mutual trade is still liberal to a high
degree.
Measured by the nominal gross domestic product (GDP), Croatia is a three times
economically larger country than BH.9 In the context of IIT analysis, this difference
in the economic size could result in a lower intensity of BH IIT with Croatia than in
the case of countries of approximately same size. However, it should be noted that
the other significant BH trading partners, in economic terms, are countries far larger
than BH – Slovenia and Serbia, same as Croatia, have two to three times larger
economies than BH, while the differences in the size of BH and other trading
partners are extremely great (Appendix Table 1). BH and Croatia also reveal a
certain difference in the level of economic development, although not to the degree
to which the two countries differ from their significant trading partners from the
EU. Croatia had almost three times higher GDP per capita (p/c) than BH over the
entire observed period.10 The average GDP p/c amounted to USD 3,970.6 for BH
and USD 12,469.1 for Croatia while, for instance, the average GDP p/c of Germany
and Austria amounted to USD 41,478.6 and USD 45,020.81 respectively.
(Appendix, Table 2) If we compare gross national product (GNI), or GNP p/c
calculated according to the World Bank Atlas method, we will see that both
countries belong to the group of upper middle income countries11, although Croatia,
as opposed to BH is on the upper limit of the interval in the group (World Bank,
2016).

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

109

�Snježana Brkić	&#13;  

Intensity and Trend of Bilateral Intra-Industry Trade
The largest part of trade in goods between BH and Croatia is of the inter-industry
character, while approximately 37% (0.37) on average is the IIT. The average share
of IIT in the trade between BH and Croatia is lower than the average IIT share in
the BH overall trade, which amounts to 45% (Appendix, Table 5). According to the
average IIT intensity measured in the period 2003-2016, Croatia is ranked fourth
among the most significant BH trading partners, after Serbia 12 (0.42), Slovenia
(0.39) and Italy (0.38), and before Austria (0.34) and Germany (0.31) (Appendix,
Table 6). IIT indices in BH trade with larger trading partners over the past few years
were fairly uniform, except for a significant increase of IIT with Austria.
Figure 1: Trend of Intra-Industry Trade of BH with Croatia (G-L Index)
0.70
0.60
0.50
0.40
0.30
0.20
0.10
0.00
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

IIT - all industries (SITC 0-9)

IIT - manufacturing (SITC 5-8)

Source: Author's own work based on data of Agency for Statistics of BH (2017)

However, over the entire observed period, IIT index in the trade with Croatia
showed a moderately increasing trend (except in 2011, when a sharp decrease of a
few percentage points was registered), and significantly increased compared to the
beginning of the period. (Figure 1) From the level of 0.25 in 2003, IIT index
reached the level of 0.45 in the last three years, and thus surpassed all the other
trading partners except Austria (Appendix, Table 6). IIT indices in the
manufacturing industry products show even more prominent rising trend,
particularly after 2011.
The analysis of the manufacturing industry only (sectors SITC 5-8) reveals that the
share of BH IIT with Croatia is by 10 percentage points higher – 0.47 on average

110

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Bilateral Intra-Industry Trade in Country Characteristics Context: The Case Study of Trade
of Bosnia and Herzegovina with Croatia	&#13;  

over the observed period, which is expected due to a few times empirically proven
claim that IIT is larger in the trade of manufacturing industry products than in the
products of resource-based industries or in agricultural products.
Both in the case of the index of BH IIT with Croatia by years and as an average for a
given period, both for all industries and for manufacturing industry only, the
prevalence of inter-industry trade is always evident. The situation changes only if the
standard aggregate G-L index is replaced with the index corrected for trade
imbalance – the IIT index value then enters the zone of weaker intra-industry
tendencies.
Since it has been proven that trade imbalance results in the underestimate of the IIT
degree calculated using the G-L index, and that in its trade with Croatia BH registers
a significant trade deficit every year (BH imports from Croatia exceeded BH exports
to the country for a number of years13), it is reasonable to assume a negative impact
of trade imbalance on the measured IIT share. Compared to other significant BH
trading partners, the use of correction for trade imbalance is most justified in case of
its trade with Croatia. Although Croatia is the most significant foreign trade partner
of BH, it is in the trade with this country that almost the lowest import coverage by
exports is registered compared to the other significant partners 14 . After 2010 15 ,
import coverage by exports with Croatia mostly ranged between 52 and 55% (except
for 60% in 2016)16, as opposed to the trade with Austria, where it amounted to over
90% in the same period (even to 142% in 2014), with Slovenia also over 90% after
2012 (97% in 2015), with Germany and Italy to over 70% (MOFTER, 2011, 2013,
2015, 2016, 2017)17.
The repeated measurement of IIT with correcting the trade imbalance (using the socalled corrected or adjusted G-L index at the aggregate level) resulted in indices that
were by 14-25 percentage points higher and that, except in 2006, entered the area of
dominant (though less intensive) IIT. The average of corrected G-L index for the
observed period amounted to 0.5718 (Table 1).
Table 1: Intra-Industry Trade of BH with Croatia
IIT Share 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Aver.
Standard
0.25 0.26 0.31 0.29 0.31 0.33 0.37 0.45 0.40 0.43 0.43 0.45 0.45 0.45 0.37
G-L index
Corrected
0.57 0.50 0.53 0.43 0.51 0.56 0.62 0.66 0.58 0.62 0.57 0.66 0.62 0.60 0.57
G-L index

Source: Author's own work based on data of Agency for Statistics of BH (2017)

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

111

�Snježana Brkić	&#13;  

In the period after Croatia’s accession to the EU, which implied a somewhat
changed foreign trade regime, no significant changes regarding the IIT index were
observed. In 2014, the increasing trend of IIT continued, while by 2016 stagnation
in the overall IIT and a slight increase (1-2 percentage points) of the manufacturing
industry IIT were observed.
IIT analysis by industries defined as SITC divisions showed the dominance of interindustry trade in over two-thirds of the total number of industries which registered
trade with Croatia. However, the number of industries with very low G-L indices
0≤GL≤0.25 (industries with prominent dominance of inter-industry trade)
significantly decreased over the observed period, while the number of industries in
the category of highest G-L indices (extremely intensive IIT) slightly increased
(Figure 2).
Figure 2: Number of Product Groups by G-L Index
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

0.00-0.25

0.26-0.50

0.51-0.75

0.76-1.00

Source: Author's own work based on data of Agency for Statistics of BH (2017)

Generally viewed, the number of industries where IIT prevails (GL&gt;0.50) gradually
increased. In 2003, it amounted to 19, while over the last few years (starting from
2009) it ranged in the interval between 24 and 28. Besides, after 2009 the number of
industries in the category with lowest G-L indices (0≤GL≤0.10) – decreased
significantly – from 20 product groups in the beginning of the period to 12 at the
end of the period (Appendix, Table 8).
The analysis of relative unit values of exports and imports for the purpose of
differentiating vertical from horizontal IIT revealed a weak presence of horizontal
IIT, which serves as an indicator of convergence of the observed economies.
112

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Bilateral Intra-Industry Trade in Country Characteristics Context: The Case Study of Trade
of Bosnia and Herzegovina with Croatia	&#13;  

Horizontal IIT was observed in a small number of industries – the number mostly
ranged between 7 and 10 industries out of total 63-6519, except in 2013 and 2014,
when it increased to 14 and 15 industries respectively (Table 2).
Table 2: Number of Product Groups, by Dominant IIT Type
IIT type
HIIT
VIITh
VIITl
noRUV20
Total

Number of Product Groups
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
7
13
10
9
7
11
6
8
8
9
14
15
9
10
17
14
6
16
10
9
14
12
12
12
9
9
13
10
35
35
43
36
44
42
40
40
41
40
37
34
35
38
4
3
5
3
3
2
3
4
3
2
5
6
6
5
63
65
64
64
64
64
63
64
64
63
65
64
63
63

Legend: HIIT – horizontal IIT; VIITh – vertical IIT with high quality export of BH; VIITl – vertical IIT with low
quality export of BH; RUV – relative unit value;

Source: Author's own work based on data of Agency for Statistics of BH (2017)

In more than ¾ of the total number of industries which BH and Croatia trade in,
the vertical type of IIT is encountered, mostly with exports of lower-quality products
from BH. This phenomenon typically occurs in the trade of countries which differ
by size and development more than BH and Croatia do.

Discussion and Policy Implications
In general, the paper contributes to empirical research of IIT in transition countries,
especially because of its focus on South East European countries – research of IIT of
these countries still are lacked in the empirical literature. More concretely, the
research results are of a special interest for BH in the context of the country's trade
relations with its main trading partners and the future EU membership. Results of
analysis of IIT trend and pattern serve both as an indicator of sectoral similarity of
observed economies and for approximation of intensity of factor-market adjustment
pressures caused by trade expansion and economic integration.
The research indicates a continuous growth in IIT between BH and Croatia
suggesting the process of structural converegence – given economies have become
more similar in terms of their sectoral structure. However, the observed relatively
low intensity of IIT associated with prevalence of vertical IIT with BH low quality
exports indicates weaker structural convergence than expected in case of similar
countries. More quality advantages of Croatia suggest the need to develop sectoral
policies in BH aiming at increase in product quality level and technological intensity.
Among others, attracting of foreign direct investment to BH manufacturing sector
could contribute to reduction in quality and technological differences between
countries and changing trade structure toward horizontal IIT. Adequate sectoral
Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

113

�Snježana Brkić	&#13;  

policies will lead to catching-up not only with Croatia than also with some other EU
members that are more different from BH in terms of their size, income per capita
and other characteristics. Because of less mobile production factors within vertical
differentiated industries than in horizontal ones (Brülhart and Elliott, 2002),
dominancy of vertical IIT does not speak in favor of so called “smoothy-adjustment
hypothesis”21. In case of a deeper economic integration it is expected that vertical IIT
will have more implications on adjustment process in terms of higher economic and
social costs.

Conclusion
Based on the three-decade-long theoretical and empirical research into IIT, certain
regularities were observed regarding relationship between some country
characteristics and this phenomenon. In general, the literature indicates that
similarity between countries in size and level of economic development, intensive
mutual trading, geographic proximity, existence of common border, economic
integration, as well as similarity of culture and language, result in greater mutual IIT,
particularly of horizontal type (Brkić, 2012).
The analysis of IIT of BH with Croatia for the period 2003-2016 revealed a trade
pattern which is not fully consistent with the described theoretical theses on IIT
between countries with given characteristics. This is a case of neighboring countries
with strong mutual historical, economic, political and cultural ties, countries which
were tied with a free trade agreement for two decades, seven years out of which
within the same regional integration, due to which they have been intensely trading
with each other for a long period of time, and transition countries with no
significantly different macroeconomic performance. Therefore, the existence of
intensive and growing mutual IIT was assumed compared to IIT with other
significant trading partners (except for Serbia, which also has a few similarities to
BH), with a greater presence of horizontal IIT.
However, the research identified BH foreign trade with Croatia as primarily interindustry one, both at the aggregate and sectoral level (in most industries that register
the mutual trade), except in the analysis of manufacturing industry only over the last
four years. In the same time, most industries showed the dominant vertical type of
IIT. The measured IIT shares in the trade with Croatia become more significant
when compared with IIT shares in BH trade with other important trading partners
and with the world, as well as in case of index correction for trade imbalance.
Actually, the dominance of inter-industry trade was also discovered in BH trade with
other important partners, with IIT indices in the trade with Croatia being among

114

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Bilateral Intra-Industry Trade in Country Characteristics Context: The Case Study of Trade
of Bosnia and Herzegovina with Croatia	&#13;  

the highest (after Austria) over the last few years, due to the continuously rising
trend. The explanation of a lower IIT level with Croatia than expected is also helped
by the existence of prominent bilateral trade imbalance. The use of corrected IIT
indices at the aggregate level identified a turning point in the direction of slight IIT
dominance in BH trade with Croatia since 2007.
The used methodology does not allow the determination of the impact of individual
characteristics of given countries on their mutual IIT. However, if we understand
IIT as an indicator of an economy’s competitiveness and its convergence with other
countries’ economies, an explanation of what seems to be an insufficient consistency
between empirical findings and the theoretical assumption on IIT of countries with
certain characteristics, could be probably found in unsatisfactory competitiveness of
BH economy in general and its insufficient convergence with Croatian economy in
particular.

References
Agency for Statistics of BH (2017). Statistic database. Retrieved from
http://www.bhas.gov.ba/index.php?option=com_publikacija&amp;view=publikacija_preg
led&amp;ids=2&amp;id=7&amp;n=Vanjska%20trgovina
Amiti, M. &amp; Anthony J. V. (2002). The Geography of Intra-Industry Trade. In:
Lloyd, P. J. &amp; Lee, H.-H. (Eds.). (2002). Frontiers of Research in Intra-Industry
Trade. Hampshire and New York: Palgrave Macmillan Ltd., 87-106
Aquino, A. (1978). Intra-Industry Trade and Intra-Industry Specialisation as
Concurrent Sources of International Trade in Manufactures. Tübingen.
Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, 114(2), 275-295
Balassa, B. (1966). Tariff Reductions and Trade in Manufactures among Industrial
Countries. American Economic Review, 56 (June), 466-473
Balassa, B. (1967). Trade Liberalization among Industrial Countries: Objectives and
Alternatives. New York: McGraw-Hill
Balassa, B. (1979). Intra-Industry Trade and Integration of Developing Countries in
the World Economy. World Bank Staff Working Paper, 312
Balassa, B. (1986a). Intra-Industry Specialisation: A Cross-Country Analysis.
European Economic Review, 30, 27-42
Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

115

�Snježana Brkić	&#13;  

Balassa, B. (1986b). IIT among Exporters of Manufactured Goods. In: Greenaway,
D. &amp;. Tharakan P. K. M. (Eds.). (1986). Imperfect Competition and International
Trade. Brighton: Wheatshef
Balassa, B. (1986c). The Determinants of Intra-Industry Specialization in United
States Trade. Oxford Economic Papers. New Series, 38(2), 220-233
Balassa, B. &amp; Bauwens, L. (1987). Intra-Industry Specialisation in a Multi-Country
and Multi-Industry Framework. The Economic Journal, 97, 923-939
Bergstrand, J. H. (1983). Measurement and Determinants of Intra-Industry
International Trade. In: Tharakan, P. K. M. (Ed.). (1983). Intra-Industry Trade:
Empirical and Methodological Aspects. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science Publisher, 202235
Bergstrand, J. H. (1989). The Generalized Gravity Equation, Monopolistic
Competition, and the Factor-Proportions Theory in International Trade. Review of
Economics and Statistics, 71, 143-153, DOI: 10.2307/1928061
Bergstrand, J. H. (1990). The Heckscher-Ohlin-Samuelson Model, the Linder
Hypothesis and the Determinants of Bilateral Intra-Industry Trade. The Economic
Journal, 100
Brkić, S. (2012). Intra-industry Trade: Theoretical and Empirical Aspects. Sarajevo:
School of Economics and Business University of Sarajevo
Brkić, S. (2010). Determination of Intra-Industry Trade: Impact of CountrySpecific Characteristics. Sarajevo Business and Economics Review, 30, 516-541
Brülhart, M. (1994). Marginal Intra-Industry Trade: Measurement and Relevance
for Pattern of Industrial Adjustment. Tübingen: Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, 130(3),
600-613
Brülhart, M. (2008). An Account of Global Intra-Industry Trade, 1962-2006.
Research Paper Series on Globalization, Productivity and Technology, 2008/08,
Nottingham: University of Nottingham

116

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Bilateral Intra-Industry Trade in Country Characteristics Context: The Case Study of Trade
of Bosnia and Herzegovina with Croatia	&#13;  

Brülhart, M. &amp; Elliott, R. J. R. (1998). Adjustment to the European Single Market:
Inferences from Intra-Industry Trade Patterns. Journal of Economic Studies, 25(3),
225-247
Brülhart, M. &amp; Elliott, R. J. R. (2002). Labour-Market Effects of Intra-Industry
Trade: Evidence for the United Kingdom. Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, 138(2), 207–
228
Caves, R. E. (1981). Intra-Industry Trade and Market Structure in the Industrial
Countries. Oxford Economic Papers, 33(2), 203-223
Centre d’études prospectives et d’informations internationales – CEPII. (2013).
Distance Database. Retrieved from
http://www.cepii.fr/anglaisgraph/bdd/distances.htm
Croatian Bureau of Statistics. (2015). Statistical Yearbook 2015. Retrieved from
https://www.dzs.hr/hrv_eng/ljetopis/2015/sljh2015.pdf
Croatian Bureau of Statistics. (2016). PC-Axis Database: Foreign Trade in Goods
2010-2012 and 2013-2016. Retrieved from https://www.dzs.hr/default.htm
Culem, C. G. &amp; Lundberg, L. (1986). The Product Pattern of Intra-Industry Trade:
Stability among Countries and Over Time. Review of World Economics,12(1), 113130
Davis, D. R. (1995). Intra-Industry Trade: A Heckscher-Ohlin-Ricardo Approach.
Journal of International Economics, 39, 201-226
Drabek, Z. &amp; Greenaway, D. (1984). Economic Integration and Intra-Industry
Trade: The EEC and CMEA Compared. Kyklos, 37(3), 444-469
Durkin, J. T. Jr. &amp; Krygier, M. (2000). Differences in GDP Per Capita and the
Share of Intraindustry Trade: The Role of Vertically Differentiated Trade. Review of
International Economics, 8(4), 760-774
Eaton, J. &amp; Kierzkowski, H. (1984). Oligopolistic Competition, Product Variety,
and International Trade. In: Kierzkowski, H. (Ed.). (1984). Monopolistic
Competition and International Trade. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 69-83

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

117

�Snježana Brkić	&#13;  

Falvey, R. E. (1981). Commercial Policy and Intra-Industry Trade. Journal of
International Economics, 11(4), 495-511
Falvey, R. E. &amp; Kierzkowski, H. (1987). Product Quality, Intra-Industry Trade and
(Im)Perfect Competition. In: Kierzkowski, H. (Ed.). (1987). Protection and
Competition in International Trade. Essays in Honor of W. M. Corden. Oxford:
Blackwell, 143-161
Federal Ministry of Environment and Tourism (2017) General Data. Retrieved from
http://www.fmoit.gov.ba/bh_chm/osnovni_podaci_o_BiH.pdf
Flam, H. &amp; Helpman, E. (1987). Vertical Product Differentiation and North-South
Trade. American Economic Review,77(5), 810-822
Glejser, H., Gossens, K. &amp; Eede, V. (1982). Inter-Industry versus Intra-Industry
Specialization in Exports and Imports. Journal of International Economics, 12, 363369
Greenaway, D. (1987). Intra-Industry Trade, Intra-Firm Trade and European
Integration: Evidence, Gains and Policy Aspects. Journal of Common Market Studies,
XXVI (2)
Greenaway, D., Hine, R., &amp; Milner, Ch. (1995). Vertical and Horizontal IntraIndustry Trade: A Cross Industry Analysis for The United Kingdom. The Economic
Journal, 105, 1505-1518
Grubel, H. &amp; Llyod, P. J. (1971). The Empirical Measurement in Intra-Industry
Trade. The Economic Record, 47(120), 494-517
Grubel, H. &amp; Lloyd, P. J. (1975). Intra-Industry Trade: The Theory and Measurement
of International Trade in Differentiated Products. London: The Macmillan Press
Guell, R. C. and Richard, D. G. (1998). Regional Integration and Intra-Industry
Trade in Latin America, 1980-90. International Review of Applied Economics, 12(2),
283-300
Hamilton, C. &amp; Kniest, P. (1991). Trade Liberalization, Structural Adjustment and
Intra-Industry Trade: A Note. Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, 127, 365-367

118

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Bilateral Intra-Industry Trade in Country Characteristics Context: The Case Study of Trade
of Bosnia and Herzegovina with Croatia	&#13;  

Harrigan, J. (1994). OECD Imports and Trade Barriers in 1983. Journal of
International Economics, Elsevier, 35(1-2), 91-111
Harrigan, J. (1996). Openness to Trade in Manufactures in the OECD. Journal of
International Economics, Elsevier, 40(1-2), 23-29
Havrylyshyn, O. &amp; Civan, E. (1983). Intra-Industry Trade and the Stage of
Development: A Regression Analysis of Industrial and Developing Countries. In:
Tharakan, P. K. M. (Ed.) (1983). Intra-Industry Trade: Empirical and Methodological
Aspects. Amsterdam: North-Holland, 111-140
Havrylyshyn, O. &amp; Kunzel, P. (1997). Intra-Industry Trade of Arab Countries: An
Indicator of Potential Competitiveness. IMF Working Paper
Helpman, E. (1981). International Trade in the Presence of Product Differentiation,
Economies of Scale and Monopolistic Competition: A Chamberlin-HeckscherOhlin Approach. Journal of International Economics, Elsevier, 11 (3), 305-340
Helpman, E. (1987). Imperfect Competition and International Trade: Evidence
from Fourteen Industrial Countries. Journal of the Japanese and International
Economies, 1, 62-81
Helpman, E. &amp; Krugman, P.R. (1985). Market Structure and Foreign Trade (8th ed).
Cambridge: The MIT Press
Hummels, D. &amp; Levinsohn, J. (1995). Monopolistic Competition and International
Trade: Reconsidering the Evidence. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 110(3), 799836
International Monetary Fund (IMF) (2017). World Economic Outlook Database.
April 2017 Edition. Retrieved from
http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/weo/2017/01/weodata/index.aspx
Jambor, A. &amp; Torok, A. (2013). Intra-Industry Agri-Food Trade of the Baltic
Countries. Paper presented at the 87th Annual Conference of the Agricultural
Economics
Society,
University
of
Warwick.
Retrieved
from
https://ageconsearch.umn.edu/bitstream/158684/2/Attila_Jambor_Jambor_Torok_
Warwick.pdf
Kandogan, Y. (2003). Intra-Industry Trade of Transition Countries: Trends and
Determinants. William Davidson Working Paper, 566
Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

119

�Snježana Brkić	&#13;  

Krugman, P. R. (1979). Increasing Returns, Monopolistic Competition and
International Trade. Journal of International Economics, 9(4), 469-479
Krugman, P. R. (1980). Scale Economies, Product Differentiation, and the Patterns
of Trade. American Economic Review, 70, 950-959
Lancaster, K. (1980). Intra-Industry Trade Under Perfect
Competition. Journal of International Economics, 10(2), 151-175

Monopolistic

Leamer, E. E. (1988). Measures of Openness. NBER Chapters in: Trade, Policy
Issues and Empirical Analysis. National Bureau of Economic Research Inc., 145-204
Lee, H.-H. &amp; Sohn, Ch.-H. (2005). South Korea’s Marginal Intra-Industry Trade
and the Choice of Preferential Partners. Asian Economic Papers, 3(3), 94-116
Linder, S. B. (1961). An Essay on Trade and Transformation. New York: John Wiley
&amp; Sons
Loertscher, R. &amp; Wolter, F. (1980). Determinants of Intra-Industry Trade: Among
Countries and Across Industries. Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, 116, 280-293
Manger, M. (2015). PTA Design, Tariffs and Intra-Industry Trade. In: Dür, A. &amp;
Elsig, M. (Eds.). (2015). Trade Cooperation: The Purpose, Design and Effects of
Preferential Trade Agreements. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 195–217
Matthews, K. (1998). Intra-Industry Trade: An Australian Panel Study. Journal of
Economic Studies, 25(2), 84-97
Ministry of Foreign Trade and Economic Relations of BH (MOFTER) (2011).
Analysis
of
Foreign
Trade
of
BH
for
2010.
Retrieved
from
http://www.mvteo.gov.ba/izvjestaji_publikacije/izvjestaji/default.aspx?id=3332&amp;lang
Tag=bs-BA
Ministry of Foreign Trade and Economic Relations of BH (MOFTER) (2013).
Analysis
of
Foreign
Trade
of
BH
for
2012.
Retrieved
from
http://www.mvteo.gov.ba/izvjestaji_publikacije/izvjestaji/default.aspx?id=5477&amp;lang
Tag=bs-BA

120

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�Bilateral Intra-Industry Trade in Country Characteristics Context: The Case Study of Trade
of Bosnia and Herzegovina with Croatia	&#13;  

Ministry of Foreign Trade and Economic Relations of BH (MOFTER) (2015).
Analysis
of
Foreign
Trade
of
BH
for
2014.
Retrieved
from
http://www.mvteo.gov.ba/izvjestaji_publikacije/izvjestaji/Archive.aspx?langTag=bsBA&amp;template_id=96&amp;pageIndex=2
Ministry of Foreign Trade and Economic Relations of BH (MOFTER) (2016).
Analysis
of
Foreign
Trade
of
BH
for
2015.
Retrieved
from
http://www.mvteo.gov.ba/izvjestaji_publikacije/izvjestaji/default.aspx?id=7897&amp;lang
Tag=bs-BA
Ministry of Foreign Trade and Economic Relations of BH (MOFTER) (2017).
Analysis
of
Foreign
Trade
of
BH
for
2016.
Retrieved
from
http://www.mvteo.gov.ba/izvjestaji_publikacije/izvjestaji/default.aspx?id=8622&amp;lang
Tag=bs-BA
Nilsson, L. (1999). Two-Way Trade between Unequal Partners: The EU and the
Developing Countries. Review of World Economics, 135(1), 102–127
Pagoulatos, E. &amp; Sorensen, R. (1975). Two-way International trade: An
Econometric Analysis. Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, 111(3), 454-465
Rauch, J. E. (1999). Networks versus Markets in International Trade. Journal of
International Economics, 48, 7-35
Shaked, A. &amp; Sutton, J. (1984). Natural Oligopolies and International Trade. In:
Kierzkowski, H. (Ed.). (1984). Monopolistic Competition and International Trade.
Oxford: Oxford University Press, 34-50
Sharma, K. (2000). The Pattern and Determinants of Intra-Industry Trade in
Australian Manufacturing. The Australian Economic Review, 33(3), 245-255
Sharma, K. (2002). How Important Is the Processed Food in Intra-Industry Trade?
The Australian Experience. Journal of Economic Studies, 29 (2/3), 121-130
Sharma, K. (2004). Horizontal and Vertical Intra-Industry Trade in Australian
Manufacturing: Does Trade Liberalization Have Any Impact? Applied Economics, 36,
1723 -1730
Stone, J. A. &amp; Lee, H.-H. (1995). Determinants of Intra-Industry Trade: A
Longitudinal, Cross-Country Analysis. Review of World Economics, 133(1), 67-83
Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

121

�Snježana Brkić	&#13;  

Torstensson, J. (1996). Can Factor Proportions Explain Vertical Intra-Industry
Trade? Applied Economic Letters, 3(5), 307-309
Venables, A. J., Rice, P. G., &amp; Stewart, M. (2003). The Geography of Intra-Industry
Trade: Empirics. Topics in Economic Analysis &amp; Policy, 3(1), 1-23
Veeramani, C. (2009). Trade Barriers, Multinational Involvement and IntraIndustry Trade: Panel Data Evidence from India. Applied Economics (Routledge), 41,
20, 2541-2553
Vernon, R. (1966). International Investment and International Trade in the Product
Cycle. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 80(2): 190–207. DOI: 10.2307/1880689
World Bank. (2016). Data: World Bank Country and Lending Groups. Retrieved
from https://datahelpdesk.worldbank.org/knowledgebase/articles/906519.

122

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�2003
2,197.1
32,176.9
8,048.9
30,785.6
27,527.4
14,906.0
2,836.5

2004
2,611.8
36,754.6
9,365.6
34,657.5
31,319.7
17,282.6
3,315.3

2005
2,789.9
38,319.4
10,224.2
35,239.9
32,066.4
18,222.6
3,504.3

2006
3,178.9
40,469.9
11,359.5
37,020.4
33,486.0
19,777.1
4,145.0

Gross domestic product per capita (GDP p/c), in USD
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
3,912.4 4,784.5 4,508.2 4,404.4 4,788.8 4,430.5
46,652.9 51,629.7 47,785.6 46,757.1 51,192.6 48,381.4
13,544.0 15,889.1 14,142.3 13,505.0 14,538.0 13,234.7
42,531.4 46,681.1 42,576.3 42,641.7 46,853.2 44,089.7
37,890.2 40,953.9 37,130.2 35,969.2 38,379.3 34,918.7
23,959.2 27,784.0 24,785.1 23,499.6 25,040.5 22,517.1
5,486.5 6,689.0 5,820.5 5,353.6 6,424.0 5,656.3

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

Source: Prepared by the author on the basis of IMF World Economic Outlook Database (2017)

Country
BH
Austria
Croatia
Germany
Italy
Slovenia
Serbia

Table 2: Gross Domestic Product Per Capita of BH and Its Most Important Trading Partners

Source: Prepared by author on the basis of IMF World Economic Outlook Database (2017)

2013
4,681.9
50,533.3
13,573.7
46,545.1
35,706.6
23,170.3
6,351.7

2014
4,784.8
51,390.0
13,468.7
47,978.6
35,456.7
24,069.3
6,199.1

2015
4,206.7
43,749.6
11,578.5
41,197.4
30,032.1
20,746.9
5,244.3

123

2016
4,308.2
44,498.4
12,095.5
41,902.3
30,507.2
21,320.2
5,376.3

Gross domestic product (GDP), in billion USD
Country 2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
BH
8.48
10.16
10.94
12.46
15.32
18.71
17.60
17.16
18.63
17.21
18.16
18.52
16.25
16.61
Austria 261.22 300.26 315.19 334.60 386.00 429.64 398.60 390.94 429.43 407.68 428.38 439.07 377.16 386.75
Croatia 34.66
41.57
45.42
50.44
60.08
70.45
62.64
59.67
62.24
56.49
57.77
57.08
48.68
50.44
Germany 2,510.53 2,823.07 2,866.31 3,005.08 3,444.72 3,770.15 3,426.67 3,423.47 3,761.14 3,545.95 3,753.69 3,885.44 3,365.29 3,466.64
Italy 1,572.65 1,800.76 1,855.83 1,944.34 2,206.11 2,402.06 2,190.70 2,129.02 2,278.38 2,073.97 2,131.16 2,155.15 1,825.82 1,850.74
Slovenia 29.74
34.50
36.40
39.62
48.17
55.85
50.37
48.10
51.34
46.28
47.70
49.61
42.80
44.01
Serbia
21.22
24.74
26.08
30.72
40.50
49.17
42.61
39.04
46.49
40.73
45.52
44.21
37.16
37.75

Table 1: Gross Domestic Product of BH and Its Most Important Trading Partners

Appendix

Bilateral Intra-Industry Trade in Country Characteristics Context: The Case Study of Trade of Bosnia and Herzegovina with Croatia	&#13;  

�2003
17.87
1
18.27
1
18.12

2004
20.15
1
18.40
1
18.83

2005
20.50
1
16.87
1
17.79

2006
18.69
1
17.10
1
17.59

2007
18.36
1
17.78
1
17.96

2008
17.24
1
17.06
1
17.11

2009
17.07
1
18.28
1
17.90

14.38
2.10
6,11

1.62
5.44

2004

13.91

2003

2.44
6.25

14.32

2005

2.79
5.99

12.63

2006

2.84
6.59

14.41

2007

2.67
6.66

15.32

2008

2.67
6.04

12.83

2009

0.26

0.40

0.25

0.39

2004
0.32

0.44

0.31

2005
0.36

0.42

0.29

2006
0.44

0.44

0.31

2007
0.46

0.44

0.33

2008
0.46

124

3.05
6.22

11.61

0.50

0.37

0.46

0.45

2011

0.46

0.43

2012
0,50

3.34
6.64

12.24

2011

14.65
2
14.47
1
14.53

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

0.44

0.40

IIT Share (G-L Index)
2009
2010
2011
0.45
0.49
0.49

Source: Author's own work based on data of Agency for Statistics of BH (2017)

IIT with Croatia, all
industries (SITC 09)
IIT with Croatia –
manufacturing
(SITC 5-8)

IIT with the world

2003
0.30

Table 5: Intra-industry Trade of BH with the World and with Croatia

2010
15.09
2
15.12
1
15.11

2010

Source: Author's own work based on data of Croatian Bureau of Statistics (2016)

Share of BH in Croatian
export %
Share of BH in Croatian
import %
Trade Intensity

Table 4: Trade Intensity of Croatia in Trade with BH

Source: Author's own work based on data of Agency for Statistics of BH (2017)

Share of Croatia in BH export,%
Rank of Croatia in BH export
Share of Croatia in BH import,%
Rank of Croatia in BH import
Trade intensity

Table 3: Trade Intensity of BH in Trade with Croatia

Snježana Brkić	&#13;  

2012

6.95

3.50

2013

0.50

0.43

6.72

3.52

12.23

2013

14.25
2
12.90
1
13.38

2013
0.50

12.76

2012

14.83
2
14.44
1
14.57

2014

0.55

0.45

2014
0.50

6.12

2.69

11.80

2014

11.00
3
11.43
2
11.28

2015

0.57

0.45

2015
0.53

5.39

2.68

9.73

2015

10.29
3
10.56
4
10.46

2016

0.58

0.45

2016
0.54

5.29

2.91

9.09

2016

10.46
3
10.02
4
10.19

0.47

0.37

Average
0.45

3.11
6.19

11.31

Average

15.75
1
15.19
1
15.34

Average

�0.21
0.26
0.27

0.13
0.25
0.29

0.36
0.19
0.42

Country
Austria
Croatia
Germany

Italia
Slovenia
Serbia

0.32
0.30
0.42

0.23
0.31
0.28

2005

0.39
0.33
0.47

0.28
0.29
0.29

2006

0.36
0.44
0.50

0.31
0.31
0.29

2007

0.37
0.44
0.50

0.35
0.33
0.29

2008

0.41
0.44
0.41

0.37
0.37
0.28

2009

44.51%

41.61%

41.81%

-671.80

Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

52.00%

-505.32

53.62%

-532.74

52.89%

-530.48

61.06%

-389.47

51.58%

-458.44

-829.87

595.66

2014

0.38
0.46
0.37

0.47
0.45
0.34

2015

-694.89

615.82

2013

0.39
0.47
0.40

0.43
0.45
0.34

2014

946.75

547.40

2012

0.37
0.43
0.44

0.36
0.43
0.35

2013

1,252.26 1,421.35 1,154.53 1,052.72 1,148.56 1,126.14 1,000.28

482.73

2011

0.41
0.44
0.41

0.38
0.43
0.35

2012

488.31

591.48

557.37

2009

0.41
0.45
0.37

0.37
0.40
0.32

2011

610.81

2008

2007

Source: Author's own work based on data of Agency for Statistics of BH (2017)

2003
2004
2005
2006
Exports to
Croatia, mil EUR
218.64 310.37 396.45 493.53
Imports from
Croatia, mil EUR
779.58 885.31 964.51 995.44
Trade balance,
mil EUR
-560.94 -574.93 -568.05 -501.91
Export/import
28.05% 35.06% 41.10%
49.58%
coverage %

Table 7: Trade Balance of BH with Croatia
2010

0.42
0.43
0.39

0.35
0.45
0.33

2010

IIT Share (G-L Index)

Source: Author's own work based on data of Agency for Statistics of BH (2017)

0.35
0.24
0.40

2004

2003

Table 6: Intra-industry Trade of BH with Its Most Important Trading Partners

55.29%

-382.44

855.47

473.03

2015

0.34
0.44
0.40

0.50
0.45
0.36

2016

125

60.91%

-323.31

827.11

503.81

2016

0.38
0.39
0.42

0.34
0.37
0.31

Average

Bilateral Intra-Industry Trade in Country Characteristics Context: The Case Study of Trade of Bosnia and Herzegovina with Croatia	&#13;  

�2004

31
/16
14
11
9
65

2003

35
/20
10
11
8
63

28
/17
16
11
9
64

2005
26
/19
16
14
8
64

2006
30
/16
14
11
9
64

2007
29
/16
14
10
11
64

2008
21
/12
16
14
12
63

20
/13
19
13
12
64

23
/14
17
13
11
64

20
/13
16
11
16
63

Number of Product Groups
2009
2010
2011
2012
22
/14
15
11
17
65

2013
22
/13
15
15
12
64

2014
21
/14
16
11
15
63

2015

126

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

Note: Second number in every cell of the first row (after slash) indicates the number of product groups with 0≤GL≤0.10.
Source: Author's own work based on data of Agency for Statistics of BH (2017)

0.26-0.50
0.51-0.75
0.76-1.00
Total

Interval
GL
0.00-0.25

Table 8: Number of Product Groups, by G-L Index

Snježana Brkić	&#13;  

21
/12
17
13
12
63

2016

25
/15
15
12
12

Av.

�Journal of Economic and Social Studies

	&#13;  
	&#13;  
	&#13;  
	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;   	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  
1

	&#13;  Empirical studies of IIT typically use industry definitions at a three-digit SITC level, since
it is believed that it is a category closest to the economic definition of industry. However,
reliable data at this aggregation level were not available for BH trade with Croatia in the
BH national statistics over a long time period (all until 2008). Using and combining data
from other sources (other countries' statistics, international organizations and groups'
databases) would affect the reliability and comparability of input „values“in the analysis
and the validity of obtained results.
2
The inclusion of data from the period before 2003 into the analysis would mean using data
collected and processed by means of different methodologies in BH entities, or combining
data from international sources. Since 2003, due to the adoption of appropriate legal
documents, it has been possible to merge data on BH foreign trade at a country level, i.e.
to collect and express them according to the unique methodology for both BH entities
(The Federation of Bosnia and Hercegovina and the Republic of Srpska), and the Brčko
District.
3
Balassa (1986a, 1986c)
4
A significant part of IIT in the world pertains to differentiated products for the purchase of
which, as opposed to the purchase of standardized products, it is essential that buyers are
well informed on varieties' characteristics. Greater proximity leads to an increase in
informartion availability – contacts between companies, and between companies and
consumers intensify, and thus lower the costs of providing information to buyers, facilitate
trade and make it less expensive (Brkić, 2010).
5
Distance between Sarajevo and Belgrade equals 193 km, between Sarajevo and Vienna 510
km, between Sarajevo and Ljubljana 395 km, between Sarajevo and Rome 532 km, and
between Sarajevo and Berlin 1,033 km (CEPII, 2013).
6
According to the Croatian Bureau of Statistics (2015), the length of land border between
Croatia and BH, including borders on rivers, amounts to 1,011.4 km.
7
CEFTA agreement was signed on 19.12.2006. Croatia became its member in 2006, and
BH in 2007 (BH ratified the Agreement on 27.09.2007).
8
Trade coefficient is calculated as a share of foreign trade of a given country in its GDP.
9
In the beginning of the analyzed period, Croatian GDP was four times higher than BH
GDP, so that the difference decreased in the meantime.
10
In 2003, Croatian GDP p/c amounted to USD 8,048.9 compared to USD 2,197.1 in BH,
while in 2016 it amounted to USD 12,095.5 compared to 4,308.2 in BH (Appendix,
Table 1).
11
Countries of this group have incomes p/c between USD 3,956 and USD 12,235 for 2016.
12
Until 2014, IIT index pertains to Serbia and Montenegro together, since the two countries
were in a state union at the time.
13
Appendix, Table 7.
14
Except for Serbia. According to the analyses of the Ministry of Foreign Trade and
Economic Relations of BH, import coverage by exports in the trade with Serbia decreased
to approximately 50% after 2010 and 2011, when it amounted to over 60%.
Volume 7 | Issue 2 |

127

�Snježana Brkić	&#13;  

	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;   	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;   	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;   	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  	&#13;  
15

Before 2010, it typically amounted to approximately 41% (Appendix, Table 7).
Appendix, Table 7.
17
Data from publications on analysis of BH foreign trade issued by Ministry of Foreign
Trade and Economic Relations of Bosnia and Herzegovina in the following years; 2011,
2013, 2015, 2016, 2017.
18
These results are usually not taken as completely accurate, due to certain weaknesses of the
use of corrected G-L index. It is however irrefutable that due to the trade imbalance in the
mutual trade of these countries, the IIT share is to a degree underestimated.
19
According to parameter ±0.15.
20
Note: „no RUV “means that RUV could not be calculated because of one-way trade i.e.
only export or only import registered in a given industry.
16

21

“Smooth-adjustment hypothesis” refers to realocation of production factors (labour and
capital) between different product lines within a given sector rather than between sectors.
Adjustment in terms of temporary unemployment and wage disparities is “smoothy” if
expanding product lines and declining product lines belong to the same sector (Brülhart &amp;
Elliot, 1998).	&#13;  

	&#13;  

128

Journal of Economic and Social Studies

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="79">
            <name>Extent</name>
            <description>The size or duration of the resource.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="913">
                <text>3755</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="914">
                <text>Bilateral Intra-Industry Trade in Country  Characteristics Context: The Case Study of Trade of  Bosnia and Herzegovina with Croatia</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="96">
            <name>Author</name>
            <description>Author</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="915">
                <text>Brkić, Snježana</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="94">
            <name>Abstract</name>
            <description>A summary of the resource.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="916">
                <text>Abstract: The paper focuses primarily on intra-industry trade (IIT)  which is researched in the context of country-specific characteristics. A  three-decade-long academic research of IIT phenomena suggests that IIT  is likely to be more intensive and mostly of horizontal type between  countries that are at a similar stage of economic development, with the  same level of trade openness and with intensive and significantly  liberalized mutual trade. Geographical proximity of countries, especially  their common border, as well as their similarities in some non-economic  characteristics such as history, culture, language, also contribute to IIT  intensity. Bosnia and Herzegovina (BH) and Croatia match most of  these criteria for intensive and increasing IIT. The aim of the research is  to check aforementioned thesis on IIT on a case study of BH in its trade  with Croatia over the period from 2003 till 2016. Research is focused  on IIT characteristics – intensity, trend and structure, both at aggregate  level (based on calculating corrected and uncorrected Grubel-Lloyd  indices) and at division level of Standard International Trade  Classification – SITC (based on calculating standard Grubel-Lloyd  index and relative unit values of export and import). The research  findings indicate a continuously rising, although lower than expected,  intensity of IIT, taking into account similarities between given countries  in comparison with other important trading partners of BH and taking  into account a high level of data aggregation. In BH trade with Croatia  inter-industry trade still prevails while high intensive IIT appears in a  very low number of product groups, coupled with the dominance of  vertical IIT. However,at the same time a growing trend and a  significant increase of IIT intensity in trade with Croatia have been  identified.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="45">
            <name>Publisher</name>
            <description>An entity responsible for making the resource available</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="917">
                <text>International Burch University</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="918">
                <text>2018</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="97">
            <name>Keywords</name>
            <description>Keywords.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="919">
                <text>Article
PeerReviewed</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="98">
            <name>DOI</name>
            <description>Digital object identifier</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="920">
                <text>doi: "10.14706/JECOSS17726 "     </text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="921">
                <text>ISSN 1986-8499, </text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="11">
        <name>H Social Sciences (General),HB Economic Theory</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="120" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="122">
        <src>https://omeka.ibu.edu.ba/files/original/e4bfd31774208becfe0269abe98a4ae0.pdf</src>
        <authentication>4c79705625710cec4cfc2b2adff216b8</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="931">
                    <text>���Ilda Kovačević
Sanin Džidić

HIGH - RISE BUILDINGS
STRUCTURES AND MATERIALS

Sarajevo, 2018

�Authors:
Ilda Kovačević
Sanin Džidić
Publisher:
International BURCH University Sarajevo
Critical Review:
Assoc. Prof Dr. Amir Čaušević, University of Sarajevo, Faculty of Architecture
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Nerman Rustempašić, University of Sarajevo, Faculty of Architecture
Assist. Prof. Dr. Emina Zejnilović, International BURCH University, Faculty of Engineering and Natural
Sciences, Department of Architecture
Proofreading:
Dijana Misaljević, MA
Desktop publishing:
Authors
Date and Place:
February 2018, Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina
Copyright
International BURCH University Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina, 2018
Reproduction of this Publication for Educational or other non-commercial purposes is authorized without
prior permission from the copyright holder. Reproduction for resale or other commercial purposes
prohibited without prior written permission of the copyright holder.
Disclaimer: While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information, contained in
this publication, the publisher will not assume liability for writing and any use made of the proceedings,
and the presentation of the participating organizations concerning the legal status of any country,
territory, or area, or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries.
_________________________________________________________

CIP - Katalogizacija u publikaciji
Nacionalna i univerzitetska biblioteka Bosne i Hercegovine, Sarajevo
725.222(075.8)
KOVAČEVIĆ, Ilda
High-rise buildings [Elektronski izvor] : structures and materials / Ilda Kovačević, Sanin Džidić. El. knjiga. - Sarajevo : International Burch University, 2018. - 175 str. : ilustr.
Način dostupa (URL): http://eprints.ibu.edu.ba/3717. - Nasl. s nasl. ekrana. - Izvor opisan dana
23.1.2018. - Bibliografija: str. 163-175.
ISBN 978-9958-834-59-2
1. Džidić, Sanin
COBISS.BH-ID 24918278

���TABLE OF CONTENT
Preface ......................................................................................................................... 7
List of Figures ............................................................................................................ 9
List of Tables ........................................................................................................... 15
Introduction .............................................................................................................. 17
High-Rise Buildings through World Architecture ................................................... 25
High-Rise Buildings in Bosnia and Herzegovina ..................................................... 43
Structures of High-Rise Buildings ........................................................................... 59
Classification of the Structures of High–Rise Buildings .......................................... 65
Frame System ........................................................................................................... 69
Shear Walls System .................................................................................................. 71
Outrigger System ...................................................................................................... 75
Tube System ............................................................................................................. 79
Diagrid System ......................................................................................................... 85
Space Truss System, Exo–Skeleton System and Super Frame Structures ............... 87
Hybrid Structures ..................................................................................................... 91
Steel as Structural Material for High-Rise Buildings ............................................... 93
Concrete as Structural Material for High-Rise Buildings ...................................... 105
High-Strength Concrete (HSC) as Structural Material for High-Rise Buildings ... 119
Composite Steel-Concrete Structures for High-Rise Buildings ............................. 133
Risk of Progressive Collapse in High-Rise Structures ........................................... 143
References .............................................................................................................. 163

��PREFACE
High-rise buildings present a challenge; they present a challenge for architects,
engineers, occupants as well as observers. They attract the viewer's eye. They are our
monuments and often become city landmarks and tourist attractions. City views from
the tops of the buildings are also extremely appealing. People either praise them or
criticize them, but they are indeed an important part of urban landscape in every
modern city. They are here, present, and can be found in every metropolis or city that
intends to become one. Sometimes they stand in awe, and sometimes they stretch
above. For all they are, or for all they are not, their builders are the culprits
responsible for these magnificent structures.
This book is the result of a serious research, and it is intended to become a textbook
for the "High-Rise Buildings" course held at the Master's Degree Program at the
Department of Architecture at the Faculty of Engineering and Natural Sciences of the
International BURCH University in Sarajevo. However, students of other
architectural faculties or departments of architecture, students of structural
engineering, as well as architects and structural engineers in design and construction
themselves may find this book helpful. Parts of the book, or the entire book may also
be of interest for a common reader.
As the human body is composed of brain, skeleton, muscles, organs, blood and
nervous system, all of which have their own functionality and appearance, the
organism we call a high-rise building is also composed of load-bearing structure,
different materials applied, and various embedded functional systems that allow for
comfort and serviceability of these structures. Their appearance catches the
observer’s eye and causes different emotions; sometimes these emotions are positive,
sometimes not so much, but essentially everything that initiates any emotion in a
person becomes a truly memorable experience.
This book attempts to simultaneously analyze high-rise buildings from several aspects
- form, appearance and beauty, and in the next step, their architectural and structural
functionality and comfort. But no project is possible without the actual materialization
and functional load-bearing structure. Like a human being, each building has its own
requirements and expectations, as well as its needs to properly behave in dangerous
situations that may happen in one’s lifetime, or in the case of buildings, in a service
life. Every high-rise building should adequately respond to common situations, and
those that are not so common, but also be prepared to those that are entirely
unexpected. This book will try to explain the symbiosis and causative consequential
relationships and synergy of architecture, load-bearing structure and applied
materials. If this synergy did not exist, it would be difficult to talk about a successful
7

�project, but if it existed, then the story about that building would be shared and passed
on.
Readers of the book will decide if we succeeded in our attempt; if we contributed to
the improvement of one’s knowledge in this field of expertise, then we succeeded as
authors. If we caught up your interest in the subject, we did it again. If not, forgive
us, because we had the best possible intention of doing so. However, we will look for
the opportunity to improve and redeem ourselves through some other future projects.
We use this opportunity to thank our reviewers for their remarks, recommendations
and suggestions. We’d like to thank mr. Elmir Halebić for the design of the book cover,
and also to everyone who has in any way contributed to the process of publishing this
book, at the mutual pleasure of readers and authors.
Authors

8

�LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1 - Around the World in Tall Buildings – Current Location
of the Top 100 [94]................................................................................ 18
Figure 2 – Comparison of Historical High–Rise Structures, Pyramids of
Giza and Colosseum, Rome ................................................................ 25
Figure 3 – Notre – Dame Cathedral, Reims, France 1211 – 1311 [108, 5] .......... 26
Figure 4 – First Steel Framed Skyscraper, Home Insurance Building, Chicago
1884-85 [155] ....................................................................................... 28
Figure 5 – First Safe Elevator in Crystal Palace, E.G. Otis, 1853 [145] .............. 29
Figure 6 – New York (up) Compared to Paris (down), Period of 1915 [69, 93] ... 30
Figure 7 – Le Corbusier’s Radiant City [162] ....................................................... 31
Figure 8 – Chrysler Building, Manhattan – Steel Frame [112] ........................... 32
Figure 9 – Empire State Building [186] ................................................................. 33
Figure 10 – World Trade Center (left) and Sears Tower (Willis Tower)
(in the middle and right) [135, 146] ..................................................... 34
Figure 11 – Ingalls Building, Cincinnati – Concrete Structure [11] ...................... 34
Figure 12 – Petronas Towers, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, 452 m [163] .................. 35
Figure 13 – Shanghai, China, Landscape [113] ..................................................... 36
Figure 14 – Structural Material for High-Rises in Shanghai [187] ........................ 36
Figure 15 – Shanghai Tower [187] ......................................................................... 37
Figure 16 – Dubai – 1991(left) and Dubai – 2016 (right) – with World’s Highest
Building Burj Khalifa (829,9 m height) [90] ....................................... 37
Figure 17 – Illustration: “Would you like to live
in a vertical city?” [197] ..................................................................... 39
Figure 18 – Shanghai – Pudong District (left) – Vertical Living, Land
Consumption and Low–Rise Settlement in Less Developed Areas of
Shanghai (below) [149, 153] ................................................................ 39
Figure 19 – Shanghai Tower – during Construction Phase – Showing
the Structural Design of the Building (left) and Characteristic Floor
Plan of Shanghai Tower (right) [133, 97] ........................................... 40
Figure 20 – Wind Turbines at the Top of the Residential Building, Indigo
Building, Portland Oregon – Renewable Energy Source (left) and
Breathable Double Elevation on Shanghai Tower Enables Natural
Building’s Ventilation, Saving Costs and Use of Electric Energy
(right) [141, 168] ................................................................................. 41
Figure 21 – Burj Khalifa, Dubai [148, 159] ........................................................... 41
Figure 22 – Capital City of BiH – Sarajevo 1900 (above)
and Sarajevo (1950) (below) [72, 166] ................................................ 43

9

�Figure 23 – First High–Rise Building in BiH, “Vakufski neboder”
after Last Renovation [129] ................................................................. 44
Figure 24 – Apartment Blocks at the Miljacka River Bank in Sarajevo, 1962 [39] . 45
Figure 25 – Faculty of Natural Sciences and Mathematics in Sarajevo, 1966 [76] . 45
Figure 26 – Residential Block of High–Rise Buildings, Čengić Vila [119] ............. 46
Figure 27 – Prefabricated High–Rise Buildings – Alipašino Polje [77] ................. 46
Figure 28 – National Parliament - J. Neidhardt (left) and UNITIC Office
Buildings - I. Štraus (right) [80, 101] .................................................. 47
Figure 29 – Banja Luka after Devastating Earthquake in 1969 [110] .................... 48
Figure 30 – ”Incelov neboder” or “Čajavčev neboder”, Banja Luka [152] ........... 49
Figure 31 – Zenica – Residential Blocks at River Bank (left) and Lamela – Highest
High–Rise Building in Zenica (right) [131, 125] ................................. 50
Figure 32 – Tuzla’s Settlement of High–Rises – Sjenjak [73] .................................. 50
Figure 33 – Bijeli neboder (White Skyscraper),
Bihać’s Highest High–Rise [120] ........................................................ 51
Figure 34 – UNIS Office Building in Sarajevo, Burning, Last War (1992) [138] ... 52
Figure 35 – Bosmal City Centre Sarajevo [156] ....................................................... 53
Figure 36 – New Generation of BH High–Rises in Sarajevo [188] ........................ 53
Figure 37 – Avaz Twist Tower [124, 150] ............................................................... 54
Figure 38 – Sarajevo City Center (SCC) [158] ........................................................ 55
Figure 39 – Administrative Building of the
Government of the Republika Srpska [99] ........................................... 55
Figure 40 – Mellain Complex, Tuzla under Construction (left)
and Constructed (right) [125, 130] ...................................................... 56
Figure 41 – Franciscan Church and its Bell Tower–Symbol of Peace,
Mostar [140] ......................................................................................... 57
Figure 42 - Frame (left) and Braced Frame (right) ................................................. 61
Figure 43 - Detail of Figure 42 ................................................................................. 61
Figure 44 - Hearst Magazine Building - 2004, NYC (left),
Hotel de las Artes – 1992, Barcelona (right) [87, 100] ....................... 62
Figure 45 - Classification of the Structures of High–Rise Buildings according to
F.R. Khan (steel structures) [1] ........................................................... 65
Figure 46 - Classification of the Structures of High–Rise Buildings according to
F.R. Khan (concrete structures) [1] ..................................................... 66
Figure 47 - Classification of the Structures of High–Rise Buildings according to Mir
M. Ali (interior structures) [1] ............................................................. 66
Figure 48 - Classification of the Structures of High–Rise Buildings according to Mir
M. Ali (exterior structures) [1] ............................................................ 67
Figure 49 - Rigid Frames of High–Rises, Combination of the Displacement due to
Sway and Bending [177] ...................................................................... 69
10

�Figure 50 - Lake Shore Apartments – Rigid Steel Frame Structure (left)
and Stanhope Building – Rigid Concrete Frame Structure
(right, axonometric) [179] ................................................................... 70
Figure 51 - Common Type of Bracings ..................................................................... 70
Figure 52 - Variations of Interruptions in Shear Walls [176] .................................. 71
Figure 53 - Axonometric View of Shear Walls System, Example (left)
and Characteristic Floor Plan of the National Commercial Bank,
Showing the Symmetry in Arrangement of Shear Walls (right) [180] . 72
Figure 54 - Casselden Place, Melbourne – Concrete Shear Walls + Steel Frame,
43 Stories (left) and 311 South Wacker Drive – Concrete Shear
Walls + Concrete Frame, 75 Stories (right) [102, 104] ...................... 73
Figure 55 - Shanghai’s Tower Structural System [139] ............................................ 75
Figure 56 - Bending Moment Diagram under Applied Wind Load on Shear Core
and Frame Structure (above) and Bending Moment Diagram under
Applied Wind Load on Outrigged Structure System (below) ................ 76
Figure 57 - Variation of Tubular Structures ............................................................. 79
Figure 58 - Characteristic Arrangement of the Structural Elements for Framed
Tubes in Plan (left) and Diagram of Shear Lag Effect (right) [1] ....... 80
Figure 59 - De Witt Chestnut Apartment Building in Chicago, F. Khan,
Characteristic Floor Plan Showing Perimeter Column Arrangement
(left), and De Witt Chestnut Apartment Building Constructed (right)
[178, 137] ............................................................................................. 80
Figure 60 - John Hancock Centre, Representative Example of Braced Tube
Structure [79] ....................................................................................... 81
Figure 61 - Sears Tower, Chicago (left), Schemes of Modular Floor
Configuration (mid and right) [67, 181] .............................................. 82
Figure 62 - Different Plan Configuration for Bundled Tube Structures ................... 82
Figure 63 - 181 West Madison Street, (left), Characteristic Floor Plan (right)
[144, 143] ............................................................................................. 83
Figure 64 - Hearst Headquarters Centre in New York (left), and 30 St. Mary Ave
in London (right) [170, 96] .................................................................. 85
Figure 65 - Variations of Diagrid Geometry [62] ................................................... 86
Figure 66 - Concrete Diagrid, O-14 Building Dubai (left)
and Construction of Diagrid (right) [161, 167] ................................... 86
Figure 67 - China Tower of 1990 (left) and View on Buildings Structure from
Interior of the Building (right) [160, 64] ............................................. 87
Figure 68 - Hotel de las Artes, Exo – Structure at Main Structural System (left)
and View on Detail of Elevation, Structure Connection to the
Buildings Volume (right) [128] ............................................................ 88

11

�Figure 69 - Parque Central Tower, Caracas, Venezuela,
Concrete Super Frame Structure, under Construction (left),
on fire (mid), Renovated (right) [91, 134, 132] ................................... 88
Figure 70 - Chicago Ultra–High Building, Proposal for Steel Super Framed
Structure, Elevation (left) and Characteristic Floor Plans (right)[71] 89
Figure 71 - Belvedere Building, Rotterdam - Horizontal Forces Scheme (left),
Inclined Strut (mid), Constructed Building (right) [41] ....................... 91
Figure 72 - Bessemer Steelmaking Process (illustration of furnace) [142] ............. 94
Figure 73 - Contemporary Steel Making Process, Combination of Blast Furnace
Top Gas Recycling and Blast Oxygen Furnaces, Highly Reduces
Steelmaking Emissions (illustration) [151] .......................................... 94
Figure 74 – UK Hot – Rolled Steel Open Sections [191] ......................................... 96
Figure 75 – Tubular Steel Sections [191] ................................................................. 97
Figure 76 – European Steel Sections [123] .............................................................. 97
Figure 77 – Standard Z and C Cold Rolled Steel Sections [117] ............................. 98
Figure 78 – Stress – Strain Diagram for a Steel in Tension [85] ............................. 99
Figure 79 – Schematic Expression of Steel’s Ductile Failure Phases [183] .......... 100
Figure 80 – The Influence of Temperature on Loss of Toughness [154] ............... 101
Figure 81 – Home Insurance Building, Chicago, World’s First High–Rise
Building Steel Structured [192] ......................................................... 101
Figure 82 – World Trade Centre I and II, Results of the Attack High Fire
Demolished or “Burnt” Steel Structure of High–Rises,
September 11, 2001 [194] .................................................................. 102
Figure 83 – John Hancock Building - Elevation (left)
and in Urban Context (right) [109, 88] ............................................. 103
Figure 84 – Pantheon, Rome, Interior (left) and Exterior (right) [193, 81] .......... 105
Figure 85 – Ingalls Building, First Concrete High-Rise (left)
and Hoover Dam right [105, 111] ..................................................... 106
Figure 86 – Concrete Compressive Strength in Relation to W/C Ratio [165] ....... 108
Figure 87 – Importance of the Aggregate Grading –
Single Sized Aggregates (left), Poorly Graded Aggregates (middle)
and Well Graded Aggregates (right) [175] ........................................ 109
Figure 88 – Reinforcing Steel – Textured Rebar and Meshes [121] ...................... 110
Figure 89 – Difference in Behaviour of Reinforced Concrete and Prestressed
Concrete under Applied Load [11] .................................................... 111
Figure 90 – Concrete Cylinder and Cube Test Samples [75] ................................. 113
Figure 91 – Concrete Compression Strength Development in Relation to
Conditioning of Test Specimens [164] ............................................... 114
Figure 92 – Tangent and Secant Modulus of Elasticity of Concrete [126] ............ 114
Figure 93 – Creep of Concrete [89] ....................................................................... 115
12

�Figure 94 – Concrete Shrinkage Development [38] ............................................... 115
Figure 95 – Petronas Tower- Characteristic Floor Plan Showing Concept and
Structure [66] ..................................................................................... 117
Figure 96 – Burj Khalifa (left), Petronas Twin Tower (mid) and
Ingalls Building (left) [82] ................................................................. 118
Figure 97- The Last Completed Super High–Rise, Burj Khalifa, 2010 (left)
and the First Completed High- Strength Concrete High–Rise,
Outer Drive East.1963 [83] ............................................................... 120
Figure 98 - Common Mineral Admixtures – Supplementary Cementitious
Materials for High-Strength Concrete [103] .................................... 124
Figure 99 - Eureka Tower Characteristic Floor Plans, 26-52 Storeys(left–top),
53-65 Storeys(left – mid), 66-88 Storeys(left – bottom),
Black Hatch Stands for High–Strength Structural Elements
and in 2006 (right) [78] ..................................................................... 127
Figure 100 - Baiyoke Tower 2 [118, 60] ................................................................ 128
Figure 101 - Characteristic Floor Plan of Trianon Building (left–top), Schematic
Scenario of Possible Collapse (left–bottom) and Trianon Building,
1992, completed (right) [199, 200] .................................................... 129
Figure 102 - Altieri Spinelli Building, Brussels, Belgium [157] ............................ 130
Figure 103 - Summary of the Representative HSC High–Rises [136] ................... 131
Figure 104 - Rolled Beam Enchased with Concrete, Section through Railway
Bridge (Kommerell) [28] ................................................................... 133
Figure 105 - Composite Steel Beam Patented by Julius Khan, 1926, USA [28] .... 134
Figure 106 - Composite Beam with Shear Connection between Steel Beam and
Concrete Slab, with Diagrams of Stress Distribution in
Cross Section [68] .............................................................................. 136
Figure 107 - Composite Columns Types, a) Steel Section Fully Enchased with
Reinforced Concrete, b) Steel Section Partially Enchased with
Reinforced Concrete, c) Steel Section Partially Enchased with
Concrete [70] ..................................................................................... 136
Figure 108 - Composite Column Types, d) Rectangular Hollow Steel Section
Filled with Concrete, e) Circular Hollow Steel Section Filled with
Concrete, f) Circular Hollow Steel Section Filled with Concrete with
Embedded I Steel Section [70] ........................................................... 137
Figure 109 - Components of Composite Slab, Casting
and Installation Principle [190] ........................................................ 137
Figure 110 - Shapes and Dimensions of Shear Connectors, Angle, Circular
Hexagonal or Circular Headed and Channel Section [174] ............. 138
Figure 111 - Composite Structured High–Rises on the List of the World’s Tallest
High–Rises in 2011 by CTBUH [188] ............................................ 139
13

�Figure 112 - Taipei 101 - Schematic View of Characteristic Plans
and Elevation [14] ............................................................................. 140
Figure 113 - Taipei 101 – Composite Structure Compared to the Petronas
Towers–Reinforced Concrete Structure in Terms of Perimeter
Columns [189, 14, 98] ........................................................................ 141
Figure 114 - Types of Structural Loads on High-Rise Structure [185] .................. 145
Figure 115 - Progressive Collapse, Schematic Presentation of the Progressive
Collapses of World Trade Centre (9/11) [61] .................................... 146
Figure 116 - Illustrative Presentation of Permanent and Variable Actions [122] . 147
Figure 117 - Effect of the Wind on Snow Load Distribution on Roof Top [115] ... 148
Figure 118 - Flat Roof with Ponding Issue [116] .................................................. 149
Figure 119 - Burj Khalifa, Model for Wind Tunnel Testing, Scale 1:500 [84] ...... 150
Figure 120 - Schemes of Possible Aerodynamic Solutions in Architectural Forms
of High–Rise Buildings Caused with Drastic Plan Variations from
Floor to Floor [65] ............................................................................ 151
Figure 121 - Wind Behaviour - Characteristic Floor Plans of Burj Khalifa [159] 152
Figure 122 - Taipei 101’s 728 Ton Tuned Mass Damper, World’s Largest Tuned
Damper, and the Only One Visible to the Public and Opened for
Visits [95,127] .................................................................................... 153
Figure 123 - Damping System Types for High–Rise Buildings - Classification [5]
............................................................................................................ 153
Figure 124 - Diagram of Seismic Action Distribution, with Respective
Increase of the Buildings Height [184] .............................................. 154
Figure 125 - Progressive Collapse of Residential 17-Storey High–Rise,
Caused by the Earthquake in Taiwan, February, 2016 [173] ........... 154
Figure 126 - World Trade Centre – 9/11 [107, 172, 92, 86] .................................. 155
Figure 127 – Progressive Collapse of the World Trade Centre
in 6.5 seconds [171] ........................................................................... 156
Figure 128 - Exterior Blasts– Explosion Next to the Building [182] ..................... 157
Figure 129 - Collapse Simulation, High–Rise Building Exposed to Interior
Explosion, Where the Structure Does Not Resist for the Applied
Blasts, and Continues with Progressive Collapse [198] .................... 158
Figure 130 - Mandarin Oriental Hotel, 2/9/2009, Beijing, 44 Storey, Composite
Concrete and Steel Framed Structure, was Entirely Affected
by Fire Remained without Structural Collapse [195,63] ................... 159
Figure 131 - Grenfell Tower, the Most Recent Fire Incident on the High–Rise in
Such Large Scale, June 15, 2017 [102] ............................................. 159
Figure 132 - Grenfell Tower, Cross Section Pointing on Place of Fire Start,
with Characteristic Floor Plan Pointing out the Only Staircases
Down the Centre of the Building [74] ................................................ 160
14

�LIST OF TABLES
Table 1 – Steel Classification according to Carbon Percentage Presence ............... 98
Table 2 - Concrete Classification according to
Compression Strength of Concrete ......................................................... 112
Table 3 - Concrete Classification according to Unit Weight of Concrete .............. 112
Table 4 - Concrete Classification according to Admixtures Used in Concrete ...... 113
Table 5 - Classification of Structural Systems
of High–Rises Interior Structures [1] ...................................................... 161
Table 6 - Classification of Structural Systems
of High–Rises Exterior Structures [1] ..................................................... 161

15

��INTRODUCTION
Race and desire in constructing tall and high exist since periods of early civilizations.
The architectural heritage and remains from early civilizations, are undeniable
evidences that constructing high and massive is not innovation and reflection of the
contemporary society. Looking back at Egyptian pyramids, Greek and Roman temples
which introduced high, massive columns, human desire to express the power and
wealth through building high and tall continued with European churches, towers and
castles back in Late Middle Ages and Renaissance period lasting up to the
contemporary ultra–high–rise buildings and skyscrapers. However, turnkeys for high–
rise buildings we are familiar with, were innovation of the mechanism for safe vertical
transportation-elevator and new structural materials in late 19th century. Since late
nineties of the 19th century and early twenties of the 20th century, high–rise buildings
and structures are becoming daily challenge and new direction for architectural,
constructional and material technology development. For contemporary societies
worldwide, high–rise structures are becoming common thing and inevitable part of
new living style. Whether high–rise buildings function as commercial, residential or
educational use of these forms of vertical architecture is becoming more and more
popular.
“Today it is almost impossible to imagine a major city without tall buildings.
As the most important symbols of today’s cities, tall buildings have become a
source of faith in technology and national pride, and have changed the
concept of the modern city along with its scale and appearance. Despite the
fact that tall buildings have moved city life away from the human scale, in
general it is accepted that these buildings are an inevitable feature of urban
development.” [14]
Even though, high–rise buildings occupied architectural and construction scene and
do play an important role for solving excessive land consumption problems and
problems of accommodation in overpopulated zones, architectural critic are generally
describing high–rises as gigantic hazards in urban areas and tools to show off the
prestige, power and wealth; which do create environment oversized if compared to
human scale and do cause harmful influences on environment. As everything, highrise buildings do have its advantages and disadvantages, but one is sure, high–rise
buildings are accepted by mass population. It is common for every urban area to have
structures and buildings which are characterized as high–rise because they outstand
among other buildings in surrounding, primarily by height.

17

�Figure 1 – Around the World in Tall Buildings – Current Location of the Top 100 [94]

High–rise buildings are landmarks of the present and do form urban identity in form
of grandiose unique skylines. However, not always high–rise buildings are to be
successful, whether failure may happen during construction or service life of the
structure. Thus, along with increase in building’s height, breath-taking futuristic
architectural forms and concepts, awareness of necessity for highly advanced
structural systems and materials in order to respond greater loads increases as well.
Those advances sought for higher safety, stability, resistance and prevention of
possible progressive collapses due to possible accidental occasions.
In terms of these advanced technologies, high–rise buildings were celebrated on the
cast iron and steel load–bearing structural elements which were designed to form rigid
frame. More slender structural elements, larger spans more open floor plans presented
steel as material of future, while concrete as structural material was at the beginning
mostly excluded as option in structuring of high–rises. Neither concrete’s high fire
resistance, nor its high resistance to very aggressive environments, abrasion and
corrosion could overcome the problem of large and massive structural elements, in
the eyes of the architects, designers etc.
Early advanced technological developments and experimental studies tried to
overcome the problem of massiveness of the concrete structures and at the end of the
day all efforts resulted in form of material with better properties with focus on
compression strength. For better understanding, at that time, the concrete with greater
strength, high–strength concrete, referred to the concrete’s with compressive strengths

18

�up to 35 – 51 MPa. Even though, nowadays, such compressive strength is considered
as conventional normal strength concrete, than it was sufficient to initiate use of the
concrete in structuring high–rise buildings. Second half of the 20th century, was the
period of both structural materials steel and concrete development. In this period
upgrading weaknesses of one material with powers of another one, developed new
concept of composite steel–concrete structures. Steel, high–strength concrete and
composite materials, were three subjects to material technology development in
structuring of high–rise buildings. At the same time, keeping up with newest
technological achievements of material, structural engineers, architects and designers
were developing numerous different structural systems which could relate between
desired heights and environmental conditions which causes the most severe loads for
high–rise buildings (wind load, seismic actions, etc.). However, real turnover in
structuring of high rise buildings whether it is about structure or structural material
happened at early 21st century. Unfortunately, fires that affected few of the world’s
famous and the tallest high–rises in large scale showed weaknesses of steel structures.
Rapid progressive collapse, material used which had low fire resistance, insufficient
time for secure evacuations resulted in irreplaceable losses. These events, exposed
one of the concrete’s greatest advantage in high–rise resistance and initiate greater use
of the concrete, and high–strength concrete for structuring of high–rises.
Nowadays, around developed urban areas which are living high–rise, there are
concrete plants which daily produce concrete with compressive strengths up to 95
MPa.
Bosnia and Herzegovina and Balkan area were undergoing rapid urbanisation and
development during late fifties and early sixties of the last century. Sarajevo, Zenica,
Tuzla, Bihać, Mostar were enriched with numerous high–rises. Unlike World’s scene
where the high–rises represented office and commercial blocks, high–rises in former
Yugoslavia were strictly functioned as residential with few exceptions, and generally
were structured with concrete. For the country at the beginning of industrialisation
process, where large migrations were toward urban zones, high–rise residential
settlements were logic solution to prevent excessive land consumption and to form
urban and spatial plans. The last war (1992–1995) stopped technological development
in all fields in Bosnia and Herzegovina, and the years after the war were dedicated to
reconstructions and repairs of damaged buildings, infrastructures etc. High – rises
suffered many accidental impacts during the war years. However the resistance of
concrete structures, largely saved many buildings.
Lately, Bosnia and Herzegovina is being enriched by new samples of the high–rise
buildings with more architectural valued high–rises. However, low material

19

�technological development is not enabling the possibility for any of futuristic
worldwide seen structures. Structural engineers, architects and designers in Bosnia
and Herzegovina are still rather choosing the concrete than any other material, but
concrete technology is still remaining at conventional–normal strength concrete.
Thus, there are numerous rigid frame structures with oversized columns, beams, and
overuse of raw material, meaning on aggregate, cement, and superplasticizer while
there are domestic materials which are sufficient for the first researches on high–
strength concrete and later on productions. Presently, there are numerous easy ways
to find out about newest technologies and knowledge. This book is being concerned
at the high–rise buildings, from what are the most successful high–rises worldwide,
its structural, architectural, mechanical design, its resistance as physical object in
different environments, at different loadings and actions to the situation in Bosnia and
Herzegovina and ability to catch up with new concrete technologies using domestic
materials.
Concepts and forms of the high–rise buildings are under constant change. Specific
and detailed analysis of phenomena, high–rise buildings, rises different questions,
opinions and understandings, both supportive and those critical ones. Along with the
idea of high–rise buildings, there is mostly dose of scepticism after announcement of
its primary design due to oversize when compared to human scales. However high–
rise buildings are widely becoming accepted as part of the lifestyle and represent great
urban development, national pride and construction, which is undoubtedly
environmental friendly and efficient at least in decrease of land overconsumption.
Even though this book is concerned on contemporary high–rise building’s structures
and material technology development, it also includes historical analysis of what,
when and how society ended up with these monumental structures.
According to the short documentary published by New York Times “A Short History
of the High-Rises” by Katerina Cizek, the historical analysis of high–rise begins back
in 2500 BC. This documentary contain four parts “Mud”, “Concrete” , “Glass” and
“Home”, which express the power of vertical living and variety in materials used for
high-rise construction from mud and dusty sands in Yemen to advanced high–strength
materials (steel and concrete) with curtain glass walls all around the world.
Documentary “A Short History of High-Rises” gave excellent insight toward
phenomena of high–rise buildings.
However, turnkey for high–rise buildings and forms we are familiar with nowadays
according to Mark Sarkisian are large fires which burnt large area of the Chicago and
initiate diverse thinking in both designs and technologies. In his book, “Designing
Tall Buildings, Structure as Architecture” he wrote:

20

�“The fire of 1871 devastated the city of Chicago but created an opportunity
to re-think design and construction in an urban environment, to consider the
limits of available, engineered building materials, to expand on the
understanding of others, and to conceive and develop vertical transportation
systems that would move people and materials within taller structures.“ [33]
To enrich the collected data with situation in the area of Bosnia and Herzegovina,
literature includes vision and perception of one of the most important modernist
architect of former Yugoslavia, Ivan Štraus. His book, “The Architecture of Bosnia
and Herzegovina, 1945–1991”, [39] informs us about the most successful high–rise
buildings in entire area of Bosnia and Herzegovina through this period. However, as
the architect and architectural critic, Štraus had chance to choose those building which
outstand among the others and represent valuable architectural object partially
expressing subjective opinion. Such approach to analysis of architecture in Bosnia and
Herzegovina was more than supportive for high–rises, because exactly high–rises
were main tool for directing architecture and urbanism for the above mentioned
period. Another source, which explains the historical development at the Bosnian
territory, is “Arhitektura Bosne i Hercegovine (The Architecture of Bosnia and
Herzegovina)” [27] by Prof. dr. Amir Pašić, which as the Štraus tended to explain
how and in what directions Bosnian architecture and urban areas were developing
during the 20th century.
Conducted historical analyses express rapid and advanced development of high–rises.
By textual and visual sources, it is possible to analyse how societies worldwide were
experiencing taller and taller structures year by year, and how the architects and
engineers were pushing the limits of structural, mechanical and material technologies.
Each phenomena interconnected with high–rise building is subjected to CTBUH,
Council on Tall Building and Urban Habitat. [106] CTBUH in criteria for defining
and measuring of tall buildings, evokes the concept and form of the high–rise building,
indicates architectural (form, concept and function), structural (structural systems,
accent on specific actions on structure, structural material) parameters. Thus, to satisfy
world accepted criteria, literature focuses on structural system, new actions and
hazards to high–rise structures and as final ability in materialisation of the structure.
Classification of structural systems in high–rise buildings was initiated by Fazlur
Khan, which considered height and structural efficiency. Such classification was not
supporting rapid classification and variety of new systems. Thus in 1972/3 [1], he
modified and delivered new classifications with accordance to the material used.
Unlike Fazlur Khan, Mir M. Ali and Kyoung Sun Moon, in their study “Structural
Developments in Tall Buildings: Current Trends and Future Prospects” [1] invites
21

�the new way of understanding and analysing the structural systems. Key role in their
classification was location of main structural system, where the structures can be
interior or exterior. In catching up with contemporary trends and futuristic approaches,
this classification on exterior and interior structures seems as updated, and shows
Khan’s classification as highly confusing and hard to incorporate with contemporary
advanced material technologies which are more integrating composite structures, than
steel or concrete individually.
Due to extreme heights, high–rise structures are to be well designed to give the
occupants or inhabitants comfort and safety. Mehmet Halis Günel and Hüseyin Emre
Ilgin, worked on book “Tall Buildings, Structural Systems and Aerodynamic Forms”
[14] where main focus is at the power of the wind forces which are influencing the
design and which require complex approaches and design to overcome possible
displacements, bending or sway of the building. According to the authors,
architectural design approach should be aerodynamic and structure based, structural
approach should integrate the structures with mega columns, outriggers, mega come
and tube systems as important as this two is mechanical approach which refers to
damping systems for additional stability. M. H. Günel and H. E. Ilgin, developed the
high–rise structuring with accordance to way of structure’s responding to the loads
and design ability and approaches to reduce load actions on structure. In their work
materials do not play an important role which do not lead the structural development.
Although, statistical data which are mentioned in their book, taken from CTBUH,
clearly show that concrete as structural material is overtaking steel’s popularity. Such
turnover in choosing structural materials happened at the period when steel showed
its greatest weakness in fire resistance, at early 21 century. According to report, “Tall
Buildings and Sustainability” [26], by authors Will Pank, Herbert Girardet and Greg
Cox, concrete is leading material in structuring.
“Conventional–normal strength concrete which was initially use is extremely
harmful for environment and is guilty for 5–7 percent of world’s CO2 emission.
For instance 1 tonne of cement uses 4000–7500 MJ energy, and releases 1–1.2
tonnes of CO2.“ [26]
However if high–strength concrete is considered, with use of silica fume, fly ash or
slag as substitute for cement then is a concrete much more environmental friendly. At
the same time concrete has better properties to answer the needs for structuring of
high–rises. As additional literature for deeper study on high–strength concrete is the
book “High–Strength Concrete” [3], by Michael A. Caldarone, and “Journal of
Mechanical and Civil Engineering” Volume 10 [2], which discusses the high–strength
concrete properties, mix and proportioning, constituent materials.

22

�In Bosnia and Herzegovina there is not much interest, researches or studies on high–
strength concrete. However there are highly qualified constituent materials which can
be used for high–strength concrete, unfortunately those physical resources are still
insufficiently used in Bosnia and are waiting on architects, engineers to take their
advantageous properties.

23

��HIGH – RISE BUILDNGS THROUGH WORLD ARCHITECTURE
Even in early civilisations, high–rise structures and buildings, represented the power,
strength and development of the specific civilisation. Dating back to 2500 BC, high–
rise structures originated in Egypt. High, massive structures, such as pyramids, were
made for pharaoh’s afterlife, in order to show off his greatness and power to his
inheritors. Those pyramids, are nowadays taken as the greatest heritage of the
Egyptian Civilisation to the field of architecture and they still raise many question
about the way they were built and what the construction technologies and abilities
Egyptians had in order to support such structures. Another historical and architectural
achievement, world known and valued, high–rise readable structure, is the
Colosseum, Rome.
Unlike the pyramids, the Colosseum’s function was not to worship kings, rulers or
God, but to serve and reflect the development of the society. It is also lower than the
pyramids, but structural system, construction and architectural principles, are clearly
defined, constructed and readable in scale of the Colosseum and are worthy of
examining even today.

Figure 2 – Comparison of Historical High – Rise Structures, Pyramids of Giza and
Colosseum, Rome

As already stated, the Colosseum was built for public use; new amphitheatre was built
for public to enjoy the gladiatorial fights. The construction lasted for 10 years, which
seems like a short period of time when we consider the building’s structural system
that has clearly defined columns, precise arches and exceptional openings–doors, with
symmetrical and regular repetitions of the same which add a great value to the
Colosseum. What makes Colosseum stand out from other structures from that period,
besides the mentioned structural values, is its location. Located in Rome, Italy,
Colosseum is situated at one of the highest seismic zones in Europe.
The most valued examples of the architecture through history are defined with
inherited high–rise structures, which serve as the undeniable evidences that
constructing upward, high, nearer to sky presented a mirror image of the greatness,
wealth, strength, and the leader position. However, in the Late Middle ages and the
25

�Renaissance, high-rise structures and buildings, were reserved only for the churches,
mosques, observatory towers, castells etc. This leads to the conclusion that churches
and other specific buildings were focal point, or monument of the specific area which
could easily be seen from the distance.

Figure 3 – Notre – Dame Cathedral, Reims, France 1211 – 1311 [108, 5]

While still meeting the accommodation needs, living spaces and business zones were
constructed low–rise, and were spreading horizontally. Causes for such development
and construction appear to be the lack of construction abilities, the lack of fast vertical
communication through buildings, and fast evacuation which was impossible in the
case of emergency.
Construction abilities and knowledge of the mid–19th century show the high–rise
buildings as very expansive and impractical. Commonly used masonry structures were
very rigid, with load bearing walls that were too thick at the lower floors because of
the design structural elements that could transfer loads from higher floors. Clustered
interior spaces that were produced by these massive structural systems made high rise
buildings undesirable places to work in or live in.
Real turnover for the high–rise structures, which became high–rise buildings that
humanity is familiar with nowadays happened with the introduction of steel structures.
Load–bearing systems became much lighter in weight, and created open, breathable
interior spaces, and also made facades of the buildings much lighter and more diverse.
Former limits of construction were broken, making a complete shift and creating a
new field for the architects, designers and engineers. Experiments with steel structured
26

�high–rise buildings started in the United States of America, in the Chicago School of
Architecture. Filled with curiosity of what the abilities of this new structural material
were, designers, architects and engineers, designed and constructed first high–rise
building made entirely out of steel.
By making a brief skim through global history of architecture, it becomes clear that
each great civilisation or each period of architecture has some remarkable
monumental high–rise structure. It clearly shows that those high–rise structures and
buildings are becoming closer and closer to the population as time goes by. Today the
overall development of the high–rise buildings, both in design and construction, made
high–rise buildings to become a new sustainable living style, solving the problems
such as overpopulation, or lack of the horizontal space and area for spreading in the
urban, metropolitan areas.
The analysis of the high–rise structures shows that even in distant past humans had a
desire to build large and high. It does not matter whether we mention the pyramids in
Egypt, thin towers which became focal points of the cities, Roman’s amphitheatres,
religious buildings such as churches and mosques, mansions of former leaders etc., it
is clear that during the history, architects and builders tended to build as high and big
as the circumstances allowed for.
The term high–rise building was first used to refer to tall building in Chicago. If we
consider the pyramids in Egypt as one of the oldest high–rise structures which made
Egypt as motherland of the high–rise structures, United States of America can be
considered the motherland of the modern high–rise buildings, skyscrapers and tall
skylines of the cities. The Great Chicago Fire of 1871 lasted for two days, burning
down the whole city which was built out of wood; this event forced the technological
development in construction and introduction of the new material, the one that could
have better resistance in such situations.
Owners of the Home Insurance Building in New York City wanted a new office
building in devastated Chicago, and they demanded high building that could
accommodate numerous offices; the most important and greatest challenge for the
construction was to find the material which would have greater fire resistance than
timber has. The Chicago School of Architecture and the representative engineer
William Le Baron Jenney designed a steel framed building for the contest and won it,
primarily for the material's fire resistance properties. With this project and design,
Jenney was the first to introduce and welcome steel structure to the world, publicizing
the material that supported the first high rise building we are familiar with nowadays.
Home Insurance Building, Chicago, the first high–rise building, was a 10 storey
building with steel framed structure. The whole building weighted one third than it
27

�would weight if it were made out of stone. In 1884–1885, Home Insurance Building,
evoked scepticism with numerous experts, but nevertheless this building serves as the
first example of such construction, and its’ great design opened and forced a new
movement in architecture and construction during the late 19th century and early 20th.

Figure 4 – First Steel Framed Skyscraper, Home Insurance Building, Chicago 1884-85
[155]

Since the high–rise buildings started to develop, the experts claimed Home Insurance
Building as the pioneer in upward building; it represents a great achievement, and it
is for sure the tallest structure of the period. However questions such as, What is the
high–rise building? What are the parameters?, What are the definitions of high–rise
buildings? remained. While there are different fields of expertise closely connected to
this field of architecture and civil engineering, there are also numerous definition of
the high – rise buildings with the shortest one stating that the high–rise building is a
building that is 23 to 30 m high, depending on the floor height; that is 7 to 10 storeys
building, where the height of the building can have a great impact on the evacuation.
The Home Insurance Building could be seen as a great breakthrough in the
development of the high–rise structures from the design point of view; however the
actual revolution happened with the growth of the construction technology, and with
28

�the development of the elevators and their improvement. Thus, the flourishing of the
construction of the high–rise buildings may be defined through two main occurrences:
 The first occurrence may refer to the steel structures that replaced the heavy
stone structures or the weaker forerunners of steel, cast iron and timber
structures, which were thick and massive. Steel proved to be a much lighter
material, more durable and more fire–resistant more than any other known
material suitable for high–rise constructions. Due to its lightness, and at
same time its stiffness, steel as a main structural material enabled buildings
to be constructed higher than ever before;
 The second occurrence is the great innovation of the Elisha Graves Otis, the
American innovator who invented the first safety elevator. Elevator as a
main transportation in vertical direction enabled people to travel safely to
upper floors and provided faster communication with higher floors, when
compared to using stairs (walking).

Figure 5 – First Safe Elevator in Crystal Palace, E.G. Otis, 1853 [145]

Construction technology and architectural concepts, both in volume of the building
and interior spaces, started to flourish after 1885. High–rise buildings became more
available to the mass population; rapid and fast growth of the high–rise buildings
dramatically changed the urban layouts through the cities of the United States of
America, forming new skylines of the city. This period of the late 19th and 20th century,
period of Modernism, might be seen as the Renaissance of the high–rise buildings.
29

�North America experienced and forced this trend of high–rise buildings to the fullest,
while Europe still tried to keep their traditional and historical landmarks.

Figure 6 – New York (up) Compared to Paris (down), Period of 1915 [69, 93]

While Europe tried to keep skylines and landmarks of their cities, few great European
modernists were developing the idea of ideal cities; their concept included new
designs of the cities filled with vertical buildings, and they were taking any chance
they could to experiment and realize all the potentials of the upward building.
Le Corbusier, Swiss–French architect, created a hypothesis according to which
buildings were nothing but sleeping machines. This meant that buildings were in a

30

�way like cars, whose main function was to transport people from one place to another,
and to reduce time needed for travel.
Also, the buildings should not take up much space, but rather spread vertically and
still serve their function. Le Corbusier, in his concept of Ideal cities designed the
buildings as high–rise units, serving different functions, but strictly separated hotels,
and business and residential buildings. This idea was different from what was actually
happening in the cities of the United States and the Ideal city would have taken bigger
area between the high–rise buildings, while across the ocean, high– rise buildings
were growing uncontrollably, creating forests of the high–rise buildings.

Figure 7 – Le Corbusier’s Radiant City [162]

On the other hand, majority of modernists were traveling to the United States of
America, exploring the abilities for new designs, new technological development and
new building materials. The early 20th century was marked by the steel frame
construction and steel tubular construction, where the main focus was to use the steel
and to use all the advantages of one material. Thin structural elements made out of
steel were leaving the elevations of the buildings opened for free design, including
openings which could be filled with glass, or in the early 20th century, non load–
bearing brick wall. Chrysler building, located in Midtown of Manhattan, is the tallest
steel–framed brick building, with total height of 319 m, with 77 storeys. Construction
of the building was finished in 1931, showing how perception of high–rise building
changed during the period of 45 years. Construction technology development in the
next 45 years showed huge improvement, and the buildings nowadays can achieve
seven times the height of the pioneering high–rise building. With the development of
high–rise buildings, new materials and systems developed as well; glass facades, glass
walls, or the system of enveloping the building’s structures etc.
31

�Figure 8 – Chrysler Building, Manhattan – Steel Frame [112]

Larger spans of steel columns wrote the parameters of the modernist period, such as
open floor plans, multifunctional areas, movable wall systems, free positioning of the
partitioning walls, opening the opportunity for easier and more usable space. Steel and
development of steel structures, played the greatest role in the construction of high–
rise buildings. Steel as a material was new and unexplored, opening the opportunities
for engineers, architects and designers to experiment with it.
The tallest building in the world from 1931-1972 was Empire State Building in New
York. Originally, it was 381 m high, but in 1951, a broadcasting antenna was added
to the building, increasing total building height to 443 m. It is steel framed structure
with masonry infill. Excavation began on January 22, 1930 with actual construction
on March 17, 1930. Construction took just over 18 months. The building incorporates
10 million bricks, 1,886 kilometers of elevator cables, 6,400 windows, and weighs
331,000 tons. It was constructed with 60,000 tons of structural steel. The facade is
composed of more than 200,000 cubic feet of Indiana limestone and granite, and
utilizes several setbacks to offset the optical distortion of its 102-story height. [186]

32

�Figure 9 – Empire State Building [186]

In 1973, it was completed a construction of the World Trade Center in New York. The
World Trade Center was more than its signature twin towers: it was a complex of
seven buildings on 6.5 ha. The towers, One and Two World Trade Center, rose at the
heart of the complex, each climbing more than 30 m higher than the silver mast of the
Empire State Building. Architect Minoru Yamasaki was selected to design the project;
architects Emery Roth &amp; Sons handled production work, and, at the request of
Yamasaki, the firm of Worthington, Skilling, Helle and Jackson served as engineers.
Yamasaki and engineers John Skilling and Les Robertson worked closely, and the
relationship between the towers' design and structure was clear. Faced with the
difficulties of building to unprecedented heights, the engineers employed an
innovative structural model: a rigid "hollow tube" of closely spaced steel columns
with floor trusses extended across to a central core. The columns, finished with a
silver-colored aluminum alloy making the towers appear from afar to have no
windows at all. When complete, the Center met with mixed reviews, but at 417 and
415 m and 110 stories each, the twin towers were the world's tallest, and largest
buildings until the Sears Tower in Chicago surpassed them both in 1974 by
approximately 30 m. [135]

33

�Figure 10 – World Trade Center (left) and
Sears Tower (Willis Tower) (in the middle and right) [135, 146]

However, the reinforced concrete was another option for high–rise structures.
Construction technology development of steel was faster than the development of the
RC structures due to fact that steel structural elements (columns and beams) were pre–
made, and more accurate for load designs, but also steel had better capacity for tension
forces, than RC structures.

Figure 11 – Ingalls Building, Cincinnati – Concrete Structure [11]
34

�While the first steel high–rise building was built in 1885, the first concrete high–rise
building was built in 1903. The Ingalls Building in Cincinnati, Ohio was a 16 storeys
tall building, which was constructed out of concrete columns, beams, floors and stairs;
it was suspected both by public and engineers alike, that the removal of the supports,
the wind load or just its weight, would lead to its collapse. The architect of the
building, Alfred Oscar Elzner, received a reward for this building (for the concrete
structure of the building), which surpassed the steel frames in fire resistance and cost
savings.
The Ingalls Building was declared a National Historical Civil Engineering Landmark
in 1974 and was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1975 in USA.
[11]
Number of high–rises worldwide are being created, the highest one at the moment
being in the development process and construction may last for another year. Even
though high-rise buildings were “born” in the United States, Asian countries are
becoming leaders in the high–rise construction. The centres and urban areas in Asia
are undergoing a transformation into vertical expansion rather than the horizontal.

Figure 12 – Petronas Towers, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, 452 m [163]
35

�The greatest example of such expansion is Shanghai. There are currently 141
completed high rises buildings and eleven under construction with height above 150
m, and five constructed and one under the construction above 300 m.

Figure 13 – Shanghai, China, Landscape [113]

The analysis [187] on high-rises above 150 m in Shanghai shows that structures of
high rises are dominantly made of concrete (54 percent) and composite structures (38
percent).

Figure 14 – Structural Material for High-Rises in Shanghai [187]

The Shanghai Tower is currently the highest building in Shanghai and Asia and
second tallest in the world (632 m).

36

�Figure 15 – Shanghai Tower [187]

Another undeveloped area, with infrastructure, and construction, but with no defined
zones of urban areas, such as Singapore or Dubai are designed to function with high–
rise buildings.

Figure 16 – Dubai – 1991(left) and Dubai – 2016 (right) – with World’s Highest Building
Burj Khalifa (829,9 m height) [90]

Since their beginnings up to today the high-rise buildings can be classified into three
categories, based on the material used for their construction or the abilities of the
construction technology:
 The first category, is the high–rise building with exterior walls built out of
bricks or stone, with columns and beams cast out of iron and steel, and were
mostly unprotected. Floors were wooden, with unenclosed elevators. Most

37

�of these buildings were demolished due to lack of standards for steel and
iron protection which made them, a risk to use;
 The second category of high–rises are frame structures, where the skeleton
of the building is made out of steel. The steel columns and beams are
protected, by casting them in concrete, which makes them different from the
first category. This created a higher level of structure’s protection. These
high–rise structures, used non-combustible materials, and greatly reduced
the possibility of collapse in case of an impact action on structure, or in case
of fire.
 The third category of high–rises was developed after World War II. In the
case of structure, there are steel–framed constructions, reinforced concrete
construction, as well steel–framed concrete constructions or composite
structures. Numerous standards created a normative in order to serve and
bring new level of safety for high–rise uses. [6]
To be precise, demand for high–rise buildings is constantly growing; desire to build
upwards is going to be a necessity for the humanity. High–rise buildings are becoming
more of a living style, than the modernist experiment. The constant growth of
population and economic growth of urban areas made humanity to face problems of
the horizontal spreading of the constructed areas, be it for accommodation, business
or industries, and infrastructures brought the rapid destruction of the natural
environment, at same time causing natural disasters and climate changes. Thus,
contemporary architecture and engineering within futuristic conceptual designs are
creating new ways of vertical living and working, where high–rise buildings and
skyscrapers, are entering a new era, and where sustainability is becoming the new
parameter that has to support the vertical expansion rather than horizontal one.
Vertical cities, also called the sky cities, in their simplest definition refer to high–rise
buildings and skyscrapers. On one hand, some people are stunned by this attractive
living style, while others are still debating about these ideas, deeming them unideal
and do not support this way of development. However, the global community is
confronted with problems of overpopulation and destruction of natural environment
in order to accommodate growing population on daily basis, and the only solution
seems to be in the form of vertical living.
European countries haven’t faced such problem yet, and haven’t felt necessity to build
upwards; on the other hand, certain areas of America and Asia have already been
opening, creating and exploring the conceptual designs of vertical living. High–rise
buildings are already becoming multi–functional, defined by their verticality. So it is
not rare to have buildings that function as offices, retail or hotels, with underground
38

�garages, and safe storages etc. But just how safe this environment is in the case of an
emergency? And are these buildings sustainable and energy efficient? Do they have
positive sociological impact on humanity?

Figure 17 - Illustration: “Would you like to live in a vertical city?” [197]

If consider the urban planning, high–rises take as little square meters of the ground as
possible, leaving the open space or keeping the natural environment. Phenomena of
Vertical Cities, with detailed spatial planning is clearing infrastructures of the
urbanized area.

Figure 18 - Low – Rise Settlement in Less Developed Areas of Shanghai (left)
and Shanghai – Pudong District (right) – Vertical Living [149, 153]

Also, we have to take into consideration that structure of such buildings is built out of
the material which may resist various loads depending on the area where it is located;
buildings that were built in the last few years, have used the best and the most
developed technology in order to meet all the needs of the construction. Turnover for
the use of such material for construction of these structures happened because of the
incidents which took place in New York, USA; the World Trade Centre on 9/11
showed that, steel structures were not sufficient enough to resist impact loads and fire,
39

�and completely collapse. All this lead to the switch from steel material to concrete,
and with rapid technology development of concrete’s variations which proved to be
more economic, sustainable and most importantly more resistant or with higher
resistance to intruded loads.
In other words, the importance of safety for the inhabitants grew with technological
development of the materials, which also lead to the development of structural design,
into core hybrid structures which had the capability to transfer lateral loadings.

Figure 19 - Shanghai Tower – during Construction Phase – Showing the Structure of the
Building (left) and Characteristic Floor Plan of Shanghai Tower (right) [133, 97]

Technology has, more or less, developed material and structures that are well designed
for constructions of vertical cities, but have they taken sustainability or energy
efficiency into considerations? To construct a high–rise that could function as a city
inside the building, it would have to consume more energy than a low – rise building
would. High-rises are under the impact of strong winds on the upper floors, and
instead of strengthening the structure, wind serves as a natural source of ventilation;
also, wind turbines are being built, to get renewable energy which can sustain the
building.
With this safe and sustainable way of working and functioning, vertical cites, apropos
high–rises, are becoming the new way of living.

40

�Figure 20 - Wind Turbines at the Top of the Residential Building, Indigo Building, Portland
Oregon – Renewable Energy Source (left) and Breathable Double Elevation on Shanghai
Tower Enables Natural Building’s Ventilation, Saving Costs and Use of Electric Energy
(right) [141, 168]

In Asia and America this is a living style that has certain tradition, and where we can
talk about some super high buildings, ranging from 300 up to 500 m in height, with
the highest example being Burj Khalifa, Dubai, 829.9 m.

Figure 21 – Burj Khalifa, Dubai, [148, 159]

In these areas, sociological impact is not something that plays a great role nowadays;
almost all living population have experienced the vertical living since their childhood.
On the other hand Europe, one of the more developed continents, does not have the
culture of vertical living in such scale; buildings in Europe range from 150 to 300 m

41

�in height, and still requires the safety and sustainability in order to give and to receive
positive sociological aspect to their inhabitants.
Despite the initials and constant scepticism of the public and expertise towards the
high–rise buildings, the construction technology development has brought high–rise
buildings to a new level, where it is not the one building in question, but the entire
system of liveable cities. This rough history of the high–rises had numerous turnovers
in the use of structural materials, systems and vertical communications, and they were
basically all leading to constructing a safer environment for tenants, providing more
resistant structures that were well designed, variable, impact and wind loads resistant,
and seismic and fire resistant.

42

�HIGH – RISE BUILDNGS IN BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA
By the time world got its first high–rise building, Bosnia and Herzegovina was going
through fundamental changes in urbanization, taking the principles of urbanization
and construction technology of Austro–Hungary (1878 – 1917), and inhabitants of
Bosnia were slowly abandoning the way of living of the previous years. It was
previously mentioned that Europe lagged behind the United States of America in
terms of high–rise construction due to European politics that wanted to preserve
landmarks from early periods and the cities skylines. This politics lead to high–rise
buildings being still unfamiliar in Bosnia and Herzegovina. However, it is important
to mention that Austro–Hungarian period in great measure created overall skyline of
Bosnian cites by constructing mostly residential buildings up to four, five storeys
high, infrastructures and numerous monumental buildings in the cities. Flourishing of
Austro–Hungarian plans for development of Bosnian territory was stopped by
escalation of the World War I. Urbanized and constructed areas of Bosnia and
Herzegovina were not devastated in great scales, but poverty of the after World War
I period stopped development of any new buildings or technology in Bosnia and
Herzegovina, and this situation remained for the next two decades ending together
with the World War II.

Figure 22 - Capital City of BiH – Sarajevo 1900 (above) and Sarajevo (1950) (below)
[72, 166]

After the World War II, Bosnia and Herzegovina became one of the six republics in
The Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia (SFRY). With development and
strengthening of the SFRY, Bosnia and Herzegovina became a place of opportunities
in various fields, where architecture and engineering took high position in terms of
development interests. Such situation, and new opportunities were extremely
43

�interesting for numerous highly educated professionals from European schools of
architecture.
The capital city of the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Sarajevo, was the centre
of new technological achievements, and it is not surprising that the first high–rise
building was constructed in Sarajevo. Reuf Kadić, assisted by Muhamed Kadić, both
architects that brought modernism in Bosnia from the Prague Academy, were
designers of the first Bosnian high–rise building. The first high–rise building, named
“Vakufski neboder”1, was 12 storeys high building, with underground level that
served as a foundation of the building.

Figure 23 - First High – Rise Building in BiH, “Vakufski neboder”, after Last Renovation
[129]

Despite the concrete construction, outer walls were in large scale enclosed with large
windows, which introduced new interior spaces than those inhabitants of Bosnian
buildings were used to. Even though the building was designed in 1930, the
construction of the building was completed in 1947, and it was 40 meters tall.

1

Endowment Skyscraper–Investor of this building was Endowments Directorate of Bosnia and Herzegovina, and the
building was named after directorate, Endowment Skyscraper/ Vakufski Neboder, commonly known by name JAT –
ov neboder.

44

�Period of the late fifties and early sixties of the 20th century was period of the great
expansion of architectural achievements, both in terms of horizontal and vertical
constructions. This period is best perceived through residential blocks at the Miljacka
river bank dating back to 1962; the group of 4 residential buildings, cubic in shape,
with clear white facade were 13 storeys high, with concrete structures, and to a great
degree, they introduced the new culture of living in apartment blocks in this area.

Figure 24 - Apartment Blocks at the Miljacka River Bank in Sarajevo, 1962 [39]

The first 12–storey high–rise buildings in this area that served a specific function was
a Faculty of Natural Sciences and Mathematics of the University of Sarajevo in
Sarajevo; the construction of the building was finished in 1966.

Figure 25 - Faculty of Natural Sciences and Mathematics in Sarajevo, 1966 [76]

Shortly after, the culture of high–rise living was accepted by the inhabitants of
Sarajevo, and it proved to be the only possible way to accommodate all the new
population that was migrating from the rural areas to Sarajevo. The demand for high–
45

�rise buildings in Sarajevo continued with the expansion of city which continued to
create a neighbourhood of high-rise buildings; the area of Čengić Vila, with residential
block of four high-rises, each being 17 storeys high, pushed the limits and improved
the technology of the construction in the period of the late sixties.

Figure 26 - Residential Block of High – Rise Buildings, Čengić Vila [119]

However, the analysis of the functions of high–rise buildings in Sarajevo, showed that
they were mostly used as residential blocks. This situation lead to restrictions in the
SFRJ laws, where high–rise building could be designed or built only with a purpose
to accommodate the influx of population. Such trend continued throughout the next
decade in Sarajevo, and by the early eighties, new settlements or forests, of high–rise
buildings were constructed in Sarajevo. Winter Olympic Games in 1984, were also
one of the stimulating factors for rapid high-rise construction, and this rapid
construction and large demand for high-rises, resulted in a great number of similar
buildings, with variation ranging from 12-18 storeys, built as concrete structures, or
prefabricated concrete structures.

Figure 27 - Prefabricated High – Rise Buildings – Alipašino Polje [77]

Just before the Winter Olympic Games in 1984, previously mentioned government
restriction were cancelled in order to build and design remarkably important buildings
46

�to represent modern Sarajevo to the world. One of the most successful designs is
building of National Parliament of Bosnia and Herzegovina and the building of State
Administration in Sarajevo, 1980, where the complex was designed by an architect,
academic and professor, Juraj Neidhardt back in 1955. Even though the building was
designed with horizontal volume and vertical as unity back in 1955, construction was
disposed in two parts, where vertical volume was constructed in first. With 21 storeys,
it is still at the top ten highest high–rises in Bosnia and Herzegovina.
Among all these examples of high–rise buildings built in the period of SFRY, it is
impossible not to mention UNITIC Office Block building in Sarajevo, designed by
the academic Ivan Štraus.
UNITIC Office Block, known as “Momo and Uzeir”, is designed as two equal high–
rises. It’s design showed great protection for the future actions undertaken on these
buildings; it is also enclosed by reflective glass envelope facade and it changed city’s
skyline making it unique. Even though UNITIC Office buildings were constructed in
1986, its technological achievements and designs of modern architecture, as well as
its height, can compete with the new generation of high–rises in Bosnia and
Herzegovina.

Figure 28 - National Parliament - J. Neidhardt (left) and
UNITIC Office Buildings - I. Štraus (right) [80, 101]

Despite the evidence that Sarajevo was the centre with the highest rate of development
in the period of SFRY, other cities like Zenica, Tuzla, Bihać, and Banja Luka also
47

�resembled a large construction site and deserve to be mentioned for the examples of
high–rise constructions that can be seen in these areas. All these cities were under
different forces that required fast and rapid development in short periods of time. The
strict law restriction in spatial planning and construction of SFRY, could be a reason
why the architecture in these cities didn’t have examples of notable architecture.
Numerous high–rises buildings, mostly had accommodation function for the arriving
labour population that was migrating during the industrial development.
At the list of Bosnian largest cities, Banja Luka, is immediately after Sarajevo as
Bosnian second largest city. However, there aren’t many examples of high–rise
construction; even in the period of the great expansion of the cities in SFRY, Banja
Luka was primarily oriented toward low–rise buildings. That phenomena was unique
for Banja Luka and surrounding areas due to the location of the city on the very
seismic area. Back in the late sixties, when the rest of the country was developing,
Banja Luka was damaged by two devastating earthquakes. Fifteen people lost their
lives and more than thousand were injured in the earthquake in 1969, and significant
number of the buildings were damaged or destroyed.

Figure 29 - Banja Luka after Devastating Earthquake in 1969 [110]

Newer buildings were concrete structured which proved to have more favourable
transfer of the lateral forces. This was a case with ”Incelov neboder” or “Čajavčev
neboder” constructed in 1967 in very close urban core, 14–storey tall. Besides its
height, this building located at “Krajina Square,” outstands in its surrounding with
characteristic architecture of socialist period.

48

�Figure 30 -”Incelov neboder” or “Čajavčev neboder”, Banja Luka [152]

However, Banja Luka recovered and rebuild fast, but as a low-rise city, where nature
has proven more powerful that the current technological capabilities.
Another urban core in Bosnia and Herzegovina is Zenica, where all high-rises still
resemble those examples of the residential blocks in Sarajevo, from the same period.
Cubic shaped towers with openings in one vertical line with nothing striking to show,
but already seen and recognizable architecture. Also, the construction principles were
those that were already seen with the concrete structure, designed as a frame system.
However, high–rise named “Lamela”, served the inhabitants and local government as
a representation of their power and strength. The building was designed as a complex
of six cubic vertical forms, set one next to another from the lowest to the highest.
In the initial project the highest cubic was designed to be 30 storeys high, but the lack
of construction technology and problems with water supply and other mechanical
systems, reduced the number of storey to 27, with final height being 101.9 m. Building
was designed by an architect Slobodan Jovandić, and it took five years to finish the
construction (1971-1976), due to the utility problems of the building, but not the
structure itself.

49

�Figure 31 - Zenica – Residential Blocks at River Bank (left) and Lamela – Highest High–
Rise Building in Zenica (right) [131, 125]

Along with Sarajevo and Zenica, Bihać and Tuzla also had large income; Tuzla as the
industrial city, and Bihać as military city were developing rapidly. Even though both
of these areas had problematic load bearing soil in terms of quality and strength, urban
cores still have examples of high–rise structures. Like Sarajevo, Tuzla experienced
birth of new high–rise buildings growing as new defined settlements, where high–rise
buildings formed group of detached high–rises with courtyards, which served as
gardens and parking lots. What is Alipašino Polje and high–rises for Sarajevo, Sjenjak
settlement is for Tuzla. Structure and function of both settlements are not much
different, but variation of the storeys constructed exist. However, in the psychological
perception of the people living in these cities, Sjenjak was and still is an elite
settlement, while Alipašino Polje, for most architectural critics represents an area of
the sleeping units.

Figure 32 - Tuzla’s Settlement of High–Rises – Sjenjak [73]
50

�The centre of the northwest of the republic Bosnia and Herzegovina was Bihać.
Construction of the largest military airport in SFRY and industrialisation of Bihać,
were turnover for new investments in construction in order to accommodate the influx
of population, military and otherwise. Bihać, unlike other cities, was not one of the
cities with newly constructed high – rise settlements. Somehow, most of the buildings
were up to 5 storeys high, which shows awareness of former architects and engineers
about the quality, strength and stability of the load bearing soil, as well as their
attention to seismic forces, due to the fact that Bihać lied at very seismically active
area.

Figure 33 - Bijeli neboder (White Skyscraper), Bihać’s Highest High–Rise [120]

In spite of this, there are examples of the high–rises in Bihać, but in smaller scales
than those in other Bosnian cities. Highest high-rise in Bihać reaches 16 storeys, and
it functioned as residential building with commercial at the first two floors, commonly
known as Bijeli Neboder (The White Skyscraper), and it is recognizable for its finishes
on the outer walls and its facade, where the whole solid area of the facades is cladded
with “Bihacit2” stone tiles, which was an unusual example during this period.
The period of constant development, rapid construction and acceleration in the
development of construction technologies in this areas was stopped in the early
nineties when war broke out in the area. Period of devastating war and vandalism
lasted from 1991 to 1995. During this period, that what was built in the era of rapid
2

Bihacit is a clean granular, gravelly and cavernous limestone, created at the tertiary
freshwaters basin around Bihać
51

�development was under daily destruction and bombing. Sarajevo was the city with the
longest siege of the modern period. During this period, buildings that were valued as
greatest achievements, became military targets.
Neither the building of the BH Parliament, nor UNITIC Office Building, among
numerous others were spared. Reason for the survival of pre–war high–rises was their
solid structure that actually resisted devastating fires and preserved the high–rises in
their volume. July 7, 1992 was the day when images of the twin high–rise on fire
spread as sun light worldwide, and the day when architect Ivan Štraus wrote in its
diary the best description of that period:
“…Tonight, barbarian burned one of two glass towers of UNIS Office Building,
at Marijindvor. Both of them were already damaged in large scale, but now one
of them is burning. With immeasurable sadness, I was watching it being
helpless with flames breaking out of its windows, while my minds were filled
with memories of construction days and how actually I was proud of them. The
rest of the night I spent in basement, sleepless, lying at improvised bed,
watching game of black cobweb pieces and their shadows at cracked off – white
ceiling, counting latticework and span between them. However image of the
tower burning as torch, I could not expel“ [39]
After the last war, Bosnia and Herzegovina was devastated in large scale; there was
not a single building that was not damaged. Most of the country’s infrastructure, roads
and bridges, were highly destructed or demolished, so was the economy.
Reconstruction of everything that was built before the war was set priority and
inevitable for rehabilitation of the whole country.

Figure 34 - UNIS Office Building in Sarajevo, Burning, Last War (1992) [138]

52

�While the years after the war were mostly cited as the period of stagnation, it would
seem unfair to dismiss efforts that were done to bring back the old shine of great and
fast development. However, early 21st century for high–rises in Bosnia and
Herzegovina represented a new generation of high-rise buildings.
Pioneer of the new generation of high–rises in BH is Bosmal City Centre,
conceptually designed as a city within a city, or more precisely, a city within a
building. Bosmal City Centre consists of two buildings, used for residential,
commercial and other functions.

Figure 35 - Bosmal City Centre Sarajevo [156]

Construction of the BCC started in 2001 and lasted for 5 years, the predicted and
designed height of the Centre was 118 m, which would give it a title of the highest
residential building in the area of Balkans. Shortly after Sarajevo became birthplace
of another high–rise building that would become the highest among high–rises at the
area of south–east Europe.

Figure 36 - New Generation of BH High – Rises in Sarajevo [188]
53

�Located at Marijindvor, by 2006, the construction of high–rise Avaz Twist Tower had
started. Avaz Twist Tower was designed as a concrete high–rise, 40 storeys high, with
final height of 175 m, enveloped with twisted glass curtain wall.

Figure 37 – Avaz Twist Tower [124, 150]

Few years later, Marijin Dvor hosted construction of new business and commercial
complex. Sarajevo City Centre (SCC) with two tall volumes, was promising
remarkable piece of tall architecture. With 74 meters SCC for sure did not reach the
heights already seen in Sarajevo, but rather expressed playful forms with strongly
defined broken lines which states for unique example of high–rise architecture in
Sarajevo and wider area. Its exterior construction was completed in 2013, however
interior of the towers is still under construction. And nowadays if observed Marijin
Dvor appears to be neighbour of the most representative high–rises in Sarajevo
including, UNITIC Office Blocks, National Parliament, Avaz Twist Tower and
Sarajevo City Centre.
Besides the mentioned buildings, there are other newly constructed or under
construction high–rises filling the contemporary Sarajevo’s skyline.

54

�Figure 38 – Sarajevo City Center (SCC) [158]

On the other hand other cities that were trying to catch up with the capital city in pre–
war years, in terms of rapid high–rise construction, in the following years and
nowadays were dealing with dramatic reduction in demand for high–rises.
However, positive example of the new generation of high–rises in BiH, besides
Sarajevo is the administrative building of Government of the Republika Srpska,
located in Banja Luka. In comparison to the previous periods, this was a greatest step
forward in high–rise construction in this area. Previously mentioned area of Banja
Luka is marked as intense seismic zone, which makes it obvious why there are not
many examples of high–rises in Banja Luka as there are in other cities in Bosnia and
Herzegovina.

Figure 39 - Administrative Building of the Government of the Republika Srpska [99]
55

�Administrative building of the Government of the Republika Srpska was constructed
in 2007, 18 storeys high (ground floor + 17, 70 m high), enveloped with glass facade,
cubic shaped tower, and was nothing new worth of high praise for architecture in
Bosnia and Herzegovina, due to the fact that period of 2005/7 was marked with the
highest building in the Balkan area, Avaz Twist Tower. However, this high–rise is
worth mentioning in the analysis of high–rises in BiH due to its location in intense
seismic zone, if nothing else.
Besides Sarajevo and Banja Luka, other BiH cities Tuzla and Mostar also have
examples of new–generation of high–rises. Tuzla recently became a place of few new
high–rises, the most impressive being Mellain building; large scaled, massive
complex of four attached buildings, where three of them are high–rises. Building is
designed as multi–functional, where the design of volumes was used to enhance each
function. When observed from the main street, this complex seems as three united
high–rises. Focus was added to the central high–rise, whose function reflects in
hospitality, and at the same time this is the highest part of the complex with the height
of 96.45 m, and 21 storeys high. Facade design differs, from the previously mentioned
buildings, glass curtain walls were used to enhance the main entrances and to add a
touch of glamour.
Other two high–rises, are identical residential blocks, one on the left, and other on the
right side of the complex, resembling as wings of the strongly stated central high–rise,
which is 19 storeys high.

Figure 40 - Mellain Complex, Tuzla under Construction (left) and Constructed (right)
[125, 130]
56

�Mostar’s skyline is enriched with high–rise building that serves a unique function,
unlike other cities in Bosnia and Herzegovina, Mostar’s highest building serves to
religious purposes, as well as touristic attraction. As celebration of the new
millennium in Mostar, an idea to design and construct a bell tower as part of the
reconstructed Franciscan Church was born. Cubic, pure concrete tower, with 107.20
meters height, was designed by an architect Davor Smoljan. The tower was defined
as a symbol of peace, and its design was divided in two phases. First phase was to
construct the height of 75 meters which is used as an observation tower of Mostar’s
landscapes and natural environment. In order to reach the observation floor, vertical
communication was designed as elevator and stairs, which was however finished in
2016. Second phase, was to establish International Art Gallery of “Peace”, from the
ground level up to the observatory. After the construction was completed, it became
obvious that compared to this building all other Mostar’s high–rises buildings looked
like dwarfs.

Figure 41 - Franciscan Church and its Bell Tower – Symbol of Peace, Mostar [140]

Even though BIH scene of high rise buildings and their construction, started some 50
years later than the rest of the world’s scene, it is more than obvious that architects
and engineers in Bosnia and Herzegovina achieved great success in the last 70 years.
In the beginnings, high–rise buildings in this area were mostly defined as sleeping
units, with few exceptions. Increased number of rural population migrating to urban
zones required fast solution in accommodation. High–rise buildings in this case
proved to be as the best solution for fast construction and low land consumption. As
main structural material, architects, designers and engineers chose reinforced concrete
structures, or prefab concrete structures, rather than other materials, which proved to
be one of the greatest advantages in the design of high-rises. Era of constant, rapid
and mass development of Bosnia and Herzegovina as part in the SFRY was all of a
57

�sudden interrupted and stopped by the war. It was impossible to find a building in
Bosnia and Herzegovina that was not partially of fully damaged both by heavy
artillery or fires. High–rise buildings were “easy targets”, and what saved most of
them from complete demolition to the ground was high–fire resistance of concrete. In
large scale, the war slowed down the construction of new high rises; after the war, a
period of restauration, conservation and reconstruction of demolished and damaged
buildings followed. First years of the 21st century, brought new ideas and attempts of
construction of new high-rises.
Pioneers of the new–generations of high–rises in Bosnia and Herzegovina, still kept
concrete structures, while breaking the limits of previous heights. Also, the function
of the new high-rises was not reserved only for residential purposes anymore; with
few exceptions, new high – rises in Bosnia and Herzegovina followed new living
style, and most of the buildings are multifunctional, accommodating residential zones,
hospitality, business etc.

58

�STRUCTURES OF HIGH - RISE BUILDINGS
Architecture depends on many factors, which greatly vary from initial concepts,
functionality of designed spaces, its proportions both to human perception and urban
context, and structural support and technological capabilities to support desired
concept. Thus, any analysis of the above stated factors that architecture depends on,
as its final result shows that crucial factor among these is structural support, which
has to maintain the stability of the building.
Scholar proficiency in architectural structures mostly focuses on basic structural
systems which are common within different structural materials and within different
volumes of the buildings, however reality is more than complicated, especially if we
consider high–rise buildings, or buildings designed by architects such as Frank Gehry,
Daniel Libeskind or Zaha Hadid. However, high–rise buildings are completely
another and specific field with longer technological development history than those
new contemporary buildings that show futuristic designs and which are defined with
curved volumes and elongated elements. In high–rises, increased safety for the
inhabitants of the building, greater resistance of the structure to various actions, and
necessity for decreased overuse of structural materials and overdesigned load-bearing
structural elements, as well as economic benefit, forced the development of structures
of high-rise buildings since their beginnings. Structures of high–rise buildings are
analysed and grouped by different approaches, focusing on structural material or the
composition of the structural elements.
However numerous divisions and subdivisions of structures of high–rises and an an
excellent start for understanding complex issue of high-rise structures might lay in the
definition approved by many critics and The Council of Tall Buildings and Urban
Habitat, which states that high–rise is: “A building whose height creates different
conditions in the design, construction and use than those that exist in common
building of a certain region or period.”
As an example that supports this statement is a remarkable contemporary high–rise
Burj Khalifa, which rises 829.9 meters above Dubai. Even its urban context is created
by numerous high–rise buildings, the height of Burj Khalifa creates a vision that the
rest of the high–rises are just common buildings in this area. Opposite to this, one of
the highest building in the area of south–east Europe, Avaz Twist Tower, rises 175
meters above Sarajevo, where achieved height is outstanding compared to other
buildings in this urban context. So it is more than obvious that these two buildings
required different treatments, different structural systems and technological
requirements, even though they were built around the same period, and both have the
title of the highest buildings in their areas.
59

�Despite various contemporary requirements and technological developments of high–
rise building’s structural systems, history and beginnings of high–rises were less
complicated and simple when compared to nowadays technology. During the period
of the first–high rise building, widely in use and best known were massive load
bearing masonry structures, rigid thick shear walls with small perimeter openings with
low resistance to lateral forces which are crucial for structural design of high–rise
buildings. Masonry structures were replaced with an iron and steel structures which
created larger spans between columns, creating more open areas at the building’s
perimeter for the windows, and it also facilitated the construction. At that time, terms
such as load–bearing systems, in shape of rigid steel frames and non–load bearing
structural elements, such as separation walls, or fill–in brick non–load bearing walls
between the columns at the perimeter of the buildings that were not glass surfaces,
were introduced to structural design. Non–load bearing elements and cladding
materials were carrying nothing but self–weight and lateral wind load in their areas.
Development in this range was more than sufficient for designers and investors to start
racing for expansion in vertical dimensions. High rate in increase in height of the
buildings was not equally accelerated with technological development of the
structural systems and designs.
With tendency to go higher, while keeping the same steel frame systems braced to
resist wind loadings, made high–rises of the late 19th century and early 20th century
were very expensive due to overuse of structural materials in order to construct
overdesigned structural elements.
At this point, initial forces that created an idea of high–rises, reflected in economic
benefits of the investor, expecting that desired height could reduce cost on low land
consumption, proved to be pure imagination. However, a turnover for fast
development occurred in the second half of the 20th century; strong economy forced
and supported technological developments, and even the new generation of computers
and software helped in the development of more efficient structural systems.
Innovative structural systems, enacted use of tubular forms, outriggers, diagrids and
megastructures, reduced the overuse of material and low scaled the dimensions of the
structural elements. Each of these structures had to satisfy four primary structural
requirements, and in following order: static equilibrium, stability, strength and rigidity
of the structure. Static equilibrium, as the first requirement is to test the structure in
order for it to respond to designed loads acting at the structure, which should go
without major displacements of the structure, where sum of forces in the foundation
could resist the designed loads. Stability refers to the structure in equilibrium which
has to avoid major changes in shape of the structure. In the case of high–rise buildings
the structure is more exposed to strong lateral forces, wind and seismic loads; in this
case, static equilibrium and stability of the structure are strongly connected. Structure
60

�of the high–rises requires adequate treatment to exclude possible sway of structure or
even collapse. In the figure below, in the left scheme we can see rigid frame of high–
rise structure, in static equilibrium but deformed, while the scheme on the right side
shows braced frame of high–rise structure, where bracings added axial respond to
lateral load providing static equilibrium and stability.

Figure 42 - Frame (left) and Braced Frame (right)

Figure 43 - Detail of Figure 42

61

�Figure 43 on the left shows sway of the high–rise frame structure upon lateral wind
loads which disturbed the stability of the building, while the right side shows
distribution of the axial forces in braces, which improved the stability remaining with
in static equilibrium. Once the static equilibrium and stability are satisfied, the
question of required strength of the elements comes to the table, which has to
determine the internal forces, the best material for the structure depending on its
strength and to design the structural element, the element sufficient enough to respond
to internal forces.
Last requirement for the structure is rigidity. The first two requirements are closely
connected, the last two are also, both strength and rigidity depend on the material used
and cross sections of the structural elements. Elements designed in such way are
supposed to exclude excessive deflection in respond to loadings.
Notwithstanding fact that major requirements crucial for the structure are to meet
equilibrium, stability, strength and rigidity, which should not tolerate any other design
requirements, structures itself are nevertheless in architectural sense becoming an
additional aesthetic value for a building supporting the concept. Structural diagrids,
tubes, braces of the frame system, space trusses etc., commonly represent structural
systems that bring an additional aesthetic value to high–rise buildings.
An excellent example of the high–rises with an exposed structures (megastructures)
is Hearst Magazine Building, tower designed by Norman Foster in New York City.

Figure 44 - Hearst Magazine Building - 2004, NYC (left), Hotel de las Artes – 1992,
Barcelona (right) [87, 100]

62

�It is an outstanding high–rise in neighbourhood of high–rises, due to the specific
exposed steel structure–diagrid, which even reduced the structural material
consumption, due to its geometrical disposition of the structural elements, when
compared to the braced steel frames.
Unlike the Hearst Magazine Building whose diagrid is full–filled with glass walls,
structure of the Hotel de las artes was practically attached to the building volume; an
exo–structure was attached by design at the building perimeter in order to resist lateral
forces. Being hidden or exposed, it is more than obvious that evolution and
development of structures contributed to the overall architectural expression. Also,
the structures are not heavy anymore; there are no massive barriers in interior spaces,
but there is a variety of aesthetic forms of architecture.

63

��CLASSIFICATION OF THE STRUCTURES
OF HIGH – RISE BUILDINGS
Architectural structures of the high–rise buildings have been a new field for various
scientific researches, analysis and classifications ever since their rapid developments
in the sixties. Structures were classified according to the use of structural material in
ratio with economic benefits and heights, whether they were visible (at the perimeter
of the building, supporting architectural expression, exterior structures) or invisible
(such cores, or structures hidden in interior of the building, interior structures).
However, each of the classification is greatly upgrade of the previous one, in an effort
to find a place for a newly developed structural system of the high–rise.
According to F.R. Khan, back in 1969, high–rise structural systems were classified
according to the efficiency relating to their height. As a final result of such attempt to
classify structures upon these factors, diagrams “Heights for the Structural Systems”
were created. [20]
However, this era of rapid development in order to catch up with desired heights and
economic benefits brought necessity for upgrade of the existing diagrams. In 1972/73,
new schematic diagrams were created for classification of structural systems, based
on the structural material used, concrete or steel. With these diagrams, Khan enhanced
the close relationship between progressive demand for height and economic benefits,
while the decision not to use steel structures in buildings under 20 storeys, in order
for it to be the most sufficient, is not surprising. According to Khan, doable systems
were frames, shear walls, framed trusses and tubular forms.

Figure 45 - Classification of the Structures of High–Rise Buildings according to F.R. Khan
(steel structures) [1]

65

�Figure 46 - Classification of the Structures of High–Rise Buildings according to F.R. Khan
(concrete structures) [1]

With such accelerated evolution of the structural systems, high–rise structures
required more updated classification. In 2007, Mir M. Ali developed new
classification guided by lateral load resisting capabilities. According to Mir M. Ali,
each structure had a major structure which was capable to resists lateral actions (wind
and seismic actions), and minor one which was not as dominant as major, but did have
capacity to resist lateral actions.

Figure 47 - Classification of the Structures of High–Rise Buildings according to Mir M. Ali
(interior structures) [1]

66

�If the major structure was placed at the inner part of the building, while minor
structural elements were positioned at the perimeter of the building, structure was
classified as interior structure. If the major structure was positioned at the perimeter
of the building and minor at the interior, structure was classified as exterior structure.

Figure 48 - Classification of the Structures of High–Rise Buildings according to Mir M. Ali
(exterior structures) [1]

67

��FRAME SYSTEM
Frame system was pioneering system in structuring and maintaining the concept of
high–rises as physical objects. The first generation of high–rises were structured with
rigid frames. Such system appeared as regular grid, with girders as horizontal
elements and columns as vertical elements, rigidly connected. Rigid frame structure,
primarily resisted loadings through flexural stiffness of the members, where vertical
members of the frames were designed upon the gravity actions (permanent and
variable actions), while the girders, horizontal members were designed to withstand
possible deflection under permanent and variable actions, and were also designed to
resist lateral sway of the structure under lateral actions.

Figure 49 - Rigid Frames of High–Rises
Combination of the Displacement due to Sway and Bending [177]

However, if the span between the columns was larger, which was the actual case due
to necessity for more open space, girders and columns were respectively increasing in
cross–sectional dimensions in order to ensure overall stability of the structure. The
same goes with the height increasing, where the columns that were close to the ground
or foundation was wider in cross section than columns at the upper floors. Rigid Frame
System can be made out of both structural steel and concrete. However, prevalent
material for these structures is structural steel, which accelerates the construction and
proves as very efficient for the high–rises up to 30 storeys, while the concrete is
efficient up to 20 stories but high fire resistance of concrete is what made concrete the
number one choice in structural material for rigid frame systems.

69

�Figure 50 - Lake Shore Apartments – Rigid Steel Frame Structure (left)
and Stanhope Building – Rigid Concrete Frame Structure (right, axonometric) [179]

The subcategory, described as developed method of rigid frame is braced rigid frame
system. Unlike rigid frame, braced frame system was more economic and efficient
steel structure; bracings minimizes or exclude bending of the columns and beams in
such a way that, axial stress in bracings mimics the rest of the lateral forces. By
bracings the structural elements such as girders and columns became more slender
and overall structure got a geometry of vertical trusses, where columns appeared as
chords. There are various ways of bracing systems, most common being: single
diagonal, double diagonal and bracings in appearance of letter “K”. Such structural
system might be used for building up to 40 storeys high.

Figure 51 - Common Type of Bracings

70

�SHEAR WALLS SYSTEM
Even though load–bearing walls, forerunners of shear wall system, were main break
for high–rise construction, development and change to a more efficient structural
material such as reinforced concrete (and other strengthened types of concrete)
resulted in development of shear wall system. Shear walls, plane structural elements
extended from the foundation to the final height, proved to be the greatest advantage
in bracing of high-rise buildings that could resist lateral actions (wind and seismic).
Large in plane, shear walls had great stiffness and strength. However if the shear walls
were interrupted in order to build windows or doors, stiffness of the overall structure
respectively decreased in ratio of solid to void areas; similarly, if two shear walls were
connected with a beam, two walls acted as one unit, and such system was named
coupled shear walls.

Figure 52 - Variations of Interruptions in Shear Walls [176]

Figure 52, shows different percentage of shear wall interrupted, the first version shear
wall is interrupted with small openings, not largely affecting the stiffness of the wall,
the second however has larger opening which in ratio of solid void decreased overall
performance of the shear wall–coupled shear walls, and the third figure shows the
void area that fully separated wall to two smaller plane areas noticeable decreasing
overall structural stiffness. In statics, shear wall might be described as cantilever
beam, fixed at the foundation, extending up to the final height of the building. Such
system is chosen when constructing in highly seismic zones, due to its greater stiffness
because “cantilevered” vertical beams transfer seismic lateral loading to the
foundation.

71

�Arrangement in the plan of shear walls, in any case, should be symmetrical; if not, the
structure can undergo torsion. Such proposal for symmetry of the shear walls
arrangement imposes mirrored floor plans, and debatable flexibility of the space. This
might be additional plus in the design of hotels, dormitories or residential buildings
in terms of creating shafts for the rooms, or apartments; otherwise in architectural
design, shear walls system is considered highly inefficient and creates various
limitation. However use of the shear walls to create cores, and shafts for stairs and
elevators, mostly located in the centre of the floor plan axis, partially solves problem
of the space’s flexibility. With such approach, a new sub category was developed as
structure of shear walls + frame system.

Figure 53 - Axonometric View of Shear Walls System, Example (left)
and Characteristic Floor Plan of the National Commercial Bank, Showing the Symmetry in
Arrangement of Shear Walls (right) [180]

In terms of height, shear wall system can reach the height of 35 storeys in order for it
to be economic, while the use of reinforced concrete will still be used effectively. On
the other hand, when combined with a frame system, possibility of steel or concrete
framing of shear walls lead to more storeys, but also proved to be more economic and
efficient, which means that concrete shear wall and steel rigid frame can reach up to
60 storeys, while concrete shear walls and concrete frame systems goes up to 70+
storeys high.

72

�Figure 54 - Casselden Place, Melbourne – Concrete Shear Walls + Steel Frame, 43 Stories
(left) and 311 South Wacker Drive – Concrete Shear Walls + Concrete Frame, 75 Stories
(right) [102, 104]

73

��OUTRIGGER SYSTEM
Outrigger structures are generally a unity of the core, outriggers, belt trusses and mega
columns. Shear cores are mostly designed at the axial centre of the floor plan; however
it is not impossible for it to be located at either one side of the building. Commonly
in a form of concrete cores or rarely in a form of steel trusses, shear cores do act as
vertical cantilevered beam fixed at the foundation. Outriggers, might be in a form of
steel trusses or concrete walls, and depending on the design the outriggers are
approximately 1 to 2 storeys deep. Depending on the position of the core, outriggers
may extend from both sides if the core is centrally positioned or from one side if the
core is placed on one side of the building. The role of the outriggers is to reduce
moment in the structure’s core by acting as the stiff headers that transfer the moment
from the core, to the mega columns generally located at the perimeter of the building
by stimulating a tension–compression couple in mega columns. Belt trusses connect
the mega columns at the perimeter of the building, reducing the elongations in tensile
zone and shortening in compression zone of mega columns, while also being capable
to resist a shear load, which can cause bending. Even though, the columns and belt
trusses are capable of taking over lateral actions, the design of major structure is
interior core and outrigger, which classifies this structure as interior structure.

Figure 55 - Shanghai’s Tower Structural System [139]

75

�Outrigger structures are lately becoming very popular in super high-rise buildings,
where outriggers trusses or walls advance shear wall/core system in resisting lateral
actions in a form of re–distribution of shear forces. With outriggers in buildings higher
than 70 storey, bending caused by overturning is highly resistant.

Figure 56 - Bending Moment Diagram under Applied Wind Load on Shear Core and Frame
Structure (above) and Bending Moment Diagram under Applied Wind Load on Outrigged
Structure (below)

Besides valued advantages, in terms of additional stiffness, stability, higher resistance
of the structure to crucial lateral loads, high performance and efficiency in use of the
materials and design, the main disadvantage is perceived in occupied rentable space
reserved for outriggers. If consider that 1 or 2 storeys are required per one outrigger,
it becomes obvious that the greater height leads to the percentage of occupied stories
respectively increasing as well. However if well planned and designed, outrigged
stories can be used as mechanical floors; such approach excludes “waste” of space.
Considering structural material, this structure might be designed as steel structure or
76

�concrete, or in most cases as composite structure. Due to the high fire resistance
requirements, cores are mostly designed in concrete, which adds to the safety for
occupants of the building in the case of emergency. However, lightness of structural
steel makes steel preferable in comparison to heavy concrete for outriggers and belt
trusses, such structure and relation between materials and structural elements, is
showed as efficient when constructing 150 storeys high buildings.

77

��TUBE SYSTEM
One of the most spread exterior structures of high–rise buildings is tube structure.
Lateral actions in such structure are resisted with the structural element positioned at
the perimeter of the building. As one of the greatest innovation in the sixties, tube
structure was designed by F. Khan back in 1961. It was delivered as an actual structure
with De Witt Chestnut Apartment Building in Chicago. Construction was finished by
1963, with 43 storeys height, and in arrangement of framed tube.

Figure 57 - Variation of Tubular Structures

Frame tube structure was the first example of tubular approach for construction of in
high–rise buildings. It is designed as hollow cantilever, fixed at the foundation to the
ground, in order to resist lateral loads. It consists of closely arranged columns, while
the span between central axes of columns’ cross section is approximately between 1.5
to 4.5 meters and spandrel beams being rigidly connected. The depths of beams vary
between 60 and 120 cm. Term framed tube structures is closely related to, shear lag
effect, which means that within this type of structure corner columns experience the
largest axial forces, which are not distributed linearly along the direction
perpendicular or parallel to the wind.
Frame tube can be designed both out of, steel or concrete, with efficiency up to 80
storeys.

79

�Figure 58 - Characteristic Arrangement of the Structural Elements for Framed Tubes in
Plan (left) and Diagram of Shear Lag Effect (right) [1]

For architectural functionality or aesthetics such system strongly leads the overall
composition, dynamic and geometry of the elevation, while at the same time decreases
costs for the additional curtain wall or fill in walls, but also reduces daily light
penetration to the building.

Figure 59 - De Witt Chestnut Apartment Building in Chicago, F. Khan,
Characteristic Floor Plan Showing Perimeter Column Arrangement (left),
and De Witt Chestnut Apartment Building Constructed (right) [178, 137]

A type of tube structure, braced tube, also called truss tube, was first used back in
1970 in Chicago, at John Hancock Centre. Such structure developed as newly evolved
frame tube. Instead of closely arranged columns, required structural stiffness was
achieved by diagonal bracing. Braced tube overcame the problem of progressive
inefficiency in over 60 storey high buildings which was the case with frame tube. With
bracing, perimeter frames acted as stiffener and the braces overtook floors’ gravity
80

�actions. Each joint of the diagonals and columns, in structure of braced tubes,
eliminated effect of shear lag by being tubular in framework. Besides structural
advantages of braced truss tubular structure, larger spans between columns that were
provided by bracings, created larger areas for the openings glass areas increased the
interior quality and at the same ratio, the glass areas increases themselves. Also, the
braces which were left as visible by design, enhanced and gave a character to each
elevation.

Figure 60 - John Hancock Centre, Representative Example of Braced Tube Structure [79]

Unlike other tubular structures, bundled tube system, made high–rise buildings
structured with this system a vertical play of the various volumes, which differentiated
it from the cubic shaped towers. In this variation of tube structural system, couple of
tubes were interconnected and acted as one unit. Back in 1974, Sears Tower was the
first bundled structure, with 9 tubes at the base level, which created regular grid of 3
rows and 3 columns, while still following the principle of bundled structure; as the
final storey was not cubic. Approach of the bundled structures, concept and the overall
design of structure reduced the elements of the lower storeys, slandering lower
structural elements, when compared to those that would be required for other type of
structure.

81

�Figure 61 - Sears Tower, Chicago (left),
Schemes of Modular Floor Configuration (mid and right) [67, 181]

Bundled concept, unlike others structure’s concepts gives variety of characteristic
floor plans in areas, with greater lower storeys and those smaller at the upper storeys.
There are different geometrical shapes in grid plan, such as: rectangular, triangular,
hexagonal etc., which mould vertical volume of the high–rise tube. Bundled tube
structures, efficiency is up to 110 storeys, with possibility of steel or concrete as main
structural material. Even though such composition reduces shear lag and enables
slenderer structural elements, the configuration of tubes may have created limitation
in arrangement of the interior space.

Figure 62 - Different Plan Configuration for Bundled Tube Structures

82

�One of the safest tubular structures due to resistance to the impact loads, besides its
high stiffness of structure in resisting lateral and gravity loads is tube in tube structure.
It is usually composed of two tubes, one larger at perimeter and smaller inside
perimeter of building, however it may be designed with more tubes within a tube if it
is required due to higher safety and if such attempt and concept shows as efficient. An
example of tube in tube structure is 181 West Madison Street in Chicago, which has
52 storeys.

Figure 63 - 181 West Madison Street, (left), Characteristic Floor Plan (right) [144, 143]

Such structure effectively resists lateral actions with both tubes due to its system that
inner core (inner tube) and outer tube with slabs, which makes both core and cube
able to resist lateral actions. As far as the structural material is concerned, both exterior
and interior tubes can be designed as concrete or steel cores or frame tubes. In terms
of height, tube in tube system is efficient up to 80 storey high buildings. However,
such structures excludes a high demand for numerous columns in interior design, inner
core if not used with specific purpose as elevators, stairs, mechanic installations core,
can develop limitation in arrangement of interior space.

83

��DIAGRID SYSTEM
Diagrid is an exterior structural system used in high–rise buildings, which is even
though entirely exposed at the elevation, both in architectural and structural fields of
science and art, defined as extremely aesthetic. Unlike, diagrid braced tubular
structure, which may be seen as a forerunner of diagrids, it is mostly degraded by
expertise and critics. Entirely braced John Hancock Centre in Chicago, was one of the
pioneers in braced tube structures; despite the improved structural efficiency, new
aesthetic style, innovation, structure exposed through all four elevations was not
welcomed. However, a decade later, newly named form of diagrid, gained full
attention. Dating back to 1980’s Sir Norman Foster, proposed diagrid solution for the
Humana Headquarters composition. Even though diagrid was not a best solution for
Sir Norman Foster, Hearst Headquarters Centre in New York and 30 St. Mary Ave in
London received praise and become monuments of Sir Norman Foster, and were
closely related to diagrid structures.

Figure 64 - Hearst Headquarters Centre in New York (left),
and 30 St. Mary Ave in London (right) [170, 96]

In diagrid structures, the whole structure depends on diagonal members. Due to stored
shear by axial forces in diagonal members diagrid structures reduces and minimize
shear deformation.

85

�Diagonal members of diagrid were also capable of carrying gravity actions, and its
triangulated configuration of diagonals could resist for lateral actions. As structure,
diagrid did not seek for shear rigidity cores, because diagrid had high bending and
shear rigidity at the perimeter’s diagonals.

Figure 65 - Variations of Diagrid Geometry [62]

Diagrid structures are commonly steel structures, with very complicated joints of the
diagonals, however they are efficient in up to 100 storeys buildings, and represent
regular geometry in diagrids. Lately diagrids are designed and constructed out of
concrete, as main structural material, which is far different from steel diagrid, with
more irregular and organic shape, which lead to the new futuristic architectural
aesthetics. Concrete diagrid structures, require expensive formwork and the
construction. An example of such design is reflected in O–14 Building in Dubai.

Figure 66 - Concrete Diagrid, O-14 Building Dubai (left)
and Construction of Diagrid (right) [161, 167]
86

�SPACE TRUSS SYSTEM, EXO–SKELETON SYSTEM AND SUPER
FRAME STRUCTURES
Besides Tube and Diagrid, exterior structures that resist lateral actions and structures
that supports high–rise buildings in physical world include, Space Truss, Exo Skeleton
and super frames.
An example of Space Truss structure can be seen in China Tower of 1990, in Hong
Kong. In appearance, space truss is described as braced tube with modified diagonals
that penetrates from the exterior to the interior of the building. That is at the same time
greatest difference between the two, braced tubes diagonals and chords members are
connected in plane areas, while space trusses diagonals have third direction toward to
the interior space. Axial forces of the space truss members, resist lateral actions, while
space trusses are steel structures which are efficient up to 150 storeys. Diagonals that
penetrate the interior of the building are one of the crucial elements for structure’s
resistance, however if not well designed they might appear as obstacle in interior of
the building.

Figure 67 - China Tower of 1990 (left)
and View on Buildings Structure from Interior of the Building (right) [160, 64]

Unlike all other structural systems, Exo–Skeleton is located on the outside of the
building, which means that the actual lateral load resisting structure is located outside
of the building and its elevation plane. An example of this structure is Hotel de las
Artes, in Barcelona, Spain. Due to such exposed structure, buildings volume and
elevations are catchy and act as identifiers. Main structural material for this structure
is steel. However, fire proofing for this exterior structure is not highly demanded as
87

�for the other structures, because it is solely responsible for resisting lateral actions,
and its failure should not initiate progressive collapse of the entire building. However,
due to ever–lasting exposure of the structure to weather conditions, corresponding
thermal bridge should be carefully designed. This structure hasn’t got any obstacles
in interior space and it is efficient for up to 100 storeys high buildings.

Figure 68 - Hotel de las Artes, Exo – Structure at Main Structural System (left) and View on
Detail of Elevation, Structure Connection to the Buildings Volume (right) [128]

Super frame structures are ideal for the concepts of skyscrapers or ultra–high
buildings. Super frames are efficient for up to 160 storeys, but there are buildings
structured with super frames, with lower numbers of storeys, and example of such
structure is Parque Central Tower (Caracas, Venezuela), which has 56 storeys, while
an even higher buildings structured with the use of super frames, is designed but still
not built – the Chicago World Trade Centre, with 170 storeys.

Figure 69 - Parque Central Tower, Caracas, Venezuela, Concrete Super Frame Structure,
under Construction (left), on fire (mid), Renovated (right) [91, 134, 132]

88

�Super frame building reacts as tubular structure in order to resist lateral actions. Such
structure consists of vertical structural truss in a shape of mega columns, arranged at
each corner, where this position of the mega columns imposes that highest efficiency
for resisting wind actions is at the corners.
Unlike vertical, horizontal like trusses are linking mega columns, after every 12 to 14
storeys respectively. The major disadvantage for architectural design and form of the
high–rise with this structure, is that the structure is actually leading the form of the
high–rise. Super frames could be both steel and concrete, where more efficient
material is steel, with efficiency up to 160 storeys, unlike concrete where efficiency
stops at 100 storeys.

Figure 70 - Chicago Ultra – High Building, Proposal for Steel Super Framed Structure,
Elevation (left) and Characteristic Floor Plans (right) [71]

89

��HYBRID STRUCTURES
After the period of modernism, architectural aesthetics imposed more irregular
shapes, conceptually designed as unity of more different geometrical volumes, with
more curved lines, inclined elevations, bridges, buildings etc., which made none of
the previously known individual structures able to support such volumes. As a
solution for this concept, an idea of hybrid/mix structural systems in form of
combination of advantages of different structural systems and materials, and in order
to maximise structural efficiency of the building. Such structures, were mostly mix
of a composite structures and materials, however it is important to distinguish these
two structures, because of their difference in load resisting capabilities.
While the composite materials, present two or more materials combined in order to
form a new material, more efficient one, in hybrid structures, structural materials may
perform their properties individually, or together in order to get the highest
performance and efficiency of materials. As long as hybrid structures engaged
variations of different structural systems, principle of the load bearing and resisting
was hard to explain with the unique principle. However evolution in the production
of the concrete, in form of innovative HSC (High-Strength Concrete), certainly
reduced deformation of the columns, increased axial load capacity of the material, and
in same time decreased self –weight when compared to conventional concrete.

Figure 71 - Belvedere Building, Rotterdam - Horizontal Forces Scheme (left), Inclined Strut
(mid), Constructed Building (right) [41]
91

�Sloping tower “Belvedere” in Rotterdam, designed by an architect Renzo Piano is one
of the most representative example of hybrid structures. Inclined design of the eastern
elevation represented great challenge for structural design. Even though, columns
were positioned in optimum arrangement, horizontal forces were too high to be
resistant by any of the ordinary structural systems, like core, tubes, or shear walls.
Strut, which was actually part of the overall building’s concept, became part of the
structural system in case of an emergency and in order to resist horizontal forces. [41]

92

�STEEL AS STRUCUTURAL MATERIAL
FOR HIGH–RISE BUILDINGS
Steel, as structural material has dominated worldwide for a long period of time,
enabling various achievements in both architecture and construction. Due to its
mechanical properties and construction abilities, steel encouraged development of
high–rise buildings, bridges, towers and other structures, which required lighter
material, but with at least the same or higher bearing capacity than masonry structures
allowed. Steel, an iron alloy, is basically manufactured in steel factories in high–
advanced conditions; that way it is more predictable in its behaviour than materials
such as concrete or other manmade materials. Strength, uniformity, light weight, ease
of erection and prefabrication, in demand for rapid construction made the steel a
material of the future.
It could be said that the history of steel can be traced back up to 4000 years in the past.
Due to its strength being greater than that of a bronze, iron started to replace the use
of bronze for weapons and various tools. However in the 6th century B.C., Chinese
were the first to use blast furnace in order to work with cast iron. What Chinese started
doing in the 6th century B.C., Europe developed in the Middle Ages; their attempts
and experiments almost clarified most of the iron properties, with one of the main
explanation being that carbon is affecting iron’s workability.
Cast iron in that period was in great measure strong material, despite high level of
carbon varying from 2.5 to 4.5%, which lead to the problem of brittleness. Although
this was an obvious problem, solution wasn’t developed until few centuries later.
Solution was an innovation of puddling furnaces offered in the 18th century by Henry
Cort. Despite efforts of different metallurgist, puddling furnace and cast iron were the
greatest achievement in the development of technology. Higher interest for the
development of steel was evoked by 19th century. In 1856, Henry Bessemer introduced
process of inducing oxygen into iron in order to reduce the amount of carbon. Process
was named after Bessemer but it did not succeed as it was planned due to the portion
of induced oxygen, which was not easily defined, creating iron with too much reduced
carbon, containing overdosed remains of induced oxygen. Shortly after, in 1860s, new
process of steel production and carbon reduction was disclosed with success, known
as Open Heart Process.

93

�Figure 72 - Bessemer Steelmaking Process (illustration of furnace) [142]

After these innovations, vast iron or earliest steel were a turnover for spread of steel
structures. With the development of steel, idea of high–rise structures and high–rise
constructions was born. Along with that, Chicago became place of the world’s first
high–rise building. Home Insurance Building, 1884/85, the first worlds’ high–rise
constructed with cast iron and pioneering steel.

Figure 73 - Contemporary Steel Making Process, Combination of Blast Furnace Top Gas
Recycling and Blast Oxygen Furnaces, Highly Reduces Steelmaking Emissions (illustration)
[151]
94

�After the first high–rises, it is hard to separate whether the development of material
was rapid due to the necessity for high–rise constructions, or high–rises were designed
and constructed in order to achieve and push the steels’ abilities and limitations.
However, it was sure that the world was undergoing a revolution of steel industry,
parallel with the race for high constructions. Different requirements developed new
steel manufacturing processes, Electric Arc Furnaces and latest oxygen steelmaking.
The latest widely used steel manufacturing process is oxygen steelmaking, with the
basic oxygen furnaces being developed back in 1960, and is still remains one of the
66% of world production of steel.
Although steel has been used in various ways, and has many representative
achievements in construction, its low fire resistance and high maintenance costs, are
reasons why steel is taken with reserve, and reasons why there are more composite
structures rather than single steel structures.
Steel’s properties as structural material are mostly taken as its advantages. As a
material that can answer most of the architectural requirements on its own, with wide
range of shapes and excellent properties, steel was declared as a material of future
architectural concepts and future high–rises, long span constructions. However, steel
weaknesses were not treated well in earlier buildings, so events of collapses, damages
or maintenance issues with buildings made steel less desirable as major structural
material.
However, steel as a structural material has significant advantages and are as follows:
 High–strength material, with equal resistance both in tension and
compression stresses;
 High–strength/ weight ratio declare steel suitable for high–rise structures,
long span bridges due to slenderness of structural elements compared to
concrete structures;
 Prefabrication – factory made material with the best conditions and high
quality control of the production and processing of steel elements;
 Time – schedule of the structure erection;
 Predictable material in its behaviour;
 Ductile material, steel can undergo large plastic deformation before failure;
and
 Fatigue strength.

95

�Steel disadvantages are also important for consideration:
 Unlike concrete rigid connection, in steel structures weakest point may
occur in joints/ connections;
 Cost of steel structures – in general steel structures are much more expensive
than other structural materials;
 Fireproofing costs – steel has low fire resistance which is mostly one of the
weakest point in steel structures, especially if there is word about high–rise
buildings with no sufficient time to evacuate the building; however, there
are different fire proof coats which highly increase total cost of structure,
but elongate time for fire resistance;
 Maintenance costs – maintenance may request same or even higher costs in
time. Besides fireproofing coatings, steel structures require additional
coatings to prevent corrosion; due to different environmental conditions,
constant humidity may cause corrosion which reduces cross sections and
durability;
 Buckling as much as the slenderness of steel element is one of its greatest
advantages and desirable in architectural expressions, steel columns are
subjected to the buckling of steel columns due to columns slenderness,
which explains why steel columns are mostly avoided and replaced at
closest composite concrete steel columns.
Steel sections used in construction are classified according to the way they are formed,
or manufactured. However steel is also classified according to its chemical
compositions, that is, according to the percentage of carbon present, type of the alloys
or stainless.

Figure 74 – UK Hot – Rolled Steel Open Sections [191]
96

�What lead to some of the newly developed ways of classification of steel is
development of steels with highly increased strengths, so classification of steel based
on its physical strength is now also a common thing.
Numerous types of steel section are produced by hot rolling, with different shape,
weight or size. For instance, open sections in UK are defined as universal beam (UB),
universal column (UC), and parallel flange channel (PFC) or angle section.
Tubular hollow sections have circular or rectangular shape (CHS and RHS), and
proved to be a better solution for buckling resistance of structural elements. There are
two types of steel hollow sections and they are distinguished by the method of
production: cold formed hollow sections and hot formed hollow profiles.

Figure 75 – Tubular Steel Sections [191]

There are also so called European Steel Sections with appropriate tables for all the
steel sections, with their dimensions, properties, classification, resistance and
buckling resistance values according to Eurocode 3, EN1993-1-1:2005. The tables are
extended to welded section with dimensions. The designers can select section type
e.g. IPE, HE etc.

Figure 76 – European Steel Sections [123]

On the other hand, cold formed sections are mostly used as secondary elements in
structures or in light steel frames. Typical cold formed section are C and Z sections,
produced by cold rolling from galvanized strip steel, with 1.2 to 3.2 mm in thickness.

97

�Figure 77 – Standard Z and C Cold Rolled Steel Sections [117]

Another important classification of steel is also in accordance of steel’s chemical
compositions, which influences its properties and dedicates its purpose.
Table 1 - Steel Classification according to Carbon Percentage Presence

CARBON STEEL
TYPE

Low – carbon steel
(Mild steel)

CARBON
PERCENTAGE

APPLICATION
 various shapes from flat sheets
to structural beams

0.04 % - 0.30 %

 other chemical elements are
added or increased to achieve
desired properties.
 manganese 0.06% - 1.65 %

Medium – carbon steel

0.31 % - 0.60 %

 stronger than low carbon steel
 more difficult to form, cut and
weld

High – carbon steel
(Carbon tool steel)

0.61 - 1.50 %

 once threated with heat
becomes very hard and brittle

Alloy steels are reserved for pipelines, car parts, electric motors, power generators etc.
They contain elements such as silicon, copper, chromium, titanium, nickel, aluminium
in order to improve steel’s properties. Although not used as structural steel, stainless
steels is an important category itself, which contains 10-20 % of chromium, and is
98

�valued for high corrosion resistance. However, its costly production is not economical
for construction of building’s structures.
For structural steel, the most important strength property is its yield stress (fy).
However it in great measure depends on steels’ chemical constitutes, among which
carbon and manganese increase yield stress. For yield stress, the heat treatment and
amount of rolling process in production and shaping is important for instance, thinner
plates, which were more processed, have higher yield stress than thicker ones.
The minimum yield stress is identified individually for different steel classifications,
depending on chemical compositions and heat treatments, where yield stress is
defined in accordance to the results of a standard tension tests. Howsoever, yield stress
allowable for design is listed in different tables, with specific characteristics of
specific steel.

Figure 78 – Stress – Strain Diagram for a Steel in Tension [85]

Steel’s yield stress determined for uniaxial tension is usually also accepted for
uniaxial compression. This means that tensile strength of the steel is also referring to
compression strength.
Another steel property is very important for the behaviour of structures and elements,
particularly for resisting the shock loadings, such as seismic or impact load. This is
ductility. Steel ductility is responsible for avoiding brittle fracture, meaning that steel
can undergo great plastic deformation before failure.

99

�Figure 79 – Schematic Expression of Steel’s Ductile Failure Phases [183]

Steel’s minimal ductility is expressed by:


Elongation after fracture at the measurement length of 5.65√A0 (where A0 is
the initial surface of cross section). According to Eurocode 3, the elongation
after fracture should not be less than 15 %; [35]



fu /f y ratio of a specified minimum strength, fu , and a specified minimum
yield strength fy . According to Eurocode 3, the minimum value should be fu
/f y ≥ 1.10. [35]

According to this, steel with greater yield stress is limited to the smaller elongation.
There is a possibility for all materials to develop some defects during a production,
curing and erecting time, or during its service life. Such defects may take any forms,
but in case of steel, the smallest crack is sufficient to result in brittle fracture of
structure, due to its acceleration in spreading through the specific element. Brittle
fracture stands for undesirable sudden failure, without expresses the plastic
deformation of material. Risk of steel’s brittle fracture increases with thickness of the
element, tensile strength, or cooler temperature.
Steel toughness is its ability to resist brittle fracture after loaded, and is defined as
quantity of energy pre unit volume. This is determined by means of the Charpy test,
where energy–temperature curve is derived. Due to this, steel toughness is influenced
by temperature, loading speed, cold–forming and thickness of material.

100

�Figure 80 – The Influence of Temperature on Loss of Toughness [154]

Steel celebrated the phenomena of high–rise construction, where structural properties
of steel enabled larger and higher buildings than those structured with timber or stone.
So without any overstatement it is safe to say, that steel structures are foundation of
high–rise structures.

Figure 81 – Home Insurance Building, Chicago, World’s First High – Rise Building Steel
Structured [192]
101

�The Home Insurance building, in Chicago was entitled the first high–rise building in
1885. Cast iron and steel were the only materials used in structure which framed this
10–storeys high–rise. The building gained a lot of attention and succeeded as new
architectural concept, which initiated a race of high–rise construction. All steel high–
rises and buildings, were also characterized with large open surface of the facades,
which indicated the role of steel in large spans and slender elements, columns and
beams, which was innovation for the earliest high–rises. To express the earliest
success of steel in high–rise buildings, according to the researches of CTBUH, in
1930, 96% of the world’s highest high–rises were steel structured. Sears Towers,
World Trade Centre I and II, Empire State Building, Chrysler Building, John Hancock
Centre are the examples of World’s highest high–rise buildings, although it is
interesting that all these building were constructed before 1990.
Evidence of a great decrease in high–rise buildings constructed of steel is repeated
CTBUH researches in 2000, where among world’s 10 tallest high–rises only 4 of them
are steel structured, along with devastating data of researches from 2011, where
among 10 tallest buildings there is only 1 steel structured buildings, Willis Towers
(Sears Tower, 1974). So, it is hard to see these results and not to raise a question of
why steel structures lost their role in structuring of the high–rise buildings.

Figure 82 – World Trade Centre I and II, Results of the Attack High Fire – Demolished or
“Burnt” Steel Structure of High–Rises, September 11, 2001 [194]

102

�The answer certainly lies in steel’s weaknesses, among which its low fire resistance
is crucial for the decrease in demand for steel structures. In the late nineties and at the
beginning of the new millennium, few high–rises were attacked and/or caught by fire.
Unfortunately, steel’s low fire resistance did not provide enough time for evacuation
of the many people that were inside the building, so the results and losses were huge,
and the human lives were irreplaceable.
One of the most known and valued steel high–rises is John Hancock Centre in
Chicago. The 100–storey building was designed by Bruce Graham and F.R. Khan.
Trussed–tube steel system, with tough integration of architectural aesthetics, entitled
J. Hancock Centre as one of the most recognizable and unique high–rises. J.H. Centre,
became an icon of Chicago. Its sloping form, narrowing as it rises and its continuous
mega cross bracings of trussed–tube system, enhanced harmony between architecture
and structure created, an outstanding piece.

Figure 83 – John Hancock Building - Elevation (left) and in Urban Context (right)
[109, 88]

Mega X–braces on facades are designed as truss element with 45o angle, which
support large percentage of wind load, while sloping structure and volume of the high–
rise also reduce wind effect at higher storeys.
103

��CONCRETE AS STRUCUTURAL MATERIAL
FOR HIGH–RISE BUILDINGS
Concrete, the name of the artificial stone, is one of the most spread structural material
worldwide. Even though it is the most valued for construction of buildings (structural
systems, slabs, walls and foundations), it is not fair to neglect its merits in the
construction of bridge decks, piers, grandstands, chimneys, pipes and also urban
furniture. The most common definition of concrete states that concrete is a mixture of
sand, gravel, crushed rock or other aggregate held together in a rocklike mass with a
paste and water. Besides these basic materials mentioned in the definition above,
technological and chemical development of concrete industry created various
admixtures that worked to improve concrete’s properties and its main strengths
compared to other structural materials, such as durability under hostile environments,
high resistance to water etc.
The first appearance of concrete is often thought to be many centuries ago, which in
one hand may be true. Dating back to the Roman period, their approach in design and
material mixing technology may take a role of contemporary concrete’s forerunner.
Romans used domestic material, pozzolana–sandy volcanic ash, found near volcanic
areas in Italy. Pozzolana was mixed with water and quick lime, sand and gravel, and
when it hardened, it was used as a building material. Most of the Roman’s impressive
buildings were built with this material. Even though from this point of view such
mixture may be equal to very weak contemporary concrete, Roman buildings still
remain intact, with one of the most outstanding being Pantheon with its impressive
great dome, located in Rome.

Figure 84 – Pantheon, Rome, Interior (left) and Exterior (right) [193, 81]

105

�After, to say, Roman’s pioneering in this building material, concrete technology was
stagnant until the late eighteenth century. In 1796, natural cement rock named after
the Roman cement was discovered in England. Similar cement rock was found
throughout Europe and America and was used for several decades. Patent for Portland
cement was received by Joseph Aspdin in 1824, in England. Cement was produced
through long and various experiments of pulverizing clay and limestone into a fine
powder. Even though Portland cement was accepted in Europe and America at a
slower rate, it could be seen as a turning point for further development of concrete.
Francois Le Burn, Joseph Lambot and Joseph Monier were the first to present concrete
to mass public. Le Burn built concrete house (1832), school (1834) and church (1835).
Lambot introduced concrete boat, reinforced with wires and bars back in the middle
of the 19th century. However, back in 1867, Monier invented widely known reinforced
concrete. Along with these three names, great credits should be given to Francois
Coignet for publishing a book on the application of concrete, with conclusion that too
much water greatly reduces concrete’s strength together with designing ribbed iron
bars as reinforcement and patenting. In early 20th century, rediscovered and improved
concrete was used to build the first high–rise building. Back in 1903, Ingalls building
was the first high–rise with 16 storeys in Cincinnati that was built out of concrete.
Besides high – rise buildings, various engineering infrastructure and facilities were
constructed with concrete due to its high water resistance and the most magnificent
example is Hoover Dam, with height of 221 meters, finished in 1936.

Figure 85 – Ingalls Building, First Concrete High- Rise (left) and Hoover Dam right)
[105, 111]

Thus, concrete similar to the contemporary one, dates back to the 19th century. Since
then, concrete became structural material that underwent constant technological
106

�development and improvement in its greatest advantages and its physical properties,
and concrete became applicable everywhere, becoming the “universal material”,
suitable for low–rise and high–rise buildings, megastructures, architectural aesthetics,
tubes, grandstands (stadiums) etc.
As any other material concrete has it strong and weak points, advantages and
disadvantages; high compressive strength of a widely known concrete is its one of the
greatest advantages, while its tensile strength is just approximately 10% of its
compressive strength. Due to its weakness in tension, concrete is combined with steel
reinforcing, where steel upgrades concrete’s weakness. Concrete advantages are:
 High compressive strength;
 High fire resistance and water resistance – during the fire, it suffers only
surface damages, and in constant touch with water concrete proves to be as
almost immutable material;
 Compared to other materials, concrete requires lowest maintenance;
 Concrete structures are very rigid;
 Concrete has long service life, without decreasing in bearing capacity;
 Concrete can be produced almost everywhere out of domestic materials
(sand, gravel, water);
 In demand for footing, pillars, basement walls, concrete becomes the only
economical solution;
 Cast in situ concrete, does not require highly skilled labour;
 Prefabricated concrete may be derived in any desired shape and volume,
creating shells, arches, domes etc.
Concrete disadvantages are as follows:


Very low tensile strength;



Necessity for formwork, whose costs can go from 1/3 to 2/3 of total cost of
the structure, however forms are in most cases reusable, where if handled
correctly may be economically profitable;



Properties of concrete may vary, due to different proportions od used
material;



Placing and curing cannot be controlled as for other materials, such as steel;
107

�

Weak in large spans, where structural elements requires large cross sections,
so it can create situation that self-weight of concrete elements become one of
dominate loads on the structure.

Portland cement is one of the concrete’s main components, where cement paste
influences concrete’s workability. Raw materials that are crushed and blended at high
temperatures in a rotary kiln are: lime, silica, alumina and iron oxide. When cooled,
clinker is mixed with gypsum in order to get fine powder cement. There are many
types of cement, whose use depends on the environmental conditions.


Type 1 – Common type, all purposes cement;



Type 2 – Rapid hardening Portland cement



Type 3 – Low heat Portland cement



Type 4 – Sulphate – resisting Portland cement.

Cement mixed with water creates cement paste, which has function to bind, or in other
words to glue other components of the concrete to form a unique mass. Cement paste,
or in other words, the water/cement ratio is the important property of concrete, where
w/c ratio role influences compressive strength, permeability of concrete and other
characteristics. Meaning, the lower w/c ratio is, concrete appears to be more durable
and much stronger.

Figure 86 – Concrete Compressive Strength in Relation to W/C Ratio [165]

In concrete volumes, aggregates occupy about three thirds. Aggregates are much
cheaper than cement, and due to economical profitability, there is a need for as much
of aggregates as possible. In concrete production, coarse aggregates, gravel - 4 mm
108

�and larger in sizes crushed rocks, and fine aggregates, sand less than 4 mm in diameter
are used.
Rock types classify as natural aggregates, such as limestone, quartz, dolomite, granite
etc. whereas they should be clean, hard and durable. In the case of fine aggregates
used in concrete production, it is important to avoid sea sand due to the high
percentage of salts which may react with reinforcement and create corrosion.
Well graded aggregates, lead to a better compressive strength and low permeability.
Besides the grade of aggregates, aggregate shapes and surfaces, fine/coarse aggregate
ratios, and aggregate/cement ratio are crucial. For higher concrete workability,
spherical shaped aggregates with smooth surfaces showed as a better choice, while
angular shaped aggregates with rough surfaces resulted with lower control, but with
better mechanical properties and bonds in the concrete mixtures.
However, if the cohesiveness needed to be increased, it appeared that the most
effective, way was to increase fine/coarse aggregates ratio. On the other hand
increased aggregate/cement ratio provided higher stiffness, compressive strength and
at same time improved concrete’s stability due to the reduction of shrinkage and creep.

Figure 87 – Importance of the Aggregate Grading – Single Sized Aggregates (left), Poorly
Graded Aggregates (middle) and Well Graded Aggregates (right) [175]

Indispensable part of the contemporary concrete technology are various admixtures.
Being added to concrete during or before mixing, admixtures improve concrete’s
performance, both in fresh or hardened state. For example, concrete workability may
be affected by air entraining agents, or fly ash, while the strength may be improved
by silica fume. Most common admixtures are:

109

� Accelerating admixtures, accelerate concrete’s early strength development,
reduce time of curing with earlier removal of formworks. An example:
calcium chloride;
 Air – entraining admixtures, used to increase concrete’s resistance to
freezing and thawing and decrease its damage;
 Retarders, retarding admixtures, prolong the plasticity of concrete, slow the
setting of concrete and retard temperature increases. An example: various
acids, or sugar and sugar derivatives;
 Superplasticizers are used to keep water – cement ratio constant, while using
less of cement. They are mostly derived from organic sulfonates;
 Waterproofing materials, exclusion among other admixtures due to their
appliance to hardened concrete, but might also be in fresh concrete, to assist
retard the penetration of water into concrete. An example: various soap or
petroleum products.
Plain concrete is material with high compressive and very low tensile strength;
therefore plain concrete does not have major role in building construction.
Reinforcement in concrete overtakes tensile forces and presents a revolution in the
success of Reinforced Concrete (RC). Most common reinforcement material is steel,
whose characteristic yield strength (fy), ultimate tensile strength (fu), ductility,
bendability and weld ability are design requirements in RC structures.

Figure 88 – Reinforcing Steel – Textured Rebar and Meshes [121]

110

�Steel reinforcement for concrete is available in two forms: steel rebar and steel
meshes, all with fyk = 500 MPa (N/mm2) in Europe, which are manufactured in three
grades due to different ductility. Manufactured steel rebar are textured in order to
achieve better bond between rebar and concrete.
As composite material with various mix designs, wide range of application and high
technology development, concrete is classified according to different criteria.
Concrete is classified according to the construction technology applied, on cast in situ
concrete and prefabricated concrete and at the chosen way of reinforcing the concrete,
conventionally reinforced concrete (steel bars, meshes) and pre–stressed concrete
elements.

Figure 89 – Difference in Behaviour of Reinforced Concrete and Prestressed Concrete under
Applied Load [11]

Generally, concrete can be classified based on its properties in compressive strength,
unit weight or according to concretes admixtures and additives.
One of concrete’s greatest advantage lies in its compressive strength. Concrete’s
primary property, characteristic compressive strength (fck) is affected by various
factors: water/cement ratio, cement type, type of aggregate, age of concrete and
curing time and type of admixture, if used.

111

�Table 2 - Concrete Classification according to Compression Strength of Concrete

CONCRETE TYPE

COMPRESSIVE
STRENGTH
fck (MPa)

Low – strength concrete

&lt; 20

Moderate – strength
concrete

20 &lt; MSC &lt; 50

High – strength concrete

Ultra – high strength
concrete

50 &lt; HSC &lt; 150

APPLICATION
 mass concrete
structures
 subgrade of roads
 partitions
 buildings
 bridges





150 &lt; UHS

high – rise buildings
bridge towers
shear walls
not widely used, only
few foot bridges and
some structural
segments, girders

Table 3 - Concrete Classification according to Unit Weight of Concrete

CONCRETE TYPE

UNIT WEIGHT
(kg/m3)

Ultra – light – weight
concrete

&lt; 1200

 non–structural members

Light – weight concrete

1200 &lt; LWC &lt; 1800

 non–structural members
 structural members

Normal - weight concrete

~ 2400

 infrastructure
 buildings

&gt; 3200






Heavy - weight concrete

112

APPLICATION

special structures
laboratories
hospitals
nuclear plants

�Table 4 - Concrete Classification according to Admixtures Used in Concrete

CONCRETE TYPE

ADMIXTURES

Fibre reinforced concrete

include steel, glass,
polymers and carbon
fibers

MDF – Macro defect free

incorporate large
amount of water
soluble polymer

DSP

large amount of
silica fume

Polymer concrete

polymer

APPLICATION
 improve tensile property,
to enhance toughness
shrinkage control and
decoration
 improve tensile and
flexural properties of
concrete
 provide an excellent
abrasion resistance to
produce machine tools
and industrial moulds
 polymer–binder
 polymer–impregnated
into Portland cement
concrete members
 polymer–admixture in
Portland cement concrete

In almost entire Europe and some other parts of the world, concrete is designed based
on rules of Eurocode 2. The characteristic compressive strength refers to uniaxial
compressive strength measured by compression tests, done on test samples being
concrete cylinder 15 x 30 cm or cube 15 x 15 x 15 cm, 28 days of age. Test samples
are conditioned in a room temperature with high specified humidity level.

Figure 90 – Concrete Cylinder and Cube Test Samples [75]
113

�Conditioning of the tests samples significantly affects the concrete compressive
strength as presented in Figure 91.

Figure 91 – Concrete Compression Strength Development in Relation to Conditioning of
Test Specimens [164]

Modulus of elasticity is an important property of concrete used for stiffness and
deflection determination; however concrete does not have unique and clear linear
modulus of elasticity. It varies due to the age of concrete, different compressive
strength, stress level, type of loadings, characteristics and properties of cement and
aggregates, whereas it’s important to point out aggregate type in high–strength
concrete where type of coarse aggregates is crucial. Concrete is characterized as non–
linear stress–strain curve, where modulus of elasticity is defined by being tangent or
secant to stress–strain curve in range of elastic strain.

Figure 92 – Tangent and Secant Modulus of Elasticity of Concrete [126]
114

�Concrete will continually keep deforming during time and under continual
compressive load. The additional deformation that comes after the initial one is called
creep or plastic flow. In other words creep refers to plastic time dependent
deformation that occurs under continual stress.

Figure 93 – Creep of Concrete [89]

Creep is related to hydration process in cement paste; therefore, concrete with the
highest percentage of cement paste ratio (water/cement ratio) will have the highest
creep. This leads to the conclusion that high–strength concrete with lower w/c ratio
will undergo decreased or very low creep compared to normal strength concrete.
Once concrete is cured and starts to dry, excess of chemically unbounded water starts
to evaporate; the result of this leads to the shrinking and cracking of concrete. Such
cracks reduce shear strength and tensile strength and that cracking may leave
reinforcement unprotected which can start to corrode due to different environmental
factors. Even though shrinkage occurs during a long period of time, 90% of it happens
during the first year.

Figure 94 – Concrete Shrinkage Development in Ordinary Concrete [38]
115

�During construction of structures of high–rise buildings almost any structure may be
derived and erected out of reinforced concrete; with strong, durable and highly
resistant, rigid concrete structures, if well designed, it may overcome all the struggles
in high–rise construction. Use of concrete in construction of high–rise buildings has
been rapidly increasing in the last few decades, where the main factor includes
chemical industry admixtures in concrete mix design, better curing abilities, and better
technology for concrete pumping to higher storeys in high–rise buildings.
Back in 1903, the first idea for concrete high–rise building, was not widely accepted.
For most experts, critics and public, such idea evoked doubtfulness. However, 16–
storey concrete high–rise was constructed in Cincinnati. Ingalls building was designed
as very rigid structure, enveloped by the 20 cm thick walls, structured with rigid
concrete frame of 76 x 86 cm columns up to the 10th storey, and 30 cm x 30 cm for
the rest of the storeys, connected with concrete beams. In Ingalls building, slabs and
stairs were also made of concrete. Such massive elements were not welcomed by
architects and designers. Unfortunately, during that period concrete technology was
only familiar with types of concrete of lower strength, and large cross sections of the
elements were a necessity. When concrete was discovered as a material with high
potentials in various fields, the reinforced concrete technology quickly started to
develop concrete with high–strengths, improved by various admixtures which also
upgraded properties of concrete.
In high–rise buildings, safety and time of evacuation is one of the most important
factors, which follow immediately after its load bearing design. High fire resistance
of concrete was also one of the encouraging factors for the further use of concrete in
high–rises.
In favour of reinforced concrete application of the structures of high–rises are
Petronas Twin Towers. Back in 1998, the world’s highest buildings were Petronas
Twin Towers in Kuala Lumpur, two identical towers with heights of 452 m and
diameter of 46.3 m. Mega structure of these towers consists of 16 perimeter columns
varying in diameter from 2.40 m from the ground to 1.20 m on the top of the towers.
With the decrease in columns cross section, reinforced concrete core is respectively
decreases from the bottom from 22.9 x 22.9 meters to 18.9 x 22 meters, while beams
are about 79 cm in depth. Petronas Twin Towers were developed with high–strength
concrete of 80 MPa in compressive strength of the columns of lower floors, however
middle floors had the compressive strength of 60 MPa and upper floors of 40 MPa.
As latest achievement in reinforced concrete structure of high–rise building is
definitely Burj Khalifa, Dubai. Burj Khalifa, was designed in shape of Y; such form
of the building maximises the exterior view, but also derives a newly supported core
named buttressed core.
116

�Figure 95 – Petronas Tower- Characteristic Floor Plan Showing Concept and Structure [66]

The material used for structure materialisation was high–strength concrete, varying
from 60 MPa to 80 MPa. Although use of steel in this 829.9 meters high building was
not fully excluded, major structure is erected out of high–strength concrete.
The Ingalls Building, Petronas Twin Towers and Burj Khalifa are chosen as
representative examples of reinforced structures, with different aesthetics, volumes
achievements in vertical direction due to the period of their designs. However, all of
these structures are in a way key points for the development and achievements of
reinforced concrete, despite the fact that the only common point for these buildings is
their RC structure. To summarize, an imposing fact is that with contemporary
technology, concrete excluded the adjectives massive, clustered and large structural
elements for RC structures in high–rise buildings and became more desired material
in construction.

117

�Figure 96 – Burj Khalifa (left), Petronas Twin Tower (mid) and Ingalls Building (left) [82]

118

�HIGH STRENGTH CONCRETE (HSC) AS STRUCUTURAL
MATERIAL FOR HIGH–RISE BUILDINGS
It is hard to define high–strength concrete (HSC) with one unique number, or create
any strict border between conventional normal strength concrete and high–strength
concrete. As long as achieved concrete or target strength is about the same quality as
the local material, curing conditions, size and age of testing specimens, it imposes the
fact that nor unique nor unified definition of high–strength concrete is neither possible
nor necessary. Another factor in defining ranging lines of high–strength concrete is
also a demand for specific strengths or performances of concrete. In the specific case
of the USA or some rapidly growing Asian country or city, 95 MPa high–strength
concrete is available in most of concrete plants, and at same time it is economically
and cost efficient.
On the other hand, situation in Balkan area is totally opposite. Abilities to use highstrength concrete in this area is not even adequately researched, and the top limit of
concretes’ strength may appears to be up to 60 MPa, which corresponds to weak
economical and cost efficiency. However, in different standards there are some
differences in classifications of concrete up to the characteristic compression
strengths. According to EN 206:2013, normal–weight and heavy–weight concretes
are divided into sixteen classes according to their compressive strengths; high–
strength concrete is in range between C55/67 and C100/115.
Terms high–strength concrete and high–performance concrete were commonly used
as synonyms, which was acceptable at the early beginnings. However, in the
contemporary concrete technology, this interchangeable use of the two terms is not
acceptable.
High–strength concrete commonly refers to the increase in compressive strength of
concrete, while high–performance concrete refers to the increase of all concrete’s
properties, with accent on mechanical properties, durability, workability, permeability
etc. which is more than just increase of strength.
Commonly, the periphrastic high–strength concrete is introduced as new material or
as a result of new technological development. Although such periphrasis may be taken
as correct, term high strength concrete and practice of creating high–strength concrete
occurred many decades ago. Dating back to 1950s, concrete with compressive
strength of 34–35 MPa, was considered to be high–strength concrete. However, when
compared to contemporary daily routine in concrete solutions, designed compressive
strength of 34–35 MPa, at 28th day of age is one of the most common examples of
conventional or so called normal strength concrete.

119

�Figure 97- The Last Completed Super High–Rise, Burj Khalifa, 2010 (left) and the
First Completed High- Strength Concrete High–Rise, Outer Drive East 1963 [83]

More specific and more scientific approach to the subject of high strength concrete
occurred in the 1960s. Newly developed high–strength concrete with compressive
strength of 41 to 52 MPa, rapidly spread through the construction sites across the
USA. For high–strength concrete technology, sixties of the last century were crucial
turning point because all experimental studies of technological development were
aiming for the achievements of the desired results.
In the early sixties, Japan was a place where the first superplasticizers were developed.
Formaldehyde condensates of beta naphthalene sulfonates, were developed by Dr
Hattori. These superplasticizers had primary function to reduce water demand in
production of high–strength concrete. Product created was named Mighty 150, which
could decrease water usage up to 30 percent. Along with superplasticizers, use of
120

�another supplementary material for high–strength concreting developed in this period
was silica fume or so called microsilica; micro–filler in between cement particles, a
by-product of Ferro–alloy industry was first introduced by German Doctor
Aignesberger.
Although invention of superplasticizers and silica fume took place in Japan and
Germany, most of the credits in HSC development for wide use went to Chicago,
United States. During the early sixties, Chicago was a place which accelerated
development of high–strength concrete and increased that day available concrete’s
compressive strength of 35 MPa to 41 MPa for 40–storeys high–rise buildings. An
engineering step forward pioneered the use of high–strength concrete in Chicago on
the Outer Drive East high–rise building
The USA, also constructed numerous bridges, river dams, marina piers and terminals;
however their main focus was on structuring of high–rise buildings, multi–storey
garages, shopping malls etc. For instance, it was almost mandatory for high–rise
buildings in Chicago to be structured with high–strength concrete. In 1972, from
previous 41 MPa, concrete’s strength already increased to 52 MPa for structuring of
52–storey Mid–Continental Plaza. It is important to mention that production and
application of high–strength concrete used to structure Mid-Continental Plaza, was
more of an economical choice rather than a solutions. Achievable strength of concrete
and all performances of concrete were increasing year after year with correspondence
to cost efficiency, and due to the development of chemical admixtures and other
supplementary materials; the result was of 74–storeys Water Tower Palace, in 1976.
Water Tower Palace, was the world’s highest high–rise structure in that period,
designed as concrete structure reaching compressive strength of 62 MPa.
After all, American Concrete Institute can take all credits for the rapid development
of high–strength concrete and actual exposing of high–strength concrete to a wider
market for application in most of the high rise buildings worldwide.
Nowadays, high–strength concrete is in wide use all around the developed world, and
it is more than common to find concrete plants which can catch up with the production
of concrete with compressive strength of 95 MPa, on daily basis.
High–strength concrete was developed as better and as structural material of higher
quality when compared to normal strength concrete. Therefore it has many benefits,
both in performance and cost efficiency, so HSC advantages are as follows:
 Reduction in structural element size;

121

� Reduction in amount of longitudinal reinforcement and compression
members, focusing on slenderer columns;
 Higher strength and better performance leads to larger spans and decrease
of total number of beams, columns etc.;
 Decreased time necessary for concrete’s formwork due to early strength
development;
 Decrease in concrete cover due to lower permeability;
 Long performance under the most critical action combinations;
 Lower creep and shrinkage with higher resistance for freezing and thawing;
 Increased resistance to very aggressive environments;
 Decreased axial shortening, buckling of supporting elements;
 Increased rentable space, due to slenderer and thinner elements, but also
decreased number of supporting elements due to larger spans;
 Decreased permanent action of self–weight of structure;
 Decreased maintenance and repair costs;
 Greater stiffness due to higher modulus of elasticity with high compressive
and flexural strengths.
Although high–strength concrete has many advantages as a material, it also has
disadvantages which may occur due to some impurities or even as a consequence of
some advantages mentioned above. High strength concrete disadvantages are:


Bond strength between cement paste and aggregate does not increases with
the same acceleration as compressive strength;



High–vibration are required for better compaction, and to exclude possible
segregations;



Minimal concrete cover for reinforcement protection may prevent the use of
maximum benefits in reduction of element sizes;



Available prestressing may be inadequate for the maximum use of high–
strength concrete’s strength;

122

� High–strength concrete requires very detailed, precise and careful material
selection and does not accept any impurities;
 Due to low W/C ratio, high–strength concrete requires special curing and
installation or placement;
 There is a possibility of decrease in stiffness, whereas modulus of elasticity
does not respectively increase with concrete’s strength, therefore use of
high–strength concrete may provide slenderer elements but with lower
stiffness which may lead to stability problems, whereas solution lays in very
precise choice of structural systems.
Like a conventional normal–strength concrete, HSC also contains constituents, or in
other words raw materials. Materials which participate in high–strength concrete
proportioning are: supplementary cementitious materials, fly ash, silica fume and
some other mineral admixtures, aggregates of the best quality, and of high
compressive strengths which include dolomites, granites, quartz etc., as well as
superplasticizers or some other types of chemical admixtures.
It is important for high–strength concrete to have raw materials of the highest quality
without any compromises for marginal or lower qualities. If raw high quality materials
are well proportioned and combined, it is possible to produce high–strength concrete
with long lasting compressive strength and other mechanical properties.
Generally, all types of Portland cement proved to be suitable in production of concrete
of compressive strength up to 60 MPa at the 28th day of age. However, to achieve
higher strength with respective increase in performance and workability it is necessary
to design and study reactions between additional chemical and mineral admixture.
Along with Portland cement, use of Blended hydraulic cement in production of high–
strength concrete is common. Blended hydraulic cement is mixture of Portland cement
and other supplementary cementitious materials, also named mineral admixtures.
Benefits of Blended hydraulic cements lay in lower rate of heat development, higher
strength, lower permeability, increased durability and overall performances.
Credits for accelerating the development of high strength concrete technology go to
the mineral admixtures, usually denoted as supplementary cementitious materials
(SCM). These are the materials which developed and increased concretes’
performance and strength of both fresh and hardened concrete. Generally, mineral
admixtures are siliceous and alumina siliceous materials which with the addition of
water chemically react with calcium hydroxide in order to perform cementitious
properties.

123

�The most common types used in preparation of high–strength concrete are fly ash,
cement slag and silica fume, while less in use are ultra-fly–ash, volcanic ashes, metkaolin, diatomaceous earths and calcined natural pozzolans. Benefits of blended
hydraulic cement in lower permeability, higher strength, and lower heat of hydration
are also benefits of mineral admixture (SCM).

Figure 98 - Common Mineral Admixtures – Supplementary Cementitious Materials
for High-Strength Concrete [103]

Fly ash is the most common type of SCM and by–product of combustion of pulverized
coal; it is spherically shaped and glassy residue. Fly ash is commonly added to all
concretes for higher performances. When combine fly ash and slag cement with
Portland cement, it may create concretes with compressive strengths of 70 MPa.
Silica fume or micro silica is a by–product of silicon metals and ferrosilicon alloys,
generated during reduction of quartz in the production of silicon metals and
ferrosilicon alloys. This ultra–fine non–crystalline by–product, enabled widespread of
high–strength concrete and the ability to produce ultra–high–strength concrete at all.
Generally, silica is described as grey to black dust. Silica fume is available in forms
of raw powder, water based slurry, densified or palletized. Silica fume in form of
densified powder is the most common practice of adding silica directly to concrete
mix. Silica fume grains are approximately 100 times smaller than Portland cement
grains with sizes of 0.1 to 0.3 μm. Although silica fume or micro silica has numerous
advantages, its fineness may require higher percentage of water which may cause a
decrease in workability and other desired properties if high–range water reduction
admixtures are not added.

124

�The principle of micro–filling with silica fume benefited in strengthening the bond
between coarse aggregate and concrete paste, with the ability of achieving
compressive strength of over 105 MPa. Silica fume also tends to be efficient in
reduced demand of other cementitious materials, for instance 1 kg of silica fume may
replace 2 to 5 kg of cement, while the remaining content of water.
Production of high–strength concrete would be impossible without superplasticizers
such as high–range water reducers, retarders etc. As SCM (supplementary
cementitious materials/ mineral admixtures), chemical admixtures improve both fresh
and hardened concrete. Without chemical admixtures, even the ability for transport,
placement and curing of conventional normal–strength concrete would be
questionable, and therefore lack of chemical admixture in high–strength concrete
would make high–strength concrete impossible.
High–range water admixtures as more common superplasticizers (HRWR) decrease
W/C ratio, but it is important to determine correct dose and type of the admixture.
Thus, HRWR increase strength, with decrease W/C ratio, while maintaining slump
constant, but also increase slump while maintaining W/C ratio.
When compared to conventional normal–strength concrete, W/C ratio in high–
strength concretes is lower varying from 0.22 to 0.40. However, it is important to
analyse whether the certain decrease in W/C ratio is necessary and whether it leads to
the requested increase of concrete’s strength and performance.
The highest percentage of concrete’s volume goes to aggregate volume. Selection of
the appropriate aggregate is very important; in high–strength concrete, the best quality
and the strongest aggregates are required. What effects aggregate is its density, grain
size composition, shape and texture of the aggregate surfaces. In high–strength
concrete rough textured and angular aggregates increase mechanical cement paste–
aggregate bond and therefore such aggregates are more workable in high–strength
concrete. Trap rock, granite, dolomite and quartzite are mineralogy types of
aggregates, suitable for high-strength concrete.
Although high–strength concrete has lower fire resistance than normal strength
concrete, it still has higher fire resistance than any other structural materials’ and
becomes economically efficient solution able to improve its fire resistance.
According to the most of the nowadays standards, high–strength concrete and ultra–
high-strength concrete are leading concretes with compressive strengths of above 50
MPa and 150 MPa respectively. Many countries are somehow limited to maximum
concrete strengths up to 50–60 MPa due to lack of demand for higher performance
and higher strength concretes or because of the lower rate of development. However,
125

�areas under rapid and constant construction and development in vertical directions,
routinely produce concretes with compressive strengths of over 80 and 100 MPa. The
USA, Canada, Singapore, China, Malaysia, UAE are countries and areas with the
highest usage of high–strength concrete. Such fact is not surprising because these are
the areas with the largest construction sites dedicated to high–rise construction and
way of living. In circumstances, where daily human habits are lifted way above the
ground, safety comes first. High–strength concrete showed its power in ensuring
necessary safety in high–rise buildings, providing safety and comfortable living
environment, with its high rate of resistance to any possible structure’s daily
displacements due to wind actions, seismic actions, or high–rate of resistance in cases
of emergencies such as fire or progressive collapse, where the structure itself enables
sufficient time for safety evacuation.
Possibilities in structuring of high–rise buildings out of high–strength concrete are
best described on examples of Burj Khalifa, Petronas Twin Towers, Taipei 101
(composite structure–steel and high–strength concrete), etc. Magnificent architecture
and breath-taking heights were enabled without any concessions by virtue of high–
strength concrete. High–strength concrete in these examples showed limitless abilities
in concrete technology, and at same time provided sufficient safety to occupants and
inhabitants. Besides mentioned, there are numerous examples of high–rise buildings
which represent great examples of concrete technology development.
Eureka Tower in Melbourne, Australia, a 91–storey tall high rise building is structured
as outrigger system, and entirely erected with high–strength concrete. It is designed
with central core, perimeter columns, shear walls and continuous outrigger with
thickness of 30 cm. This choice of high–strength concrete as structural material,
decreased cross sections of structural elements and increased rentable area of floor
plans.
Core walls for the first 15-storeys are 75 cm thick, made of high–strength concrete
with compressive strength of 80 MPa, while perimeter columns were erected with
concrete of compressive strength of 100 MPa. As the height of the building increased,
characteristic compressive strength of used concrete decreased. Thus, structural
elements near the top of the building were made with concrete of 40 MPa for shear
walls, and 60 MPa for perimeter buildings.

126

�Figure 99 - Eureka Tower Characteristic Floor Plans
26-52 Storeys(left – top), 53-65 Storeys(left – mid), 66-88 Storeys(left – bottom),
Black Hatch Stands for High–Strength Structural Elements and in 2006 (right) [78]

Another example is Baiyoke-2 Tower in Bangkok, Thailand, a 90–storeys high–rise
building which was designed with the desire to break the world record as the tallest
hotel and the tallest high–strength concrete building. This 90–storeys structure was
constructed with high–strength concrete, and represented turning point in concrete
technology seen up to that day in Thailand. Concrete columns, and concrete central
core, as well as concrete slabs, were built out of high–strength concrete with
compressive strength of 60 MPa up to 65–storey. Final 25 storeys were constructed
out of concrete with compressive strength of 50 MPa.

127

�Figure 100 - Baiyoke Tower 2 [118, 60]

Although Europe is a few steps behind the USA, Canada, China and others in vertical
expansion, Holland, Finland, Germany, Denmark and Norway are European countries
which have practice in production and use of high–strength concrete for specific
purposes in construction of high–rise buildings.
Germany pioneered the use of high–strength concrete through the Trianon, high–rise
building in the Westend of the Frankfurt am Main, in 1992. This high–rise building
with final height of 186 meters has 47 storeys above and 4 storeys below the ground
level. High strength concrete B 85, was used for four main columns 54 cm wide and
partially for shear walls. The rest of the structure was erected with concrete B 45. The
use of the high–strength concrete proved to be very economically efficient due to
reduced dimensions of structural elements and reduced demand for the further use of
reinforced steel. Concrete mixture for Trianon building contained fly ash,
superplasticizer and retarders. These concrete cube specimens taken for the
compression tests showed that average compressive strength of B85 after 56 days was
112 MPa.

128

�Figure 101 - Characteristic Floor Plan of Trianon Building (left–top), Schematic Scenario of
Possible Collapse (left–bottom) and Trianon Building, 1992, completed (right) [199, 200]

Altieri Spinelli Building, formerly called D3 building with its 24 storeys represents
remarkable achievement in concrete technology in Europe; Altieri Spinelli Building
is part of the complex of the parliament buildings in Brussels. High–strength concrete
was used as a material for prefabricated columns in storeys that were reserved as
garaging space. Target strength for these columns was 80 MPa, which was achieved
by the addition of superplasticizers, reduced W/C ratio and the use of fly ash. Such
concrete mixture and ability for prefabrication, resulted in accelerated construction
and higher economic efficiency, smaller structural elements in this specific case of
columns, left more free space than it would have if any other material was used.

129

�Figure 102 - Altieri Spinelli Building, Brussels, Belgium [157]

To summarize, successful examples of high–rise buildings mentioned and described
earlier are obvious evidences that the use of high–strength concrete is nowadays
reality in construction worldwide. Whether focus on high–rise buildings up to 15– 24
storeys, or the super tall high–rise buildings that are few hundred of storeys high,
high–strength concrete of different qualities is the unavoidable choice in search for
structural material. If technology development and economic efficiency opened up a
gate to high–strength concrete towards wider market, high–rise buildings for sure
enhanced benefits and abilities of high–strength concrete as commonly available
structural material. Use of such environmental friendly, structurally safe and very
resistant material enabled previously mentioned idea and concepts of vertical cities
and vertical living.

130

�Figure 103 - Summary of the Representative HSC High–Rises [136]

131

��COMPOSITE STEEL–CONCRETE STRUCTURES
FOR HIGH–RISE BUILDINGS
Composite structure is term which refers to the use of different materials within one
structural element, where these two materials act as one material. Even though
composite structures may refer to composition of any two or more structural materials,
due to common use in composite structures it generally refer to the steel–reinforced
concrete structures. Composite elements might be beams, columns and slabs, where
it is important to enable composite acting of two materials with sufficient shear
connection between materials’ bonding surfaces. Philosophy of composite materials
seeks for enhancement of single materials’ strength and cutting down of its
weaknesses and disadvantage, by combining it into new material.
Back in the late 19th century, earliest form of composite structure referred to the
composite material commonly known as reinforced concrete. However, it did not take
long until the advantages of combining steel sections with reinforced concrete defined
new way in construction of buildings, bridges, urban garages structures etc. Early 20th
century introduced steel and reinforced concrete in composite structures as flexural
members, although lack of shear connection between the two materials resulted in
lateral slipping of one material from another.
In 1911, O. Kommerell was the first to use transversal steel bars for his bridge design
to connect steel beams and concrete in order to prevent lateral slipping; although he
solved the problem of the lack of shear connection between the two materials, the
function of shear connectors were still not explained. However, few decades later, L.
Combournac was the first to explain the function and design principles with shear
connectors.

Figure 104 - Rolled Beam Enchased with Concrete, Section through Railway Bridge
(Kommerell) [28]
133

�In composite structures, earliest forms were composite beams or span girders for the
bridges, with low application for high–rise buildings. In composite beams, steel
section and reinforced concrete shear were connected and worked together to resist
bending moments. Next ability in composite structures was in the shape of composite
columns, where steel’s slenderness and concrete’s fire and buckling resistance
resulted in more economical and structurally efficient element.

Figure 105 - Composite Steel Beam Patented by Julius Khan, 1926, USA [28]

Such columns were used for high–rise buildings. In the eighties, composite structures
were enriched, combining steel sections and cast in situ concrete deck. Main
advantage of composite deck was reduction of formwork, and more efficient and
faster construction. Nowadays, composite structures are commonly used, especially
for bridges and high–rise buildings, with same working philosophy, just following the
innovative technology of steel and reinforced concrete as hybrid material, while
taking all its advantages.
Design philosophy of composite structures is to use advantages of both steel and
concrete, while enhancing them in order to provide higher resistance, strength and
durability of the structure. Besides utilization of both individual material advantages,
composite structures reduce or exclude material’s disadvantages and weaknesses.
Advantages of composite structures:
 Ability for larger spans, creating more usable space;
 Reinforced concrete appears in compression and steel appears in tension
zone, taking the best of both materials;
134

� Shorter construction – schedule due to fabricated steel elements;
 Coating steel with concrete adds protection layer toward environmental
conditions, which prevents corrosion and increases fire resistance;
 Greater stiffness is achieved, with the decrease in bending and deflection of
structural beams and columns (buckling);
 Better resistance to seismic forces;
 Lighter structure when compared to the RC structures due to smaller cross
section of structural elements;
 Reduced cost for the formwork; and
 Shallower beams, which can reduce building’s height.
Disadvantages of composite structures are:
 If not well done, low strength of shear connectors or any deformation of
shear connectors may enable sliding between concrete deck and steel girder;
 Additional subcontractor needed for shear connector installation; and
 Time consuming due to installation of shear connectors.
First composite elements were composite beams, designed as steel beams with shear
connectors at the top flange, encased with reinforced concrete slab, or lately
composite slabs. Crucial for composite beams are shear connectors, which exclude
the possibility for the two materials to behave independently with lateral slipping.
When shear connectors unify steel beam and RC or composite slab, the structure acts
as composite structure. For the analysis of the structure’s behaviour, composite beam
is taken as the behaviour of the cross section of T shaped beams. Concept of composite
beams lays in the use of concrete in compression zone in order to achieve better
stiffness of the structure, and in order to prevent deflection and buckling, while steel
takes place in tensile zone to behave elastically and prevent brittle failure.
Composites are more economical for the same span and combination of actions, where
composite beams weight and depth are reduced when compared to steel structures.

135

�Figure 106 - Composite Beam with Shear Connection between Steel Beam and Concrete
Slab, with Diagrams of Stress Distribution in Cross Section [68]

Composite columns overcome the problem of intensive buckling of steel columns, as
the RC column’s large cross section. Composite steel–concrete column is erected by
two principles; the first steel sections are fully or partially enchased with concrete,
while other principle lies in filling steel’s hollow sections with concrete.

Figure 107 - Composite Columns Types, a) Steel Section Fully Enchased with Reinforced
Concrete, b) Steel Section Partially Enchased with Reinforced Concrete, c) Steel Section
Partially Enchased with Concrete [70]

An important difference lies in the lack of need for the additional reinforcement of
filled hollow steel section, unless there is a necessity for higher fire resistance of the
reinforced concrete. The greatest advantage of the composite columns lies in greater
fire resistance compared to the steel’s fire resistance, as well as in better corrosion
protection of enchased composite columns. Another advantages is in the reduced use
136

�of formwork, because filled hollow steel sections’ formwork is excluded, it increases
stiffness of the columns, reduces slenderness and increases buckling resistance.

Figure 108 - Composite Column Types, d) Rectangular Hollow Steel Section Filled with
Concrete, e) Circular Hollow Steel Section Filled with Concrete, f) Circular Hollow Steel
Section Filled with Concrete with Embedded I Steel Section [70]

Composite columns are mostly used for construction of high–rise buildings, where
the reinforced concrete structures require large cross section elements, using much of
the rentable space and where steel column require high maintenance cost and high
cost of fire and corrosion protection, which isn’t economical, while composite
columns proved to be a more economical solution.
Composite slabs consists of steel decking shear connected with concrete slabs.
Technology of composite slabs developed new, stiff, light weight and economical
slabs. Metal decking in composite slabs exclude necessity of formwork and also acts
as a tension member. Steel decking is available in various shapes, with various surface
textures and may vary in decking thickness.

Figure 109 - Components of Composite Slab, Casting and Installation Principle [190]

137

�The most commonly used is decking with deformed ribs, which results in stronger
bond between metal decking and concrete, however, composite slabs, as other
composite elements, require shear connectors. Number of shear connectors per
surface area and its installation, along with the type of shear connection is designed
according to the principles of Eurocode 4 (EC4) – Design of composite steel and
concrete structures.
In composite structures, a natural bond between concrete and steel exists, however,
required bond is not available without any other strengthening method. Shear
connector, in shape of steel bars or sections is installed at steel decking or section to
achieve desired strength. This leads to the role of the shear connector, which is to
resist horizontal slipping between the steel and reinforced concrete, and in the same
time, to prevent vertical separation of concrete between steel sections. Dimensions,
shapes, types or numbers required to resist horizontal movement are designed
according to the design rules of EC4. Composite structures have three types of shear
connectors: rigid type, flexible type and bond or anchorage type connectors.

Figure 110 - Shapes and Common Dimensions of Shear Connectors, Angle, Circular,
Hexagonal or Circular Headed and Channel Section [174]

Rigid type of shear connectors can be found in various shapes, short bars, angles or
tees welded on steel girder or steel decking. Failure of such connectors occur in terms
of cracking of concrete.
Flexible type of shear connectors appears in the shape of studs, channels welded to
structural beam or decking. As long as these connectors resist bending of the
connectors, failure occurs when yield stress in the connector is exceeded.
138

�Bond or anchorage type of shear connectors consists of inclined bars with one end
welled to the steel’s top flange, while other is bent and enhanced with concrete.
High–rises structures, besides concrete and steel as main structural material, are also
constructed as composite structures. Composite structures in case of high–rises strictly
refers to steel and concrete, where advantages of both materials are utilized to create
one new, high resistant and stiff material. Use of composite structures in high–rise
buildings varies from entirely composite structure to specific use of composite
columns, beams or slabs. Even though philosophy of composite structures and its
advantages in favour of high–rises, composites were not a choice for high–rise
buildings until 1970. After the seventies, composite structures took an important role
in construction of high–rises and multi–storey buildings, however, the focus was on
composite columns, whose principle was to overcome disadvantages and weaknesses
of steel and concrete columns. According to the CTBUH, Franklin Centre–North
Tower (1989, Chicago) and Bank of China Tower (1985, Hong Kong) were placed
among world’s ten tallest high–rises up until 1990. However, the first composite
structured high–rise that was entitled the world’s tallest high–rise is building Taipei
101, 2004, with its height of 508 meters. In addition the success of composite
structures in terms of high–rise buildings is shown in the latest CTBUH’s researches,
where among top ten world’s tallest structure in 2011, six of them were composite
structures, Taipei 101, Shanghai World Financial Centre, International Commerce
Centre (ICC), Zifeng Tower, Kingkey 100 and Guangzhou International Finance
Centre.

Figure 111 - Composite Structured High–Rises on the List of the World’s Tallest
High–Rises in 2011 by CTBUH [188]
139

�According to the design philosophies, the most critical elements for high–rise
buildings have to correspond to wind and seismic actions, where seismic actions are
increased with buildings’ weight and height. When compared to RC structures, steel
structures acted better in terms of dimension of the cross-section of the structural
elements, weighing less and having slenderer elements, making them more resistant;
on the other hand concrete had better stiffness and higher resistance to any deflection
and buckling of columns.
As solution to such problem are composite structures as they remain the best option
for structuring of high–rises. Composite structures have better bending and buckling
resistance than steel structures, but also weigh less when compared to RC structures.
World’s tallest building of 2004, and at the same time the first building that is over
half the kilometre tall and has 101 storeys, is Taipei 101, designed by C. Y. Lee and
Partners.

Figure 112 - Taipei 101 - Schematic View of Characteristic Plans and Elevation [14]
140

�This composite structure is conceptual interpretation of bamboo, where volume is
divided following vertical axis. The first part is pyramidal shaped volume with height
of 25 storeys, and the last part of vertical division is rectangular shaped 12 storeys,
while the rest of the inner storeys are divided in inverted pyramidal shape and have 8
storeys.
Located in windy area, structure of this tall building had to be designed to resist
constant wind action, whose velocity achieves 156 km/h. Overall building design had
to correspond to large wind actions, and the use of composite structure together with
volume concept made it able to resist strong winds without suffering any serious
deflection or damages.
Building is enclosed with 8 perimeter composite columns and 16 core columns, all
composed of rectangular steel hollow section, filled with high strength concrete of 70
MPa, where the ground columns are 2.4 x 3 meter in cross section.

Figure 113 - Taipei 101–Composite Structure Compared to the Petronas Towers–Reinforced
Concrete Structure in Terms of Perimeter Columns [189, 14, 98]

If compare concrete structure of Petronas Towers, where the height of 452 meters is
achieved, and which has high strength concrete columns with diameter of 2.4 meters
(80 MPa), but also located in less windy environment to composite structure of Taipei
141

�101, it is evident that composite structures are more efficient. Being taller, located in
much windier environment, meant greater lateral actions on structure happened, and
the use of high–strength concrete of lower strength, 70 MPa, than it was used for pure
concrete structure enhanced the success of composite structure in the case of Taipei
101, when compared to RC structure of Petronas Towers.

142

�RISK OF PROGRESSIVE COLLAPSE
IN HIGH–RISE STRUCTURES
Architectural design focuses on aesthetics and functionality of designed spaces in
accordance with anthropological measurements in order to satisfy users and
inhabitants. Following this philosophy buildings’, structures fit right into architectural
design and concepts as well. It is possible to apply this philosophy due to its greatest
aim in providing comfortable and rentable spaces. Structures following the
architectural plans, concepts and ideas represent a common design principle in any
type of buildings, low-rise buildings allow fast and secure evacuation in cases of
emergencies accepting this as proper practice.
However, in the specific case of high–rise buildings, structures don’t compromises on
architectural design, but rather combine its advantages to preform unique aesthetic
values of the high–rise volume concepts. Main responsibility of the structure is to be
capable to resist failure or collapse of building under various and the critical
combination of actions, meaning that the structure should have efficient performance
as long as the building’s service life.
In high–rise structures, vertical elements columns and walls are designed to resist and
transfer all actions to the foundation ground. Design process of high–rise buildings is
important in order to provide efficient structure and in resisting various actions with
efficiently designed composition of structural elements which would provide rentable
and functional space. Structural design should be economical in selection of structural
material and required time of the erection.
Worldwide accepted design method for building’s structural design is limit states
design method, where limit states refer to the structure’s behaviour at different limit
states, providing necessary safety against all limitations. Such design is based on
probability that a structure will not collapse or become unusable due to various
deflection, cracking, etc.; in other words that structure will not reach any limit states
under the critical combination of any action. In the mid–20th century, previously
working stress method was replaced by the limit states design method. With more
precise and more economical designs, and increased safety of the building, limit states
design method became worldwide accepted method in structural design. Working
stress methods (WSM) follows Hook’s law, considering that stress–strain diagram is
linear. In WSM, stresses in structural elements are received through working loads
when compared to permissible stress. For WSM, ultimate load carrying capacity is
not accurate, as it is for ULS, so generally working stress method is uneconomical due
to structural elements being overdesigned than it is actually required. On the other
hand, limit states design considered stress–strain diagram as non–linear and more
143

�acceptable principle, with stresses received from designed loads in comparison to
designed strength.
Partial safety factors appear to be crucial for limit states design, which varies up to
action type and action predictability and refers to material type. With partial safety
factors, possible errors in constructional inaccuracies, design assumptions and stress
redistribution are covered in structural design.
There are two limit states:
 Ultimate limit state (ULS) – state for the structure in which it must not
collapse under maximum design loads up to which it is designed. This
means that it must satisfy ultimate state criteria for flexure, compression
including stability, tension, shear or combined stresses; and
 Serviceability limit state (SLS) – which focuses on governing building
service life, most importantly refers to deflections, durability, crackings and
fatigue.
Limit States Design is defined in Europe in Eurocodes. Basis of design explains the
definition classification and principles of limit states designs. This means that limit
states designs, according to Eurocodes are in correspondence to structural material
type and design of the structure, or in other words, they are in correspondence to a
building type.
In Eurocodes, term load is practically replaced with the term action, which refers to a
load but with wider meaning, where actions are being classified as:
 Direct actions, forces or loads applied to the structure; and
 Indirect actions, deformation imposed on structure, by temperature change
shrinkage, settlement of foundation etc.
In structural design, there are three types of design situation; persistent situation which
corresponds to a normal design use, transient situation which happens during the
construction phase, and accidental situation which occurs in case of earthquake or fire
which is also greatly influenced by structural system and material type. According to
Eurocodes, along with these three designed situation there are also three main types
of actions:
 Permanent action (K), self–weight of a structure, or so called dead loads;
 Variable action (Q), wind snow or any imposed load, including live load;
 Accidental action (A), impact from vehicle, explosion, fire etc.
144

�Besides Eurocodes’ classification of actions, actions may be classified according to
direction of acting on gravity actions, lateral actions and special action cases. Gravity
actions include permanent actions, variable actions and snow loads, while lateral
actions are crucial for high–rises and include seismic and wind actions, which
respectively increase with the buildings’ height requiring more precise analysis in
estimating them, and special action cases which include impacts, blasts, fire etc.

Figure 114 - Types of Structural Loads on High-Rise Structure [185]

Generally, no structure is designed to respond to one single action, but up to the
critical possible combinations of estimated actions. What differs high–rise buildings
form low–rises is necessity for high quality wind control and tests due to the increase
of wind actions which happen along with the increase of height. Basic principles of
action combinations are reflected in taking permanent actions in any action
combination at any structure, and that each variable action is the leading action
depending on building’s service type and function. Even though limit states design in
analysis takes the critical combinations of all loads and the critical distribution
combinations, accidental actions, such as impact loads, explosion and fire, can cause
reaching of the structure’s limit state, or in other words failure of the structure will
occur. Another issue that structure is dealing with is localisation of that specific failure
and prevention of progressive collapse. Progressive collapse is collapse of the whole
structure or large part of it, initiated by failure of one or more structural elements or
part of the structure. Such failure or damage of one structural element or part of it
initiates chain reaction, comparable to domino effect and failure of other structural
damages resulting in total collapse of the structure.

145

�Figure 115 - Progressive Collapse, Schematic Presentation of the Progressive Collapses of
World Trade Centre (9/11) [61]

Few decades ago design for progressive collapse was taken into account only partially
or was entirely neglected; however, recent happenings in the USA and Asian
countries, whether discuss the attacks or gas explosion, forced accelerated and more
detailed structural design to prevent progressive collapses. The regulations of high–
rise buildings mostly require addition of redundant members and additional tie of
structural elements in order to provide more robust structures, strong, ductile and
capable of redistributing accidental loads. In such design requirements new high
strength and high performance materials greatly assist, whether it is the case of
concrete structures or composite steel and concrete structures. Both of the mentioned
materials provide more slenderness, and with slenderness lighter structures with
higher resistance to fire and explosions, which are main actuators of progressive
collapse when compared to normal strength or conventional concrete.
Gravity actions are group of possible actions which act perpendicularly to the slab
surfaces, including all actions which are induced by gravity. In high–rise buildings,
gravity actions do not differ from those acting on low–rise buildings. Exceptions occur
in addition of permanent actions from increased number of storeys, therefore
permanent actions of high rises when compared to those form low–rises increase as
many times as the number of storeys increases.
Gravity actions are permanent loads such as self-weight of structure, densities etc.,
variable actions – which include service actions, actions during execution, various of
vibrations and snow load, where the environmental characteristics define average
degree of snow loadings.
Unlike any other action types, permanent action may be precisely determined and
designed. Permanent actions remain constant and in the same position throughout
146

�buildings’ service life, including weight of the structure and weight of the various
attachments which are permanently attached. For the design of permanent action, it is
important to have a defined type of the structural material and its density, where exact
sizes and weights of the structural elements are derived through presumption and
structural analysis.
Permanent actions include structural system, frames, walls, floors, slabs, ceilings,
stairways, elevators roofs and plumbing, which can be constructed and made from
various materials. All of possible materials have specific and characteristic
approximate weights required for the design of permanent actions. In limit states
design due to high accuracy of permanent actions design and calculation, safety
factors are lower than those of other action types.
While structural materials in high–rises structures are mostly concrete, steel or
composite materials; concrete with greater density seeks for larger structural elements
such as columns, beams etc., while on the other hand very light and slender structures
can be achieved with steel.
Variable actions vary in their value and position of acting on structure. Variable
actions include actions during execution, service load such as furniture, users,
inhabitants, equipment, and many others with shearing property of being movable and
being induced by gravity to the structure.

Figure 116 - Illustrative Presentation of Permanent and Variable Actions [122]

147

�Variable actions, besides these occupancy weights, include traffic vibration of the
vehicle movements in garages, car ramps etc., in the specific case of high–rise
buildings, but also the accelerations of elevators has to be well calculated as type of
variable action
However, practice of the Eurocodes declares specific action values for various
occupancy of the buildings. For instance, National Annex to Eurocode 1, BAS EN
1991-1-1 in Bosnia and Herzegovina [49] specifies service load for residential, office,
commercial, hotel and university buildings from 2 kN/m2 for residential buildings, to
3-5 kN/m2 in office buildings, and finally to max. 7 kN/m2 in department stores and
commercial buildings.
Different global climate conditions develop different environmental impacts and
actions on structure. All of the environmental actions are considered to be variable
actions due to constant change in climate conditions. Among environmental actions,
snow and rain loads are the ones that are being induced by gravity to the structure.
Areas with long winter season, where the snow remains for few months, require
specific roof designs up to the snow load. Snow load is defined in national annexes to
Eurocode 1 – Part 3, from country to country with correspondence to data of average
snow amounts during the last few decades, nevertheless roof design and type (flat,
gable, hip etc.,) play an important role with the degree of roof slope, windy areas or
areas with no wind, snow type, single or multiple snow. Single snow refers to the
areas where snow remains for few days, and thaws before the new cycle of snow in
following days, however multiple snow refers to the areas where first snow does not
thaw before the new cycle of snow arrives, causing multiplicity of the load acting on
structure. For multiple snow type, presence of wind and direction in specific
environment is also important, which dictates whether the snow load is uniformly
distributed, or it accumulates on one side of the structure.

Figure 117 - Effect of the Wind on Snow Load Distribution on Roof Top [115]
148

�Cases of high–rises showed that practice in roofing reflects on flat roofs, or slightly
sloped roofs, which indicates another issue of snow remaining until it is being
physically removed or until the sun solves the problem, which happens due to lack of
slopes and possibility of snow sliding down.
Along with the common issues of snow remaining, on the top of the roofs, there is
high possibility of rainwater accumulation on flat roofs which can also create
problems, commonly called ponding. Ponding however, may be caused by accelerated
snow melting on flat roof types. Nevertheless, problem of ponding can be solved by
proper drainage systems, but in case it is missing, problem of ponding may be solved
by installation of water tanks at the roof of the high–rises which have a capacity to
collect rainwater at the rooftop area. Amount of value of this kind of load is also
defined according to the data of national meteorological institutes of specific
environments and areas, which shows the average rainwater fallen per square metre
in the last few decades. Collected water is later recycled and reused in water supplies
of the higher floors, due to natural fall which excludes the necessity for strong pumps
to pump the water from the ground to the top floors.

Figure 118 - Flat Roof with Ponding Issue [116]

When discuss the lateral actions, their effects are major factors for high–rise
structures. Lateral actions, such as wind and seismic actions increase with buildings’
height and become main problem which may make building unstable, unusable, with
the critical case scenario of building’s collapse or over turning. Design of the buildings
up to 10–storeys high, is affected by lateral actions with diminished effect, but also
capable to cause deformations, cracking, deflections etc. However, with buildings
over ten storeys high, lateral actions become crucial in structural and architectural
design. In such cases, structural elements increase in cross sections, and design
requires additional redesigning and arrangement of structural elements. At the early
149

�beginnings of high–rises in the late 19th century, wind actions and seismic actions
were not the main focus of design, due to large, massive and stiffened structural
elements and structures. However, with the development of high–strength structural
materials, lighter and slenderer structures, possibility of deflection and sway became
daily problems for engineers. Such situation enhanced the necessity for wind and
seismic design in order to prevent collapses, loss of money, economy destruction and
prevention of loss of numerous lives.
One of the most important issues of high–rise structures is wind action. Lighter,
slenderer and more flexible structures are prone to sway, movement, and shake due to
wind loadings. As the building’s height increases, importance of wind load design
increases respectively. Under the effects of wind high–rises might have different
motion and direction of movements, such as, motion along wind, motion across wind
and torsional motion. Due to excessive heights and great wind actions, high–rise
buildings can be tested in wind tunnels, which determine intensity and nature of wind
acting upon a building. Wind tunnel test actually represents behaviour of the
structure’s scaled model with its urban context in specific environmental loading,
wind. Usually, scale is 300–400 decreased, where the case of the Burj Khalifa required
scale was 1:500.

Figure 119 - Burj Khalifa, Model for Wind Tunnel Testing, Scale 1:500 [84]

Ever since wind became one of the most important factors in high–rise structures,
techniques, methods and approaches multiplied and different categories were
discovered, which had different focuses in order to achieve better resistance to wind
150

�actions. Approaches for wind design include architectural design approach, structural
design approach and mechanical design approach.
Architectural design approach has its foundations in aerodynamic based designs and
structure based designs. Aerodynamic architectural design is based on various factors
such as: building’s position–orientation, plan variations/modifications in height,
aerodynamic forms and aerodynamic tops. Each of these approaches may decrease
wind effect up to 50%. Effective design, if considering building positioning or
orientation at the site is prevailing wind direction. However if the shape or urban
context of the site itself allows the correct positioning, effects of wind upon structure
may decrease up to 20 per cent. Burj Khalifa, one of the masterpieces in aerodynamic
approach to high–rise design, where successfully the building with its butterfly
structure resists six types of the wind.
Plan variation, as it says, is a variations in characteristic floor plans and height, and it
may reflect in reduction of floor plan area or changes in geometrical shapes. In 1973,
F. Khan [21] proved in his studies that at the high–rise, which has 40–storeys, and
sloped facade of 8 per cent, reduced lateral drift for 50%.
Along with plan variation, aerodynamics may be developed through architectural
modification, which refers to the modified rectangular in plan of high–rises, whose
corners may appear to be notched, slotted, rounded, recessed etc., all in order to reduce
across wind motion on the high–rise building.

Figure 120 - Schemes of Possible Aerodynamic Solutions in Architectural Forms
of High–Rise Buildings Caused with Drastic Plan Variations from Floor to Floor [65]
151

�Aerodynamic form, mostly refers to various cylindrical, conical, twisted or elliptical
forms, proved to be the most efficient forms and methods in reducing wind loadings.
For instance, choosing circular plan form, rather than rectangular form at the initial
phase of the design decreases possible wind actions by 20 percent. However,
aerodynamic volumes are still perceived as the monumental in architecture and
uncommon for high–rises; the most common of the aerodynamic forms lays in
aerodynamic top approach. Such design is based on tapering the structure’s upper part,
following the practice of creation of the openings in between 80 and 90 percent of
buildings total height; such example may be seen in Shanghai World Financial Centre,
Shanghai.
Along with aerodynamic based design, structure based design is also important for
architectural design approach. In such design symmetrical, circular, elliptical and
triangular plans have high structural efficiency and higher response to wind action.

Figure 121 - Wind Behaviour on Characteristic Floor Plans of Burj Khalifa [159]

Structural design should respond to resist any wind displacement which makes
building undesirable and uncomfortable for use. Shear frame systems, core systems,
mega frames, tubular systems, mega columns and outrigger systems are structural
approaches in resisting wind.
Within mechanical design approach, engineers usually take some inherent damping
in order to estimate serviceability under lateral actions, which are induced by both
seismic and wind actions. Structural systems, structural materials, non–structural
152

�materials, soil structure connection and its interaction, all affect damping which makes
it difficult to measure. The installed damper reduces wind or seismic effects.

Figure 122 - Taipei 101’s 728 Ton Tuned Mass Damper, World’s Largest Tuned Damper,
and the Only One Visible to the Public and Opened for Visits [95,127]

Dampers are divided into four groups: passive and active systems, semi–active and
hybrids. In the case of high–rises, passive dampers are generally used and may be
installed initially or later as retrofit, in order to upgrade buildings with low design for
wind or seismic actions.

Figure 123 - Damping System Types for High–Rise Buildings - Classification [1]

There are many territories worldwide which are described as seismic zones, with
different degree of seismic actions. Seismic actions are result of the buildings’
dynamic response to the shaking ground. As rule for lateral actions is that it increases
153

�with the height of the structure and seismic action as class of lateral action has the
same impact on high–rise structures. Until the mid 20th century, most of the buildings
and infrastructural constructions were not adequately designed for seismic actions due
to lack of technology and scientific approaches.

Figure 124 - Diagram of Seismic Action Distribution, with Respective Increase of the
Buildings Height [184]

There are evidences worldwide how even a low earthquake may cause damages or
even collapse of structures. One of the latest case of progressive collapse of high–rise
building due to earthquake took place in Taiwan, in February 2016, on 17–storeys
high residential building.

Figure 125 - Progressive Collapse of Residential 17-Storey High–Rise, Caused by the
Earthquake in Taiwan, February, 2016 [173]

154

�Commonly, the main issue of collapses reflects in weak structural design and
inadequately designed structures. The seismic action depends on building’s mass,
ground acceleration, type of foundations, structure, and also load–bearing soil.
So far, high–rise structures, showed that accidental actions are the hardest to predict
and toughest to resist if they occurs. In structural design, accidental actions refer to all
possible actions which are the result of accident, impact or blast which can occur in
exceptional circumstances.
Accidental actions include blasts such as explosions, detonations and bombs etc.,
impacts which take vehicle into consideration such as aircraft impact etc., and include
fire incidents, which are the possible result of previously mentioned two load types,
but is also possible to be caused by anything else. Such actions are not commonly
treated and considered within structural design, but rather with variations of passive
protection systems.
Impact happens at the moment when a body with known velocity hits structure and
applies impact action. This kind of dynamic effect is mostly short but inflict a hit that
causes further damages, cracking etc. When discuss the crucial impacts, those include
aircraft impacts in the air and vehicle impacts on the ground.

Figure 126 - World Trade Centre – 9/11 [107, 172, 92, 86]
155

�Aircraft impacts, became one of the greatest hazards for high–rise structures in the
last decade. Because of their height, high–rise structures are easy targets. The most
known recent aircraft impact on high–rise structures is impact on World Trade Centre,
where the possibility of progressive collapse and fast fire expansion happened with
the worst case scenario. Although, if we exclude aircraft attacks that happen on
purpose, chances for any aircraft impact is reduced to the minimum.
Figure 126 shows how an aircraft impact and bomb attack at the World Trade Centre,
Manhattan, New York City, initiated fire with progressive collapse of the whole
structure, where the attack did not demolish only the targets, World Trade Centre twin
towers, but surrounding buildings as well; this case proved the necessity of designing
the structure able to resist such or similar impacts.

Figure 127 – Progressive Collapse of the World Trade Centre in 6.5 seconds [171]

Along with the aircraft impacts, urban areas have to deal with issues of vehicle
impacts as well, which cause less destructive load for structures with partial or local
damages. Lower velocity achieved by the vehicle is crucial for decreasing the
possibility of great injuries on the structure. However, other factors which can be
taken into consideration in order to reduce the risk of vehicle actions are distance of
the building from the traffic road, direction of the impact, weight of the vehicle as the
velocity at the moment of impact. If location and urban context of the structure require
design for accidental actions, impacts are generally analysed through modelling of
possible impact, evaluation of structural safety after the impact, and rate of fire
expansion after the impact if there is any possibility of fire.
Blasts include bomb and gas explosions, which refers to blast with condensed high
explosive of hot gasses with maximal pressure of 300 kilo bars and temperature of
3000˚ C. Such pressure and expansion form waves with greater velocity than the
velocity of sound.
156

�Figure 128 - Exterior Blasts– Explosion Next to the Building [182]

Bomb and gas explosions are difficult to take into design consideration and it is almost
impossible to erect the structure which is immune to their effects. Some special
laboratories and other buildings that deal with hazardous materials are constructed
with special techniques and materials which are not cost efficient for wider use in
construction of residential buildings, offices, commercial buildings, etc.
Gas explosions, as weaker type of blast load, generally happen due to weak and
improper installation of gas pipeline in building’s heating systems or mishandling of
gas appliances. At the same time the most common accidents are caused by gas
explosions, which is not surprising due to the fact that gas is most common fuel used
for building’s heating system and that there are other auxiliary necessities that run on
gas. Even though gas explosions are localised and cause small damages, they may
also initiate fire or grater damages and cracking.
Blast that initiates the worst case scenario is caused by bomb explosions which are
created on purpose to injure, devastate and demolish a target. Such actions have their
targets, but to design a building able to resist such power is questionable. Bomb
detonations create shock waves, which expands with velocity of 1 km/s. Bomb
explosions may happen next to the structure (exterior) or inside the structure (interior).
Common exterior explosion scenarios includes, broken windows and wall or column
failure on the buildings’ perimeter due to the pressure waves acting upon it, waves
than move further into the building where ceilings and floors become borders, which
are also under pressure. Floor generally falls due to large area being under excessive
pressure. However, in the case of high–rise structures, losing floor and beams means
losing the lateral stiffness and support which indicates collapse.

157

�Figure 129 - Collapse Simulation, High–Rise Building Exposed to Interior Explosion, where
the Structure does tot Resist for the Applied Blasts, and Continues with Progressive Collapse
[198]

On the other hand, interior explosions may be localised due to floor systems above
the detonation, with load bearing walls made of concrete or masonry, which results in
some local damages and possible failure of non–structural elements; however it still
depends on the amount and strength of the bomb explosion.
Fire has been a main problem for construction, since the beginnings of the first more
complex buildings and structures. Along with all the merits that fire enabled, there
were much more damages and injuries that happened accidentally or on purpose. It
is almost impossible to find a city or any urban zone, with high concentration of
buildings and infrastructure that did not undergo at least partial fire expansion through
city. Fire was and still is one of the greatest weapons one can have. Lately, fire became
mankind’s weapon with purposes to resolve disagreements; however a fire may be
caused by an earthquake or any other natural disasters.
Bosnia and Herzegovina and Sarajevo witnessed many of the pre–war monumental
buildings and the greatest achievements from many different periods in architecture
caught fire in the last war (1992-1995). However, almost all of the reinforced concrete
structures remained and resisted fires, most of the reinforced concrete buildings that
were on fire were reconstructed after the war. On the other, hand steel structures that
were affected by fire during the war, collapsed and were demolished in most cases,
with remains relocated and locations still waiting for their new purposes. World Trade
Centre and many other builidngs indicate that structural engineers should be more

158

�responsible for fire protection and structures’ resistance to fire, which unfortunately
was not the case previously.

Figure 130 - Mandarin Oriental Hotel, 2/9/2009, Beijing, 44 Storey, Composite Concrete
and Steel Framed Structure, was Entirely Affected by Fire Remained without Structural
Collapse [195, 63]

First design for fire safety were prescriptive–based designs, where the whole design
was based on fire resistance of materials used in structure, while new design is based
on the performance design, including evaluated strength and stiffness for a fire safety
design, coupled stress–thermal analysis, specialized design for fire effects and use of
fire retardants. In addition, new design for fire safety deal with advanced structural
analysis in the shape of temperature–time curves, which derive structural responses
during heating or cooling phases during fire.
The most terrifying recent fire which affected high–rise building, was Grenfell Tower,
in London. Scenes from Grenfell Tower over flooded world, with scenes of 24–storey
high–rise building disappearing in oversized flame, spreading through the entire
height of the building’s elevation.

Figure 131 - Grenfell Tower, the Most Recent Fire Incident on the High–Rise in Such Large
Scale, June 15, 2017 [102]
159

�Building was built in 1974, designed as concrete residential high–rise structure.
Initiator of fire and architectural and mechanical failures in fire protection on one side,
besides structural design, structure’s resistance to high fire and its concrete structure
prevented progressive collapse. It can be seen in characteristic floor plans that this tall
high–rise had only one staircase down the centre of the building, with two elevators
which didn’t seem helpful in the case of fire. One staircase unfortunately, showed
insufficient for fast and secure evacuation, as well as lack of fire–resistant doors on
staircase’s entrance, and lack of building’s firefighting equipment, and maintenance
of the existing resulted in loss of many lives.

Figure 132 - Grenfell Tower, Cross Section Pointing on Place of Fire Start, with
Characteristic Floor Plan Pointing out the Only Staircases Down the Centre of the Building
[74]

In conclusion, constructing building that are able to resist fire does not only mean to
have right choice of the structural material and structure, which indeed are crucial and
which is the case with Grenfell Tower, but also an integration of fire–resisting
mechanical and technical equipment, active and passive fire protection measures,
relying on fire resisting doors, sprinkler systems, early smoke detector etc., all play a
crucial role. Well planned architectural design takes in consideration all fire
compartments, with correspondence to the maximum number of inhabitants or
occupants at any given moment, because accidental actions are not planned and not
predictable.
160

�Studies on structural systems defined up to date classification of structures, with
systematic approach based on exposure of major structures which were conducted by
Mir M. Ali. [1] In general, all of the structures have their advantages and
disadvantages, but commonly opens up a possibility to choose the main structural
material, depending on many factors such as domestic material, ease of erection, time
required, accessibility and safety both during construction and during service life.
Table 5 - Classification of Structural Systems of High–Rises Interior Structures [1]

Table 6 - Classification of Structural Systems of High–Rises Exterior Structures [1]

161

��REFERENCES
[1] Ali M.M, Moon K. S, 2007, "Structural Developments in Tall
Buildings: Current Trends and Future Prospects", Invited Review Paper
of Architectural Science Review, Volume 50.3, University of Sydney, AU,
pp 205-223;
[2] Annadurai A, Ravichandran A, 2014, "Development of Mix Design for High
Strength Concrete with Admixtures", IOSR Journal of Mechanical and Civil
Engineering (IOSR-JMCE), e-ISSN: 2278-1684,p-ISSN: 2320-334X,
Volume 10, Issue 5, pp 22-27;
[3] Caldarone M. A, 2009. “High-Strength Concrete - A Practical Guide”, Taylor
&amp; Francis Group, London and New York, UK and USA, ISBN10: 0-41540432 (hbk), ISBN 13: 978-0-415-40432-7 (hbk);
[4] Chen W. F, Liew J. Y. R, 2003. “The Civil Engineering Handbook – Second
Edition”, CRC Press LLC, 2000 N.W. Corporate Blvd., Boca Raton, Florida
33431, USA, ISBN 0-8493-0958-1;
[5] Ching F. D. K, Jarzombek M, Prakash V, 2011, "A Global History of
Architecture I", 2nd Edition, Wiley, New Yersey, USA, ISBN: 978-0-47040257-3;
[6] Craighead G, 2009. “High-Rise Building Definition, Development and Use”,
Butterworth-Heinemann is an imprint of Elsevier, 30 Corporate Drive, Suite
400, Burlington, MA 01803, USA, Linacre House, Jordan Hill, Oxford OX2
8DP, UK, ISBN 978-1-85617-555-5;
[7] Dawson S, 2003. “Cast in Concrete”, Architectural Cladding Association, 60
Charles Street, Leicester, LE1 1FB, UK;
[8] Deplazes A, 2005. “Constructing Architecture: Materials, Processes,
Structures – A Handbook”, Birkhäuser – Publishers for Architecture, Basel,
Switzerland, Part of Springer Science+Business Media, ISBN-10: 3-76437189-7, ISBN-13: 978-3-7643-7189-0;
[9] Ding J, Chao S, Chen J, 2005. “Design and Research for a Tall Buildings of
Concrete Filled Square Steel Tube.”, Tall Buildings (from Engineerng to
Sustainability), Hong Kong:, World Scientific Publichinf Co. Pte. Ltd., pp
739 – 742;

163

�[10] Džidić S, “Otpornost betonskih konstrukcija na požar”, International BURCH
University Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina, ISBN 978-9958-834-47-9;
COBISS.BH-ID 22444550;
[11] Džidić S, Okugić H, Bajramović E, 2017. “Studije o betonu 2015-2016”, CIP
624.012.4, ISBN 978-9958-834-57-8; COBISS.BH-ID 24495622;
[12] Ellingwood B, R, Smilowitz R, Dusenberry D.O, Duthinh D, Lew H.S, Carino
N. J, 2007. “Best Practices for Reducing the Potential for Progressive
Collapse in Buildings, NISTIR 7396, National Institute of Standards and
Technology, Technology Administration, U.S. Department of Commerce;
[13] Gardner L, Grubb P. J, 2010, “Eurocode Load Combinations for Steel
Structures”, Steel Construction Institute, Silwood Park, Ascot. SL5 7QN,
ISBN 1850730636, 978185073063;
[14] Günel M. H, Ilgin H. E, 2014. "Tall Buildings: Structural Systems and
Aerodynamic Forms", Routledge, New York, NY, USA, ISBN 13: 978-1315-77652-1(ebk);
[15] Hrasnica M, 2005, “Seizmička analiza zgrada”, Građevinski fakultet
Univerziteta u Sarajevu, ISBN 9958-9461-8-X;
[16] Hrasnica M, 2012, “Aseizmičko građenje”, Građevinski fakultet Univerziteta
u Sarajevu, ISBN 978-9958-638-31-2;
[17] Johnson R. P, 2004. “Composite Structures of Steel and Concrete; Beams,
Slabs, Columns and Frames fo Buildings”, Blackwell Scientific Publications,
Oxford UK and Malden, MA, USA, ISBN 1-4051-0035-4;
[18] Johnson R.P, 2004. “Designer Guide to Eurocode 4 Design of Composite
Steel and Concrete Structures”, Ice Publishing, London, UK, ISBN10
072774173X , ISBN13 9780727741738;
[19] Kelly A, 1994. “Consise Encyclopedia of Composite Materials”, Pergamon
Press Oxford, UK, ISBN SBN 0-08-034718-5;
[20] Khan F. R, 1969. “Recent Structural Systems in Steel for High-Rise
Buildings“, Proceedings of the Conference on Steel in Architecture, British
Constructional Steelwork Association, London, UK;
[21] Khan F. R, 1973. “Evolution of Structural Systems for High-Rise Buildings
in Steel and Concrete”, in J. Kozak (ed.), Tall Buildings in the Middle and
East Europe: Proceedings of the 10th Regional Conference on Tall Buildings

164

�Planning, Design and Construction, Czechoslovak Scientific and Technical
Association Bratislava, Czechslovakia;
[22] Mahendran M, 1996. “The Modulus of Elasticity of Steel Is It 200 GPa?” 13th
International Specialty Conference on Cold-Formed Steel Structures,
Missouri S&amp;T, St. Louis, Missouri USA, pp. 641-648;
[23] Martin O, MacDonald C. M, 2007. “Advances in Structural Design for High
-Rise Residential Buildings in Australia”, CTBUH 2007, 7th World Congress,
New York, USA;
[24] Mei N, 2005. “A City Beyond Tall Buildings - Rediscover City Value and
People Value”, Sixth International Conference on Tall Buildings, Mini
Symposium on Sustainable Cities, Mini Symposium on Planning, Design and
Socio-Economic Aspects of Tall Residential Living Environment, Hong
Kong, China, pp 49-55;
[25] Mosley B, Bungey J, Hulse R, 2007. “Reinforced Concrete to Eurocode 2”,
Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire Palgrave MacMillan, RG 21 6XS, UK
and New York, USA ISBN-13 978-0-230-50071-6, ISBN-10 0-230-50071-4;
[26] Pank W, Girardet H, Cox G, 2002. “Tall buildings and Sustainability”,
London: Corporation of London, UK, Dewey Number 720.483094212;
[27] Pašić A, 2010. “Arhitektura Bosne i Hercegovine 1918–1992”, Arhitektonski
Fakultet Univerziteta u Sarajevu, Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina;
[28] Pelke E, Kurrer K. E, 2015. “On the Evolution of Steel - Concrete Composite
Constructions.”, 5th International Congress on Construction History,
Chicago; USA, 5ICCH Proceedings [Volume 3], The Construction History
Society of America, ISBN-13: 9781329150355, pp 107-116;
[29] Portland Cement Association, 1994, “Concrete Technology Today, HighStrength Concrete”, Volume 15/Number 1, 5420 Old Orchard Road, Skokie,
Illinois 60077-1083, USA;
[30] Rana E. N, Rana S, 2014. “Structural Forms Systems for Tall Building
Structures.”, SSRG International Journal of Civil Engineering (SSRG-IJCE)
– Volume 1, Issue 4, ISSN: 2348 –8352, pp 33–35;
[31] Rashid M. A, Mansur, M.A, 2009. “Considerations in Producing HighStrength Concrete.” Journal of Civil Engineering (IEB), 37(1) (2009), pp 5363;

165

�[32] Sivakumar N, Muthukumar S, Sivakumar V, Gowthaw D, Muthuraj V, 2014.
“Experimental Studies on High-Strength Concrete by Using Recycled Coarse
Aggregate”, International Journal of Engineering And Science Vol.4, Issue
01 (January 2014), ISSN(e): 2278-4721, ISSN (p):2319-6483, pp 27-36;
[33] Sarkisian M, 2012. “Designing Tall Buildings - Structure as Architecture”,
Routledge, New York, USA, ISBN 978-1-138-88670-4;
[34] Skazlić M, Tomičić I, 2006. “Arimiranobetonski elementi od betona visokih
čvrstoća naprezani savijanjem”, GRAĐEVINAR 58 (2006) 8, Journal of the
Croatian Association of Civil Engineers, Zagreb, Croatia, ISSN 1333-9095,
pp 631 - 640;
[35] Skejić D, Androić B, Dujmović D, 2012. “Selection of Steel Based on
Ductility.” GRAĐEVINAR 64 (2012) 10, , Journal of the Croatian
Association of Civil Engineers, Zagreb, Croatia, ISSN 1333-9095, pp 805815;
[36] Smith B. A, Coull A, 1991. “Tall Building Structures: Analysis and Design”,
John Wiley &amp; Sons, New York, USA, ISBN 0471512370 9780471512370;
[37] Soja E, Wade C, Ducan C, Clampett J, 2000. “Fire Protection for High-Rise
Buidlings”, Building Control Commission, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia,
ISBN 0-9577-638-3-2;
[38] Šahinagić-Isović, M, Markovski G, Ćećez M, 2012. “Shrinkage Strain of
Concrete - Causes and Types”, GRAĐEVINAR, 64 (2012) 9, Journal of the
Croatian Association of Civil Engineers, Zagreb, Croatia, ISSN 1333-9095,
pp 727-734;
[39] Štraus I, 1998. “The Architecture of Bosnia and Herzegovina 1945 – 1995;
Printing and Publishing House “Oko” Inc, Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina,
ISBN 9958-43-034-7;
[40] Vakufska direkcija Sarajevo, 2014. “Vakufi sa područja općina Stari Grad i
Centar Sarajevo, nekad i sad”, Islamska zajednica u Bosni i Hercegovini,
Vakufska direkcija Sarajevo, Bosna i Hercegovina;
[41] Vambersky, J. N. J. A, 2004. “High-Rise Buildings in the Netherlands:
Hybrid Structures and Precast Concrete”, CTBUH 2004 - Seoul Conference,
Seoul, Korea, pp 136 – 143;
[42] Wu D, Sofi M, Mendis P, 2010. “High-Strength Concrete for Sustainable
Construction”, Proceedings of the International Conference on Sustainable

166

�Built Environment, (ICSBE-2010), University of Moratuwa, Society for the
Promotion of Science, Kandy, Japan, pp 434 – 442;
[43] Zils J, Viise J, 2003. “An Introduction to High-Rise Design” Structure
Magazine”, National Council of Structural Engineers Associations (NCSEA),
ASCE’s Structural Engineering Institute (SEI) and the Council of American
Structural Engineers (CASE), November 2003, pp 12–16.
STANDARDS
[44] BAS EN 12390-1:2013 Testing hardened concrete - Part 1: Shape,
dimensions and other requirements for specimens and moulds, Institut za
standardizaciju Bosne i Hercegovine, Istočno Sarajevo, Bosna i Hercegovina;
[45] BAS EN 12390-2:2010 Testing hardened concrete - Part 2: Making and
curing specimens for strength tests, Institut za standardizaciju Bosne i
Hercegovine, Istočno Sarajevo, Bosna i Hercegovina;
[46] BAS EN 12390-3:2010 Testing hardened concrete - Part 3: Compressive
strength of test specimens, Institut za standardizaciju Bosne i Hercegovine,
Istočno Sarajevo, Bosna i Hercegovina;
[47] BAS EN 12390-4:2003 Testing hardened concrete - Part 4: Compressive
strength - Specification for testing machines, Institut za standardizaciju Bosne
i Hercegovine, Istočno Sarajevo, Bosna i Hercegovina;
[48] BAS EN 1991-1-1:2015 Eurocode 1 - Actions on structures: Part 1-1: General
actions - Densities, self-weight and imposed loads for buildings, Institut za
standardizaciju Bosne i Hercegovine, Istočno Sarajevo, Bosna i Hercegovina;
[49] BAS EN 1991-1-1/NA:2016 Eurocode 1 - Actions on structures: Part 1-1:
General actions - Densities, self-weight and imposed loads for buildings National annex, Institut za standardizaciju Bosne i Hercegovine, Istočno
Sarajevo, Bosna i Hercegovina;
[50] BAS EN 1991-1-2:2015 Eurocode 1: Actions on structures - Part 1-2: General
actions - Actions on structures exposed to fire, Institut za standardizaciju
Bosne i Hercegovine, Istočno Sarajevo, Bosna i Hercegovina;
[51] BAS EN 1991-1-3:2015 Eurocode 1: Actions on structures - Part 1-3: General
actions - Snow loads, Institut za standardizaciju Bosne i Hercegovine, Istočno
Sarajevo, Bosna i Hercegovina;

167

�[52] BAS EN 1991-1-4:2015 Eurocode 1: Actions on structures - Part 1-4: General
actions - Wind actions, Institut za standardizaciju Bosne i Hercegovine,
Istočno Sarajevo, Bosna i Hercegovina;
[53] BAS EN 1991-1-5:2015 Eurocode 1 - Actions on structures - Part 1-5:
General actions - Thermal actions, Institut za standardizaciju Bosne i
Hercegovine, Istočno Sarajevo, Bosna i Hercegovina;
[54] BAS EN 1991-1-5/NA:2017 Eurocode 1 - Actions on structures - Part 1-5:
General actions - Thermal actions - National annex, Institut za standardizaciju
Bosne i Hercegovine, Istočno Sarajevo, Bosna i Hercegovina;
[55] BAS EN 1992-1-1:2017 Eurocode 2: Design of concrete structures - Part 11: General rules and rules for buildings, Institut za standardizaciju Bosne i
Hercegovine, Istočno Sarajevo, Bosna i Hercegovina;
[56] BAS EN 1993-1-1:2017 Eurocode 3 - Design of steel structures - Part 1-1:
General rules and rules for buildings, Institut za standardizaciju Bosne i
Hercegovine, Istočno Sarajevo, Bosna i Hercegovina;
[57] BAS EN 1994-1-1:2006 Eurocode 4 - Design of composite steel and concrete
structures - Part 1-1: General rules and rules for buildings, Institut za
standardizaciju Bosne i Hercegovine, Istočno Sarajevo, Bosna i Hercegovina;
[58] BAS EN 1998-1:2017 Eurocode 8: Design of structures for earthquake
resistance - Part 1: General rules, seismic actions and rules for buildings,
Institut za standardizaciju Bosne i Hercegovine, Istočno Sarajevo, Bosna i
Hercegovina;
[59] BAS EN 206:2014 Concrete - Specification, performance, production and
conformity, Institut za standardizaciju Bosne i Hercegovine, Istočno
Sarajevo, Bosna i Hercegovina.
INTERNET RESOURCES
[60] http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_hDq5sbmfrSY/TIg7rmnA3yI/ AAAAAAAABI
k/wWROTiN1FmY/s400/BaiyokeTowerII-BangkokThailand.jpg
[61]

http://911review.com/myth/crumbling.html

[62]

http://ae390g6diagrid.weebly.com/parameters.html

[63]

http://aparaskevas.blogspot.ba/2009/02/fire-engulfs-under-constructionbeijing.html

168

�[64]

http://arcspace.com/feature/bank-of-china-headquarters

[65]

http://article.sapub.org/10.5923.j.arch.20140403.01.html

[66]

http://aspiretoinspiredesign.blogspot.ba/2010/10/petronas-towers.html

[67]

http://blog.endpoint.com/2016/04/how-to-build-skyscraper.html

[68]

http://eurocodes.jrc.ec.europa.eu/showpage.php?id=134

[69]

http://faculty.kirkwood.edu/ryost/stereographs/WWI%20Illustrations/
Seeing%20New%20York/Seeing%20NY,%20Times%20Square%20(1915).
gif

[70]

http://fgg-web.fgg.unilj.si/~/pmoze/ESDEP/media/wg10/f0810001.jpg

[71]

http://fgg-web.fgg.uni-lj.si/~/pmoze/ESDEP/master/wg14/l1500.htm/

[72]

http://ibac2013.org/

[73]

http://img849.imageshack.us/img849/4573/sjenjak2.jpg

[74]

http://latestnewsnetwork.com/stringent-provisions-are-in-place-canadiancities-well-prepared-for-highrise-fires-say-fire-officials/

[75]

http://learnandearnd5.blogspot.ba/2017/05/concrete-cube-and-cylinderstrength13.html

[76]

http://mapio.net/pic/p-2439410/

[77]

http://mapio.net/pic/p-84469909/

[78]

http://openbuildings.com/buildings/eureka-tower-profile-3730/media

[79]

http://openbuildings.com/buildings/john-hancock-center-profile-1408/media

[80]

http://radiobet.eu/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/zgrada-parlament-bih590x330.jpg

[81]

http://romeonsegway.com/10-facts-about-the-pantheon/

[82]

http://skyscraperpage.com/diagrams/?searchID=79165401

[83]

http://skyscraperpage.com/diagrams/?searchID=79170701

[84]

http://skyscraper.org/EXHIBITIONS/TEN_TOPS/engineering.php

169

�[85]

http://stementor.tistory.com/entry/The-12%EC%9E%AC%EB%A3%8C%EC%97%AD%ED%95%99%ED%8E%B8
-312

[86]

http://thegreaterpicture.com/9-11.html

[87]

http://thethreetomatoes.com/developing-architectural-appreciation

[88]

http://watchdogpm.com/blog/watchdog-long-weekend-guide-great-lakes

[89]

http://civil-online2010.blogspot.ba/2015/02/creep-of-concrete.html

[90]

http://whatson.ae/dubai/2013/11/35-years-of-whats-on-dubai/

[91]

http://wikimapia.org/37860/Parque-Central-East-Tower

[92]

http://world-visits.blogspot.ba/2012/03/world-trade-center-911.html

[93]

http://ww1blog.osborneink.com/?p=5612

[94]

http://www.agcs.allianz.com/assets/PDFs/risk%20bulletins/SupertallBuildings-Bulletin.pdf

[95]

http://www.amusingplanet.com/2014/08/the-728-ton-tuned-mass-damperof-taipei.html

[96]

http://www.archilovers.com/projects/406/30-st-mary-axe.html

[97]

http://www.architectural-review.com/buildings/chinese-developments-arebeginning-to-show-a-concern-for-more-sensitive-design/8691351.article

[98]

http://www.archute.com/2016/01/28/petronas-towers-worlds-tallest-twintowers-cesar-pelli)

[99]

http://www.arths-studiocubra.com/portfolio-item/republic-of-srpskagovernment-building

[100] http://www.aviewoncities.com/gallery/ showpicture.htm?key=kvesp4754
[101] http://www.balkanforum.info/f20/sarajevo-sarajewo-bosnien-herzegowinabosna-i-hercegovina-bih-88035/index57.html
[102] http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-40272168
[102]

http://www.casselden.com.au/image-gallery/

[103]

http://www.civilengineeringforum.me/supplementary-cementing-materials/

[104]

http://www.chicagoarchitecture.info/Building/1055/311-South-WackerDrive.php
170

�[105]

http://www.concretecontractor.com/concrete-construction-projects/ingallsbuilding/

[106]

http://www.ctbuh.org/TallBuildings/HeightStatistics/Criteria/tabid/
446/language/en-US/Default.aspx

[107]

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2365931/Larry-Silverstein-WorldTrade-Center-owner-trying-sue-airlines-billions-9-11-attacks.html

[108]

http://www.discoverfrance.net/France/Cathedrals/Paris/Notre-Dame.shtml

[109]

http://www.gettyimages.com/detail/illustration/iconic-buildings-of-chicagoroyalty-free-illustration/166055120

[110]

http://www.historija.ba/d/35-zemljotres-u-banja-luci/

[111]

http://www.history.com/topics/hoover-dam

[112]

http://www.hoffarch.com/assets/Chrysler-full.jpg

[113]

http://www.infocampo.com.ar/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/ShangaiPudong.jpg

[114]

http://www.kakanjcement.ba/

[115]

http://www.kdietrich.com/thesis/d9aresearch/section%202%20science/section%202-0%20science.htm

[116]

http://www.mainlandroofing.com/Sloping%20a%20flat%20roof.html

[117]

http://www.metalandtech.com/cold.html

[118]

http://www.oocities.org/topsyturvy_6051/Baiyoke2con.html?201711

[119]

http://www.panoramio.com/photo/46370626

[120]
[121]

http://www.panoramio.com/user/274162?with_photo_id=1311558
http://www.pcwirestrand.com/pcwirestrand/deformed-steel-bar.html

[122]

https://www.pitsco.com/content/?art=28&amp;ap=

[123]

http://www.runet-software.com/documents/SteelSectionsEC3ENG.pdf

[124]

http://www.sac.net/images/stories/avaz_twist_update/visual/avaz_twist_tower_ads_studio.
jpg

171

�[125]

http://www.sa-c.net/images/stories/TZ__Mellain_Center/04.mart.2013/DSC_0036.jpg

[126]

http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&amp;pid=S198341952012000500001

[127]

http://www.slate.com/blogs/atlas_obscura/2014/11/17/
the_tuned_mass_damper_of_taipei_101_in_taiwan.html8

[128]

http://www.skyscrapercenter.com/building/hotel-de-las-artes/3720

[129]

http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showthread.php?page=239&amp;t=918678

[130]

http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showthread.php?t=1822957&amp;page=6

[131]

http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showthread.php?t=267607

[132]

http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showthread.php?t=28656

[133]

http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showthread.php?t=391698&amp;page=505

[134]

http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showthread.php?t=548892&amp;page=2

[135]

http://www.skyscraper.org/TALLEST_TOWERS/t_wtc.htm

[136]

http://skyscraperpage.com/diagrams/?searchID=79174628

[137]

http://www.streetervillehomes.com/common/images/260chestnut/1.jpg

[138]

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/
serbia/9270654/ plotted-to-raze-Sarajevo-to-the-ground.html

[139]

http://www.thestructuralmadness.com/2015/10/outriggers-in-tallbuildings.html

[140]

http://jetsettingfools.com/visit-mostar-21-things-to-do//

[141]

http://www.wind-works.org/cms/index.php?id=539

[142]
[143]

https://aehistory.wordpress.com/1855/10/07/1855-bessemer-steel-process/
https://app.vts.com/properties/181-west-madison

[144]

https://bomaelevatorspeech.wordpress.com/2012/04/27/cre-news-whatwere-reading-the-week-of-april-23/

[145]

https://booksite.elsevier.com/samplechapters/9781856175555/02~
Chapter_1.pdf

[146]

https://en.wikiarquitectura.com/wp content/uploads/2017/01/Sears_Tower
172

�[147]

https://historicconstructions.blogspot.ba/2014/11/beroemde-gebouwenfamous-buildings.html

[148]

https://image.slidesharecdn.com/burjkhalifa-150516084413-lva1app6892/95/burj-khalifa-16-638.jpg?cb=1431766190

[149]

https://inhabitat.com/swaying-shanghai-tower-handles-peak-wind-loads-of114-mph

[150]

https://i.pinimg.com/originals/50/5a/85/505a850c20290066
d28cb3a7cd243cbf.jpg

[151]

https://myassignmenthelp.com/free-samples/advanced-persistent-threatimpacts

[152]

https://myspace.com/banjaluka4ever/mixes/classic-stare-fotografije-oldphotographies-banja-luka-506905

[153]

https://readingdevelopment.files.wordpress.com/2013/10/china.jpg

[154]

https://sassda.co.za/the-mechnical-properties-of-stainless-steel/

[155]

https://science.howstuffworks.com/engineering/structural/first-steel-framedskyscraper.htm

[156]

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/44/
Bosmal_City_Centar.jpg

[157]

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/70/Belgique__Bruxelles_-_Parlement_europ%C3%A9en_-_01.jpg

[158]

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/8/80/
Sarajevo_City_Center_Summer_2015_%281%29.jpg/1200pxSarajevo_City_Center_Summer_2015_%281%29.jpg

[159]

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/9/93/Burj_Khalifa.jpg

[160]
[161]

https://www.archdaily.com/153297/ad-classics-bank-of-china-tower-i-m-pei
https://www.archdaily.com/273404/o-14-reiser-umemoto

[162]

https://www.archdaily.com/411878/ad-classics-ville-radieuse-le-corbusier

[163]

https://www.askideas.com/media/37/Petronas-Towers-Malaysia-Picture.jpg

[164]

https://www.bayt.com/en/specialties/q/118811/what-is-the-curing-period-ofreinforced-concrete

173

�[165]

https://www.buildotechindia.com/development-of-self-compactingconcrete-using-fly-ash/

[166]

https://www.delcampe.net/en_US/collectibles/postcards/bosnia-andherzegovina/ak-sarajevo-capaje-bo-1950-298006755.html

[167]

https://www.e-architect.co.uk/dubai/o14-tower

[168]

https://www.e-architect.co.uk/shanghai/shanghai-tower-development

[169]

https://www.emaze.com/@AQFFRLRF/Final-copy1

[170]

https://www.fosterandpartners.com/projects/hearst-headquarters

[171]

https://www.infowars.com/building-7-implosion-the-smoking-gun-of-911/

[172]

https://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/local/911-Plane-Part-Moved-GroundZero-Mosque--205586781.html

[173]

https://www.ndtv.com/world-news/7-dead-after-powerful-taiwanearthquake-fells-buildings-1274373

[174]

https://www.researchgate.net/figure/264143713_fig1_Fig-3-Compositebeams-and-shear-connectors

[175]

https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-practical-use-of-controlling-thegrading-of-concrete-aggregate

[176]

https://www.slideshare.net/chuhonsan/l3-vertical-structure-p

[177]

https://www.slideshare.net/chuhonsan/l3-vertical-structure-pt1-1

[178]

https://www.slideshare.net/chuhonsan/l5-vertical-structure-pt-3

[179]

https://www.slideshare.net/chuhonsan/l5-vertical-structure-pt-3-3341134

[180]

https://www.slideshare.net/joymeer/high-rise-structure-cor

[181]

https://www.slideshare.net/neel1104/sears-tower

[182]

https://www.slideshare.net/SoumyabrataSaha1/blast-load-and-its-analysis

[183]

https://www.slideshare.net/varunteja7330/mi-291-chapter-4-learning-fromfailure

[184]

https://www.slideshare.net/WolfgangSchueller/lateral-stability-of-buildingstructures-58620763

[185]

https://www.slideshare.net/zabihullahnasiri/type-of-high-rise-building
174

�[186]

https://www.skyscrapercenter.com/building/empire-state-building/261

[187]

https://www.skyscrapercenter.com/city/shanghai

[188]

https://skyscraperpage.com/diagrams/?searchID=79165808

[189]

https://skyscraperpage.com/diagrams/?searchID=79165954

[190]

https://www.steelconstruction.info/Design_of_composite_steel
deck_floors_for_fire

[191]

https://www.steelconstruction.info/Steel_section_sizes

[192]

https://www.studyblue.com/notes/note/n/midtermid-s/deck/2065592

[193]

https://www.studyblue.com/notes/note/n/test-2/deck/11434458

[194]

https://www.theatlantic.com/photo/2011/09/911-the-day-of-theattacks/100143/

[195]

https://www.thebeijinger.com/blog/2014/02/09/five-years-ago-today-cctvhotel-tower-burns

[196]

http://www.thestructuralmadness.com/2015/10/outriggers-in-tallbuildings.html

[197]

https://www.theurbandeveloper.com/would-you-live-in-a-vertical-citysuperskyscrapers-of-the-future/

[198]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GbiUR57w4pA

[199]

https://books.google.ba/books?id=24CMQS09MUcC&amp;printsec=frontcover
&amp;hl=hr#v=onepage&amp;q&amp;f=false

[200]

http://www.skyscrapercenter.com/building/trianon/2102

175

����</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="79">
            <name>Extent</name>
            <description>The size or duration of the resource.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="923">
                <text>3717</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="924">
                <text>HIGH - RISE BUILDINGS  STRUCTURES AND MATERIALS</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="96">
            <name>Author</name>
            <description>Author</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="925">
                <text>DŽIDIĆ, Sanin
KOVAČEVIĆ, Ilda</text>
              </elementText>
              <elementText elementTextId="928">
                <text>Causevic, Amir
Rustempasic, Nerman
Zejnilovic, Emina</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="94">
            <name>Abstract</name>
            <description>A summary of the resource.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="926">
                <text>High-rise buildings present a challenge; they present a challenge for architects,  engineers, occupants as well as observers. They attract the viewer's eye. They are  our monuments and often become city landmarks and tourist attractions. City views  from the tops of the buildings are also extremely appealing. People either praise  them or criticize them, but they are indeed an important part of urban landscape in  every modern city. They are here, present, and can be found in every metropolis or  city that intends to become one. Sometimes they stand in awe, and sometimes they  stretch above. For all they are, or for all they are not, their builders are the culprits  responsible for these magnificent structures.  This book is the result of a serious research, and it is intended to become a textbook  for the "High-Rise Buildings" course held at the Master's Degree Program at the  Department of Architecture at the Faculty of Engineering and Natural Sciences of  the International BURCH University in Sarajevo. However, students of other  architectural faculties or departments of architecture, students of structural  engineering, as well as architects and structural engineers in design and  construction themselves may find this book helpful. Parts of the book, or the entire  book may also be of interest for a common reader.  As the human body is composed of brain, skeleton, muscles, organs, blood and  nervous system, all of which have their own functionality and appearance, the  organism we call a high-rise building is also composed of load-bearing structure,  different materials applied, and various embedded functional systems that allow for  comfort and serviceability of these structures. Their appearance catches the  observer’s eye and causes different emotions; sometimes these emotions are  positive, sometimes not so much, but essentially everything that initiates any  emotion in a person becomes a truly memorable experience</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="45">
            <name>Publisher</name>
            <description>An entity responsible for making the resource available</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="927">
                <text>International Burch University</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="929">
                <text>2018</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="97">
            <name>Keywords</name>
            <description>Keywords.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="930">
                <text>Book
PeerReviewed</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="13">
        <name>NA Architecture</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="121" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="123">
        <src>https://omeka.ibu.edu.ba/files/original/1a2e31136c575fce1eef8c541f556a9e.pdf</src>
        <authentication>483d48d892292b8f93f25af7943e1caa</authentication>
      </file>
      <file fileId="124">
        <src>https://omeka.ibu.edu.ba/files/original/cdae919ff6bb6b828a68ac51dc93a183.pdf</src>
        <authentication>8509d7ae6ab2386b6bd97b2c1639e521</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="940">
                    <text>CONCRETE STUDIES 2017

CONCRETE
STUDIES 2017

SANIN DŽIDIĆ | ILDA KOVAČEVIĆ | SABINA KOZLICA

DŽIDIĆ | KOVAČEVIĆ | KOZLICA

SARAJEVO, 2018

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="79">
            <name>Extent</name>
            <description>The size or duration of the resource.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="932">
                <text>3731</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="933">
                <text>Concrete Studies 2017</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="96">
            <name>Author</name>
            <description>Author</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="934">
                <text>DŽIDIĆ, Sanin
KOVAČEVIĆ, Ilda
Kozlica, Sabina</text>
              </elementText>
              <elementText elementTextId="937">
                <text>Causevic, Amir
Sahinagic Isovic, Merima</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="94">
            <name>Abstract</name>
            <description>A summary of the resource.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="935">
                <text>The first study is “Comparison of Fire Resistance of RC Slabs Determined according  to Different Methods“. We construct our buildings and facilities to last 50, 100 or  even 200 years. There is a high probability that fire will eventually occur during the  service life of practically every structure. Fire can happen anytime and anywhere.  This study explores fire resistance of RC slabs that are the most sensitive concrete  elements in fire situation. We compared the results of determination of fire resistance  according to four different methods. We got some conclusions, but also opened an  area for new research on fire resistance of some other concrete elements.  Concrete is principal construction material in Bosnia and Herzegovina. It is very  common. However, concrete of high compression strength is almost unknown in  Bosnia and Herzegovina. The study of “High-Strength Concrete (HSC) and  Possibilities for Production in Bosnia and Herzegovina“ discusses the recent history,  advantages and disadvantages, application and benefits of it, as well as the  constituent materials, mix design and proportioning and properties of high strength  concrete. Experimental part of this study proves that it is feasible to produce highstrength  concrete of slightly modified ordinary concrete mix improved by domestic  admixtures and additives at minimal cost. This study aims to encourage concrete  factories to produce it and engineers to apply it in their designs and actual  construction.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="45">
            <name>Publisher</name>
            <description>An entity responsible for making the resource available</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="936">
                <text>International Burch University</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="938">
                <text>2018</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="97">
            <name>Keywords</name>
            <description>Keywords.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="939">
                <text>Book
PeerReviewed</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="5">
        <name>TA Engineering (General). Civil engineering (General)</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="122" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="125">
        <src>https://omeka.ibu.edu.ba/files/original/615f8b4038e76bfd8159ff65dc0a5c45.pdf</src>
        <authentication>4111745c7351fa7364c87bdf60ba2688</authentication>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="79">
            <name>Extent</name>
            <description>The size or duration of the resource.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="941">
                <text>3733</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="942">
                <text>Concrete studies 2018</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="96">
            <name>Author</name>
            <description>Author</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="943">
                <text>DŽIDIĆ, Sanin
KOVAČEVIĆ, Ilda
Kozlica, Sabina</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="94">
            <name>Abstract</name>
            <description>A summary of the resource.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="944">
                <text>We love concrete! We love it because it is concrete. We love it because it is reliable.  We love it for it is steady and durable. We love it because it is mysterious. We would  like to discover some of its mysteries and share them with you!  That is why the “Concrete Studies“! Actually, this is a continuation of “Concrete  Studies 2015-2016“ and hopefully predecessor of some other future concrete studies.  Again, we present you with the additional three studies conducted at the International  BURCH University Sarajevo and University of Bihać in Bosnia and Herzegovina.  The first study is “Comparison of Fire Resistance of RC Slabs Determined according  to Different Methods“. We construct our buildings and facilities to last 50, 100 or  even 200 years. There is a high probability that fire will eventually occur during the  service life of practically every structure. Fire can happen anytime and anywhere.  This study explores fire resistance of RC slabs that are the most sensitive concrete  elements in fire situation. We compared the results of determination of fire resistance  according to four different methods. We got some conclusions, but also opened an  area for new research on fire resistance of some other concrete elements.  Concrete is principal construction material in Bosnia and Herzegovina. It is very  common. However, concrete of high compression strength is almost unknown in  Bosnia and Herzegovina. The study of “High-Strength Concrete (HSC) and  Possibilities for Production in Bosnia and Herzegovina“ discusses the recent history,  advantages and disadvantages, application and benefits of it, as well as the  constituent materials, mix design and proportioning and properties of high strength  concrete. Experimental part of this study proves that it is feasible to produce highstrength  concrete of slightly modified ordinary concrete mix improved by domestic  admixtures and additives at minimal cost. This study aims to encourage concrete  factories to produce it and engineers to apply it in their designs and actual  construction.  In his book “Advanced Concrete Technology“1  , Dr. Zongjin Li said: “Fresh concrete  requires considerable care, just like a baby.” With 28 days of age, we consider  concrete to be mature. However, to get concrete quality as required by design after  28 days, the curing procedure requires a whole set of steps, controls and tests.  Unfortunately, concrete quality control in Bosnia and Herzegovina is usually related  just to testing of concrete compression strength. The study of “Concrete Quality    1 Li, Zongjin, 2011, “Advanced Concrete Technology“, (John Wiley &amp; Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey, USA ISBN  978-0-470-90239-4 (ebk),   8  Control according to European Standards –Case Study– Construction of the Waste  Treatment Plant in Bihać“ presents a unique example of Quality Assurance Program  for construction project in Bosnia and Herzegovina, but with particular attention to  concrete works in details. Testing of fresh concrete, testing of hardened concrete, and  testing of steel reinforcement were integral parts of the QA Program during the  implementation of the project. The approach presented in this study and implemented  in the actual project could serve as a model, or at least for concrete quality control  according to European Standards for other large construction projects in Bosnia and  Herzegovina. Lessons learned from this project are important and experiences are  tremendous.  We believe that engineers, architects, designers, construction and project managers,  contractors, clients and students can gain and find useful some of our experiences  based upon the critical approach and thinking, and also keeping in mind that  knowledge, same as seed, cannot be just transplanted anywhere without a detailed  analysis of each piece of the land, climate, and many other factors - and in this case  any individual project. We do hope that findings from these studies can serve as a  reference for your future endeavors.  We use this opportunity to thank our reviewers for their remarks, recommendations  and suggestions. We’d also like to thank Ms. Dijana Misaljević for English  proofreading that made this text better and Mr. Elmir Halebić for the design of the  book cover. We also appreciate any effort and support by everyone who has in any  way contributed to the process of publishing this book.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="45">
            <name>Publisher</name>
            <description>An entity responsible for making the resource available</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="945">
                <text>International Burch University</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="946">
                <text>2018</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="97">
            <name>Keywords</name>
            <description>Keywords.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="947">
                <text>Book
PeerReviewed</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="5">
        <name>TA Engineering (General). Civil engineering (General)</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="123" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="126">
        <src>https://omeka.ibu.edu.ba/files/original/b64076f8673c3e9c29558ece9d1b2b06.pdf</src>
        <authentication>ba708e5b169703ff79fd3c8bb3dfe09c</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="955">
                    <text>Cyber Security Audit in Business
Environments

Kemal Hajdarevic

�II

�Cyber Security Audit in Business
Environments

Kemal Hajdarevic

Sarajevo, 2018

III

�Author:
Dr. Kemal Hajdarević
Proofreading
Pat Allen &amp; Ana Tankosić
Publisher:
International Burch University
Editor-in-Chief:
Dr. Kemal Hajdarević
Reviewed by:
Prof. Dr. Colin Pattinson
Prof. Dr. Mario Spremić
DTP &amp; Design:
Dr. Kemal Hajdarević
DTP and Prepress:
International Burch University
Circulation: Electronic document
Place of Publication: Sarajevo
Copyright: International Burch University, 2018
Reproduction of this Publication for educational or other non-commercial purposes is
authorized without prior permission from the copyright holder. Reproduction for resale or
other commercial purposes prohibited without prior written permission of the copyright
holder.
Disclaimer: While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information,
contained in this publication, International Burch University will not assume liability for
writing and any use made of the proceedings, and the presentation of the participating
organizations concerning the legal status of any country, territory, or area, or of its
authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries.
----------------------------------CIP - Katalogizacija u publikaciji
Nacionalna i univerzitetska biblioteka
Bosne i Hercegovine, Sarajevo
004.056:658
HAJDAREVIĆ, Kemal
Cyber security audit in business environments [Elektronski izvor] / Kemal Hajdarevic. - El. knjiga. Sarajevo : International Burch University, 2018, XVI,160 str. : ilustr. ; 25cm About author: str. 161.
Način dostupa
(URL): http://eprints.ibu.edu.ba/3776/1/Cyber%20Security%20Audit%20in%20Business%2 0Environments_
12.12.2018.pdf. - Nasl. sa nasl. ekrana. - Opis izvora dana 19. 12. 2018.
ISBN 978-9958-834-64-6
COBISS.BH-ID 26733830
-----------------------------------

IV

�V

�VI

�Table of Contents

Author’s Preface .......................................................................................................XIII
ORGANISATION OF BOOK SECTIONS ....................................................................... XV
LEARNING TRACKS ............................................................................................... XVI
IMPORTANT DEFINITIONS ..................................................................................... XVI
1.

Introduction ......................................................................................................... 1
CHAPTER ABSTRACT .................................................................................................. 1
ONE VIEW ON THE HISTORY OF DOCUMENTING PAST EVENTS.................................. 1
ONE VIEW ON DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION ............................................................... 3
DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION CYBER SECURITY CHALLENGES .................................... 5
PURPOSE OF THIS BOOK.............................................................................................. 6
CYBER SECURITY ........................................................................................................ 8
CYBER SECURITY MANAGEMENT ............................................................................... 9
SUMMARY ................................................................................................................ 10
KNOWLEDGE ACQUIRED .......................................................................................... 11
REVIEW QUESTIONS.................................................................................................. 11
FURTHER READINGS ................................................................................................. 11

2.

Security of cyber and information system components ............................... 13
CHAPTER ABSTRACT ................................................................................................ 13
NETWORK COMPONENTS AND INFRASTRUCTURE................................................... 13
NETWORK RELIABILITY REQUIREMENTS .................................................................. 14
COMMUNICATION MODEL ....................................................................................... 14
OSI REFERENCE MODEL AND TCP/IP SUITE ........................................................... 15
TCP/IP protocol suite .......................................................................................... 15
ISO / OSI reference model ................................................................................... 16
NETWORK TOPOLOGIES ........................................................................................... 17
CLIENT – SERVER COMMUNICATION MODEL.......................................................... 18

VII

�PEER-TO-PEER COMMUNICATION MODEL............................................................... 19
INFRASTRUCTURE AND AD-HOC COMMUNICATION MODEL................................... 19
NETWORK COMMUNICATION MEDIA ...................................................................... 20
Wired communication media ............................................................................... 20
Wireless communication media ........................................................................... 22
Weaknesses associated with communication media ............................................. 22
NETWORK COMMUNICATION DEVICES ................................................................... 23
Hubs ..................................................................................................................... 23
Bridges ................................................................................................................. 23
Switches ............................................................................................................... 24
Network TAPs ..................................................................................................... 25
Routers ................................................................................................................. 26
Firewalls ............................................................................................................... 26
Intrusion detection and prevention systems ........................................................ 27
VOIP and PBX .................................................................................................... 27
NETWORK TYPES ...................................................................................................... 28
BAN ..................................................................................................................... 28
PAN ..................................................................................................................... 28
LAN ..................................................................................................................... 28
SAN ..................................................................................................................... 28
WAN .................................................................................................................... 28
MAN .................................................................................................................... 29
NETWORK TERMINAL DEVICES ................................................................................ 29
Supercomputers ................................................................................................... 29
Mainframes .......................................................................................................... 29
High-end and midrange servers ........................................................................... 29
Personal computers .............................................................................................. 30
Thin client computers .......................................................................................... 30
Laptop computers ................................................................................................. 30
Smartphones and handheld computers ................................................................ 30
IoT ........................................................................................................................ 31
NETWORK SERVICES ................................................................................................. 31
NFS ...................................................................................................................... 31
DHCP .................................................................................................................. 31
E-mail................................................................................................................... 32
Print service ......................................................................................................... 33

VIII

�RAS ...................................................................................................................... 34
Directory services................................................................................................. 34
Peer-to-Peer services and applications ................................................................. 35
FTP ...................................................................................................................... 35
Telnet ................................................................................................................... 36
VPN ..................................................................................................................... 36
Communication ports used .................................................................................. 37
NETWORK MANAGEMENT ....................................................................................... 38
Passive monitoring .............................................................................................. 38
Active monitoring ................................................................................................ 39
History of network management .......................................................................... 39
OSI model and framework for network management........................................... 40
SUMMARY ................................................................................................................ 43
KNOWLEDGE ACQUIRED .......................................................................................... 44
REVIEW QUESTIONS.................................................................................................. 44
FURTHER READINGS ................................................................................................. 45
3.

Cyber security landscape ................................................................................. 47
CHAPTER ABSTRACT ................................................................................................ 47
FUNDAMENTAL ASPECTS OF CYBER AND INFORMATION SECURITY........................ 47
CYBER SECURITY INCIDENTS AND MOTIVATIONS .................................................... 48
Common cyber threats ......................................................................................... 49
Malicious software – history and types................................................................ 50
PASSIVE AND ACTIVE ATTACKS ............................................................................... 52
Masquerading ...................................................................................................... 53
Man in the middle attacks .................................................................................... 53
Message modification ........................................................................................... 53
Eavesdropping ...................................................................................................... 53
Intrusion attacks .................................................................................................. 54
Packet reply .......................................................................................................... 54
Spoofing ............................................................................................................... 54
Pharming ............................................................................................................. 54
War dialling ......................................................................................................... 54
War driving ......................................................................................................... 55
War walking ......................................................................................................... 55
War chalking ........................................................................................................ 55

IX

�Code injection....................................................................................................... 55
Interrupt attacks .................................................................................................. 55
DoS, DDoS, flood attacks .................................................................................... 56
Flood attacks......................................................................................................... 57
Protocol specific attacks ....................................................................................... 57
DNS attacks ......................................................................................................... 57
ARP attacks ......................................................................................................... 58
DHCP attack ........................................................................................................ 59
Alteration attacks ................................................................................................. 59
Botnets ................................................................................................................. 59
Fraud .................................................................................................................... 59
Salami .................................................................................................................. 60
Phishing ............................................................................................................... 61
DEEP WEB, DARK WEB ............................................................................................ 61
Deep Web ............................................................................................................. 61
Dark Web ............................................................................................................. 61
Dark Net .............................................................................................................. 62
TOR operation ..................................................................................................... 63
PENETRATION TESTING, ETHICAL HACKING, AND INTRUSIONS ............................. 63
Common intrusion steps, techniques, and tools ................................................... 65
SUMMARY ................................................................................................................ 73
KNOWLEDGE ACQUIRED .......................................................................................... 74
REVIEW QUESTIONS.................................................................................................. 74
FURTHER READINGS ................................................................................................. 75
4.

Cyber security incident cases .......................................................................... 77
CHAPTER ABSTRACT ................................................................................................ 77
CHAPTER SECURITY INCIDENTS ............................................................................... 77
CENTRAL BANK OF BANGLADESH ........................................................................... 77
RETAIL CHAIN TARGET ............................................................................................ 80
SONY ENTERTAINMENT COMPANY ......................................................................... 81
HILLARY CLINTON’S PRESIDENTIAL CAMPAIGN ..................................................... 83
WEBSTRESSER ........................................................................................................... 86
SUMMARY ................................................................................................................ 89
KNOWLEDGE ACQUIRED .......................................................................................... 89
REVIEW QUESTIONS.................................................................................................. 89

X

�FURTHER READINGS ................................................................................................. 90
5.

Cyber security controls ..................................................................................... 93
CHAPTER ABSTRACT ................................................................................................ 93
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY USAGE RELATED TO CYBER RISK .............................. 93
RISK MANAGEMENT ................................................................................................. 93
Risk analysis ........................................................................................................ 94
Risk assessment .................................................................................................... 94
Risk treatment ...................................................................................................... 94
INTERNAL CONTROLS .............................................................................................. 95
Purpose of internal controls ................................................................................. 95
Control objectives ................................................................................................. 96
ISO 27001 ............................................................................................................ 97
3E's ...................................................................................................................... 99
COBIT 5............................................................................................................. 100
PREVENTIVE CONTROLS ......................................................................................... 101
DETECTIVE CONTROLS ........................................................................................... 101
CORRECTIVE CONTROLS ........................................................................................ 101
GENERAL CONTROLS ............................................................................................. 101
SPECIFIC CONTROLS ............................................................................................... 102
SPECIFIC CONTROLS EXAMPLES ............................................................................. 102
Business continuity and Disaster recovery related controls .............................. 102
Bring Your Own Device (BYOD) controls ....................................................... 104
SUMMARY .............................................................................................................. 105
KNOWLEDGE ACQUIRED ........................................................................................ 105
REVIEW QUESTIONS................................................................................................ 105
FURTHER READINGS ............................................................................................... 106

6.

Cyber security audit........................................................................................ 108
CHAPTER ABSTRACT .............................................................................................. 108
ORGANISATION DEFENCE MODEL ......................................................................... 108
THE THREE LINES OF DEFENCE MODEL .................................................................. 109
The first line of defence: Operational management ............................................ 109
The second line of defence: Compliance and Risk Management......................... 110
The third line of defence: Internal audit ............................................................. 110
ORGANISATION RESPONSIBILITIES IN SECURITY GOVERNANCE ............................ 111
CYBER SECURITY AUDIT ......................................................................................... 113

XI

�Performing an audit ........................................................................................... 113
Audit objectives .................................................................................................. 114
Types of audits ................................................................................................... 114
Risk-based auditing and audit risk .................................................................... 116
Qualitative risk-based approach ......................................................................... 116
Semi-quantitative risk-based approach .............................................................. 116
Quantitative risk-based approach ...................................................................... 116
Audit risk types .................................................................................................. 117
Evidence collection ............................................................................................. 117
Condition, Criteria, Cause and Effect of Internal Auditing .............................. 118
ENTERPRISE ARCHITECTURE AND AUDITING ........................................................ 119
HARDWARE AUDIT................................................................................................. 119
OPERATING SYSTEM AUDIT .................................................................................... 120
DATABASE AUDIT................................................................................................... 121
NETWORK INFRASTRUCTURE AUDIT ..................................................................... 122
INFORMATION SYSTEM AUDIT OPERATION AUDIT ................................................ 123
SCHEDULING AUDIT............................................................................................... 125
PROBLEM MANAGEMENT REPORTING AUDIT ........................................................ 126
TIMELINE FOR CYBER SECURITY AUDIT .................................................................. 126
SUMMARY .............................................................................................................. 128
KNOWLEDGE ACQUIRED ........................................................................................ 129
REVIEW QUESTIONS................................................................................................ 129
FURTHER READINGS ............................................................................................... 130
7.

Conclusions ...................................................................................................... 131
CHAPTER ABSTRACT .............................................................................................. 131
CYBER SECURITY OVERVIEW .................................................................................. 131
CYBER SECURITY AUDIT OVERVIEW ....................................................................... 132

List of Figures ........................................................................................................... 133
List of Tables ............................................................................................................. 135
Acronyms .................................................................................................................. 137
References ................................................................................................................. 141
Index .......................................................................................................................... 158
About author ............................................................................................................ 161

XII

�Author’s Preface

Everyday reports reveal numerous cyber security incidents, while
many more are never uncovered due to the risk of jeopardising the
reputation of the attacked systems. One definition of risk of this
sort is:
“feasible determinable outcome of an activity or action subject to
hazards” (Stamatelatos, 2000).
A more holistic and comprehensive definition, which is available
in the NIST Special Publication 800-30 Revision 1 Guide for
Conducting Risk Assessment, defines risk as:
„Adverse impact(s) that could occur... to organisational operations
(including mission, functions, image, reputation), organisational
assets, individuals, other organisations... due to the potential for
unauthorized access, use, disclosure, disruption, modification, or
destruction of information and/or information systems.“
As such, databases, as the active and passive components of
computer networks and the building blocks of computer
infrastructures, became a point of focus for every business in the
world. Unlike 30 years ago, many households nowadays rely on
Internet access and available services to support their everyday
life. The Internet and World Wide Web (WWW) resources are
accessible through various web browsers. The concept of web
browsing can be traced back to Sir Timothy John Berners-Lee, who
XIII

�in March 1989 wrote a proposal in which he proposes a unique way
to access web resources, using three components: Hyper Text
Markup Language (HTML), Hyper Text Transfer Protocol (HTTP),
and Unique Resource Locator (URL) (History of the Web, 2018).
The new and important role of computer network infrastructures,
and information technologies supported by computers and
computer communication networks, produced user who depend
and trust in the reliability and security of their operations. Every
day, media and news report on different criminal activities or
misconducts in which information technology assets were
involved. It is well known that high-tech companies, organisations,
and banks are not the only victims of cyber-crime, but that every
sphere of business and life can be subject to cyber security
incidents.
Information security encompasses the field of information security,
where information refers to both electronically stored or
transferred information, as well as information that is written on
paper or spoken in conversation.
Cyber security also has a narrower meaning that includes only
information and data stored or transferred electronically. In 1948,
Norbert Wiener defined cybernetics as the science of control of and
communication with animals and machines (Norman J., 2018),
while the term cyberspace was used by William Gibson in his 1984
book “Neuromancer” (Gibson W., 1984). In the 21st century, this
term implies control of any system using technology.
In this book, cyber security is constrained to computer
architectures and infrastructures, network components such as
routers, switches, servers, and VOIP PBXs, as well as other active
and passive devices and equipment which are part of every
modern business environment.

XIV

�This book is intended for cyber and information security auditors,
practitioners, and students, or as supplementary documentation
for students of computer communication, network administration
courses, network security, ethical hacking, or network forensics
courses, who have the intention to manage or be a part of cyber and
information security management and audit processes.
These days, universities are trying to modernise their syllabi by
creating new programs and courses that will cope with current
cyber and information security challenges. However, in most cases
university programs cannot change as dynamically as cyber
security players in cyber arenas which demand constant changing.
Students and scientists have to be aware of risks associated with
fraud (English Oxford Dictionaries, 2018), different technologies,
IoT devices, and the deep and dark web where criminals are at
large and crime connected to the real world is happening. That is
why universities in most cases still lead a losing battle when it
comes to preparing information technology students for real world
challenges in managing and auditing information and cyber
security.
Another important goal that audit process have to accomplish, if
possible, is to proactively inform stake holders regarding the state
of operations, using systems of dashboards located in one place
which will sound an alert in case of important cyber security issues.

Organisation of book sections
The book is divided into seven sections:
1. Introduction
2. Security of cyber and information system components
3. Cyber security landscape
4. Cyber security incident cases
XV

�5. Cyber security controls
6. Cyber security audit
7. Conclusions
While reading, it is possible to follow different tracks as proposed
below.

Learning tracks
It is possible to acquire specific skills and knowledge on certain
paths through different chapters in the scheme shown below.
For internal auditors, the order of reading book chapters is 1, 2, 3,
4, 5, and 6. For ethical hackers, the chapters can be read in the same
order, excluding chapter 6. For network managers, the chapter
order is 2, 3, and 5. Finally, for members of law enforcement
agencies important chapters are 3, 4, and 5, while for Chief
Information Security Officers the order of chapters to be read is 2,
3, 4, and 5.

Important definitions
Information System (IS) Security - Refers to the activities, processes,
methodologies, frameworks, and standards used for the
maintenance of information and information assets confidentiality,
integrity, and availability. (Techopedia, 2018)
IT Controls - Refers to procedure policies that provide a reasonable
assurance that information technology (IT) operations are reliable
and compliant with applicable laws and regulations. (Mar S., et.
al., 2012)
IT Auditing – Refers to an examination of the Information technology (IT)
infrastructure controls established by management. (Mar S., et. al., 2012)

XVI

�1. Introduction

Chapter abstract
Chapter goals: To present early advancements in reviewing past events,
and primarily the French war campaign against Russia. To introduce core
information security principles. To introduce and explain the relationship
between information and cyber security. To introduce the concept of
digital transformation and the risks associated with the usage of digital
technology in digital transformation.
Learning outcomes: Knowledge of core principles of information security
and cyber security. Cyber security assets that have to be supported
through cyber security management processes.

One view on the history of documenting past events
Charles Joseph Minard (27 March 1781 – 24 October 1870) was one
of the first contributors in the field of information graphics and a
historian of civil engineering and statistics. Minard was working as
Inspector General of Bridges and Roads (Mason B., 2017), and he is
well known for his graphic work from 1869 where he presented
Napoleon's disastrous military campaign against Moscow from
1812 to 1813 (Mason B., 2017). By analysing the graph shown
below, it is possible to notice that Minard analysed the causes and
consequences of the campaign within a single graph, which is why
this document can be seen as an early sample of audit finding
documentation. All findings in audit reports have to have
references based on hard evidence.

�As it can be read from Minard’s map, the campaign started on the
24th of June 1812. The retreat from Moscow began on October 18,
and ended on December 14. The graph shows the number of
soldiers lost during advances to Moscow and the following return
to France.
In the same graph we may find information concerning the
temperature during one phase of retreat, equal to -37.5 C. This
graph is probably one of the earliest flow maps containing
quantitative information ever created. In literature (Maswerk,
2013), the graph is known as “The map that made a nation cry”
because Napoleon started his campaign to Moscow with 422,000
soldiers from Niemen, France in 1812, with only 10,000 returning
alive.

Figure 1. Charles Joseph Minard: Napoleon's Retreat from Moscow (The
Russian Campaign 1812-1813), Mason B., (2017)

That means that only 2.37% of soldiers returned alive. Up to this
point, Napoleon’s army was the largest army ever in the history of
warfare. This graph presents a quantitative perspective of
disastrous events which shows a lack of logistics, military
planning, organisation, and transportation. Graph above is a

2

�presentation of many different types of data in one visual form, so
the relationship between them can be seen.
From that point onwards, warfare strategists used available
information and experience to avoid similar situations through
better planning and organization. Napoleon's Retreat from Moscow
looks like a non-interactive dashboard with a lot of useful
information. An interactive graphic dashboard version (Maswerk,
2013) where different data reported by Minard can be analysed is
available online.
Graphic maps and dashboards provide intuitive insight into
multiple sets of data, facts, and information, all presented within
one graphic view. By graphically documenting past events with
time scales from which conclusions can be drawn, we can learn
from history and available resources with the goal of preventing
future unfortunate events or to improve existing activities and
processes. Minard published his famous map 56 years (referenced
above) after the events that changed history forever. In today's
electronic or digital era we encounter activities, events,
vulnerabilities, and incidents which have to be solved as soon as
possible, and sometimes within minutes, hours, or days, since any
unnecessary delay in time can produce serious negative
consequences.

One view on digital transformation
Digital business transformation through digital technologies
provides different services to a large number of people in different
parts of the globe. This dominant technology creates a large
dependency on digital technology in every sphere of business and
life for the population at large.
Services such as mPesa, which started operating in 2007, allow
users (20 million) mostly in Africa to exchange money and use it as
a payment mechanism (Spremic, 2017).
3

�In Sweden 95% of all transactions are performed without physical
banknotes, and in Denmark from 2016 there is law that allows
shops to require only electronic payment and to refuse to accept
physical banknotes (Spremic, 2017).
The Netflix service, which started as a DVD movie renting
company, now provides online movie rental services to more than
80 million users in more than 200 countries. Wal-Mart and Macy
use the Facebook „like“ option to decide which products will have
a lower price or which products are most preferred among
customers, Spremic (2017).
Airbnb is a service which allows customers to lease or rent shortterm lodging, including cottages, apartments, homestays, hostel
beds, or hotel rooms. More bookings are done by Airbnb than
through official hotel chains. Airbnb does not have physical offices
for their customers across the world. The same is true for Uber, the
biggest global taxi service which is supported and run exclusively
through the Internet (Spremic, 2017).
Data and information in today’s business environments are the
most valuable assets, immediately after the people who are
responsible for managing information and maintain the security,
confidentiality, integrity, and availability of information (CIA).
Business sustainability depends on well-managed cyber and
information security.
Whenever technology is used to improve business operations,
there is risk that malicious individuals, such as cyber criminals,
will attempt to harm the implemented technology.
While information security deals with the security of information,
CIA treats information not only in their digital form, but in printed
form as well, as well as any information that can be stored or
transmitted in electronic form.
4

�Digital transformation cyber security challenges
It was apparent that cyber security quakes were on agenda during
and after the US elections which ended in January 2017. Cyber
events including Hilary Clinton’s leaked e-mails (Zurcher A.,
2016), and the Russian influence reported by (LaFraniere S, 2018)
throughout the campaign, still reverberate through the US political
arena at the time when this book was in the process of writing, in
the spring and summer of 2018.
Other notable cyber incidents include the Central Bangladesh Bank
heist (Ruma P., 2018), which took place in February 2016, where
Dridex malware was used for an attack against the local SWIFT
infrastructure (Thomson I., 2016). Hackers tried to steal $951
million, succeeding in stealing around $80 million (Ruma P., 2018).
The exact amount is not known, but the hackers used existing
device vulnerabilities, such as operating systems which were not
patched, and did not have proper antivirus intrusion detection and
firewall protection.
The future will most certainly bring new unseen incidents, since
we are generally only informed about incidents related to financial
frauds and malicious attacks in banking industry in the news. We
already witnessed incidents related to technology or military
espionage and attacks on elements of vital national infrastructure,
such as the attack on nuclear power plants using Stuxnet (Mueller
P. and Yadegari B., 2012). It is a question of great concern what will
happen in the future when food and pharmaceutical companies
become the target of cyber-attacks once all tasks are automated,
including, for example, the addition of chemical ingredients and
determination of dosage levels.
Attacks on any computer network infrastructure, such as food
processing facilities, could be conducted via communication
channels, servers, data bases, and applications.
5

�These kinds of attacks can severely affect human health or even
cause deaths. As such, we realise the danger of underestimating
risks associated with cyber and information security, especially by
individuals responsible for security. While key persons and top
management in most working environments will most probably be
able to recognise the importance of cyber and information security
as one of the top strategic goals, when it comes to real world
situations there are many existing problems and challenges.
The nature of information is such that it can exist in different forms,
or it can be communicated using different communication
channels. Information can be written on paper, stored on hard
disks in data bases, or transferred via wired or wireless
communication channels.

Purpose of this book
The purpose of this book is to provide insight into cyber security
landscapes, and it is intended for students, teachers,
administrators, information security auditors, forensic staff,
security consultants/professionals, professional penetration
testers, and everyone else who plans to use it for ethical reasons.
This book can be used as a review manual for cyber and
information security, or as supplemental documentation related to
computer security, digital forensics, and ethical hacking courses.
The book is also necessary in areas where it is important to monitor
the performance and compliance of information systems, and to
report the status to management or regulatory bodies in the form
of a specific type of operational feedback.
Feedback is a well-known term and mechanism from the 18th
century, used in different fields including engineering
(mechanical, electrical, electronic, software), dynamical systems,
climate science, control theory, finance and economy, biology,

6

�social science, and even medicine as a self-regulated mechanism.
Ramaprasad (1983) defines it as:
“Information about the gap between the actual level and the
reference level of a system parameter“
Business environments are supported by computer and network
infrastructures that are used for collaboration, data processing,
internal and external communication, reporting, and many other
purposes. As such, cyber and information security auditors have to
be aware of approaches presented here which can make their jobs
easier.
This book can also be used as a quick reference guide in addition
to other referenced sources for practitioners who are delegated or
are in the process of information system, cyber, and information
security audit. It can be used as supplemental material for students
of computer communications and network management courses,
information management system courses, system and network
administration courses, and cyber and network security courses.
In essence, this book is for cyber security specialists who want to
learn more about the process of auditing, using available standards
and controls applicable to today's architectures with active
components such as switches and routers. While university
programs offer technical knowledge about cyber and information
security management through courses, there is a clear need to
educate students about the organisational aspects and functions
which include auditing.
This book can be used as supplemental material for students and
practitioners to grasp the scope of expertise they will need, and to
understand what standards, methods, and tools can be used to
successfully perform future tasks in cyber and information security
arena, with a particular focus on auditing tasks.
7

�The focus of this book is on principles of auditing, applicable
standards, controls, and risk management processes. Another
contribution of this book is the visualisation of trends and the
presentation of the current state of the field of auditing.

Cyber security
Cyber security is limited to electronically stored data or
information, as well as data and information which is transferred
through communication channels, real time operational
instructions, network devices, communications links, servers ant
other similar devices which stores and transports the data.
The management of information security covers cyber related
information, as well as physical media such as paper and spoken
word. As shown in the figure below, cyber security is considered a
subset of information security.

Information security

Cyber security

Figure 2. Cyber and information security realm

8

�Cyber security management
Cyber security management is possible through implementation
and constant monitoring and improvement check-ups. Check-ups
can be implemented in various forms using the existing standards.
As we saw from the well-known cases in the media, the root of
many cyber and information security incidents stems from basic
administrative flaws such as unpatched operating systems,
unimplemented antivirus solutions, or cheap unmanaged switches
separating network traffic.
It is a common mistake on the part of the management to believe
that information security is only information technology (IT)
security or that cyber security is something that only IT experts
have to handle. The real-life cases show us that more broader
approaches, methods, and standards have to be considered,
implemented, and used. A successful response to cyber security
threats has to involve key players and decision makers who can
contribute to cyber security in key areas.
For cyber security management, IT related activities are key to
cyber and information security management for the whole
organisations. IT supports data infrastructures through
communication signalisation (which can be wired or wireless),
with passive (cables, trunks and patch cabinets) and active network
components (such as switches and routers), data bases, files,
applications, media servers, or clouds.
Unmanaged access rights, weak network controls, weak
antimalware update policy, no Bring Your Own Device (BYOD)
policy, no cryptographic controls, no media disposal or Universal
Serial Bus (USB) policy, will all likely jeopardise organisation
security.

9

�Information security has several additional responsibilities for
information assets to manage, including:


Human resources security that would include security
issues during the hiring, employment, and termination
process. It should include cyber and information security
awareness programs for employees and third parties.



Physical security that would include security of physical
perimeters around information processing facilities. The
focus of physical security should be physical access rights,
video surveillance, and physical alarm systems.



Legal issues that would include licensing and intellectual
rights.



Common affairs that would include tendering processes,
utility concerns such as power supplies from the electric
grid, redundant power supplies that would include UPSs,
generators, fuel supplies, equipment services, and water
and gas supplies.

Summary
Cyber security is a subset of information security that deals with
the security of information stored in digital form and transferred
over communication links. A great part of information security
related standards deals with cyber security issues.
Almost daily, media reports reveal cyber security related incidents.
By learning from history, we can conclude that we will see an
increase in incidents of this type, especially as more services and
users use digital technology in everyday work and life.

10

�Knowledge acquired
The difference between information and cyber security,
information and key cyber areas of management. Digital
transformation challenges related to cyber security.

Review questions
1. Explain the difference between information and cyber
security?
2. What are the key areas of information security?

Further readings
-

Digital transformation: online guide to digital business
transformation
https://www.i-scoop.eu/digitaltransformation/

-

The Cyber Security Management System: A Conceptual
Mapping, SANS Institute InfoSec Reading Room
https://www.sans.org/readingroom/whitepapers/basics/cyber-security-managementsystem-conceptual-mapping-591

-

What
Is
Cybersecurity?
https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/products/security/what-iscybersecurity.html

11

�12

�2. Security of cyber and information
system components

Chapter abstract
Chapter goals: To present Shannon’s communication model, as well as the
essential network standards related to the ISO OSI referenced model and
the TCP/IP suite. To define network topologies, and present network
communication devices, network types, and network terminal devices. To
present network services and associated protocols, to explain core network
management principles, and to explore the purpose of active and passive
monitoring.
Learning outcomes: Knowledge of core principles in computer
communications and operation of active computer communication
network devices, protocols, and services. Essential knowledge concerning
network management processes.

Network components and infrastructure
Network infrastructures in terminal devices such as client
computers, laptops, smart phones, and servers, provide a large
number of users access to different services. All these
infrastructures are supported by active and passive devices such as
modems, hubs, bridges, switches, routers, firewalls, intrusion
detection and prevention systems, and other communication
devices and communication links that guarantee reliable and
secure communication. For an internal auditor it is important to
understand and have enough knowledge of available technology
13

�to be able to conduct audits and identify the points of improvement
for audited systems.

Network reliability requirements
With the goal of providing reliable network support, network
operations have to satisfy specific requirements to be able to
support everyday business functions such as:
Interoperability, which means that different network technologies
have to be interconnected.
Availability, which means that the network architecture and
services have to be available 24-7-365.
Flexibility, which means that new network segments can be added
and expanded as new needs are introduced.
Manageability, which means that networks can be well managed
from a single point of management.

Communication model
The client–server model is one of the most common
communication models available, drawing roots from Shannon
and Weaver’s communication model presented in the 1940's
(Shannon &amp; Weaver, 1949).
Information
source

Information
transimter
(Coding)

Communication
channel
Signal / Message

Information
receiver
(Decoding)

Information
Destination

Figure 3. Shannon’s communication model

This model contains communicative highlights components such
as information source and information destination as the most
important parts of communication. With the goal of transmitting
14

�information from source to destination, a communication channel
(wired or wireless) with transmitters and receivers implemented as
hardware or software components is needed. All these components
are the building blocks of the core communication model relevant
for today’s communications.

OSI reference model and TCP/IP suite
The TCP / IP protocol is the standard Internet protocol used, and
the latest version of the TCP/IP protocol is version 6 (IPv6, 2018),
but version 4 is still widely in use.
TCP/IP protocol suite
In the late 1960s, the United States Department of Defence financed
a project known as ARPANET (Featherly K., 2018) with the goal of
developing communication protocols which would enable
computers to communicate. The initial network started working in
1969, with a set of protocols. In 1974, specifications for the TCP
protocol were published, and they were tested in the following
years as the fourth version of TCP/IP (Pelkey, 2007). In 1977, first
tests were conducted between Stanford and University College of
London (TCP/IP Internet Protocol, 1981).

Application
Transport
Internet
Link
Physical
Figure 4. TPC / IP protocol suite layers
15

�ISO / OSI reference model
The idea of standardizing computer protocols was initiated in the
1970s when two bodies for the establishment of international
standards independently began working on their reference
models. These were the International Standardisation Organisation
(ISO) and the International Telegraph and Telephone Consultative
Committee (CCITT acronym, French version of the name ) (Pelkey ,
(2007) Chapter 9 Standards: 1979-1984.

Application
Presentation
Session
Transport
Network
Data Link
Physical
Figure 5. ISO / OSI reference model

The two documents which were created by these two bodies were
merged in 1983 and published in 1984 under the name The Basic
Reference Model for Open Systems Interconnection. ISO named
their version of the standard ISO 7498 (ISO 7498:1984, 1984) and
CCITT named it ITU-T (Telecommunications Standardization Sector of
the International Telecommunication Union) x.200 (x.200, 1995).
The goal of this model was to provide a fundamental design for
future protocols which will be used for international
16

�communication for the industrial, educational, and commercial
purposes.
This model never fully came to life as, unlike TCP/IP, it was not
practically implemented in the real world of communications. The
OSI reference model is used as a model for educational purposes
in order to understand the general principles of the protocol used
for computer communications. The OSI reference model has seven
layers, as is shown in the figure above.

Network topologies
An important aspect of computer networks is network
architecture. Within network architecture, the physical layout of
computer networks is called network topology.

Ring

Star

Line /

Tree

Mesh

Bus

Point-to-point

Full mesh / Point-to/point
Figure 6. Network topologies

Network topology determines how the network and the
networked devices are interconnected. While network topology
17

�was primarily used as a hardware setting, with computer networks
and Internet, different applications were developed which use
elements from physical topologies, such as client-server and peerto-peer applications.

Client – Server Communication model
This model represent the earliest Internet building blocks where on
the service side there was a server, and on the user side was a client.

PC
PC

PC
SERVER

Client - Server

PC
PC

PC

Peer-to-Peer

PC

PC

PC
PC

Figure 7. Client-Server and Peer-to-Peer communication models

18

�Peer-to-Peer communication model
The Peer-to-Peer (P2P) model was originally concerned with how
computer hardware and computer communication were
interconnected.

Infrastructure and ad-hoc communication model
With the arrival of wireless communication, two types of
communication models were introduced.
The first one is infrastructure, where a wireless access point is
needed as a gateway for users to use network resources such as the
Internet. In this way, the network is configured in a hierarchical
infrastructure.
Internet

PC
PC

PC
PC

Figure 8. Infrastructure of the wireless communication model

The ad-hoc model is used so that devices are interconnected with
each other in point-to-point topology.

PC

PC
PC

PC
PC

Figure 9. Ad-hoc wireless communication model
19

�Network communication media
A communication channel is needed to transfer data from a sender
to a receiver over certain communication media. Communication
media can be wired or wireless.
Wired communication media
Wired communication media that can be used consists of copper
based pairs, coaxial cables, or fibre optic cables.
Twisted pairs made of copper are used for WAN and LAN
technologies. These cables are produced as Unshielded Twisted
Pairs (UTP) and Shielded Twisted Pairs (STP). Coaxial cables,
called thin net and thick net, can be used to transfer data. Because
copper cables are prone to electromagnetic interference, STPs with
a metal shield around twisted pairs are used to reduce external
noise. With the goal of providing higher frequencies and data
transfer speeds, different categories of twisted pair cables are
introduced, which allows for high data rate transfer over Ethernet
segments as shown in the table below.
CATEGORY

SHIELDING

TRANSMISSION SPEED
100 METERS SEGMENT

FREQUENCY

Cat 3

UTP
UTP
UTP
UTP / STP
STP
STP

10 Mbps

16 MHz

10/100 Mbps

100 MHz

1000 Mbps / 1 Gbps

100 MHz

1000 Mbps / 1 Gbps

250 MHz

10000 Mbps / 10 Gbps

500 MHz

10000 Mbps / 10 Gbps

600 MHz

Cat 5
Cat 5e
Cat 6
Cat 6a
Cat 7

Table 1. Ethernet cable performance (Ethernet, 2018)

Enhanced twisted pair categories and electronics allow higher
frequencies and faster data rates as is shown in Table 2.

20

�Experimental
Ethernet

1973

2.94 Mbit/s over coaxial cable (coax) bus

Ethernet II

1982

10 Mbit/s over thick coax.

IEEE 802.3

1983

10BASE5 10 Mbit/s over thick coax.

802.3a

1985

10BASE2 10 Mbit/s over thin Coax

802.3e

1987

1BASE5 or StarLAN

802.3i

1990

10BASE-T 10 Mbit/s over twisted pair

802.3j

1993

10BASE-F 10 Mbit/s over Fiber-Optic

802.3u

1995

100BASE-TX, 100BASE-T4, 100BASE-FX

802.3y

1998

100BASE-T2 100 Mbit/s

802.3z

1998

1000BASE-X Gbit/s Ethernet over Fiber-Optic at 1 Gbit/s

802.3ab

1999

1000BASE-T Gbit/s Ethernet over twisted pair at 1 Gbit/s

802.3ae

2002

10 Gigabit Ethernet over fiber

802.3an

2006

10GBASE-T 10 Gbit/s

802.3aq

2006

10GBASE-LRM 10 Gbit/s Ethernet over multimode fiber

802.3bm

2015

100G/40G Ethernet for optical fiber

802.3bp

2016

1000BASE-T1 – Gigabit Ethernet over a single twisted pair

802.3bs

2017

200GbE (200 Gbit/s) over single-mode

802.3bw

2015

100BASE-T1 – 100 Mbit/s Ethernet over a single twisted pair

802.3by

2016

Optical fiber, twinax and backplane 25 Gigabit Ethernet[6]

802.3bz

2016

2.5GBASE-T and 5GBASE-T – 2.5 Gigabit

Table 2. Ethernet standards (Ethernet IEEE 802.3 Standards, 2018)

21

�Fibre optic cables are used for faster and more reliable
communication than with twisted pairs. There are two types of
fibre optic cables: single-mode and multi-mode.
Single-mode cables use lasers as the source of light for data
transmission while multimode cables use light emitting diode
(LED) as a source of light. Single mode cables provide faster
communication data rates.
Wireless communication media
For wireless communication Radio Frequency (RF), laser, or infrared signals can be used.
Weaknesses associated with communication media
Below presented are the weaknesses associated with technology
used as communication media. Radio communication and copper
based communication media are weaker than fiber optic media
because of their physical characteristics.
Technology
Coaxial Cable

Weakness
Easy to Tap
Distance sensitive
Difficult to modify
Easy to Tap
Easy to splice
Cross talk
interference

Twisted pair

Fiber Optics
Microwave radio
and Radio links
Satellite radio link

Easy to Tap
Interference
Noise
Easy to Tap
interference
Noise

Table 3. Communication media weaknesses

22

�Network communication devices
Because network mechanisms such as protocols provide reliable
end to end communication, their functions are delivered through
all seven layers in the case of the ISO/OSI model, or five layers in
the TCP/IP protocol suite.
Aapplication

Data

Podatak

Application layer

Data

Data

Application layer

Presentation layer

Data

Data

Presentation layer

Application

Session layer

Data

Data

Session layer

Transport layer

Data

Data

Transport layer

Network layer

Data

Data

Network layer

Data link Layer

Data

Data

Data link Layer

Physical layer

Physical layer

Physical medium

Hub

Switch / Bridge

Router

Gateway

Figure 10. Encapsulation process and communication devices on layers

Every layer of the TCP/IP protocol suite (Figure 4.) has a unique
task and that is why special devices were developed to support
specific tasks at specific communication layers.
Hubs
Hubs are devices that regenerate and amplify received frames
(Protocol Data Unit -PDU at data link layer (InetDaemon, 2018))
and then send them to all device ports. This device is considered as
a device which operates on a physical level.
Bridges
Bridges are devices responsible for interconnecting different
network technologies, such as IEEE 802.3 and IEEE 802.5, and
different network segments with different physical media, such as
copper cable networks with coaxial cable networks. Bridges are
23

�devices that collect knowledge using internal media access control
MAC (InetDaemon, 2018) address tables, which helps them
distinguish which device is part of which network segment, thus
limiting unnecessary traffic in-between network segments. These
devices cannot limit collisions in the network, but can send
notifications about existing collisions.
Switches
Switches are, in essence, multiport bridges, and they operate on
both the physical and data link level. While early bridges were
computers with appropriate software, switches are hardware
devices able to provide connections for many computers, where
they can send frames in full-duplex mode. Switches separate
network segments into different collision domains. They do this
using MAC addresses (InetDaemon, 2018) to forward frames, and
their major task is to forward and filter traffic.
For network monitoring purposes, a switch can be configured to
forward all traffic to one specific port called the SPAN port. Traffic
gathered in this way can be analysed frame by frame or can be used
to create usage statistics for a specific protocol, application, and
other network management purposes explained in later chapters.

PC
PC
SPAN Port
Switch

PC

Monitoring
device

PC

Figure 11. Typical SPAN port deployment in a simplified network
diagram
24

�Network TAPs
A Network Terminal Access Point (TAP) is a specialized device
used to intercept network communication for the purposes of
analysis known as „traffic analysis“. It is a device dedicated to
intercepting network traffic. At minimum it has three ports: a port
for incoming traffic, a port for outgoing traffic, and a port to attach
the computer which is used to capture and analyse network traffic.
This device is usually placed on network segments, such as
backbones, where major network traffic flows, so that all traffic can
be captured or monitored. Specialized traffic analysis software,
such as Wireshark (2018) for wired networks and Kismet for
wireless networks together with Wireshark (2018), can be used.
The usage is explained in later chapters of the book.

PC
PC

Tap

PC

Switch

PC

Monitoring
device

Figure 12. Typical Tap location in network

A network TAP device that can be placed on a UTP network and
Fibre optic network segments is shown in the figure below. This
specific device has two ports where two monitoring devices can be
attached.

25

�Figure 13. Network TAP, Dualcomm (2018)

Routers
Routers are devices that operate on the network or IP level, as they
separate network segments into multiple broadcast domains.
Routers operate with logical or IP addresses.
They are equipped with software that allows routers to work with
routing protocols which route routed protocols and manage routes
so that packets can reach their destinations.
Firewalls
Firewalls are devices which, when deployed between different
network segments, are seen as network devices, whereas if they are
deployed on client computers, they are called personal firewalls.
Their goal is to protect local resources from security breaches.

26

�The primary task of firewalls is to limit access to sensitive internal
resources, monitor and record communication, encrypt packets,
and provide end-to-end encryption using Virtual Private
Networks (VPN) (CISCO, 2018).
There are different types of firewalls (CISA, 2015, pp.368),
including packet filtering firewalls, stateful firewalls, application
based firewalls which can be implemented through screened-host
firewalls, dual-homed firewalls, and hardware based appliances.
Intrusion detection and prevention systems
Firewall intrusion, detection, and prevention systems (IDS/IPS) can
be implemented as network-based or host-based systems. The logic
which can use these devices includes signature-based, statisticalbased, or neural networks as mechanisms for the detection of
malicious activities.
IDS/IPS is considered an additional mechanism for detecting
malicious attempts against protected and valuable network
resources.
These systems have sensors and detection logic that is used to
detect malicious activities.
VOIP and PBX
Voice over IP is becoming a dominant form of technology,
replacing old PSTN analogue services available from 1920s
onwards. VOIP is well-known for its Internet application, using
different VOIP services, such as Skype or Viber.
The VOIP private box exchange (PBX) are computer-based
switches which are installed at organisation premises with the
purpose of switching telephone calls in and out of the organisation.

27

�Network types
There are different classification types for computer
communication networks, but the most common is one that
recognises coverage for interconnected devices.
BAN
Body area networks that are limited to one meter, and are typically
wireless technology used to connect smart phones with smart
watches, and sensors inside wearables such as clothes or shoes.
PAN
Personal area networks are limited to 10 meters, and are used to
connect nearby devices, such as Bluetooth enabled devices.
LAN
A typical local area network segment spans 100 meters, but can be
extended up to 400 meters using hubs, bridges, and switches, and
even further using routers. Wireless LAN (WLAN) can be used to
connect access points below 100 meters, but using point links these
networks can be interconnected over tens of kilometres.
SAN
Storage area networks (SAN) or network area storage (NAS) are
used to provide data storage on LANs for users. These devices can
be configured to have locally managed users or they can
incorporate an already available authentication scheme.
WAN
A Wide area network is considered a network which is used to
connect all type of IT devices across a wide area in different regions
in a country or even between countries. Internet is usually referred
to as a WAN network

28

�A special type of WAN is wireless LAN (WLAN), which uses
wireless technology to interconnect communication sites within
same town.
MAN
Metropolitan area network is used to interconnect LANs across a
city to connect different buildings of, for example, a university
campus with parts of the university located in the same town on
fiscally different location.

Network terminal devices
Network terminal devices are devices where communication ends.
They are also a well-known part of Claud Shannon’s
communication model (Businesstopia, 2018), called sendingreceiving stations.
Supercomputers
Supercomputers are computers dedicated to a specific problem or
application where huge processing power is needed. The need
dictates the high prices of these computer systems, and as such
they are mostly used by research or military organisations.
Mainframes
Mainframes are computers which are used by thousands of users,
and which usually have dedicated operating systems. Usually
these computers support multiprocessor architectures.
High-end and midrange servers
These servers use operating systems such as UNIX, Linux, and
Windows. They are cheaper than mainframes, but share some
capabilities of mainframes.
Supercomputers, mainframes, and servers have to be located in airconditioned rooms with uninterruptable power supply (UPS),
29

�electric generators, and redundant power supply from
independent supply grids which are apart from the primary power
grid. It is because all critical components have to be available all
the time if possible.
Personal computers
Personal Computers are designed for single users. They use
microprocessor architecture with almost all the components that
servers have, such as a hard disk and multiprocessors, but with
weaker performances than servers. They are used for word
processing, access to common business applications, and network
resources such as printing services or intranet.
Thin client computers
Thin client computers have limited hardware capacity, and are
often without hard disks. They use network storage from servers
or dedicated network area storage devices. They are, much like
personal computers, used for personal use to common
applications.
Laptop computers
Laptops are smaller, lightweight personal computers, suitable to be
carried in a suitcase.
Smartphones and handheld computers
Smartphones, tablets, and other handheld computers are devices
lighter than laptops with high processing power, usually without
keyboards to make for easier carrying. They can be used as
telephones, organisers, PCs, tablets, as means of communication,
voice messages, or as a VOIP communicator using Skype, Viber,
and other similar tools.

30

�IoT
Internet of Things describes all devices connected to the Internet
which are not considered as conventional as PC, laptop, or
smartphones. These devices are, for example, IP cameras, VOIP
telephones, and even household devices, such as refrigerators,
which have an Internet connection that allows users to interact
with the devices.

Network services
Network services enables network users to access network
resources as they are locally available. They run as daemons on
Linux/Unix platforms, or as a service on Windows platforms.
NFS
Network File Systems (NFS) allows users of computer networks to
access files over network resources.
DHCP
Dynamic Host Configuration Protocols (DHCP) enable devices
which do not have manually configured IP addresses to obtain an
IP address, subnet masks, default gateways, and IP address DNS
servers from the DHCP service which can be located on the server
or on another device, such as a router.
Client devices have to be configured as a DHCP client which initial
DHCPs discover as a broadcast request to which available DHCP
servers reply with the offer of an IP address, subnet mask, default
gateway, or DNS addresses. After that, the client requests one of
the offered addresses, and the DHCP acknowledge the given and
accepted set of addresses.

31

�DHCP Discover
DHCP Offer
DHCP Request

DHCP
Client

DHCP Acknowledge

DHCP
SERVER

Figure 14. Simple DHCP architecture and modus operandi

E-mail
E-mail service provides the service of exchanging e-mail messages
on intranets and Internet using SMTP, IMAP, and POP3 protocols.
Common server programs send mail on Unix/Linux servers or MS
Exchange servers. A typical email architecture contains three types
of agents (an agent in this context is the software which provides a
specific function for somebody):
Mail User Agent (MUA)
MUA is software installed on end-user devices or accessed as a web
service (webmail such as Gmail), which is used to read and
compose emails
Mail Transfer Agent (MTA)
MTA is software on the server side of the application which
receives emails from MUA and checks with MDA if the recipient is
in the local mail address box. If not , the email is sent to another
receiving MTA based on the DNS name and the resolved IP
address. All emails are transferred using the Simple Mail Message
Protocol (SMTP) which uses TCP port 25.
32

�Sender MUA
Recipient MUA

MTA / MDA

MTA / MDA

Figure 15. Simple MUA, MTA, MDA architecture

Mail Delivery Agent (MDA)
MDA is software responsible for delivering emails to local
mailboxes, so that local users can use MUA to access emails. Mails
accessed by MUA to MDA use POP3 or IMAP protocols.
Print service
Print services allow users to use network printers in the
organisation in accordance with the given promotions. This type of
service provides better management of resources from a single
management point. Printers are of communicating via IP, and all
status messages such as low toner or paper can be sent directly to
administrators, so that problems of missing resources can be
resolved proactively. Users of print services can choose which
printer they want to use, such as black and white or colour printers.

Print server

Black and White printer

Colour printer

Figure 16. Simple network printing service
33

�Print servers allow the storage of printed files for a specific amount
of time so that documents can be printed later, again, or to check
what was already printed.
RAS
Remote Access Service (RAS) provides direct access to local
network resources to authorized users. This access was popular
from the beginning of the computer network era when access was
provided with WAN technologies, usually via Public Switched
Telephone Networks (PSTN), and later with Integrated Switched
Telephone Networks (ISDN).

Modem

WAN Circuit

Modem

RAS Server

Figure 17. Simple RAS architecture

Nowadays, due to available Internet connections, the Internet and
VPNs are a common way of securely connecting to remote
networks.
Directory services
Directory service provides user authentication and access to
network resources such as shared files, directories, printers,
applications, and other network resources.

34

�Peer-to-Peer services and applications
With the expansion of the Internet, P2P models were used with
common applications that share files, such as music, videos, and
other resources. One of the pioneering peer-to-peer (P2P) file
sharing services was Napster (2018), established in 1999.

Figure 18. Napster (2018)

Napster was specialized in sharing mp3 music files and had about
80 million registered users. According to (Lamont T., 2013) “The
digital music revolution started with Napster” but the service was
closed in 2001 due to a lawsuit for illegal sharing of copyrighted
materials.
FTP
File Transfer Protocol (FTP) is used to store or retrieve files and
folders from and to FTP servers.

35

�Control Port 21

FTP Client
Data port 20

FTP Server

Figure 19. Simple FTP architecture

FTP uses TCP protocols with two ports, 20 and 21. FTP is most
frequently used to transfer username and password in clear text if
additional encryption is not used.
Telnet
Telnet is a service used to access remote devices via TCP/IP using
TCP port 23.

Port 23

Telnet Client

Telnet Server

Figure 20. Simple Telnet architecture

It allows for two-way bidirectional communication. The protocol
was developed in 1969 and is still used today by many
communication and terminal devices.
VPN
Virtual Private Networks provide confidentiality and integrity of
data over unsecured networks, such as Internet, by providing
point-to-point data encryption.

36

�VPN TUNNEL

Figure 21. Simplified VPN connection

Communication ports used
Every service that acts as a server in the client/server architecture
has a predefined port, i.e. a specific service use which the client
application can use to connect.
Application / Service

Acronym

Port

Simple Network Management Protocol

SNMP

161, 162

Domain Name System

DNS

53

Hypertext Transfer Protocol

HTTP

80

Simple Mail Transfer Protocol

SMTP

25

Post Office Protocol

POP3

110

Telnet

Telnet

23

Dynamic Host Configuration Protocol

DHCP

67

File Transfer Protocol

FTP

20, 21

Table 4. Applications / Services and standard ports used

37

�Network management
Network management provides capabilities of reactively and
proactively maintaining network components. ISO published a
standardized approach to network management which contains
the architecture and modelling known as the ISO model and
Telecommunications Management Network (TMN) framework
(Overview of TMN Recommendations, 2001) for network
management (Sahin T. et. al., 1988). There is also the IETF IP
Performance Management (IPPM) (IPPM, 2018) Working Group
(WG) which developed a number of standards and metrics for IPbased networks. In essence, there are two types of network
monitoring which are part of network management: passive and
active network monitoring. These two approaches are
complementary. However, when performing passive monitoring,
active monitoring should be turned off, because it will otherwise
produce additional network traffic. Using both approaches,
monitoring results are more accurate.
Passive monitoring
Passive monitoring can be done using SPAN ports and Tap devices
to capture/sniff and analyse network traffic using software such as
Wireshark (2018).
Another way of gathering valuable information is by using Simple
Network Management Protocols (SNMP) to poll devices such as
routers, switches, and servers that have installed SNMP agents
with the Management Information Base for information on traffic,
such as the number of IP, TCP, and UDP packets.
It is possible to configure devices to send trap messages when
specific events occur. Netflow is a passive monitoring mechanism
which is able to provide the network manager with valuable
statistical information.

38

�RMON is also a passive monitoring mechanism which is used to
manage devices on network segments with limited bandwidth
capacities.
Active monitoring
The IETF IP Performance Management (IPPM, 2018) Working
Group (WG) was formed in 1997 with the task of developing
metrics as Key Performance Indicators (KPI) and standards for
active monitoring in the performance management of IP networks
History of network management
Three major organisations ISO, IETF, IETF, developed approaches
and protocols specific for network management with the different
focus to reach specific goals. Each organisation set up their own
goals presented below in each row of the table.
ISO

ITU-T

Powerful Management
Object Oriented
Reliable transport

Define management
architecture only
Using OSI protocol
(CMIP &amp; CMIS)
Out-of-band exchanged
Management
Information

IETF
Simple Management
Variable Oriented
Unreliable transport

Table 5. ISO, ITU-T, IETF basic principles

ISO developed model and framework for network management
based on five functional areas: Fault, Configuration, Accounting,
Performanse, and Security (FCAPS). Based ond FCAPS model,
newer FAB model is defined in the Business Process Framework
(eTOM, 2018).
ITU-T developed Telecommunications Management Network
(TMN) for managing open systems in a communications network.
Goal was to automate process of detecting and resolving problems
in telecommunication networks.
39

�IETF defined set of standards that defined SNMP and application
layer protocol, data objects, and database schema.
OSI model and framework for network management
This model recognises five areas of functional management: Fault,
Configuration, Accounting, Performance, and Security (FCAPS)
(Nuangjamnong C, 1998).

Figure 22. Network Management history IETF, ISO Network
Management architecture and model (Nuangjamnong C, 1998).

40

�Additionally, it proposes an organisation model which contains a
manager, an agent, and an object. OSI FCAPS model turned out to
be used for education purposes just as ISO OSI communication
model.
Network Management Station
with Network Management
Software Trap receiver
SNMP poll

SNMP poll
Agent

Agent
MIB

MIB

Managed device

Managed device

SNMP poll

SNMP poll

Agent

Trap

Agent

MIB
Managed device

MIB
Managed device

Figure 23. Network Management architecture using SNMP,
(Nuangjamnong C, 1998).

The communication protocol used for Telecommunications
Management Network (TMN) is the Simple Network Management
(SNMP) protocol which can access SNMP agents on devices such
as switches, routers, servers, and personal computers. SNMP
agents send their queries locally to the Management Information
Base (MIB) which contains information on running services,
applications, status of connections, and other useful information.
Poll (Get-Request, Get-Next-Request, Set-Request)
Get-Response

Trap

Figure 24. Network Management surrounding
41

�A Network management station (NMS) with the appropriate
network management software uses SNMP protocols to
periodically poll data from managed resources or to receive traps
if the predefined event occurs on the managed device.
Using SNMP protocols equipped with command sets, NMS can
collect information from MIB using different commands. SNMP
uses UDP and port 161 for poll requests, and port 162 for Traps.
Rmon Groups (1.3.6.1.2.1)
Statistic Group (1)

Traffic Matrix Group (6)

History Group (2)

Filter Group (7)

Alarms Group (3)

Capture Group(8)

Hosts Group (4)

Events Group (9)

Host Top N Group (5)
Table 6. RMON Groups (Cisco Remote Monitoring, 2018)

As mentioned, when it comes to networks with limited bandwidth
capacities, RMON is used to minimize the SNMP poll impact on
bandwidth resources. This mechanism allows periodic access to
already locally prepared reports about reports, most frequently
used protocols/application/devices and network resources, and
other useful information.

RMON-MIBs

Network
Management
Station

WAN Circuit

Figure 25. Simple RMON architecture
42

RMON-MIBs

�SNMP version 3 is equipped with the following set of commands:
get, getnext, set, getresponse, trap, getbulk, notification, inform,
report.

MIB OID

Device IP (local PC)
with SNMP agent

Requested data

Figure 26. Example query using iReasoning MIB Browser

Information in MIBs can be accessed using different tools. The
lightest ones are MIB query tools such as iReasoning, (shown
above) which is used for querying the system description of the
local PC.

Summary
Cyber and information components and infrastructures which use
the TCP/IP protocol suite provide common services such as VOIP,
NFS, DHCP, E-mail, Print, RAS, and Directory services. Services
43

�are supported by different network technologies such as BAN,
PAN, LAN, SAN, WAN, and MAN. Network infrastructures are
built using network communication devices such as Hubs, Bridges,
Switches, Routers, PBX and Firewalls, and protected using
intrusion detection and prevention systems. All network devices
can be managed by implementing network management solutions
such as the ISO Telecommunications Management Network (TMN)
model and an appropriate framework for network management.

Knowledge acquired
In this chapter, the reader can gain knowledge about network
topologies, network media, protocols and services, and network
devices and their interoperation. The reader can also learn about
network management purposes and activities that can help in dayto-day network operations meant to support cyber security.

Review questions
1. Explain the difference between active and passive
monitoring?
2. What is a TAP device and what is it used for?
3. What is a SPAN port and what is it used for?
4. Define the network functional model, and explain each
management area?
5. Explain the difference between polls and traps?
6. What is a communication port?
7. Describe weaknesses associated with communication
media?
8. Explain the role of MUA, MTA, and MDA in e-mail
communication?
44

�9. Explain the
operations?

difference

between

HUB

and

Switch

10. Explain the difference between infrastructure and the adhoc wireless communication model?
11. What is network topology?

Further readings
-

ISO/IEC 27000 family - Information security management
systemshttps://www.iso.org/isoiec-27001-informationsecurity.html

-

TCP/IP vs. OSI: What’s the Difference Between the Two
Models?
https://community.fs.com/blog/tcpip-vs-osiwhats-the-difference-between-the-two-models.html

-

Network
Topology
https://study.com/academy/lesson/how-star-topologyconnects-computer-networks-in-organizations.html

-

Communication Media (Data Communications and
Networking)
http://what-when-how.com/datacommunications-and-networking/communication-mediadata-communications-and-networking/

-

Communication
device
https://www.computerhope.com/jargon/c/communicationdevices.htm

-

Network Taps, Regenerator Taps, and Tap Aggregators
https://www.ixiacom.com/products/network-tapsregenerators-and-aggregators

45

�-

What
Is
a
Firewall?
https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/products/security/firewalls/
what-is-a-firewall.html

-

What
is
IDS
and
IPS?
https://www.juniper.net/us/en/products-services/whatis/ids-ips/

-

Network Management System: Best Practices White Paper

https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/support/docs/availability/highavailability/15114-NMS-bestpractice.html
-

46

What’s on Your Network? The Need for Passive Monitoring
http://www.tomsitpro.com/articles/network_monitoringnetflow-it_security-networking-snmp,2-561-2.html

�3. Cyber security landscape

Chapter abstract
Chapter goals: To explain core information security principles, to define
cyber security incidents and motivations, to present common cyber
security threats, to define cybercrime, to present different malicious
software and distinguish passive from active attacks, to explain what is
fraud and present the deep and dark web, and to present tools used, such
as TOR, and their operations. Finally, to explain penetration testing
principles and ethical hacking techniques and tools.
Learning outcomes: Acquiring knowledge of information security and
understanding the aspect of information security related to cyber security.
Raising awareness of cyber threats and possible mitigations and
strengthening organisation resilience using ethical hacking techniques.

Fundamental aspects of cyber and information security
The fundamental aspects of information security are usually
divided into Confidentiality, Integrity, Availability, Authenticity,
and Non-Reputability. Because information can be stored and
transferred in different shapes, its security depends on the security
of tools, utilities, people, hardware, software, and means of
transfer. All of them are considered information assets, and are
subject to fundamental security aspects. As stated in the
introduction, ISO 27000 27000 (ISO 27001:2013, ISO 27005:2008, and
other) standards consider Confidentiality, Integrity, Availability as
the fundamental aspects of information security, whereas some
other formal approaches and authors (Vigila et al., 2015) consider
47

�Authenticity, and Non-Reputability as important aspects for
managing information security.
Information
security
principle
Confidentiality

Integrity

Availability

Description
core
Information assets can be electronic, non-electronic, or
spoken. Information can be stored or can be transferred
over communication links. In any state, the confidentiality
of information can be jeopardized if not protected.
Information can be changed or destroyed by an
unauthorized person or information assets can be
destroyed. This is connected to integrity principles of
information security. That is why all information
transferred over communication lines and stored on hard
disks and other media has to be protected so that integrity
is guaranteed by technical and organisational mechanisms
and internal controls.
Information and information assets have to be protected so
that they are available for access and use. Information
processing facilities have to be protected so that the
business is resilient to minor and major possible outbreaks
due to internal or external impacts.

Authenticity

Authenticity has to guarantee the truthfulness of the origin
of information.

Non-Repudiation

This principle is related to the authenticity of information
so that the creator originator of specific information cannot
deny that specific information originates from a specific
person.

Table 7. Information security core principles (ISO 27001:2013 and Vigila et al.,
2015)

Cyber security incidents and motivations
Financial theft, access to resources, competitive advantage
(economic, political), personal grievances, vengeance, intellectual
or other curiosity, mischief, personal or group attention
(CNSCENTER, 2000), and fraud, are some of the most common
reasons for cyber and information security criminals to conduct
their criminal acts. In all attacks, it is clear that the attackers have a
specific goal which depends on motivations. Attackers have
48

�dangerous and destructive goals of stealing money and data, or
destroying the victim’s data and other digital resources, as well as
some less dangerous goals motivated by curiosity, intellectual
challenge, or learning about system resources
Because of potential destructive consequences, every attempt or
preparation for attack has to be seriously considered by examining
all the early indicators of unpatched equipment, uncontrolled areas
of infrastructure, lack of monitoring logs, or unexpected events in
the area of administration.
Many organisations can survive cyber and information security
attacks due to their nature and position explained below, but many
privately owned companies are not that lucky and their businesses
get terminated or seriously damaged. On a personal level, it is
almost certain that individuals responsible for cyber and
information security will be object of disciplinary or other legal
action.
Common cyber threats
It is clear that cyber threats affect different victims, including
individuals, corporations, and critical and vital national
infrastructures. There are different types of threats used for
different purposes.
Cybercrime is a connected criminal activity which uses digital
technology to commit criminal activity such as ransomware, data
theft, and virus creation and distribution. These types of attacks are
performed by individuals or groups.
Cyber industrial espionage is performed against corporations and
institutions with the goal of stealing data and producing damage.
Cyber warfare is usually conducted on critical state infrastructure,
including such examples as the Stuxnet (2010), (Mueller P. and
49

�Yadegari B., 2012) virus, or attacks on Iranian or Estonia’s critical
national infrastructure (Iasiello E, 2013).
Malicious software – history and types
As explained by Microsoft, (2003) malware is short for malicious
software which includes viruses, macro viruses, worms, Trojans,
logic bombs, ransomware, rogue adware, adware, and spyware.
Malwares are created to infect as many computer resources as
possible, to perform specific tasks such as stealing data, deleting
data, or even stealing money. Malicious software has its roots in
automated organisations proposed in John von Neumann's article,
"Theory of self-reproducing automata“(Von Neumann, J., and Burks,
Arthur W., 1966)
A Virus is malicious program able to replicate itself with the goal of

infecting other files after it is executed. Viruses can affect computer
systems in different ways, such as file deletion, change, or sending
spam mails. The concept of self-replicating software was proposed
"Theory of self-reproducing automata“(Von Neumann, J., and Burks, Arthur
W., 1966)

Macro viruses appeared in mid-nineties with the goal of infecting
Microsoft files created in Word, Excel, and other Microsoft created
documents.
Worm, as a term connected to computers, was first mentioned in
The Shockwave Rider, written by John Brunner (Brunner J., 1975).
Brunner used the word "worm" for a program which can propagate
through a computer network by itself. The first worm that was
spread over the Internet was created by Robert Morris (Eisenberg
T.et al, 1989).
Below is a table created based on Wikipedia (2018) with a short
history of software related to malicious software.

50

�1949
1971
1973
1974
1975
1981
1983

1986
1987
1988
1989

1990
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1998
1999
2000
2001

2002
2003

John von Neumann's article on
the "Theory of self-reproducing
automata“ published.
Experimental
self-replicating
program The Creeper.
Michael
Crichton
movie
Westworld mentions the concept
of a computer virus.
The Rabbit (or Wabbit) virus
ANIMAL
Elk Cloner
The term "virus" is coined
by Frederick Cohen in describing
self-replicating
computer
programs.
The Brain boot sector virus is
released.
Vienna virus, Lehigh virus,
Jerusalem virus, SCA virus,
Christmas Tree EXEC,
The Morris
worm,
created
by Robert Tappan Morris,
Ping-Pong virus, CyberAIDS and
Festering Hate Apple ProDOS
AIDS Trojan, the first known
ransomware, Ghostball,
Vienna and Cascade, Form
viruses,
The Michelangelo virus
Leandro or Leandro &amp; Kelly and
Freddy Krueger
OneHalf
The first Macro virus, called
"Concept"
"Ply" Boza, Laroux, Staog the first
Linux virus attacks Linux
machines
CIH virus
The Happy99 worm, The Melissa,
The ExploreZip worm, The Kak
worm
The ILOVEYOU worm, The
Pikachu
The Anna Kournikova, Sadmind
worm, The Sircam worm, The
Code Red worm, The Nimda
worm, The Klez worm
The Simile virus, Mylife
The SQL Slammer worm,
Graybird is a trojan horse, ProRat
trojan horse, and worms: The
Blaster, The Welchia (Nachi), The
Sobig, Swen worm, The Sober,
Agobot, Bolgimo

2004

2005
2006

2007
2008

2009
2010

2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017

2018

Bagle, The MyDoom worm, The
Netsky worm, The Witty worm,
The Sasser worm, Caribe or
Cabir, Nuclear RAT backdoor
trojan, Vundo, or the Vundo
Trojan, Bifrost, Santy,
Zotob, The Zlob Trojan
The Nyxem worm, OSX/Leap-A
or
OSX/Oompa-A,
Brontok,
Starbucks,Stration or Warezov
worm
Storm Worm, Zeus
Mocmex is a trojan, Torpig
Trojan
horse,
Rustock.C,
Bohmini.Ar trojan, The Koobface
computer worm, Computer
worm Conficker
W32.Dozer, Daprosy Worm,
Source code for MegaPanzer
Waledac botnet, The Psyb0t
worm is discovered, Alureon
Trojan, Stuxnet, a Windows
Trojan, "VBMania", Kenzero
SpyEye and Zeus, The Morto
worm, the ZeroAccess rootkit,
Duqu is a worm
May: Flame or Flamer, sKyWIper,
and Skywiper, Shamoon NGRBot
The CryptoLocker Trojan horse,
The Gameover ZeuS Trojan,
Linux.Darlloz
The Regin Trojan horse
The BASHLITE, Linux.Wifatch
Ransomware Locky, Tiny Banker
Trojan, Mirai
The WannaCry ransomware
attack, The Petya (malware)
attack, Kedi RAT (Remote Access
Trojan)
Spectre and Meltdown Flaws

Table 8. Short timeline of major malicious software appearance based on
Wikipedia (2018) information

51

�Trojan is a program that was first created in 1975 as a nonmalicious program. In 1989 the first known ransomware Trojan
was created (Lord N., 2018). In the late nineties, Trojan was used to
create backdoors on computer systems which were then used by
attackers to exploit systems and system resources.
Spyware are programs that infect computer systems and collect
information about user behaviour with the goal of offering
products or steal data such as usernames, passwords, and bank
account details.
Logic bombs can be software on their own or incorporated into
existing applications. They are software that accomplishes
malicious intents when specific conditions are met. A typical
example would be when a disgruntled programmer incorporates
malicious software into the existing organisation’s application that
deletes files or do other harm to organisation’s information
technology resources when the following criteria in the database is
met: „programmer’s name and surname“ is locked as a result of
termination from the company (CISA 2015, pp. 349).
Ransomware is a malware that encrypts user’s files and on behalf
of the attacker request ransom to be paid for a key to decrypt the
encrypted files Cowing J. (2015).

Passive and Active attacks
Passive attacks are used to intercept communication between two
ending nodes which participate in communication. Passive attacks
are different across wired and wireless networks, since for wired
networks a tap device which is physically placed on a network
segment is needed to the capture packets, whereas for wireless
networks appropriate software and hardware with antenna is
needed. The goal of passive attacks is gathering specific
information, such as passwords and data in transit. That is why the
52

�main objective of passive attacks is to target confidentiality of
information in transit (CISA 2015, pp 380).
Active attacks include active actions meant to harm specific
systems by intruding in or interrupting system operations. Whilst
the goal of passive attack is to jeopardize confidentiality only,
active attacks target integrity (change of data and information),
availability, and confidentiality as well (CISA 2015, pp. 350).
Masquerading
Masquerading is an active type of attack by presenting the identity
of somebody else with the goal of accessing resources in an
unauthorised way by impersonating people or machines (CISA,
2015. pp 350).
Man in the middle attacks
Man in the middle attacks (MITM) target the communication
between two communicating entities by secretly relaying and
possibly altering that communication. In MITM, the attacker is
attempting to play an active part in the communication (CISA 2015,
pp. 349).
Message modification
Message modification is an active type of attack where the attacker
changes the content of the message, such as a bank invoice or
payment transaction (CISA 2015, pp. 350).
Eavesdropping
Eavesdropping is a passive type of attack where the attacker
gathers information from network with the goal of acquiring data
related to login and password sessions (usernames and
passwords), e-mail content, and keystrokes. This type of activity
provides the attacker with credentials to access sensitive resources
(CISA 2015, pp. 348).
53

�Intrusion attacks
Intrusion attacks are active types of attacks where the goal is to
make an active impact on the targeted system, such as to find
system passwords and manipulate (change or steal) data.
Packet reply
This type of attack has attributes of both active and passive attacks.
It is conducted by listening (sniffing) to the network traffic and
recording it, which is the passive aspect of the attack. The active
aspect of the attack is to send the recorded network traffic, usually
for the purpose of authentication, sending encrypted passwords,
and to continue to use authenticated sessions avoiding decrypting
passwords (CISA 2015, pp. 350).
Spoofing
Attackers use this method to masquerade their presence on the
network as somebody else by falsifying data, such as the IP
address, to gain privileges or data such as passwords (CISA 2015,
pp. 349).
Pharming
This type of attacks redirects requests from a web site to other web
sites which were prepared by the attacker. For example, a web site
which looks like the exact or genuine web site of the attacked
person’s client web site. The attacker’s intention is to steal user’s
credentials such as username and password. This type of attack is
possible through changing local host files or DNS settings (CISA
2015, pp. 350).
War dialling
In War dialling, the attacker is checking the availability of modems
that can be reached through Remote Access Systems (RAS)
available via Public Switched Telephone Networks (PSTN),

54

�Integrated Switched Digital Networks (ISDN), and through remote
access devices such as modems and routers.
War driving
Similar to War dialling, except this type of attack is used for
attacking wireless networks by using equipment (laptop, wireless
antenna, software) and vehicles to gather information on weak
encryption and open wireless access networks by driving around
buildings and other physical objects (CISA 2015, pp. 351).
War walking
An identical type of attack as war driving where instead of using a
vehicle, the attacker walks around a building with the equipment
for identification of vulnerable access points (CISA 2015, pp. 351).
War chalking
War chalking is the process of marking buildings and physical
objects to notify of open wireless networks. Purpose of war
chalking is to notify other users who wants to use wireless access
to the Internet at no cost (CISA 2015, pp. 351). .
Code injection
Code injection relies on program errors which, when they receive
data or code from the attacker, change the course of execution.
There are different types of code injection techniques, such as SQL
injection, HTML script injection, Dynamic evaluation
vulnerabilities, Object injection, Remote file injection, Format
Specifier Injection, and Shell injection.
Interrupt attacks
These types of attacks are used to insert specific and malicious
routines in running operating systems using system calls to
interrupt other operating system executions (CISA 2015, pp. 349).

55

�DoS, DDoS, flood attacks
These kinds of attacks have the goal to disrupt or block all
communication to and from the attacked network.
Denial-of-service attack (DoS attack) is an active type of cyberattack with the goal of making the targeted system temporarily
unavailable. . A typical approach is to flood the targeted network
with large amounts of packets or misuse the TCP/IP stack with syn
flood attacks that misuse the vulnerability of the three-way
handshake mechanism. Typical attacks include ICMP ping flood,
Smurf attack, Syn flood attack, and Teardrop attack.

Internet
Attacked system

Attacker

Figure 27. DoS attack

A special type of DoS attack is permanent DoS or PDoS or plashing,
with the goal of damaging hardware and in this way prolonging
the recovery of the attacked system.
Distributed Denial-of-service attack (DDoS attack) is a special
type of DoS attack where many machines on the Internet are used
to amplify the strength of the attack. Machines used to amplify the
attack are called agents or botnets.
56

�Compromised host

Compromised host

Internet
Attacker

Compromised host

Attacked system

Compromised host

Compromised host

Figure 28. DDoS attack

Flood attacks
Flooding the network with large amounts of traffic disables the
communicative channels of the attacked network, and as such,
these attacks are DoS or DDoS variants.
Protocol specific attacks
Due to a weak protocol design and implementations during a
course of time, different types of attacks were launched.
DNS attacks
Most prominent attacks on DNS services include DNS spoofing or
hijacking, DNS rebinding, DNS Denial-of-service attack, and DNS
Amplification attacks.
DNS attacks are common ground or starting point for other types
of attacks because DNS services provide users with vectors and
directions of communication similar to routing protocols. The
difference is that DNS is easier to attack because it relies on enduser insecurity such as unpatched operating systems, un-updated
57

�antivirus software, weak firewall and/or intrusion detection
policies, and/or lack of network segmentation.
ARP attacks
ARP protocol are part of the TCP/IP protocol suite of Ethernet
types of network, which is used by network operating systems to
determine the MAC address of a device’s IP address so that
communication on the LAN segment can be initiated and finished
with the communication peer.
When initiating IP communication, the computer needs the MAC
address of the device so that the sending and receiving device can
communicate using data link layers. Once the initiating computer
learns the MAC address of the computer with which
communication is needed, as is the case when using DNS service
on DNS servers, communication continues using IP protocols.

1
1
ARP request

6
3

IP Traffic
IP Traffic
ARP reply
ARP reply

2

5
Attacker IP Traffic
IP Traffic

2

ARP request
1 ARP request

Gateway

ARP request

4

1
DNS Sefver

Figure 29. ARP operation and ARP attack

Attackers use techniques called ARP spoofing, ARP poison
routing, or ARP cache poisoning, which is a subtype of MITM
attacks which are used to send ARP replies to confuse the
58

�communication initiator and to “persuade” the communication
initiator that traffic should pass via the attacker’s computer.
Implementing this scenario, the attacker is able to record traffic and
get passwords, credit card numbers, and even change user data in
packets.
DHCP attack
As previously explained, the DHCP service provides dynamic IP
addresses. Attackers install malicious software on infected
computers or use other techniques or even hardware to offer IP
addresses to computers that require the IP address. The malicious
DHCP service and server where it is installed is called a rogue
DHCP server attack. The attacker sends the victim an IP address,
subnet address, default gateway address, and IP addresses of DNS
and WINS servers, which allows the attacker to hijack all
communication initiated from the victim’s computer.
Alteration attacks
This kind of attack is used to modify data or program codes, thus
affecting the integrity of data.
Botnets
Botnets are networks of compromised computers running
malicious software to amplify attacks such as DDoS, spam, and
other massive types of attacks.
Fraud
Fraud is defined by the Oxford dictionary as: “wrongful or
criminal deception intended to result in financial or personal gain”

59

�Figure 30. Fraud triangle

Opportunity to commit fraud is created by the following
conditions: misuse of privileges and entrance into the system, lack
of established monitoring activities, collaboration between coworkers, and established four eyes controls, as well as keeping
access rights through changing organisation positions (Sandwith
L. 2006).
Rationalisation represents another part of the fraud triangle. It is
based on a self-morally defensible justification for fraud which
could be in the form of medical or social programs available for all
citizens (Sandwith L. 2006).
Motivation or pressure to commit fraud, as the third part of the
triangle arises when there is a need for additional income,
expensive health interventions, nursing care, and previously undetected frauds (Sandwith L. 2006).
Salami
This type of a fraud attack uses the technique of taking small
amounts of money from accounts and sending it to other accounts
60

�which usually belongs to attackers. This type of attack is common
in banking institutions (CISA, 2015, pp. 350.).
Phishing
Phishing is cyber fraud whose goal is identity theft. This type of
attack is performed when criminals send messages which seem
genuine to victims (their bank e-mail address, or other legitimate
organisation addresses) persuading them to submit confidential
information such as credentials or other information (CISA, 2015,
pp.349).

Deep Web, Dark Web
Search engines such as Google, Bing, YouTube, Wikipedia, and
other similar services, represent available Internet resources which
are used for legitimate purposes. On the other hand, resources
available through the Deep and Dark Web (2018) are generally
considered illegal, offensive, and in focus and interest of law
enforcement agencies for detecting, preventing, and documenting
criminal activities.
Deep Web
The phenomenon known as Deep Web contains illegal information
such as web sites with medical records, published scientific
reports, and papers stored and transferred from services which
require a special fee for accessing those files.
Dark Web
The Dark Web is a part of the Internet used for drug trafficking,
illegal information, political protests, and private communications
usually supported with certain types of browsers such as The
Onion Router (TOR, 2018) which encrypts traffic.

61

�Dark Net
The Dark web uses Dark Net to transfer data and route traffic over
the Internet. This network uses hidden services available only
through web browsers such as TOR. As explained on the TOR
website, TOR protects its users against “traffic analysis.”

Figure 31. TOR (2018)

Figure 31. shows TOR’s automatic configuration for using proxy
servers before the web request reaches the Internet.
Many sources claim that TOR was developed by the United States
National Security Agency (NSA) (Lee T. B. 2013) to provide covert
communication for activists in countries with censored Internet.
However, it was used against NSA when WikiLeaks (Lee T. B.
2013) published a great amount of data which were transferred
using TOR.
TOR as a technology is used as a service for anonymous
communication by many on the Internet.

62

�TOR operation
TOR operates through three steps explained on the TOR support
web-site.

Figure 32. TOR modus operandi, TOR (2018)

In the initial phase, the local TOR browser searches for TOR nodes
from the directory server. Afterwards, it selects a random path for
each request. Communication between TOR nodes is encrypted,
while only the final hop (communication the between TOR node
and the requested destination) is not encrypted.
This type of operation was used before in P2P communication
where resources from other nodes were used by Napster (2018),
Gnutela (Mitchell B. 2018), Donkey (2018), and other similar tools.

Penetration testing, ethical hacking, and intrusions
Intrusion attacks on a critical infrastructure are common security
problems in the cyber space. Critical infrastructures must be on the
Internet to offer services to users. Because of that, it is necessary to
test critical infrastructures against potential intrusion attacks as
they would be performed in reality. These types of security tests

63

�are called penetration testing and ethical hacking, and are
performed by ethical hackers.
Ethical hackers, known as white hat hackers, are security
professionals who know how to find and exploit vulnerabilities in
different systems. They must have same technical knowledge and
skills as malicious hackers, better known as black hat hackers.
Ethical hackers use skills in a legitimate and lawful way to try to
find vulnerabilities and propose improvements before black hat
hackers can get there and try to break in.
Penetration testing and ethical hacking became very important for
organisations because they improve security. As such, educational
institutions designed courses in an attempt to teach their students
ethical hacking skills. One of the best known ethical hacking
programs is the Certified Ethical Hacker (CEH, 2018) certification
scheme developed by EC-Council, which is an organisation
headquartered in Albuquerque, New Mexico available at
https://www.eccouncil.org.
Penetration tests follow similar or same steps as real intrusions.
There are three major approaches to penetration testing (CEH,
2018) explained below.
White box – in this approach, an ethical hacker has access to a lot
of information, such as IP addresses, running services, and
operating systems, available applications, etc.
Grey box – some of the information is not given to the ethical
hacker, but rather it is left for the test team in order to discover
information needed for intrusion.
Black box – no information is given to the ethical hacker, but it is
his task to discover information needed for intrusion.

64

�Common intrusion steps, techniques, and tools
Figure 33. shows that in the time scale, there are more points which
come before successful intrusion. This knowledge can be used to
detect intrusion attempts and stop intrusion. It is very important to
know that there were months of cyber-attack preparations in cases
explained in previous sections. Preparation points could be
detected earlier if proper malware protection, intrusion detection,
fraud detection, and event monitoring activities exist.
In order to protect the local system, it is clearly important that early
signs of malicious attempts be recognised. Bejtlich (2004) suggests
common points in time when cyber-attacks could be recognised.
Reconnaissance is used to gain knowledge of the targeted system
state which includes but is not limited to hardware platforms,
operating systems, open ports, and running services.

Reconnaissance
Exploitation, Abuse, Subversion, System breach
Reinforcement
Consolidation

Pillage

Figure 33. Common steps of intrusion attacks (Bejtlich, 2004)

65

�Performing ethical hacking, penetration testing, or executing a
cyber-attack is a similar act to engaging in war. Following this
logic, it is crucial to gain knowledge on strengths and weaknesses
of the targeted system.
Network port scanning and war driving for wireless networks (a
technique known as war dialling in the modem communication
era) provide information for attackers or ethical hackers about
open and closed ports, versions of operating systems, encryption
used for wireless networks, and used certificates.
During the reconnaissance phase, attackers collect valuable
information on the security state of any system. This phase in
ethical hacking terminology uses methods such as footprinting,
port scanning, and enumeration. In this phase, collected data can
reveal system vulnerabilities which can be used against the system.
The main aim of this is to improve the approach used by the
attacker with which system vulnerabilities can be exploited.
Tool
groups.google.com
Whois (whois.net or arin.net)
SamSpade
(http://www.majorgeeks.com)
White Pages (www.whitepages.com)
OWASP Zed Attack Proxy (ZAP)
(https://www.owasp.org/)

Function
Search for posting technical or nontechnical newsgroups.
Can be used as IP address gathering
tool.
Application for gathering domain
information.
Retrieve phone and address
information
Discovers web server information
and possible vulnerabilities.

Table 9. Short timeline of major malicious software appearance Reconnaissance
and foot printing tools

In the reconnaissance phase, the attacker or the ethical hacker uses
non-intrusive and intrusive methods to gather information of
physical and logical location of the targeted system.

66

�Furthermore, the tester or attacker gains knowledge on open ports,
operating systems, and available resources, such as shares on the
network, user names, groups assigned on the network, and the last
time the user logged on.
Sometime, an organisation’s (which is object of recognisance and
footprinting) web-site can reveal phone numbers, responsible
persons, employees’ biographies, as well as the e-mail address
format which can be used to guess e-mail addresses of other
employees.

Figure 34. Reconnaissance phases (CEH, 2018)

The SampSpade (2018) tool can be used to investigate Zone
Transfer, SMTP Relay Check, Scan Addresses, Crawl website,
Browse web, Fast and Slow Traceroute, S-Lang command, Decode
URL, and Parse e-mail headers. It can give an attacker information
about users and a system or particular host which is object of the
attack, or it can be used to examine a server or web site security on
the Internet.

67

�Figure 35. SamSpade (2018)

Another tool used for reconnaissance purposes is Nmap/Zenmap
(2018), available for Linux and Windows systems.

Figure 36. Nmap / Zenmap (2018)

Google site groups.google.com can be used as a tool to find
corporate employees’ information.

68

�Whois is a commonly used tool for gathering IP addresses and
domain information that attackers can use.

Figure 37. Whois output for www.mit.edu

ZAP (2018) can be used to discovered web server information and
find possible vulnerabilities and weaknesses.

Figure 38. ZAP (2018)

All gathered information can be used for social engineering
purposes or the technical exploitation phase for the next phase of
the attacks.
69

�Figure 39. Wireshark window with captured traffic

Tools such as Wireshark (2018) can be used to sniff network traffic
from wired network segments closed using Tap devices or
Switches and SPAN ports.
Wireless networks, compared to wired networks, make surveying
network traffic easier. This is because there is no possibility to
physically protect the network flow, and the only protection is the
encryption mechanism. Based on the historical overview, weak
implementations of encryption mechanisms lead to vulnerabilities
exploited by attackers.
Software such as Kismet (2018) in combination with Wireshark
(2018) can be used to analyse captured wireless traffic.

70

�Figure 40. Kismet (2018)

System hacking or exploitation phase include abuse, subversion,
or system breach which comes after the reconnaissance stage (foot
printing, port scanning, and enumeration) because reconnaissance
phase has to provide enough information for abuse.

Figure 41. System hacking steps (CEH, 2018)

In the abuse stage, an attacker is able to log on to legitimate services
by utilizing previously used techniques such as brute force or

71

�password cracking. Password cracking is one of the earliest
hacking techniques for accessing privileges.

Passwords

Passive Online
Wire sniffing

SAM
NTLM
Kerberos

MITM
Active
online
Replay
Hash injection
Trojan – Spyware
Guessing
Phishing

Figure 42. Password cracking techniques (CEH, 2018)

Passwords have to be stored somewhere in order to authenticate
users. They are encrypted for security reasons. One approach
towards identifying one’s password represents stealing the
password or entire password files for decryption. This process is
known as password cracking.
Password cracking can be used as a password strength checking
tool in ethical hacking, technical testing, or for audit purposes.
Common tool used in this approach are John the Ripper (2018),
Cain &amp; Abel (2018), and other similar tools.

72

�Figure 43. Cain &amp; Abel (2018) captured traffic

Subverting phase of system mechanisms has the goal to perform
actions needed for escalating privileges which go into the
reinforcement stage.
In the reinforcement stage, an attacker is able to use additional
privileges by installing Trojans and opening backdoors for easier
access, which is then used in the consolidation phase that leads to
pillage, where attackers steal sensitive data and misuse other
system privileges, hiding files, and covering tracks.

Summary
The cyber and information security landscape is changing
constantly, and old threats become more sophisticated, while
criminal motivations remain the same. The aforementioned
passive and active attacks are realised through specially crafted
intrusion attacks, code injection, DoS and DDoS, man in the middle
attacks, malicious software, hacking tools, fraud, and phishing.
Efforts in securing the infrastructure can be invested through
73

�testing security via performing common intrusion steps as part of
penetration testing, and ethical hacking techniques explained in
this chapter.

Knowledge acquired
In this chapter, it is possible to learn about ethical hacking steps
and tools, cyber security threats and different attacks on
application and communication protocols, and malware threats
and the history of malware.

Review questions
1. Explain common steps of intrusion attacks.
2. What is ethical hacking?
3. What is TOR?
4. Explain what is the Deep and Dark Web.
5. Explain the elements of the fraud triangle.
6. Explain ARP, DHCP, DNS attacks.
7. Explain the difference between DoS and DDoS attacks.
8. Explain the difference between Virus and Trojan.
9. What is system hacking?
10. What tools can be used for traffic sniffing on wireless
and wired networks?
11. What are password cracking techniques?
12. Name and explain three approaches for penetration
testing.

74

�13. What is fraud?
14. Explain common cyber threats.
15. What is spoofing?

Further readings
-

Cyber Attacks – What are the Financial Impacts?
https://www.countercept.com/our-thinking/how-muchshould-you-care-about-cybersecurity/

-

Six Cyber Threats to Really Worry About in 2018
https://www.technologyreview.com/s/609641/six-cyberthreats-to-really-worry-about-in-2018/

-

A Brief History of Malware — Its Evolution and Impact
https://www.lastline.com/blog/history-of-malware-itsevolution-and-impact/

-

The Difference Between Passive &amp; Active Attacks on a
Computer
https://www.techwalla.com/articles/the-differencebetween-passive-active-attacks-on-a-computer

-

Distributed Denial of Service Attacks – The Internet
Protocol
Journal;
Volume
7,
Number
4
https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/about/press/internetprotocol-journal/back-issues/table-contents-30/dosattacks.html

-

What is the difference between the dark web and the deep
web?
https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-difference-betweenthe-dark-web-and-the-deep-web

-

Ethical Hacking Academy https://academy.ehacking.net/
75

�-

76

Hacker Tools Top Ten Our Recommended Pentesting Tools
and Hacking Software for 2018 https://www.concisecourses.com/hacking-tools/top-ten/

�4. Cyber security incident cases

Chapter abstract
Chapter goals: To present cyber incident cases and discuss presented
incidents in appropriate timelines to show that proactive detection and
prevention of incidents would have been possible if standards and controls
had been implemented.
Learning outcomes: Knowledge of cyber incidents and important breaking
points in time when incidents could be proactively resolved.

Chapter security incidents
Only cyber incidents with a great loss are reported in media.
Almost every year, we face multiple cyber incidents which marked
the cyber security arena. Graphics in this section show only a few
causes of failures, and explain when it would be possible to spot
attacks on time by using Minard's idea (Mason B., 2017) of
graphical documentation of unfortunate events.

Central bank of Bangladesh
According to Reuters (2016), and (Krishna N. Das, and Jonathan
Spicer, 2016), hackers tried to steal $951 million through multiple
bank account orders using primarily the SWIFT messaging system
in the first two weeks of February 2016. The attack was well
prepared via installed malware on the inside network of the
Central Bangladesh Bank, and sent via e-mail to one of the
77

�employees with access to the SWIFT system. In media reports, it
has been revealed that cheap communication switches were used
to connect different network parts. The attack began in late
Thursday afternoon on February 4th, when attackers started
transferring the $951 million Reuters (2016) and (Krishna N. Das,
and Jonathan Spicer, 2016). The attackers accessed almost 1 billion
dollars in the account of Central Bangladesh Bank located in New
York. Federal Employees stopped the transfer of $850 million by
asking the Central Bangladesh Bank for more information about
the transaction. However, SWIFT messages never reached the
recipient because attackers diverted all messages from New York
Fed to the Central Bangladesh Bank, which was not aware of the
attack. The rest of the money ($101 million) was not stopped, so it
was transferred via Rizal Commercial Banking Corporation
(RCBC) in Sri Lanka. However, $20 million which was supposed to
go to the bank account in the Philippines was stopped by the
Deutsche Bank because they noticed a spelling mistake.
Thursday 4th of
February 2016

Friday 5th of
February 2016

Weekend 6th and 7th Monday 8th of
of February 2016
February 2016

Tuesday 9th of
February 2016
$31 million

$951
million
35
orders
Via
SWIFT

$101
million
5 orders

$850
million
blocked
total of
30 orders

No malware
detection

$81
million
total of 5
orders

$29 million

$21 million
$20 million
blocked intended
to NGO Shalika
Foundation

No malicious
traffic detection

Figure 44. Time Scale of Central Bangladesh Bank Heist 2016 (Reuters,
2016) and (Krishna N. Das, and Jonathan Spicer, 2016)
78

�Attackers misspelled the name of the recipient of the NGO called
“Shalika Foundation,” and wrote “Fundatioin” instead of
“Foundation.”
The rest of the money ($81 million) was sent to bank accounts in Sri
Lanka. On Friday morning of February 5, Central Bangladesh Bank
noticed a problem with the SWIFT system, because it was not
possible to send or receive messages via the SWIFT system. In
addition to that, printing any kind of payment orders was not
possible. However, personnel did not pay much attention to that
because in the Central Bangladesh Bank it is a custom that after
Friday midday, employees who pray do not have to come back to
work after prayer.
On Saturday morning of February 6th, it was clear for the Central
Bangladesh Bank SWIFT operation personnel that something was
wrong, thus, they tried to contact New York Fed. However, it was
not possible to reach it because it was a non-working day for New
York Fed personnel.
On Monday of February 8th, the Central Bangladesh Bank realized
that money was transferred to the Philippines, but it was not
possible to contact the bank personnel there. The reason is because
in Philippines, February 8th is a holiday and a non-working day.
The stolen money was transferred to RCBC bank account and
further sent mostly to casinos in Philippines (Krishna N. Das, and
Jonathan Spicer, 2016).
No one was arrested or charged for this theft.
The Bangladesh police partially blamed SWIFT because there was
no written document which explains what should be done to
safeguard the local SWIFT infrastructure. The Bangladesh police
admitted that information technology equipment of the Central
Bank of Bangladesh was outdated. After the attack, SWIFT visited
the Central Bank of Bangladesh and refused to take any
79

�responsibility for the incident, stating that the Central Bank of
Bangladesh had to resolve recognised technical and organisational
security issues on its own.
As a result of this incident, Bangladesh’s central bank governor,
Atiur Rahman, resigned (Reuters, 2016). in one of the largest cyberheists in history and Bangladesh’s Prime Minister, Sheikh Hasina,
accepted his resignation one month after the incident on March 15,
2016.

Retail chain Target
As reported in the media (Vijayan, 2014), in the beginning of 2014,
a large retail chain – Target was the victim of a large scale cyber
breach, when data from up to 40 million credit and debit cards of
Target’s shoppers was stolen. In the cyber-attack analysis reports,
it was revealed that the Target retailer failed to properly segregate
systems which handled sensitive payment card data from the rest
of the internal network.
Friday 15th of
November 2013

27th of November
2013

hackers tested malware on
small number of cash
registers

No malware
detection

Sunday 15th
December 2013

of

40 million credit and
debit cards data stolen

No malicious
traffic detection

Figure 45. Time Scale of Target retail chain Cyber Attack, 2013

It was reported (Vijayan, 2014), that hackers made an intrusion
through the supplier’s network, and that of the air conditioning
systems maintenance company. This company had access to
Target's network with the goal of maintaining equipment and
80

�remotely monitoring energy consumption and temperature in
Target's stores. Attackers gained access to Target's network on
November 15, 2013, and began collecting data and uploading and
installing malware on Target's network, or more specifically on the
company's Point of Sale (POS) systems. Before the execution of this
large-scale attack, which happened between November 27 and
December 15, 2013, hackers tested the malware on a small number
of cash registers. When they were certain that they will be able to
steal a large amount of data, they carried out the attack on about 40
million debit and credit cards of Target’s customers from the U.S.,
Brazil, and Russia.

Sony Entertainment Company
On November 24, 2014, a group of hackers called "Guardians of
Peace" (GOP) (GOP, Paul 2014) released 100 TB of confidential
information from the Sony Entertainment Company. A member of
GOP claimed that they had the access a year before they released
data. The Sony Entertainment Company received warnings from
hackers on November 21st, demanding "monetary compensation."
However, this e-mail was ignored and treated as spam.
Attackers were never brought to justice and early investigations
suggested that hackers from North Korea were to blame because
Sony was about to release the comedy film “The Interview,“ about
an assassination attempt against Kim Jong-un. Later analysis
suggested some other sources of attacks. Figure below shows that
users of Sony Entertainment Company were informed about the
attack on November 24, 2014. They could have seen a warning
message on their screens or web-sites of the services which they
used. The confidential information contained personal information
of employees, social security numbers, personnel family
information, passwords of Hollywood stars, employees’ medical
confidential reports, confidential information about new movies
and music projects, released movies that were still not published,
contracts already signed and contracts that were prepared.
81

�Figure 46. "Guardians of Peace" (GOP), Paul 2014

Sony reported that direct financial loss was $15 million. That
money was spent only for the analysis and collection of
information on losses.
Intrusion started
in 2013

Hackers intrude into system
and tested malware

No malware
detection

Friday 21th of
November 2014

Monday
24th
November 2014

Hackers sent blackmail
warning

100 TB data released

of

No malicious
traffic detection

Figure 47. Time Scale of Sony Entertainment Company Cyber Attack,
2014

82

�Reputation risk that includes data loss of partners, users,
relationships, and other indirect losses, was immeasurable.

Hillary Clinton’s presidential campaign
The US presidential campaign from 2016 still causes tremors in
internal and external politics. One of the major topics was Senator
Clinton's leaked e-mails. Senator Hilary Clinton ordered her
engineers to set up an e-mail server at her home in New York, while
she was the U.S. Secretary of State.
Clinton's private e-mail system development began in June 2008,
when an Apple technician installed and configured an e-mail
server in Clintons' New York Chappaqua home (FOX NEWS,
2016).

Private mail
system set up for
governmental use
2008

No malware
detection

Confidential
governmental
information
stored on private
mail server

Email
server
configured to use
google as backup
server 2012

Hackers realised
confidential e-mail
2013

November 2015 FBI
started with official
investigation

No intrusion
detection

Mails were not
encrypted

Figure 48. Time Scale of Private mail server usage for exchange of
confidential governmental information

Two domains were created with a unique DNS names, namely
presidentclinton.com &amp; wjcoffice.com. Later that same year, Bryan
83

�Pagliano, an IT specialist, was hired to set up an additional e-mail
server. In 2009, Hilary Clinton was appointed as the Secretary of
State. In March 2009, Bryan Pagliano and Justin Cooper transferred
all e-mails from the Apple computer to a newly established e-mail
server (Clinton Email Investigation Timeline, 2018). The old Apple
computer that served as e-mail server was given to a household
staff member as a personal computer (Clinton Email Investigation
Timeline, 2018).
In November 2012, the private e-mail server was configured to use
Google as the backup server, and a month later, investigators asked
Hilary Clinton if she used a personal e-mail for classified e-mails
(CNN, 2016), (Clinton Email Investigation Timeline, 2018).. From
media reports it was obvious that e-mails were not encrypted, nor
were they digitally signed. The reason was the lack of complying
with available security standards and the best practices for official
e-mail communication.
In March 2013, a hacker named "Guccifer" widely distributed emails sent to Clinton (The Smoking Gun, 2013). In November 2014,
a special committee asked Clinton to release e-mails about terrorist
attacks on the U.S. Consulate in Benghazi, so she released e-mails
from her private and official .gov e-mail accounts (Kalvapalle R,
2016). On 10th of July 2015, the FBI formally began an investigation
to determine whether a private e-mail server was used for storing
or transmitting classified information by Hillary Clinton and her
associates. In that way they wanted to check if she violated federal
criminal statutes. On 26th of July 2015, Clinton denied that she used
her private server to send classified e-mails while she was the
Secretary of State (Scott E., 2015):
"I am confident that I never sent nor received any information that
was classified at the time it was sent and received,"
On September 23, 2016, FBI released 200 pages (LoBianco T., 2016)
from its investigation of Clinton's private e-mail server. On 28th of
84

�October, the story about Clinton's private e-mail server culminated
when FBI director James Comey announced (Silver N., 2017) his
letter (Comey Letter, 2016), where he stated that e-mail server
contains “emails that appear to be pertinent to the investigation.“

Figure 49. Comey Letter (2016), (Silver N., 2017)

This letter had a significant impact on Senator Clinton's
presidential election outcome since indicator polls (Silver N., 2017)
85

�of popularity declined and never recovered again. The US
presidential election was held 12 days after Comey's letter, on
Tuesday, November 8, 2016.

Figure 50. Polls show Clinton’s popularity declined after FBI director
letter was released (Silver N., 2017)

Webstresser
On April 2018, law enforcements from Britain, Croatia, Canada,
Serbia and other countries (Cimpanu C., 2018) arrested
administrators responsible for establishing the web service
webstresser (webstresser.org and webstresser.co) in 2015.
This service whose monthly subscription costed 15 Euros provided
its users the ability to launch DDoS attacks on selected Internet
targets. Even inexperienced users could have used this service to
launch devastating attacks (Eyerys, 2018).

86

�It was assumed that attackers used botnets to amplify attacks on
the targeted system. The service was looking for botnets which
were later used to initiate the attack on specified targets.
2015

2016

Webstresser services
has started

2018

2017

Different types of attacks
were offered as service

Webstresser was
shut down

Figure 51. Webstresser existence time line

This is one of the newer types of hacking attacks where malicious
attacks offered hacker's web service.

Figure 52. (Eyerys, 2018)

According to Washington Post (Shaban H., 2018), this service had
136,000 registered users who performed 4 million attacks. As a
result of the law enforcement action, webstresser hardware was
87

�seized in the United States, the Netherlands, and Germany. The
mastermind of this hacker service was a 17-year-old Croatian
citizen from a small town near the Croatian capital, Zagreb, with
other hackers from Serbia, Canada, and Britain (Shaban H., 2018).

Figure 53. Locked http://webstresser.org/ address accessed 01.07.2018

Law enforcements locked one of the webstresser's web pages.

88

�Summary
All the mentioned threats and attacks in this chapter resulted in
numerous known and unknown cyber and information security
incident cases. Fewer well-known cases covered by media and
presented in this book happened to the Central Bank of
Bangladesh, the retail-chain Target, the Sony Entertainment
Company, and during the 2016 US Presidential Campaign.
Presented cases could have been avoided if appropriate cyber and
information security controls had been implemented, monitored,
and audited. In previous chapters are given explanations of
security of cyber and information system components that play
important role in shaping cyber security landscape. Core of the
explained cases have roots in improper configuration and
administration of information components. In some cases such as
Webstresser case we can understand that criminals were not aware
of consequences after they create technical solutions for automated
attacks for any person who is willing to start attack. It is clear that
general knowledge of cyber security is problem as well because
attack organisers in many cases think that they will not be caught.

Knowledge acquired
In this chapter, it is possible to gain knowledge about well-known
cyber incident cases reported by many resources and media, which
further show why cyber security must be treated as one of the top
priorities.

Review questions
1. What are key attack motivations in presented cases?
2. How could e-mail and data encryption help in
preventing hacker attacks in presented cases?
3. For which of presented cases could antimalware
protection prevent attack escalation?
89

�Further readings

90

-

India bank hack 'similar' to $81 million Bangladesh central
bank heist https://www.reuters.com/article/us-city-unionbank-swift/india-bank-hack-similar-to-81-millionbangladesh-central-bank-heist-idUSKCN1G319K

-

Before massive Bangladesh heist, New York Fed feared such
cyber
attacks
https://www.reuters.com/article/usbangladesh-heist-fed-insight-idUSKCN0XX28F

-

Bangladesh to sue Manila bank over $81-million heist
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-cyber-heistbangladesh/bangladesh-to-sue-manila-bank-over-81million-heist-idUSKBN1FR1QV

-

Bangladesh Bank Attackers Hacked SWIFT Software
https://www.bankinfosecurity.com/report-swift-hackedby-bangladesh-bank-attackers-a-9061

-

The Bangladesh Bank Heist: Lessons in Cyber Vulnerability
http://theonebrief.com/the-bangladesh-bank-heist-lessonsin-cyber-vulnerability/

-

Target cyber breach hits 40 million payment cards at holiday
peak
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-target-breach/targetcyber-breach-hits-40-million-payment-cards-at-holidaypeak-idUSBRE9BH1GX20131219

-

Specialty retailer becomes target of cyber-attack
https://www.chainstoreage.com/article/specialty-retailerbecomes-target-cyber-attack/

-

Supply Chain Attacks on Retail – What Happens When
Trusted
Channels
Can’t
be
Trusted?
https://www.rsaconference.com/blogs/supply-chain-

�attacks-on-retail-what-happens-when-trusted-channelscant-be-trusted
-

The Untold Story of the Target Attack Step by Step
https://aroundcyber.files.wordpress.com/2014/09/aoratotarget-report.pdf

-

Target Confirms Point-of-Sale Malware Was Used in Attack
https://www.securityweek.com/target-confirms-point-salemalware-was-used-attack

-

Sony to pay staff $8m compensation over cyber-attack
http://www.bbc.com/news/entertainment-arts-3493148

-

The Attack on Sony https://www.cbsnews.com/news/northkorean-cyberattack-on-sony-60-minutes/

-

Clinton campaign 'hacked' along with other Democratic
groups
http://www.bbc.com/news/election-us-2016-36927523

-

How Russia-linked hackers stole the Democrats' emails and
destabilised
Hillary
Clinton's
campaign
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-11-04/how-russianshacked-democrats-and-clinton-campaign-emails/9118834

-

Exclusive: Clinton campaign also hacked in attacks on
Democrats
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-cyber-democratsinvestigation-exc/exclusive-clinton-campaign-also-hackedin-attacks-on-democrats-idUSKCN1092HK

-

2016 Presidential Campaign Hacking Fast Facts
https://edition.cnn.com/2016/12/26/us/2016-presidentialcampaign-hacking-fast-facts/index.html

91

�-

https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-andtech/news/webstresser-internet-ddos-europol-ncacybersecurity-a8321751.html

-

WebStresser.org site linked to global cyberattacks is shut
down
https://www.irishtimes.com/news/world/europe/webstress
er-org-site-linked-to-global-cyberattacks-is-shut-down1.3478112

-

DDoS-for-Hire
Service
Webstresser
Dismantled
https://krebsonsecurity.com/2018/04/ddos-for-hire-servicewebstresser-dismantled/

-

Video for Webstresser operation:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-a9roduqf4I

92

�5.

Cyber security controls

Chapter abstract
Chapter goals: To present the Risk management process, define internal
controls, and control objectives for which standards such as the ISO
27000 family 27000 (ISO 27001:2013, ISO 27005:2008, and other) and
COBIT 5 framework can be implemented. Furthermore, the chapter
explains and distinguishes between preventive, detective, corrective,
general, and specific controls.
Learning outcomes: Gaining knowledge on risk management processes
and the type of standards and frameworks which can be used for the
establishment of internal controls to manage cyber security.
Understanding different types of controls.

Information technology usage related to Cyber risk
In the present business environments, Information Technology (IT)
is used to improve business operations and performances. Usage
of IT in everyday operations is susceptible to unavoidable risks
explained in the previous chapter.

Risk management
Every organisation has to manage risks associated with
information technology usage. This process contains steps such as
risk analysis, risk assessment, and risk treatment.
93

�Risk analysis
Risk analysis helps in the identification of threats, vulnerabilities,
likelihood, and the impact of unwanted events.
Risk assessment
In the risk assessment phase, information assets (people,
information, services, hardware, software, network, site,
organisation, and intangibles) have to be identified. Identified
threats, vulnerabilities, likelihood, and impact have to be
determined and calculated for the recognised information assets.
The following phase is the risk treatment plan, and it has several
strategies.

Figure 54. Risk management process

Risk treatment
Risk treatment can be done using the following strategies:


94

Risk mitigation through implementation controls to reduce
risk.

�

Risk acceptance by accepting risk without taking any kind
of control.



Risk avoidance through avoiding the execution of an action
which can cause risk.



Risk transfer through transferring risk to somebody else,
e.g. suppliers of web hosting service, taking insurance, etc.

Internal controls
Goals of internal controls have a dual nature – what should be
achieved and what should be avoided. Internal controls are
implemented through organisational policies, procedures,
practices, and organisational systematization and structure with
the goal of managing organisation's risks. Internal controls are
applicable at all levels of any organisation. Management is
responsible for strategic decisions in introducing internal controls
into the organisation culture. There are three classes of internal
controls: preventive, detective, and corrective.
Purpose of internal controls
The essential logic of audit is to investigate whether internal
controls exist, how it is implemented, and whether it is monitored
on regular basis. If internal controls do not exist, internal auditors
suggest their implementation.
A typical risk in business is the neglecting of the need for internal
controls when new technology is introduced, since all technology
is implemented with the goal of having faster or cheaper
operations. In essence, all technology has the risk of usage, and
those who implement new technology usually overlook all
associated risks. This is because they are preoccupied with core
needs and benefits of implemented technology and do not consider
all associated risk with the specific technology.

95

�There are eight review areas Information Systems Audit and
Control Association (ISACA), (CISA 2015, pp. 295) which can also
be used in auditing:
1. Enterprise architecture and auditing
2. Hardware audit
3. Operating system audit
4. Database audit
5. Network infrastructure audit
6. Information system operation audit
7. Scheduling audit
8. Problem management reporting audit
Control objectives
Information system control objective has to be established with the
goal to provide assurance that business objectives will be reached
through selection of applicable controls which will be
implemented and monitored.
Internal control requirements could be established to fulfil some or
all aspects:

96



Confidentiality



Integrity



Availability



Effectiveness



Economy

�

Efficiency



Non-repudiation



Reliability



Accountability

Internal controls should use a goal for criteria which can be an
accepted standard and technique, best practice, or framework.

Figure 55. CIA Triad

ISO 27001
The above requirements are common for standards such as ISO
27001 (ISO 27001:2013) which acknowledges three aspects of
information security, namely Confidentiality, Integrity, and
Availability (CIA).
Implementation of the information security using the ISO 27001
standard (ISO 27001:2013) suggests that Information Security
Management System (ISMS) has to be established and maintained
97

�through the Plan-Do-Check-Act (PDCA) process of improvement
(ISO 27001:2013).
In the Plan phase, the project border agreement is established, thus,
physical locations and systems are included or excluded form the
scope. Afterwards, the overall information security policy is
established and approved by the top management. The following
stage entails the collection of information from information assets
through process mapping and GAP analysis.

D

P
Project border
agreement

Implementation
of controls

Training and
awareness

Information
security policy
approved

Statement of
applicabiloity

Record
collections

Process mapping

Asset evaluation

Audit

C

GAP analysis

Risk assesent

Improvements

A

Figure 56. ISMS PDCA cycle

In the Do phase, risk assesent (ISO 27005:2008 standard for security
risk management is developed suitable for ISO 27001:2013
implementation)
is conducted through asset evaluation
vulnerabilities, threats, likelyhood, and impact. After this stage,
statement of applicability is created with a goal to approve plan for
98

�implementation of controls. Last come training and awareness and
collection of records.
In the Check phase, information security audits are performed,
folowing the previosly explained General scheme of the auditing
process.
After detecting space for improvements in the check phase, the Act
phase ensures that improvements are actually made. The purpose
of the PDCA cycle is to constantly improve system performances
through constant improvements. ISMS as a system can be certified
by the external certification body which will additionally improve
the system performance.
3E's
The 3E's approach KPMG (2018) of excellence is used for
measuring performances of any organisation: Economy – reducing
costs of inputs, Efficiency – the right effort allocation, Effectiveness
–achieving determined goals.
Lowest cost for acquisition of
resources keeping quality level

Economy

Efficiency

Effectiveness

Obtaining maximum outputs
from given minimum of inputs

Ratio of obtained outputs or
goals compared to planned

Figure 57. Business performance measurement using 3E’s
(KPMG, 2018)
99

�COBIT 5
ISACA developed Control Objective for IT (COBIT 5) framework
with five major principles (ISACA, 2012):
1. Meeting stakeholders’ needs – every organisation exists due to
its stakeholders, thus business must use IT to meet stakeholders’
needs.
2. Covering enterprise end-to-end – covering not only IT but all
issues which encompass everyone and everything.
3. Applying single integrated framework – because there are many
IT related frameworks, COBIT 5 aligns with all other frameworks
and standards.

1. Meeting
stakeholders
needs

5. Separting
govrenanace
from
management

4. Enabling
holistic
approach

COBIT
5

2. Covering
enterprise
end-to-end

3. Applying
single
integrated
framework

Figure 58. ISACA's COBIT5 (ISACA, 2012):

4. Enabling holistic approach – COBIT 5 defines seven categories of
enablers which support governance and management of enterprise
(CISA 2015, pp.154.):

100

“Principles, Policies, and Frameworks

�

Processes



Organisational Structures



Culture, Ethics, and Behaviour



Information



Services, Infrastructure, and Applications



People, Skills, and Competencies”

5. Separating governance from management – Governance and
management, according to COBIT 5, have a recognisable
distinction.

Preventive controls
Controls are established to avoid errors and interruptions, to
segregate duties by implementing mechanisms such as four-eye,
and to monitor for potential problems in their early stages.

Detective controls
Detective controls have to be established to detect malicious
events, failures, and errors.

Corrective controls
Corrective controls are used to correct errors, interruptions,
detected problems, and bottlenecks.

General controls
General controls are controls related to all parts of organisation,
such as controls related to physical and logical security policies,
accounting, proper use of assets, and tracking transactions, as well
as administrative controls, and other related controls (CISA 2015,
pp. 45.).
101

�Specific controls
General controls can be used to create specific controls. From the
perspective of information system controls with a goal of
managing information and cyber security following areas can be
used to create specific controls:


Business continuity and disaster recovery planning;



Access to information resources such as databases,
configuration files, and communication devices;



BYOD policy.

Specific controls examples
Following are few examples of areas which appear as particularly
interesting for the implementation of specific controls.
Business continuity and Disaster recovery related controls
Business continuity and disaster recovery management addresses
availability of information and information assets.
Physical security, utilities, and environment are needed so that
equipment and employees are safe at work. Controls have to be
established, so that security perimeters and backup
communication links exist, and that backup power supply from
secondary grid is available.
Disaster recovery planning is related to hardware, software, and
infrastructure which support business operations (Everest D., et.
al., 2008).

102

�Business continuity planning is related to business operations and
relies on infrastructure, software, and hardware (Everest D., et. al.,
2008).
All mentioned aspects are needed to give resilience to business
operations in a specific business surrounding. Before the digital
age, business operations were possible without hardware and
software. However, in today’s business world, business is not
possible without computers. As such, DRP has to support BCP
(Everest D., et. al., 2008).

Figure 59. BCP DRP triangle

Risk assessment is a crucial part of BCP / DRP management process
where Recovery Time Objective (RTO) and Recovery Point
Objective (RPO) have to be determined (Everest D. et al, 2008). RTO
represents how quickly operations have to be restored, while RPO
shows the amount of unavailable operations and data, which could
consequently cause problems.

103

�Based on the risk, appetite management is willing to spend
additional money for the implementation of strategies that specific
technologies and facilities can support.
Every business process has to be supported by appropriate plans
with conducted Business Impact Analysis (BIA).
BCP / DRP plans have to be tested at regular intervals, and
recognised weaknesses in test process have to be resolved.
All the aforementioned areas are fields for the implementation of
internal controls to monitor effectiveness of implementations.

Disruption

RTO

RPO
Time

Time

No time
No time Hardware Hardware No or
frame for frame for available available minimal
Hardware Hardware
with
loss
delivery
delivery
limited
but facility but facility processing
exist
exist
power

Redundant
system,
active
clustering

Confidence

Hot
site,
hot
stand
by

Service
bureau

Cold Replacement
site,
cold
stand
by

Strategies
Money spent

Figure 60. RTO / RPO relation

Bring Your Own Device (BYOD) controls
The Bring Your Own Device (BOYD) policy implements new types
of security risks. The reason is because new personal devices are
104

�brought by people who use systems on production networks which
are allowed by policies of many organizations. Tests for security
weaknesses and risks have to be rigorous for this type of devices.
This task is not easy because personal devices are not installed
uniformly and usually have different software such as operating
systems and application. These devices have to be taken care of by
preventing infection with malware, and by making sure they are
patched.
A BYOD device has to be configured so that when it is lost all data
is deleted and information confidentiality remains intact.
If appropriate controls are not deployed, usage of these kinds of
devices can increase security risks and produce negative
consequences for the system in which they are brought.

Summary
Cyber and information security controls are needed as a
management tool for setting up internal control mechanisms. This
has to be done through appropriate risk management, such as risk
analysis, risk assessment, and risk treatment. For this purpose,
control objectives have to be defined. Control objectives can be
classified as preventive controls, detective controls, corrective
controls, general controls, or specific controls using available
standards such as ISO 27001 (ISO 27001:2013), NIST, and COBIT 5.

Knowledge acquired
In this chapter, it is possible to gain knowledge about risk
management process, different approaches for conducting risk
assessment, and different risk management approaches.

Review questions
1. Explain the risk management process.
2. What are risk treatment options?
105

�3. What are internal controls?
4. What are control objectives?
5. Explain PDCA cycle and for what purpose it is used.
6. Name possible preventive controls.
7. What can be a specific control?
8. Name possible specific controls.
9. What is BCP?
10. What is DRP?
11. Explain the meaning of RTO and RPO.
12. What is the risk analysis?
13. What are five major principles of the COBIT5 framework?

Further readings

106

-

About
Risk
Management
https://www.theirm.org/the-risk-profession/riskmanagement.aspx

-

Risk
Treatment
https://www.enisa.europa.eu/topics/threat-riskmanagement/risk-management/current-risk/riskmanagement-inventory/rm-process/risk-treatment

-

5
Types
of
Risk
https://simplicable.com/new/risk-treatment

-

INTERNAL
CONTROLS
http://www.accaglobal.com/gb/en/student/exam-support-

Treatment

�resources/fundamentals-exams-studyresources/f1/technical-articles/internal-controls.html
-

ISO/IEC 27000 family - Information security management
systems
https://www.iso.org/isoiec-27001-informationsecurity.html

-

Economy,
Efficiency,
http://www.en.valuemex.com/node/23

-

ARE YOU USING THE 3 E’S OF MANAGEMENT TO
MEASURE
YOUR
PERFORMANCE?
https://www.jhmriskmanagementservices.co.uk/blog/areyou-using-the-3-es-of-management-to-measure-yourperformance/

-

What
is
COBIT
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y8kqh9q3Jwg

-

Business Continuity and Disaster Recovery for InfoSec
Managers
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/book/978155558339
2

-

BRING YOUR OWN DEVICE... HOW TO STAY IN
CONTROL
https://www.clearswift.com/sites/default/files/documents/
pdf/bring-your-own-device-how-to-stay-in-control.pdf

Effectiveness

5?

107

�6. Cyber security audit

Chapter abstract
Chapter goals: To present the three lines of defence model, organisation
responsibilities in security governance, and cyber security audit. To
present audit objectives, types of audits, and risk-based auditing. Chapter
also aims to explain audit risk, and different types risk-based approaches
such as qualitative and quantitative. Furthermore, it will introduce audit
risk types and structure of audit reports which includes condition,
criteria, cause, and effect of Internal Auditing. Based on ISACA
guidelines, it is possible to perform cyber security audit for following
areas: hardware, operating systems, databases, network infrastructure
audit, information systems, scheduling audit, and problem management
reporting.
Learning outcomes: Gaining knowledge of three lines of defence model and
the role of internal audit in the organisation defence. Becoming acquainted
with audit risk types and risk associated to audit process. Understanding
areas and topics that can be object of auditing.

Organisation defence model
To perform audit of computer network infrastructure which
supports organisation processing facilities, it is necessary that
Internal Auditor (IA) has a good knowledge of the operation of
equipment explained in previous chapters. An auditor has to ask
questions verbally or in a documented way using questionnaire,
and check the list to determine state of information security in the
organisation so that she or he can provide audit assurance state of
the information security. Organisations such as financial
institutions (commercial services and regulatory organisations),
military capacities, nuclear power plants which are considered as
108

�vital infrastructures can bring whole countries and regions into
hard and challenging incident situations. That is why it is
important to have well-defined lines of defences in digital
surroundings at all levels. If the object of protection is
communication lines, it is necessary to have more defence
perimeters such as demilitarised zones, internal and external
firewalls, network intrusion detection systems, host intrusion
detection systems, and anti-malware software. In addition to
engineers, multiple levels of defence precautions, specific
organisational measures, and defence perimeters are needed. The
well-known three lines of defence (TLoD) model implements a
systematic approach to manage risk.
The Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA, 2013) recognised three lines
of defence as following:


First line of defence: Operational management



Second line of defence: Risk management and compliance
function



Third line of defence: Internal audit

The three lines of defence model
There is a well-known saying which says: “divide and conquer”.
This saying is applicable to governing of cyber and information
security. Explanation and modelling of the three levels of defence
mechanisms acquired all over the globe and brought by IIA (2013)
are given in the following paragraphs.
The first line of defence: Operational management
The first line of defence are managers, because they control and
manage risks. Furthermore, managers implement internal controls
and perform corrective actions. Operational management is placed
in the first line of defence, because all operations that are supported
109

�for example by IT functions must be conducted at this level.
Additionally, this defence includes controls against active and
passive attacks, anti-malware protection, and definition and
reinforcement of password policies.

Figure 61. The three lines of defence model (IIA, 2013)

The second line of defence: Compliance and Risk Management
Goal of this defence level is to provide risk management
framework by identifying risk areas and manage risk. This defence
level is also responsible for monitoring effectiveness of internal
controls, and adjusting internal operations with laws and
regulatory requirements.
The third line of defence: Internal audit
In this model, internal audit is placed in the third defence line, and
its function is to provide independent assurance using
international standards. In its operations, internal audit function
has to provide reports to audit committee and governing board
about state of specific business area that was an object of audit.
110

�Purpose of internal audit is to provide independent assurance
regarding business operations and according to IIA (2013) to:


Evaluate and report on degree of alignment;



Evaluate and report on corporate risk management
practices and results;



Evaluate and report on efficiency;



Evaluate and report on degree of effectiveness of measures
in place and metrics in use;



Evaluate and report on efficiency, effectiveness or resource
management;

According to ISACA, auditors’ task at management level is to
evaluate and report on degree of alignment, while in strategic
alignment, their task is to evaluate and report on corporate risk
management practices and results. In the risk management process
auditors need to evaluate and report on efficiency and to evaluate
and report on degree of effectiveness of measures in place and
metrics in use in organisation value delivery. Furthermore, their
role in performance measurement is to evaluate and report on
efficiency or resource management, and to evaluate and report on
effectiveness of assurance processes performed by different areas
of management compared to other organisational roles, as it is
shown in Table 10.

Organisation responsibilities in security governance
Below is Brotby, (2006): in Information Security Governance:
Guidance for Information Security Managers.

111

�Management
level
Board
Directors

Strategic
Alignment
Require
demonstrabl
e alignment

Executive
management

Institute
processes to
integrate
security with
business
objectives

Steering
committee

Review and
assist
security
strategy and
integration
efforts
Ensure that
business
owners
support
integration.
Develop the
security
strategy,
oversee the
security
program and
initiatives,
and liaise
with business
process
owners for
ongoing
alignment.
Evaluate and
report on
degree of
alignment.

CISO/
information
management

Audit
executives

Risk
Management
Establish risk
tolerance
Oversee a
policy of risk
management
Ensure
regulatory
compliance.
Ensure that
roles and
responsibilities
include risk
management in
all activities.
Monitor
regulatory
compliance
Identify
emerging risks,
promote
business unit
security
practices and
identify
compliance
issues.

Value
delivery
Require
reporting
of security
costs.

Performance
measurement
Require
reporting of
security
effectiveness.

Resource
Management
Oversee a
policy of
knowledge
management
and resource
utilization.

Process
Assurance
Oversee a
policy of
assurance
process
integration.

Require
business
case
studies of
security
activities.

Require
monitoring
and metrics
for security
initiatives

Ensure
processes for
knowledge
capture and
efficiency
metrics.

Provide
oversight of
all assurance
functions
and plans
for
integration

Review
and advise
on the
adequacy
of security
initiatives
to serve
business
functions.

Review and
advise
whether
security
initiatives
meet
objectives.

Review
processes for
knowledge
capture and
dissemination
.

Identify
critical
business and
assurance
providers.
Direct
assurance
integration
efforts

Ensure that risk
and business
impact
assessments
are conducted,
Develop risk
mitigation
strategies.
Enforce policy
and regulatory
compliance.

Monitor
utilization
and
effectivene
ss of
security
resources

Develop and
implement
monitoring
and metrics
approaches,
and direct and
monitor
security
activities.

Develop
methods for
knowledge
capture and
dissemination
, and develop
metrics for
effectiveness
and
efficiency.

Liaise with
other
assurance
providers.
Ensure that
gaps and
overlaps are
identified
and
addressed.

Evaluate and
report on
corporate risk
management
practices and
results

Evaluate
and report
on
efficiency.

Evaluate and
report on
degree of
effectiveness
of measures in
place and
metrics in use.

Evaluate and
report on
efficiency or
resources
management.

Evaluate and
report on
effectivenes
s of
assurance
processes
performed
by different
areas of
managemen
t

Table 10. Relationship matrix in organisation structure of security governance
Brotby, (2006):

Table 10. shows the way in which relationship in organisation
structure of security governance could become clearer.

112

�Cyber security audit
Cyber and information security audit is important for adding value
to organisation, conducting audits, and reporting management on
findings from conducted audits.
Performing an audit
Audit has to be performed through predefined steps with the goal
of providing provide evidence of findings gathered during audit.

Plan the audit
Audit 1

Audit 2

Scheduled
audit (n)

Audit n

Start audit

Conduct
audit

Complete
audit

Scheduled next
audit

Generate
report

Share

Figure 62. General scheme of audit process, (ISACA CISA 2015 pp. 42.)

Following steps are part of an audit process:


Plan the audit engagement, by considering audit goals and
risks associated with the object of audit.



Build the audit plan with detailed goals of audit in a time
line.
113

�

Plan the execution according to an audit plan.



Monitor project activity through reporting progress of an
audit.

Audit objectives
Audit objectives are goals that are set up for each audit project and
based on the selected audit type.
Types of audits
An information security auditor can perform different types of
audits which are briefly explained below:

114



Compliance audits are related to well-known standards
such as ISO 27001, PCI DSS, HIPPA, and other related
standards of specific industry and field of operation.



Financial audits are performed to test correctness of
financial reports.



Operational audits are performed to assess specific controls
of organisation processes, e.g. controls in implementation of
BYOD policy.



Administrative audits are performed to assess operational
productivity effectiveness of an organisation.



Information security audits can be used to assess the state of
overall information security management system through
an entire organisation. If Information Security Management
System (ISMS) is implemented, limited or overall scope of
the system can be an object of auditing. One of the examples
is conducting limited audit scope to access rights, password
policies, and segregation in networks where different
checks and tests can be performed against infrastructure to
provide assurance of implemented controls on network and

�operating systems which represent a foundation of every
infrastructure.


Specialized audits can be conducted to assess third party
services by using special standards and regulations related
to specific industry.



Integrated audits can include more types of audit, such as
financial, operational, and information system and security
audit.

Financial
Audit

Operational
Audit

Information system
and security audit

Figure 63. Integrated audit, (ISACA CISA 2015, pp. 62.)



Forensic audits are performed after detecting fraud or a
crime (CISA 2015, pp. 391.). Their main goal is to collect
evidence in controlled environment and deliver it for review
by authorities such as police and courts of law. Typical steps
to conduct forensic investigations with a goal to prepare
evidence admissible at courts are shown in Figure below.

115

�Figure 64. Digital forensic investigation (Ademu I. O., et al, 2011)

Risk-based auditing and audit risk
When selecting audit goals, it is necessary to understand what is
feasible in the risk-based audit’s conduct of risk assessment
Chartered Institute of Internal Auditors (2014).
Risk assessment can be carried out through qualitative, semiquantitative, or quantitative based risk assessment.
Qualitative risk-based approach
The simplest and most frequently used risk assessment approach
is the qualitative risk-based approach. It uses description markings
for likelihood and impacts. Furthermore, it utilizes checklists and
ranking with three or four levels of risk: high, medium, and low (or
very high, high, medium, low). It is based on a subjective opinion.
Semi-quantitative risk-based approach
Instead of using descriptive values such as high, medium, and low,
these descriptions are also given numerical values. Thus, total
weight for a specific area can be aggregated to calculate different
factors and monitor outcomes.
Quantitative risk-based approach
This type of risk-based approach uses numerical values from
different sources, such as the number of malware infections,
number of unpatched operating systems, specific log events,
number of attacks, and the time between patch release and patch
implementation.
116

�Audit risk types
Audit carries its own risks, some of which are briefly described
below (CISA 2015, pp.48):


Inherent risk existing in specific business environments,
related to activities, processes, or technology used without
any supervision, is considered audit risk.



Control risk is associated with the risk that errors will not be
detected on time due to no supervision or as a result of not
conducting check-ups.



Detection risk is associated with the risk that a specific error
will not be recognised by an auditor.



Overall audit risk associated with the risk that an error will
not be detected by an auditor.

Evidence collection
There are different techniques to collect evidence (CISA 2015, pp.
39.):

 through structured interviews with relevant personnel


using questionnaires,

 using checklists
 reviewing the organisation structure,
 reviewing policies,
 using relevant standards,
 reviewing documentations, system logs, and system
settings,
117

� observing business and employee performances
 control walk-throughs
 statistical and non-statistical sampling
 attribute sampling
 stop-or-go sampling
 discovery sampling
 variable sampling
Condition, Criteria, Cause and Effect of Internal Auditing
In the audit process it advisable to use the Condition, Criteria,
Cause and Effect approach (Watkins W., 2014) for the collection
and documentation of evidence, as well as for the presentation of
findings with audit recommendations.
Condition are pieces of evidence of that were found in the audit
process.
Criteria can be best practice, known ways of doing something, how
something should work, policy references, processes, and
standards.
Cause is the reason that caused the recognised condition.
Effect is the impact or risk recognised set by a condition, when
there are high probabilities of the condition being met, or the
condition has been met already.
As already explained, there are eight review ISACA (CISA 2015,
pp. 295) areas which can also serve as areas for cyber audit:
1. Enterprise architecture and auditing
118

�2. Hardware audit
3. Operating system audit
4. Database audit
5. Network infrastructure audit
6. Information system operation audit
7. Scheduling audit
8. Problem management reporting audit
According to ISACA, environment audit is relevant for
information systems and security audits, but is not relevant for
cyber security because it is out of the given scope. Here mentioned
are only a few issues related to environment audit in reference to
information system assets.
For each ISACA area of interest there is a set of operational controls
to be checked for which different standards were used, such as ISO
27001, NIST, COBIT5, and ISACA CISA (2015) guidelines. The list
below, which provides the operational control sets, can be
expanded with new risks recognised in the risk assessment process
and risk analysis phase.

Enterprise architecture and auditing
One of the first steps in auditing information system is to review
enterprise architecture, connections between branches, network
design, and other infrastructure components.

Hardware audit
When performing hardware audit, it is necessary to check if all
precautions are met to comply with available security controls
(CISA, 2015 pp. 300):
119

�-

Protect hardware by considering different levels of security
using security perimeters.

-

Have a designated owner for each hardware component.

-

Is the risk assessment for the critical infrastructure
performed for confidentiality, integrity, and availability?

-

Is maintenance performed at regular intervals specified by
the vendors?

-

Check if the BYOD policy is defined, and whether
information security principles are satisfied.

-

Separate power and communication cables, especially
copper communication cables, due to possible
electromagnetic interference.

-

Communication cables have to be protected with conduits.

Operating system audit
When performing operating system audit it is necessary to check if
all precautions are met in order to (CISA, 2015, pp. 297):

120

-

Restrict and block unauthorised logical access controls.

-

Prevent unauthorised physical or network access over IP
consoles to the system console.

-

Block capabilities which would enable an unauthorised
person to interact with and interrupt the system.

-

Maintain system patches and up-to-date system software.

-

Change default passwords.

�-

Is there documentation where changes (addition, deletion)
to access rights can be seen?

-

Block unsupervised usage of Universal Serial Bus (USB)
media.

When performing an operating system audit, is necessary to check
if all of the following precautions are met to comply with available
security controls connected to environment (CISA, 2015, pp. 297):
-

Establish contracts with external parties for tasks that
cannot be carried out with internal resources in process of
marinating information system.

-

Develop a mechanism to control access to critical
infrastructure rooms using CCTV camera, biometric door
locks, electronic door, or bolting door locks.

-

Have UPS and electric generators to support constant power
supply for computer and network infrastructure.

Database audit
When performing database audit, it is necessary to check if all of
the following precautions are met in order to comply with available
security controls (CISA, 2015, pp. 298.):
-

All tables and views exist in entity relations as separate
entities.

-

All access rights and roles are justified for users and groups

-

Password policy is established and a regular password
change policy is implemented.

-

Encryption is implemented as a result of the risk analysis.

121

�-

Copies of data on test environment are either masked or
encrypted.

Network infrastructure audit
When performing network infrastructure audit, it is important to
check if all of the following precautions are met in order to comply
with available security controls (CISA, 2015, pp. 299.):

122

-

Protect passive and active network components in safe
rooms, e.g. server rooms.

-

Have access control and video surveillance installed on
access points and inside server rooms.

-

Use MAC address filtering on switch ports.

-

Check whether system is configured to do the following:
change default passwords of active communication devices
on all devices, force personalisation usernames (every user
has a unique username), force password policy (remember
last five passwords, change password every n days, request
that passwords contain capital and small letters, numbers,
and special characters), request the change of password if it
is given to a third person, e.g. a maintainer, request an
immediate change of password and/or blocking of user
account if person who knew the password left the
organisation.

-

Use screen lock-out after specified time when there were no
interactions in the established session or log-on to system
resources (servers, routers).

-

Log-on attempts to administrators / supervisor accounts has
to be logged.

-

Check if all log reports are reviewed at a regular basis.

�-

Make sure that only authorised access is allowed to
computer resources, whether via network or stand-alone
devices.

-

Check if appropriate risk analysis is performed to determine
if encryption is needed for data in transit or data stored on
computer media.

-

Report when network devices and all computer
infrastructure are hardened, so that services and port which
are not used are strictly prohibited.

-

Implement segregation in
infrastructure with firewalls.

-

Implement intrusion detection systems which are updated
to recognise latest cyber and information security threats.

-

Have controls to prevent abuse of PBX for tapping,
eavesdropping (silent monitoring), traffic control, user
tracking, and fraud.

-

Document all IP addresses on interfaces.

networks

for

critical

Information system audit operation audit
When performing an operating system audit, it is necessary to
check if all of the following precautions are met in order to comply
with the available security controls (CISA, 2015, pp. 300):
-

Check if information classification is established.

-

Make sure that overall information cyber and information
security of the organisation is delegated by a single position
such as Chief Information Security Officer (CISO) or by
other person on the manager position.

123

�124

-

Implement encryption mechanisms in order to protect
personal data.

-

Implement segregation of duties. Table 11. Shows the
Segregation of duties matrix developed by ISACA (ISACA,
2015), where X indicates potential control weakness.

-

Have incident management system running.

-

Make sure that responsibilities for information security are
delegated to all employees.

-

Have backup and restore policies in place.

-

Implement four-eye principle, so that transaction cannot be
done by a single person.

-

Have patch management in place.

-

Record and monitor all logs at regular intervals to detect
potential incident and problems.

-

Have appropriate anti-malware policy and provide
appropriate anti-virus solution.

-

Have mechanisms and procedures to be able to reconstruct
events in cyber and information security incident cases.

-

Establish change management procedures, so that change
activities are performed in line with approved change
management procedures.

-

Report the restore test to confirm that all data can be
recovered and validated by data owner.

-

Establish regular practice of performing in-house security
tests and independent penetration testing.

�X
X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X
X
X

X
X
X

X
X

X

X

X

X

X
X
X

X
X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X
X

X

X
X

X

X
X

X

X
X

X

X

X
X

X

X

X

X

X
X

X

X

X
X

X
X
X

X

X

X

X
X

Quality
Assurance

X
X

System
programmer

Systems

X

Network

X

Database

Control group
Systems
analyst
Application
programmer
Help Desk
and Support
Manager
End User
Data Entry
Computer
Operator
Database
Administrator
Network
administrator
System
administrator
Security
administrator
Systems
programmer
Quality
Assurance

Security
administrator

Have adequate controls of logical access.
Computer
Operator

-

Data Entry

Have an overall cyber and information security awareness
education programme.

End User

-

Help Desk and
Support
Manager

Report that DRP and BCP plans are tested on a regular basis.

Application
programmer

-

Systems analyst

Establish Disaster Recovery Plans (DRP), and Business
Continuity Plans (BCP).

Control group

-

X
X

X

X

X

X
X

Table 11. Segregation of duties matrix (CISA 2015, pp. 116.)

Scheduling audit
When performing audit of job and personnel scheduling, it is
necessary to check if all of the following precautions are met to
comply with available security controls (CISA, 2015, pp. 301.):

125

�-

Business activities are scheduled.

-

All jobs are performed according to the schedule.

-

Persons who make changes must be authorized to make
changes.

-

Existing personnel supports scheduled business activities.

-

There is a priority list of critical applications and
infrastructure components that has to be recovered with
regard to Recovery Time Objective (RTO) and Recovery
Point Objective (RPO).

Problem management reporting audit
When performing an operating system audit, it is necessary to
check if all of the following precautions are met to comply with
available security controls (CISA, 2015, pp. 302.):
-

Functionality of a system allows problems to be reported.

-

There are responsible persons who monitor problems in the
system.

-

Mechanisms for resolving submitted reported problems
exist.

-

There are defined procedures for escalating recognised
incidents.

Timeline for cyber security audit
Because order of audits can help in a better organisation of findings
and the audit effectiveness, there needs to be a planned time scale
for cyber security audit (Figure below).

126

�Operating system audit

Network infrastructure audit

Hardware audit

Audit start

Audit Finished
Time

Environment audit

Database audit

Scheduling audit

Information system audit
Problem management reporting audit

Figure 65. Cyber security timeline audit

Every audit has limited resources, such as time, and auditors’
skills.
ISACA CISA (2015) guidelines and BCP / DRP triangle (Rouse M.,
2018), which has a specific order in establishing business
operations (DRP has to come first before BCP to support business
operations) are used for the timeline in Figure above.
First of all, environment and utility issues, followed by
infrastructure with hardware, operating systems, networking, and
data base audit need to be checked. Afterwards, information
system has to be audited for scheduling, problem and incident
management, and reporting.
Because of known limitations and possible unknown interruptions
and limitations in the audit planning phase, auditors have to
determine time windows for each phase. If possible, they should
predict the flow of events in the expected timeline.

127

�Duration of audit depends on complexity of organisation that can
be couple weeks or couple months.
The cyber security audit timeline can be seen as a workflow which
uses a set of audit practices and methods to collect information
required to complete the audit process. Each step in the workflow
might require looping, branching, and repetition of previous steps.
The Condition, Criteria, Cause, and Effect approach has to be used
to make a clear distinction between current or possible conditions
and effect/risk using criteria to detect the cause of condition.

Summary
Due to risk of cyber security incidents, it is necessary to perform
appropriate management tasks to protect information assets. One
important part of safeguarding information assets is to conduct
regular audits. Because all current or future business models
already are or will be supported by electronic ways of
communication and processing, cyber security is a crucial part that
has to be supported. As the third line of defence, audit is important
for the cyber security assurance. Audit needs to be planed
according to available standards, and audit objectives need to be
well defined. Before and during auditing, type of audit has to be
selected. To minimise human intervention in the process of
choosing the object of auditing, it is necessary to conduct riskbased auditing. In practise, there are three types of risk assessment
(Qualitative risk-based approach, Semi-quantitative risk-based
approach, Quantitative risk-based approach), which are related to
organisation maturity and to the risk-based management. Audit
process has audit risks which have to be acknowledged during
performing audits.
When auditing, it is wise to use already defined controls to
minimize risk of not detecting weaknesses. Additionally, it is
important to have a common point of reference which can be used
128

�by auditors and management or operational representatives of
organisation's unit which is the object of auditing. Without a
common ground reference and risk assessment based audit, one
might think that internal auditors reached particular findings and
requested internal controls, without understanding that they are
international standard requirements. Common ground or
reference point in auditing process is called criteria. Criteria are
used to compare auditing process with current process condition
in order to detect cause and define possible effects and risks.

Knowledge acquired
In this chapter it is possible to gain knowledge about cyber audit
processes.

Review questions
1. What are the three lines of defence model?
2. Explain the third line of defence: Internal audit.
3. Name steps of cyber security audit.
4. What are the types of audits?
5. What is an integrated audit?
6. Explain risk-based auditing and audit risk.
7. Explain risk-based approach?
8. What are audit risk types?
9. How can Condition, Criteria, Cause, and Effect of Internal
Auditing help in writing audit reports?

129

�Further readings

130

-

THE THREE LINES OF DEFENSE IN EFFECTIVE RISK
MANAGEMENT
AND
CONTROL
https://na.theiia.org/standardsguidance/Public%20Documents/PP%20The%20Three%20Li
nes%20of%20Defense%20in%20Effective%20Risk%20Mana
gement%20and%20Control.pdf

-

Governance
of
risk:
Three
lines
of
defence
https://www.iia.org.uk/resources/auditcommittees/governance-of-risk-three-lines-of-defence/

-

What
is
an
Integrated
Audit?
https://rmas.fad.harvard.edu/faq/what-integrated-audit

-

INTEGRATED
AUDITING
https://www.iia.nl/SiteFiles/IIA_leden/Praktijkgidsen/PG%
20Integrated%20Auditing[1].pdf

�7. Conclusions

Chapter abstract
Chapter goals: To summarise book goals and review gained knowledge.
Learning outcomes: Gain understanding of cyber security and audit
landscape.

Cyber security overview
Cyber security should be the core of every business which relies on
digital technologies. This strong dependence is reflected through
success of companies which use latest technologies and
incorporate them in their everyday business operations and
models which represent only one side of business associated with
the usage of information systems in the cyber space.
Another side of digital technology is related to cyber incident cases
presented in this book – Central Bank of Bangladesh, retail-chain
Target, Sony Entertainment Company, Hilary Clinton’s
presidential campaign, and Webstresser’s malicious service.
One way to prevent incidents is to treat cyber security with respect
which it deserves. That could be done by implementing applicable
industry standards such as IOS 27001, NIST, CobIT, and
performing audit by using ISACA guidelines such as CISA (2015).

131

�IIA’s three lines of defence model should be used in the internal
organisation structure for auditing. The first line of defence model
is operational management, second is supported by compliance
and risk management, and third line of defence is task of internal
audit using IIA, and other applicable standards and guidelines.

Cyber security audit overview
Cyber security audit has to be performed within defined audit
objectives and types. Audit has to be based on a risk-based analysis
where different types of risk analysis can be used: qualitative, semiquantitative, and quantitative risk-based analysis. Output of the
risk analysis has to be used for implementation of internal controls
by using relevant international standards. These controls are used
by auditors and compared to standard criteria and practices. In this
process, auditors collect the evidence which is information used to
support auditor’s opinion.
Cyber security audit can be performed using ISACA CISA (2015)
guidelines which propose eight areas for auditing: hardware audit,
operating system audit, database audit, network infrastructure
audit, information system audit, scheduling audit, problem
management reporting audit, and environment audit.
Standards from the ISO 27000 (ISO 27001:2013, ISO 27005:2008, and
other) family of standards can be used for the implementation of
internal controls. They can also be used for documentation for
creating checklists and audit implementation of internal controls.
To successfully perform auditing, an auditor should have sound
technical knowledge and experience with technological issues
which are partially presented in this book.

132

�List of Figures

Figure 1. Charles Joseph Minard: Napoleon's Retreat from Moscow (The Russian
Campaign 1812-1813), Mason B., (2017) .......................................................................... 2
Figure 2. Cyber and information security realm ..................................................................... 8
Figure 3. Shannon’s communication model .......................................................................... 14
Figure 4. TPC / IP protocol suite layers .................................................................................. 15
Figure 5. ISO / OSI reference model ....................................................................................... 16
Figure 6. Network topologies .................................................................................................. 17
Figure 7. Client-Server and Peer-to-Peer communication models ..................................... 18
Figure 8. Infrastructure of the wireless communication model .......................................... 19
Figure 9. Ad-hoc wireless communication model ................................................................ 19
Figure 10. Encapsulation process and communication devices on layers ......................... 23
Figure 11. Typical SPAN port deployment in a simplified network diagram .................. 24
Figure 12. Typical Tap location in network ........................................................................... 25
Figure 13. Network TAP, Dualcomm (2018) ......................................................................... 26
Figure 14. Simple DHCP architecture and modus operandi ............................................... 32
Figure 15. Simple MUA, MTA, MDA architecture ............................................................... 33
Figure 16. Simple network printing service .......................................................................... 33
Figure 17. Simple RAS architecture ........................................................................................ 34
Figure 18. Napster (2018) ......................................................................................................... 35
Figure 19. Simple FTP architecture ......................................................................................... 36
Figure 20. Simple Telnet architecture ..................................................................................... 36
Figure 21. Simplified VPN connection ................................................................................... 37
Figure 22. Network Management history IETF, ISO Network Management architecture
and model (Nuangjamnong C, 1998). ............................................................................ 40
Figure 23. Network Management architecture using SNMP, (Nuangjamnong C, 1998). 41
Figure 24. Network Management surrounding .................................................................... 41
Figure 25. Simple RMON architecture ................................................................................... 42
Figure 26. Example query using iReasoning MIB Browser ................................................. 43
Figure 27. DoS attack ................................................................................................................ 56
Figure 28. DDoS attack ............................................................................................................. 57
Figure 29. ARP operation and ARP attack ............................................................................. 58
Figure 30. Fraud triangle.......................................................................................................... 60
Figure 31. TOR (2018) ............................................................................................................... 62

133

�Figure 32. TOR modus operandi, TOR (2018) ....................................................................... 63
Figure 33. Common steps of intrusion attacks (Bejtlich, 2004)............................................ 65
Figure 34. Reconnaissance phases (CEH, 2018) .................................................................... 67
Figure 35. SamSpade (2018) ..................................................................................................... 68
Figure 36. Nmap / Zenmap (2018) .......................................................................................... 68
Figure 37. Whois output for www.mit.edu ........................................................................... 69
Figure 38. ZAP (2018) ............................................................................................................... 69
Figure 39. Wireshark window with captured traffic ............................................................ 70
Figure 40. Kismet (2018) ........................................................................................................... 71
Figure 41. System hacking steps (CEH, 2018) ....................................................................... 71
Figure 42. Password cracking techniques (CEH, 2018) ........................................................ 72
Figure 43. Cain &amp; Abel (2018) captured traffic ...................................................................... 73
Figure 44. Time Scale of Central Bangladesh Bank Heist 2016 (Reuters, 2016) and
(Krishna N. Das, and Jonathan Spicer, 2016) ................................................................ 78
Figure 45. Time Scale of Target retail chain Cyber Attack, 2013 ......................................... 80
Figure 46. "Guardians of Peace" (GOP), Paul 2014 ............................................................... 82
Figure 47. Time Scale of Sony Entertainment Company Cyber Attack, 2014 ................... 82
Figure 48. Time Scale of Private mail server usage for exchange of confidential
governmental information .............................................................................................. 83
Figure 49. Comey Letter (2016), (Silver N., 2017).................................................................. 85
Figure 50. Polls show Clinton’s popularity declined after FBI director letter was released
(Silver N., 2017) ................................................................................................................ 86
Figure 51. Webstresser existence time line ............................................................................ 87
Figure 52. (Eyerys, 2018) .......................................................................................................... 87
Figure 53. Locked http://webstresser.org/ address accessed 01.07.2018 ................................ 88
Figure 54. Risk management process ..................................................................................... 94
Figure 55. CIA Triad ................................................................................................................. 97
Figure 56. ISMS PDCA cycle ................................................................................................... 98
Figure 57. Business performance measurement using 3E’s ................................................. 99
(KPMG, 2018) ............................................................................................................................ 99
Figure 58. ISACA's COBIT5 (ISACA, 2012): ........................................................................ 100
Figure 59. BCP DRP triangle.................................................................................................. 103
Figure 60. RTO / RPO relation ............................................................................................... 104
Figure 61. The three lines of defence model (IIA, 2013) ..................................................... 110
Figure 62. General scheme of audit process, (ISACA CISA 2015 pp. 42.) ....................... 113
Figure 63. Integrated audit, (ISACA CISA 2015, pp. 62.) ................................................... 115
Figure 64. Digital forensic investigation (Ademu I. O., et al, 2011) .................................. 116
Figure 65. Cyber security timeline audit .............................................................................. 127

134

�List of Tables

Table 1. Ethernet cable performance (Ethernet, 2018) ........................................... 20
Table 2. Ethernet standards (Ethernet IEEE 802.3 Standards, 2018) ................... 21
Table 3. Communication media weaknesses.......................................................... 22
Table 4. Applications / Services and standard ports used.................................... 37
Table 5. ISO, ITU-T, IETF basic principles .............................................................. 39
Table 6. RMON Groups (Cisco Remote Monitoring, 2018) .................................. 42
Table 7. Information security core principles (ISO 27001:2013 and Vigila et al.,
2015) ............................................................................................................................. 48
Table 8. Short timeline of major malicious software appearance based on
Wikipedia (2018) information .................................................................................. 51
Table 9. Short timeline of major malicious software appearance Reconnaissance
and foot printing tools ............................................................................................... 66
Table 10. Relationship matrix in organisation structure of security governance
Brotby, (2006): ........................................................................................................... 112
Table 11. Segregation of duties matrix (CISA 2015, pp. 116.) ............................ 125

135

�136

�Acronyms

ACK Acknowledgement
BCM Business Continuity Management
BCP

Business Continuity Plan

BS

British standard

BSI

British Standardisation Institute

CERT Centre for Emergency Report Team
COBIT Control
Technologies

Objectives

for

Information

and

Related

CISA Certified Information Security Auditor
CISM Information Security Manager
CISP Certified Information Security Professional
CISO Chief Information Security Officer
CISWG Corporate Information Security Workgroup
CSO Chief Security Officer
DMZ Demilitarised zone
DoS

Denial of Service

DDoS Distributed Denial of Service
137

�FTP

File Transfer Protocol

HTTP Hyper Text Transfer Protocol
IA

Internal Auditor

ICMP Internet Control Message Protocol
IDS

Intrusion Detection System

IP

Internet Protocol

IPPM IP Performance Management Group
IPS

Intrusion Prevention System

IEC

International Electrotechnical Commission

IEEE Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers
IPX

Internetwork Packet Exchange

ISACA Information Systems Audit and Control Association
ISM Information Security Manager
ISMS Information Security Management System
ISO

International Standardisation Organisation

ISSEA International Systems Security Engineering Association
IT

Information Technology

ITIL

Information Technology Infrastructure Library

KPI

Key Performance Indicator

LAN Local Area Network
138

�MIB

Management Information Base

NIST National Institute of Standards &amp; Technology
NMS Network Management Station
OID

Object identifier

OSI

Open System for Interconnection

PDCA Plan Do Check Act
QoS

Quality of Service

SMTP Simple Mail Transfer Protocol
SNMP Simple Network Management Protocol
SQL

Simple query language

SPX

Sequenced Packet Exchange

SYN Synchronize
TCP

Transmission Control Protocol

TNM Telecommunications Management Network
UDP User Datagram Protocol
UPS

Uninterruptable Power Supplies

USB

Universal Serial Bus

VPN Virtual Private Network
WAN Wide Area Network
XML Extensible Markup Language
139

�140

�References

Andress J. and Winterfeld S. (Author)Cyber Warfare: Techniques,
Tactics and Tools for Security Practitioners, Syngress; 2nd edition
(October 1, 2013)
Anttila J., Jusila K., Kajava J., Kmaja I., Integrating ISO / IEC 27001
and other managerial discipline standards with processes of
management in organisations, 2012 Seventh International
Conference on Availability, Reliability, and Security, pp 425 – 436.
IEEE Conference Publications.
Aversano, Lerina; Bodhuin, Thierry; Canfora, Gerardo; Tortorella,
Maria, A framework for measuring business processes based on
GQM, Proceedings of the 37th Annual Hawaii International
Conference on System Sciences, 2004. IEEE Conference
Publications.
Aris
MashZone
(2013)
Available
from:
http://www.mashzone.com/en/mashzone [Accessed on 17.07.2013]
Arkalgud Ramaprasad, "On the Definition of Feedback",
Behavioral Science, Volume 28, Issue 1. 1983. Available at:
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/bs.3830280103/pdf
[Accessed on 08.02.2018]
Bejtlich R., (2004) The Tao of Network Security Monitoring,
Pearson Education Inc. Second printing 2004
Boehemer W., Cost-benefit trade-off analysis of an ISMS based on
ISO 27001, 2009 International Conference on Availability,
141

�Reliability, and Security, pp 392 – 399, IEEE Conference
Publications.
Brotby W. K., Bayuk J., Coleman C.,Leonardo V.,Henning R. R.,
Katz Stephen R., Malik W., Parulekar Y., Schwartz E., Tester D.,
Vael M., (2006) Information Security Governance: Guidance for
Boards of Directors and Executive Management 2nd Edition, IT
Governance
Institute,
Available
from:
http://www.isaca.org/KnowledgeCenter/Research/Documents/Information-Security-Govenancefor-Board-of-Directors-and-ExecutiveManagement_res_Eng_0510.pdf [Accessed on 25.07.2018]
Brotby W. Krag (2009), Information Security Management Metrics,
A definitive Guide to Effective Security Monitoring and
Measurement, CRC Press.
Brunner J., 1975, The Shockwave Rider, Harper &amp; Row, 1975
Businesstopia,
Avaialble
at:
https://www.businesstopia.net/communication/shannon-andweaver-model-communication [Accessed on 19.10.2018]
Cain &amp; Abel (2018), Available from: http://www.oxid.it/cain.html
[Accessed on 25.04.2018]
Calder Alan and Watkins Steve, (2007) Information Security Risk
Management, IT Governance Publishing 2007
Calder Alan and Watkins Steve, (2006) International IT
Governance, An executive Guide to ISO 17799 / 27001, Kogan Page
2006
Calder Alan (2006), implementing Information Security based on
ISO 27001 / ISO 17799 – A Management Guide, Van Haren
Publishing 2006
142

�CEH 2018, Available at: https://www.eccouncil.org. [Accessed on
25.04.2018]
CERT
vulnerability
statistics
(2008),
Available
http://www.cert.org/stats/vulnerability_remediation.html
[Accessed on 25.04.2008]

from:

Charles Joseph Minard, Napoleon's Retreat from Moscow (The
Russian
Campaign
1812-1813),
1869,
Available
at:
http://www.masswerk.at/minard/, [Accessed on 27.06.2013]
Chartered Institute of Internal Auditors (2014), Risk based internal
auditing, Available from:
https://global.theiia.org/standardsguidance/topics/documents/201501guidetorbia.pdf [Accessed on
25.07.2018]
Chevallier, V. (1871) Notice necrologique ´ sur M. Minard,
inspecteur gen´ eral ´ des ponts et chaussees, ´ en retraite. Annales
de Ponts et Chaussees ´, 2(Ser. 5, No. 15):1–22, 1871.
Chew Elizabeth, Clay Alicia, Hash Joan, Bratol Nadya, Brown
Anthony, Guide for Developing Performance metrics for
Information Security, NIST Special Publication 800-80, 2006
Cimpanu C., 2018, Europol Shuts Down World's Largest DDoS-forHire ServiceEuropol Shuts Down World's Largest DDoS-for-Hire
Service,
Available
from:
https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/europolshuts-down-worlds-largest-ddos-for-hire-service/ [Accessed on:
07.05.2018]
CISA (2015) Review manual 26th Edition, ISACA, 2015, ISBN 9781-60420-367-7
Cisco
(2018),
VPN
Services,
Available
from:
https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/products/security/vpn-endpointsecurity-clients/what-is-vpn.html, [Accessed on: 07.05.2018]
143

�Cisco
Remote
Monitoring
2018,
Available
from:
http://docwiki.cisco.com/wiki/Remote_Monitoring [Accessed on:
07.05.2018]
Clinton Email Investigation Timeline, 2018, Available from:
http://www.thompsontimeline.com/tag/justin-cooper/ [Accessed
on 24.07.2018]
Comey Letter, 2016 Oct. 28 FBI letter to congressional leaders on
Clinton
email
investigation,
Available
from:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/apps/g/page/politics/oct-28-fbiletter-to-congressional-leaders-on-clinton-emailinvestigation/2113/ [Accessed on 01.06.2018]
CNN
2016,
Available
from:
https://edition.cnn.com/2016/10/28/politics/hillary-clinton-emailtimeline/index.html [Accessed on 31.05.2018]
Cowing J., Ransomware Are You Prepared?, 2018, Available from:
http://m.isaca.org/chapters2/sanFrancisco/events/Documents/Ransomware%20ISACA%202018-628%20V0.1.pdf [Accessed on 24.10.2018]
Deep
and
Dark
Web
(2018),
Available
from:
https://www.thedarkwebsites.com/ [Accessed on 07.05.2018]
Donkey
(2018)
https://www.emuleproject.net/home/perl/general.cgi?l=1 [Accessed on 17.07.2018]
Dualcomm,
Available
from:
https://www.dualcomm.com/product-page/dual-gbe-copper-andfiber-network-tap [Accessed on 07.06.2018]
Eisenberg T., Gries D., Hartmanis J., Holcomb D., Stuart L. M.,
Thomas Sant oro The Cornell Commission:On Morris and the
Worm, ]une 1989 Volume 32 Number 6
144

�English
Oxford
Dictionaries,
2018
Available
from:
https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/fraud [Accessed on
24.07.2018]
Ethernet, 2018, Available from: https://www.electronicsnotes.com/articles/connectivity/ethernet-ieee-802-3/cables-typespinout-cat-5-5e-6.php [Accessed on 12.07.2018]
Ethernet IEEE 802.3 Standards, 2018 Available from:
https://www.electronics-notes.com/articles/connectivity/ethernetieee-802-3/standards.php [Accessed on 12.07.2018]
eTOM, 2018, Available from: https://www.tmforum.org/businessprocess-framework/ [Accessed on 12.10.2018]
Everest D., Garber R. E., Keating M., Peterson B., 2008, Business
Continuity Management, Global Technology Audit Guide (GTAG)
https://chapters.theiia.org/montreal/ChapterDocuments/GTAG%2
010%20-%20Business%20Continuity%20Management.pdf
Eyerys, Authorities Shut Down One of the World's Largest DDoSFor-Hire
Service,
Available
from:
https://www.eyerys.com/articles/timeline/authorities-shut-downone-worlds-largest-ddos-hire-service?page=4#event-a-hrefarticles-timeline-one-fifth-all-enterprise-applications-were-borncloudone-fifth-of-all-enterprise-applications-were-born-in-thecloud-a, [Accessed on 25.04.2018]
Featherly K., ARPANET UNITED STATES DEFENSE PROGRAM,
Available from: https://www.britannica.com/topic/ARPANET,
[Accessed on 25.04.2018]
FOX
NEWS,
2016,
Available
from:
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2016/09/02/timeline-clintonemail-server-setup.html
Gibson W., Neuromancer, Ace; 1st edition (July 1, 1984)
145

�Gourley Bob (2014) The Cyber Threat: Know the threat to beat the
threat, Sep 3, Amazon Digital Services LLC
Gregory H.Peter (2016) CISA Certified Information Systems
Auditor All-in-One Exam Guide, Third Edition, McGraw-Hill
Education; 3 edition (October 26, 2016)
Hajdarevic K., Allen P., A New Method for the Identification of
Proactive Information Security Management System Metrics,
MIPRO 35 Proceedings of the 35th International Convention,
Publication Year: 2013, IEEE Conference Publications.
Hajdarevic K., Kozaric K., Hadzigrahic J., Architecture and
Infrastructure for Governing Information Security in Central
Banks, Journal of Central Banking Theory and Practice, Volume 1,
Number 2, pp. 5-17, October 2012.
Hajdarevic K., Pattinson C., Kozaric K., Hadzic A., Information
Security Measurement Infrastructure for KPI Visualization,
MIPRO 35 Proceedings of the 35th International Convention,
Publication Year: 2012, Page(s): 1543 – 1548, IEEE Conference
Publications.
Henckler Aron, Waterfall Charts using Excel, Available at:
http://chandoo.org/wp/2009/08/10/excel-waterfall-charts/
[Accessed on 24.11.2012]
History of the Web, World Wide Web Foundation, Available at:
https://webfoundation.org/about/vision/history-of-the-web/
[Accessed on 12.06.2018]
IIA Position Paper: THE THREE LINES OF DEFENSE IN
EFFECTIVE RISK MANAGEMENT AND CONTROL, JANUARY
2013,
Available
at:
https://na.theiia.org/standardsguidance/Public%20Documents/PP%20The%20Three%20Lines%2

146

�0of%20Defense%20in%20Effective%20Risk%20Management%20a
nd%20Control.pdf [Accessed on 23.02.2018]
InetDaemon,
Available
at:
https://www.inetdaemon.com/tutorials/basic_concepts/communic
ation/frames_packets_n_pdus.shtml [Accessed on 23.09.2018]
Ademu I. O., Imafidon C. O., Preston D. S., A New Approach of
Digital Forensic Model for Digital Forensic Investigation, (IJACSA)
International Journal of Advanced Computer Science and
Applications, Vol. 2, No.12, 2011
Iasiello E., Cyber Attack: A Dull Tool to Shape Foreign Policy,
Available
at:
https://ccdcoe.org/cycon/2013/proceedings/d3r1s3_Iasiello.pdf
[Accessed on 23.09.2018]
Internet Protocol Version 6 (IPv6) / IP Next Generation (IPng),
Available
at:
http://tcpipguide.com/free/t_InternetProtocolVersion6IPv6IPNext
GenerationIPng.htm [Accessed on 23.02.2018]
IPPM,
2018,
Available
https://datatracker.ietf.org/wg/ippm/documents/ [Accessed
12.07.2018]

at:
on

ISACA (2008) in Information Security Governance: Guidance for
Information Security Managers
ISACA
(2012)
COBIT
5,
Available
https://www.isaca.org/COBIT/Documents/COBIT5Introduction.ppt [Accessed on 20.07.2018]

at:

ISO 27001:2013 Information technology – Security techniques –
information Сеcurity Managamanet System – Requirements,
Second edition 2013-10-01, ISO IEC
147

�ISO 27005 ISO 27005:2008 Information technology – Security
techniques – information security management, first edition 200806-15, ISO IEC
ISO 7498:1984, Information processing systems – Open Systems
Interconnection – Basic Reference Model, Available at:
https://www.iso.org/standard/14252.html [Accessed on 20.07.2018]
LoBianco T., 2016, FBI releases notes from Clinton email
investigation,
September
24,
2016https://edition.cnn.com/2016/09/23/politics/fbi-investigationhillary-clinton-emails/index.html
Jaquith Andrew, Security Metrics, Replacing Fear, Uncertainty,
and Doubt. Addison-Wesley, 2009 [Accessed on 23.07.2018]
John
the
Ripper
(2018)
Available
http://www.openwall.com/john/ [Accessed on 08.05.2008]

at:

Kalvapalle
R,
2016
Available
at:
https://globalnews.ca/news/3035703/hillary-clinton-email-scandaltimeline/ [Accessed on 08.05.2008]
Kismet (2018), Available from: https://www.kismetwireless.net/
[Accessed on 08.05.2008]
KPMG,
Value
For
Money,
Available
from:
https://home.kpmg.com/sg/en/home/services/advisory/riskconsulting/internal-audit-services/value-for-money.html,
[Accessed on 08.10.2018]
Krishna N. Das, Ruma Paul, Exclusive: Bangladesh probes 2013
hack for links to central bank heist, Available at:
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-cyber-heistbangladesh/exclusive-bangladesh-probes-2013-hack-for-links-tocentral-bank-heist-idUSKCN0YG2UT [Accessed on 08.05.2018]
148

�Krishna N. Das, and Jonathan Spicer, 2016, How millions from the
Bangladesh
Bank
heist
disappeared,
Available
at:
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-cyber-heist-philippines/howmillions-from-the-bangladesh-bank-heist-disappearedidUSKCN1011AT [Accessed on 08.05.2018]
LaFraniere S., Californian Who Unwittingly Aided Russian
Election Interference Gets 6 Months in Prison, Avaialble at:
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/10/us/politics/richard-pinedosentencingmueller.html?rref=collection%2Fnewseventcollection%2Frussianelectionhacking&amp;action=click&amp;contentCollection=politics&amp;region=stream
&amp;module=stream_unit&amp;version=latest&amp;contentPlacement=9&amp;pgt
ype=collection [Accessed on Oct. 10, 2018]
Lee T. B. 2013, Everything you need to know about the NSA and
Tor
in
one
FAQ,
Available
at:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/theswitch/wp/2013/10/04/everything-you-need-to-know-about-thensa-and-tor-in-one-faq/?noredirect=on&amp;utm_term=.815bf3f47636,
October 4, 2013, [Accessed on 08.07.2018]
Lord N., 2018, A History of Ransomware Attacks: The Biggest and
Worst Ransomware Attacks of All Time, April 6, 2018, Available
at: https://digitalguardian.com/blog/history-ransomware-attacksbiggest-and-worst-ransomware-attacks-all-time [Accessed on
24.07.2018]
Mason B. (2017), The Underappreciated Man Behind the “Best
Graphic
Ever
Produced,”
Available
at:
https://news.nationalgeographic.com/2017/03/charles-minardcartography-infographics-history/ [Accessed on 12.06.2018]
Maswerk, (2013), Available at: http://www.masswerk.at/minard/
[Accessed on 10.06.2018]
149

�Mar S., Johannessen R., Coates S., Wegrzynowicz K., Andreesen T.,
Global Technology Audit Guide (GTAG®) Information
Technology Risk and Controls, IPPF – Practice Guide, March 2012
Available:
at:
https://chapters.theiia.org/montreal/ChapterDocuments/GTAG%2
01%20%20Information%20technology%20controls_2nd%20ed.pdf
[Accessed on 16.06.2018]
Mitchell B. 2018, Gnutella P2P Free File Sharing and Download
Network,
Updated
February
06,
2018
https://www.lifewire.com/definition-of-gnutella-818024 [Accessed
on: 22. 07. 2018]
Mission
Assurance,
05.04.2000
http://www.hq.nasa.gov/office/codeq/pra.pdf
23.07.2013]

Available
[Accessed

at:
on

Mueller P. and Yadegari B., The Stuxnet Worm, Available from:
https://www2.cs.arizona.edu/~collberg/Teaching/466566/2012/Resources/presentations/2012/topic9-final/report.pdf
[Accessed on: 12. 06. 2018]
Napster,
(2018)
Available
at:
https://www.reddit.com/r/nostalgia/comments/1v98nm/downloa
ding_songs_on_napster_with_a_56k_modem/
[Accessed
on
23.05.2018]
Nimonik (2018) Available at: https://nimonik.com/help/associatea-company-or-public-template-to-a-facility/
[Accessed
on
23.05.2018]
Norman J, 2018, Norbert Wiener Issues "Cybernetics," the First
Widely
Distributed
Book
on
Electronic
Computing
http://www.historyofinformation.com/expanded.php?id=850
[Accessed on 12.06.2018]
150

�Nmap/Zenmap (2018), Available: at: https://nmap.org/zenmap/
[Accessed on 12.07.2018]
Nuangjamnong C., Maj S. P., Veal D., The OSI Network
Management Model- Capacity and Performance Management,
Proceedings of 4th IEEE International Conference on Management
of Innovation and Technology . ICMIT 2008. (pp. 1266-1270).
Bangkok, Thailand. IEEE
Overview of TMN Recommendations, Telecommunications
management network M.3000–M.3599 (02/2000), ITU 2001.
Available at: https://www.itu.int/rec/T-REC-M.3000-200002-I/en
[Accessed on 23.05.2018]
Probst W. C., Hunker J., Bishop M., Gollmann D. Insider Threats in
Cyber Security (Advances in Information Security), Springer; 2010
edition (August 10, 2010)
Passive and active attacks, SECURITY CONCEPTS FOR
CORPORATE NETWORKS, Available from: http://www.tc11.unifrankfurt.de/CONF/SEC94/roppl.html [Accessed on 08.05.2008]
Paul, December 28, 2014 20:39 New Clues in Sony Hack Point To
Insiders,
Away
from
DPRK,
Available
from:
https://securityledger.com/2014/12/new-clues-in-sony-hack-pointto-insiders-away-from-dprk/, [Accessed on: Friday, March 9, 2018]
Pelkey J., (2007) Transmission Control Protocol (TCP) 1973-1976,
Available
from:
http://www.historyofcomputercommunications.info/Book/6/6.4TransmissionControlProtocol(TCP)73-76.html, [Accessed on:
18.06.2018]
Pelkey J., (2007) Chapter 9 Standards: 1979-1984, ISO/OSI (Open
Systems Interconnection): 1979 - 1980, Available from:
http://www.historyofcomputercommunications.info/Book/9/9.5_I
151

�SO-OSI-OpenSystemsInterconnection-79-80.html, [Accessed on:
12.06. 2018]
Reuters (2016), UPDATE 3-Bangladesh central bank governor
resigns
over
cyber
heist,
Available
from:
https://www.reuters.com/article/usa-fed-bangladeshresignation/update-3-bangladesh-central-bank-governor-resignsover-cyber-heist-idUSL3N16N3MB, [Accessed on: 12.06. 2018]
Rouse
M.,
Available
from:
https://searchdisasterrecovery.techtarget.com/definition/businesscontinuity [Accessed on: 12.06. 2018]
Ruma P., (2018), Bangladesh to sue Manila bank over $81-million
heist, Available from: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-cyberheist-bangladesh/bangladesh-to-sue-manila-bank-over-81million-heist-idUSKBN1FR1QV, [Accessed on: 12.06. 2018]
Sahin T., x Omidyar 1988,
;Bauman T.M., 1988,
Telecommunications management network (TMN) architecture
and interworking designs, May 1988, Page(s): 685 - 696, IEEE
Journal on Selected Areas in Communications ( Volume: 6, Issue:
4, May 1988 )
SamSpade,
Available
http://www.majorgeeks.com/files/details/sam_spade.html
[Accessed on 23.05.2018]

at:

Sandwith L. 2006 Does Internal Audit have an effective game plan
to
address
fraud?
Available
at:
https://www.iia.org.uk/media/1688757/1-internal-audit-gameplan-l-sandwith-.pdf [Accessed on 23.10.2018]
Scott E., 2015, Hillary Clinton on emails: “The facts are pretty
clear,”
Available
at:

152

�https://edition.cnn.com/2015/07/25/politics/clinton-confidentnever-sent-classified-emails/index.html, [Accessed on 23.05.2018]
Shaban Hamza, Global police just shut down world’s largest
marketplace that allegedly disrupted millions of sites, Available
from:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/theswitch/wp/2018/04/25/global-police-just-shut-down-worldslargest-marketplace-that-allegedly-disrupted-millions-ofsites/?noredirect=on&amp;utm_term=.924b110f7630 [Accessed on:
Monday, April 9, 2018]
Shannon, C.E., &amp; Weaver, W. (1949). The mathematical theory of
communication. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
Silver N., The Comey Letter Probably Cost Clinton The Election,
Available from: https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-comeyletter-probably-cost-clinton-the-election/ [Accessed on: April 5,
2018]
Spremić, M, Sigurnost i revizija informacijskih sustava u okruženju
digitalne ekonomije, Mario Spremić, 2017, ISBN: 978-953-346-037-6
Stuxnet,
Symantec,
July
13,
2010,
Available
from:
https://www.symantec.com/security-center/writeup/2010-0714003123-99 [Accessed on: 18. 07. 2018]
Stamatelatos Michael, Probabilistic Risk Assessment: What Is It
and Why Is It Worth Performing It, NASA Office of Safety and
Stoneburner Gary, Goguen Alice, and Feringa, Risk Management
Guide for Information Technology Systems, NIST, 2002 Available
at: http://csrc.nist.gov/publications/nistpubs/800-30/sp800-30.pdf
[Accessed on 24.11.2012]
Syed Aakhtar and Syed Aafsar, Business Continuity Planning
Methodology, Sentryx, 2004
153

�TCP/IP
Internet
Protocol,
1981,
Available
from:
https://www.livinginternet.com/i/ii_tcpip.htm, [Accessed on: 18.
06. 2018]
Techopedia (2018), Information Systems Security (INFOSEC), 2018,
Techopedia,
Available
from:
https://www.techopedia.com/definition/24840/informationsystems-security-infosec, [Accessed on: 12. 06. 2018]
The
Smoking
Gun,
2013,
Available
http://www.thesmokinggun.com/buster/sidneyblumenthal/hacker-distributes-memos-784091
[Accessed
23.05.2018]

at:
on

Thomson I., 2016, Meet the malware that screwed a Bangladeshi
bank
out
of
$81m,
Available
at:
https://www.theregister.co.uk/2016/04/25/bangladeshi_malware_s
crewed_swift/ [Accessed on 02.05.2018]
Toigo Jon William, Disaster Recovery Planning Preparing for the
Unthinkable, Prentice Hall PTR 2003.
TOR
(2018)
Available
https://www.torproject.org/about/overview,
[Accessed
23.05.2018]

at:
on

Vasudaven Vinod, Anoop Mangla, Application Security in the ISO
27001 Environment, IT Governance LTD 2008
Vacca R. J., (2013) Cyber Security and IT Infrastructure Protection
1st Edition, Syngress; 1 edition (August 22, 2013)
Vigila M., Buchmann J., Cabarcasb D., Weinerta C., Wiesmaierc A.,
Integrity, authenticity, non-repudiation, and proof of existence for
long-term archiving: A survey, Computers &amp; Security Volume 50,
May 2015, Pages 16-32, Elsevier
154

�Vijayan
Jaikumar,
(2014),
Available
at:
https://www.computerworld.com/article/2487425/cybercrimehacking/target-breach-happened-because-of-a-basic-networksegmentation-error.html [Accessed on 23.04.2018]
Von Neumann, J., Burks, Arthur W., Theory of self-reproducing
automata, Urbana, University of Illinois Press, 1966
Watkins W. (2014), Condition, Criteria, Cause and Effect of Internal
Auditing,
Available
at:
https://www.iiafiji.org/resources/bbc5020b-a5ab-4388-b63383813515c797.pdf [Accessed on 24.04.2018]
Wireshark (2018) Available at:
[Accessed on 01.07.2018]

https://www.wireshark.org/,

Wikipedia (2018) Timeline of computer viruses and worms,
Available
at:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_computer_viruses_and
_worms [Accessed on 01.07.2018]
Wong Caroline, Security Metrics: A Beginner’s Guide, McGraw
Hill, 2012
(x.200. 1995), Data Networks and Open System Communications,
Open Systems Interconnection - Model and Notation, International
Telecommunication Union
Yixi, Guo; Hui, Guan, Research on Method of Metrics for
Information Ferry in Secret Intranet, International Conference on
Intelligent Computation Technology and Automation (ICICTA),
2011
ZAP
2018,
Available
https://www.owasp.org/index.php/File:ZAPScreenShotHistoryFilter.png [Accessed on 23.05.2018]

at:

155

�Zurcher A., (2016). “Hillary Clinton emails - what's it all about?,”
Available
at:
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada31806907 [Accessed on 12.06.2018]

Overview
of
Digital
Forensics,
Available
at:
https://www.isaca.org/KnowledgeCenter/Research/ResearchDeliverables/Pages/overview-of-digitalforensics.aspx, [Accessed on 12.06.2018]

156

�157

�Index

A
Access control
Access control to program source
code
Active attack
Administrator and operator logs
Applications
Architecture
Artificial
Assessment
Asset
Attacker
Attributes
Audit
Audit logging
Authenticity
Availability

B
Broadcast
Business Continuity
Business continuity and risk
assessment
Business continuity management
Business continuity planning
framework

C
Capacity management
Capacity management
Change control procedures
Change management
Clock synchronization
COBIT
Communication
Communications and operations
management

158

Compliance
Computer
Confidentiality
Continuity
Control of internal processing
Control of operational software
Control of technical vulnerabilities
Controls against malicious code
Controls against mobile code
Countermeasure
Crypto

D
Denial of service
Developing and implementing BCP
including information security
Disaster
DMZ
Distance vector

E
Electronic
Electronic messaging
Electronic commerce
Equipment identification in the
network
Encryption
Escalation

F
Fault
Fault logging
Firewall
Forensic
FTP

�G
Gap analysis
Goal, Goals

H
Hardware
Human
Human resources
HRA
HTTP

I
Incident
Including information security in the
BCM process
Information access restriction
Information Backup
Information security
Information security incident
management
Information systems acquisition,
development and maintenance
Infrastructure
Input data validation
Integrity
Interruption
Intrusion detection
IP address
IPX
ISMS
ISO 27000
ITIL

Management,
Media
Message integrity
Metric,
Monitoring system use

N
Network
Network controls
Network connection control
Network layer
Network routing control
NMS
Non-Reputability

O
OID
On-line transactions
Output data validation

P

Key management
KPI

Passive attack
Password management system
Performance
Physical and environmental security
Policy on the use of cryptographic
controls
Policy on use of network services
Privilege management
PRA
Proactive
Procedure
Protection of information systems
audit tools
Protection of log information
Protection of system test data
Protocol
Publicly available systems

L

Q

K

Likelihood
Limitation of connection time
Link state
Local area networks

QoS
Quality
Qualitative
Quantitative

M

R

MAC address

Recovery
Regulation of cryptographic controls

159

�Regulatory
Remote diagnostic and configuration
port protection
Responsibilities and procedures
Restrictions on changes to software
packages
Review of user access rights
Risk
Risk management
Router
RTGS

Unicast
UPS
Use of system utilities
User authentication for external
connections
User identification and
authentication
User password management
User registration
Utilities

S

Virus
Virtual Private Network,
Visualisation
VPN
Vulnerability

SABSA
Secure disposal
Secure log-on procedures
Security
Security of network services
Security of system documentation
Security requirements analysis and
specification
Segregation in networks
Separation of development, test and
operational facilities
Server
Session time-out
SMTP
SNMP
Software
Spyware
SQL
Switch
SYN
System acceptance

T
TCP / IP
Technical compliance checking
Technical review of applications
after operating system changes
Terminal
Testing, maintaining and reassessing business continuity plan
Threat
Trojan

U
UDP

160

V

W
WAN
Web
Wide area networks
Wireless
Worm

X
XML

Z
Zotob

�About author
Kemal Hajdarevic PhD received B.Sc. from Faculty of Electrical
Engineering, University of Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina, M.Sc.
and PhD from Leeds Metropolitan University / Leeds Beckett
University, Leeds, UK. He is currently working at the Central Bank of
Bosnia and Herzegovina as a Senior Internal Auditor for information
Security and IT projects, and he has a teaching position at the Faculty
of Electrical Engineering, University of Sarajevo, and International
Burch University, Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina. He teaches
Computer Communication and Networks, Network Management, IT
Governance, Computer Modelling and Simulations, Ethical Hacking,
and Digital Forensics. He is a licensed radio amateur with call sign
E71HK.

161

��Colin Pattinson: “As business organisations of all types and sizes place greater
dependence on their information technology to provide their core operational
requirements, it is sadly inevitable that there is a growth in the number of
malicious individuals attempting to exploit that dependency, whether by
unauthorised access to resources, theft of data or by making the systems
unusable for their required purpose. Defence against attacks like these, and the
many other ways in which systems or information can be compromised, is
invaluable, but needs careful planning combined with the tools, knowledge and
techniques to carry out those plans.
This book explains how those plans should be developed and provides the means
by which they can be carried out. It begins from the fundamental basis that
knowledge about how any system is configured and how it is behaving are
fundamental to the ability to control and manage. The second significant
requirement for defence is to know what an opponent is capable of. Identifying
which of the potential threats might be realised then leads to an audit of the
system to determine the real threats and any gaps in defences. This book covers
each of those stages in a logical and thorough manner. After an explanation of
the range and types of network and communications technologies likely to be
encountered, the book then discusses the potential threats, supported by
informative actual cases to show that these are not simply abstract concepts, but
that real organisations have suffered real losses though security breaches. The
book then provides the reader with the necessary tools and techniques to assess
and manage the risks, ending with a comprehensive discussion of the design and
conduct of a full cyber security audit, addressing all levels of a typical business
IT system. Structured tutorial / revision questions support each chapter, allowing
the reader to reinforce their learning at each stage, before moving on to the next
chapter. Alternative pathways through the book are identified to allow readers
to develop their particular specialist interest.
This book meets a demand which is certain to increase in importance in the years
to come.

Mario Spremic: “As there are not so many quality publications in this area,
especially the books like this one with holistic (technology, management,
regulation, etc.) approach to cyber security and information system auditing, I
do recommend this book for students, researchers and practitioners to gain
fundamental knowledge and understanding and broaden their horizons.”

1

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="79">
            <name>Extent</name>
            <description>The size or duration of the resource.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="948">
                <text>3776</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="949">
                <text>Cyber Security Audit in Business  Environments</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="96">
            <name>Author</name>
            <description>Author</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="950">
                <text>Hajdarevic, Kemal</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="94">
            <name>Abstract</name>
            <description>A summary of the resource.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="951">
                <text>Everyday reports reveal numerous cyber security incidents, while many more are never uncovered due to the risk of jeopardising the reputation of the attacked systems. One definition of risk of this sort is:  “feasible determinable outcome of an activity or action subject to hazards” (Stamatelatos, 2000).  A more holistic and comprehensive definition, which is available in the NIST Special Publication 800-30 Revision 1 Guide for Conducting Risk Assessment, defines risk as:  „Adverse impact(s) that could occur... to organisational operations (including mission, functions, image, reputation), organisational assets, individuals, other organisations... due to the potential for unauthorized access, use, disclosure, disruption, modification, or destruction of information and/or information systems.“  As such, databases, as the active and passive components of computer networks and the building blocks of computer infrastructures, became a point of focus for every business in the world. Unlike 30 years ago, many households nowadays rely on Internet access and available services to support their everyday life. The Internet and World Wide Web (WWW) resources are accessible through various web browsers.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="45">
            <name>Publisher</name>
            <description>An entity responsible for making the resource available</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="952">
                <text>International Burch University</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="953">
                <text>2018</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="97">
            <name>Keywords</name>
            <description>Keywords.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="954">
                <text>Book
PeerReviewed</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="14">
        <name>T Technology (General)</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="124" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="127">
        <src>https://omeka.ibu.edu.ba/files/original/9479c736ca79c280407f40ac4e8a695a.pdf</src>
        <authentication>afdbaf6dabe9bf7cdabec1e08fd0ecbe</authentication>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="79">
            <name>Extent</name>
            <description>The size or duration of the resource.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="956">
                <text>3775</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="957">
                <text>How Does Lending from Commercial Banks Impact Performance of Small  Enterprises: A Case Study of District Hafizabad, Pakistan</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="96">
            <name>Author</name>
            <description>Author</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="958">
                <text>Janjua, Azhar Ali
Hayat, Muhammad Azmat
Aslam, Muhammad</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="94">
            <name>Abstract</name>
            <description>A summary of the resource.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="959">
                <text>Abstract: This study examines the impact of lending from commercial banks  on performance of small enterprises. Financial data of forty business entities of  district Hafizabad have been collected from commercial banks, for the period of  2005 to 2013. “Net profit” in the first model and “sales” in the second model  are used as dependent variables. Working capital, accumulated profit, net-worth  and lending/financing amount are used as independent variables. The study  suggests: Firstly, banks’ lending positively affects the performance of small  enterprises. Secondly, financing amount illustrates positive effect on net profits of  the firms. Thirdly, the preferred amount of lending to small enterprises is less  than two million PKR.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="45">
            <name>Publisher</name>
            <description>An entity responsible for making the resource available</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="960">
                <text>International Burch University</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="961">
                <text>2018</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="97">
            <name>Keywords</name>
            <description>Keywords.</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="962">
                <text>Article
PeerReviewed</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="98">
            <name>DOI</name>
            <description>Digital object identifier</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="963">
                <text>doi: "10.14706/JECOSS18811 "     </text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="964">
                <text>ISSN 1986-8499, </text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="7">
        <name>HB Economic Theory</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
</itemContainer>
